Bricksandparts Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 So, what's so suspicious bout these benzini brothers?
swils Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 So, what's so suspicious bout these benzini brothers? Really, this is the question at hand. Are they really that suspicious because they werent very vocal today? Or have they perhaps acted "too innocent", like Tora? (rolls her eyes). The way I see it, upon being accused and piled against for (yet another) unconvincing reason, the Benzini brothers failed to present a convincing defense of their own. To be honest, I never even heard them say they *didnt* kill anyone last night.. Just that theyve been too busy today to participate in the discussions earlier. And okay, THAT seems kind of suspicious. But even if theyd claimed they didnt do it, would anyone believe them? Jimbob's defense wasnt much stronger, just saying he didnt so it and then almost resigning himself to the inevitable, and there are still some people who dont trust him right now, though everyone seems to have turned on the Benzinis. We need to find solid reasons to be convicting people, not just throwing our votes behind whoever drew the shortstraw when it came to "silly reasons to die" today.
UsernameMDM Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 We need to find solid reasons to be convicting people, not just throwing our votes behind whoever drew the shortstraw when it came to "silly reasons to die" today. Bravissimo! (+ gibberish)
Jedi master Brick Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 We need to think, I am going to do some of that before I vote but calm down
eiker86 Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Well. I think we are rushing a bit when we now votes for I read the Benzini Brothers. He were only missing in action, but that wouldnt say he is a scum. But im on to Jimbob. Just waiting for him to do a mistake. We need to think' date=' I am going to do some of that before I vote but calm down [/quote'] But i think he is just waiting to see if anyone is voteing for him. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) Well. I think we are rushing a bit when we now votes for I read the Benzini Brothers. He were only missing in action, but that wouldnt say he is a scum. But im on to Jimbob. Just waiting for him to do a mistake. But i think he is just waiting to see if anyone is voteing for him. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) Ups. Wrong format: I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick)
Darth Nihilus Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Really, this is the question at hand. Are they really that suspicious because they werent very vocal today? Or have they perhaps acted "too innocent", like Tora? (rolls her eyes). The way I see it, upon being accused and piled against for (yet another) unconvincing reason, the Benzini brothers failed to present a convincing defense of their own. To be honest, I never even heard them say they *didnt* kill anyone last night.. Just that theyve been too busy today to participate in the discussions earlier. And okay, THAT seems kind of suspicious. But even if theyd claimed they didnt do it, would anyone believe them? Jimbob's defense wasnt much stronger, just saying he didnt so it and then almost resigning himself to the inevitable, and there are still some people who dont trust him right now, though everyone seems to have turned on the Benzinis. We need to find solid reasons to be convicting people, not just throwing our votes behind whoever drew the shortstraw when it came to "silly reasons to die" today. The reason we are accusing the Benzinis is that they have not been contributing to help the Town. Since they are not contributing, they are either Scum, or useless Townies, and let's face it, useless Townies help the Scum. So if we vote them off, we either get a Scum, or get rid of Townies who don't even help us, and thus help the Scum. Jimbob, on the other hand, has evidence against him that nearly convicts him on its own. But that evidence is not solid. Sure, the person that accused him died, but that isn't good evidence. It could have just been a coincidence. The only way to find out is to wait and see. If another of Jimbob's accusers dies in the Night, then we know who we should be voting for. We have a double event that is solid evidence. So, if we vote out Jimbob now, we could get a Scum, or we could get a Townie who was convicted on a coincidence. It is a chance, and I don't like taking chances. We should get rid of the Benzinis, who are not helping at all, and wait for more evidence against Jimbob. I don't know about the rest of the family, but my vote still stands.
Jedi master Brick Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Well. I think we are rushing a bit when we now votes for I read the Benzini Brothers. He were only missing in action, but that wouldnt say he is a scum. But im on to Jimbob. Just waiting for him to do a mistake. But i think he is just waiting to see if anyone is voteing for him. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) Ups. Wrong format: I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) Ok, vote for me see if I care. I won't vote for you today. I am going to think though who I am going to vote
eiker86 Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 If i am correctly, the voting ends in few hours.
