robuko Posted July 17, 2011 Posted July 17, 2011 Wow! This is a spectacular finish. Camanakin's and Scotty's clues are totally bulletproof in my view. I am shocked by this, but I know Scotty is Town and I am sure Camanakin is too. Bananakin has helped the town all the way to the end though. Part of me would rather find a different scum, but it looks like we have one here. Ram Strut, thankyou for your very good summary, saves me from doing one Is there any point me playing a witness card now? There are ten people remaining. Even if the Town lynches a Townie today, that's still five Townies to four scum. Unless one scum was to stupid to play his Kill Card, it should already be impossible for the scum to win. I couldn't work this out either - if the close of last night was 8/5 it should be impossible for the Town to win, and if it was 9/4 it should be impossible for the scum to win. Yet, the Town Elder said both sides were still in with a chance. The only solution for me is if it was 8/5 but the scum are somehow not allowed to play one card. Well, as I have another witness card, and severe paranoia, I would like to use it to investigate the foul and horrid murder of General Roweena Karnata.
Brickdoctor Posted July 17, 2011 Posted July 17, 2011 I couldn't work this out either - if the close of last night was 8/5 it should be impossible for the Town to win, and if it was 9/4 it should be impossible for the scum to win. Yet, the Town Elder said both sides were still in with a chance. The only solution for me is if it was 8/5 but the scum are somehow not allowed to play one card. The only conclusions I arrived at were that either god is playing a joke on us, akin to a Conclusion of a situation in a book I read called Werewolf, but on a grander scale, or that the one missing Kill Card is, in fact, a fourth type of card that skews the results of other cards in some way.
robuko Posted July 17, 2011 Posted July 17, 2011 Well, it's like everyone says, the killer had blue eyes.
badboytje88 Posted July 17, 2011 Posted July 17, 2011 Sorry Bananakin, But these clues are just inevitable... Vote: Bananakin Skywalker/Brickdoctor
def Posted July 17, 2011 Author Posted July 17, 2011 Brickdoctor is convicted. Game End Conclusion up within the hour
Recommended Posts