TheBoyWonder Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 (edited) I believe Jimbob is acting suspicious, and one of his accusers is dead. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) Edited October 20, 2011 by JediAnakin
Jedi master Brick Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 I believe Jimbob is acting suspicious, and one of his accusers is dead. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) I was unlucky I can tell the scum are clever, but if you are not scum and have a brain don't vote for me. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote:The Benzini brothers (UsernameMDM) Sorry if you are town but I am following the advice of other people
Fred Fred Burger Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 I was unlucky I can tell the scum are clever, but if you are not scum and have a brain don't vote for me. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote:The Benzini brothers (UsernameMDM) Sorry if you are town but I am following the advice of other people Why? You are the most suspicious person among us. Certainly the scum are trying to manipulate things but we can't simply say that all evidence against us is some elaborate scum scheme against us . The fact remains that you were the first person to vote for Gingero and your accuser wound up dead. And Dorthea a dead scum is better than a dead townie, regardless of their skill level.
Jedi master Brick Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Ok, tonight I request to be incestigated by the investigater. He/she can then tell someone he/she trusts to announce for he/she. I shall have my innocence proven, ok? What do you lot think on the plan
Darth Nihilus Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 The fact remains that you were the first person to vote for Gingero and your accuser wound up dead. And Dorthea a dead scum is better than a dead townie, regardless of their skill level. I agree that Jimbob was the first to accuse Gingeroono and that his accuser wound up dead, but those could simply be coincidences. I think that we should go on the more solid accusation of being either a Scum or a useless Townie. If the Benzinis have anything to say, I might reconsider. But so far, they have not helped us Townies, and by doing so help the Scum. They are either useless Townies or Scum, and a dead useless Townie is just as good as a dead Scum. If the rest of you wish to vote for Jimbob, I will accept that. But my vote for the Benzinis is final, and I'm not changing it unless you can get solid evidence against Jimbob. Then, and only then, will I reconsider.
Darkdragon Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 I feel that the Benzini Brothers have been given plenty of chance at this point to defend themselves. We still have so little to go on as far as hard proof of anyone being scum, but as Dorathea said, if they are not helping us they are hurting us. In these difficult times we need to weed out anyone that is even possibly scum. It hurts to vote this way as I always enjoyed their fun acts, but they have given me no reason to assume innocence. Everyone is potentially scum where before we thought everyone was our friend. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: The Benzini Brothers (UsernameMDM)
Bricksandparts Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 I can't figure out who is the mafia! nobody seems super suspicious.
eiker86 Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Ok, tonight I request to be incestigated by the investigater. He/she can then tell someone he/she trusts to announce for he/she. I shall have my innocence proven, ok? What do you lot think on the plan But if we dont have any investegators. That would not happen. So we have to wait and see. *Goes back in the kitchen and makes some muffins*
Jedi master Brick Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 But if we dont have any investegators. That would not happen. So we have to wait and see. *Goes back in the kitchen and makes some muffins* It is a basic role, one of us should be one, but trust me
Fred Fred Burger Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Ok, tonight I request to be incestigated by the investigater. He/she can then tell someone he/she trusts to announce for he/she. I shall have my innocence proven, ok? What do you lot think on the plan Ok Firstly why should you get the luxury of being investigated while the Benzi Brothers do not? And secondly (For reasons already stated.) trying to force the Cop to contact someone simply for your own interests is a bad idea, honestly it's way to early to try and force it. If were lucky the cop may contact someone later in the game but again it's to early to try and force it. We need to give the cop some time to get his feet on the ground and figure out the allegiances of a few people first. But that's just my opinion ultimently the decesion lies with the cop the and if he thinks it's worth, go for it.
eiker86 Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 It is a basic role, one of us should be one, but trust me You remember that 3 townies are killed?
badboytje88 Posted October 20, 2011 Author Posted October 20, 2011 (edited) Ok Firstly why should you get the luxury of being investigated while the Benzi Brothers do not? And secondly (For reasons already stated.) trying to force the Cop to contact someone simply for your own interests is a bad idea, honestly it's way to early to try and force it. If were lucky the cop may contact someone later in the game but again it's to early to try and force it. We need to give the cop some time to get his feet on the ground and figure out the allegiances of a few people first. But that's just my opinion ultimently the decesion lies with the cop the and if he thinks it's worth, go for it. What is all this talking about a Cop, I tried to keep the cops out of this hole nasty situation by solving the crime ourselves! Votes so far: Benzini Brothers (8) Jedi Master Brick, darkdragon,Nightshroud99, Griggs, Volcanicpanik, K-nut, , Etzel, darthnihilius Jimbob (2) Eiker86, JediAnakin Tora (1) Bricksandparts Day 2 will be closed in about 7 hours. Conclusion will be up in about 20 hours (delay due to my visit to LEGOWorld, sorry for that). You may start sending in your night actions plus motivation if you have already figured out what to do. Edited October 21, 2011 by badboytje88
Nightshroud99 Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 You remember that 3 townies are killed? Yeah, what if one of them was a investigator? Besides even if someone investigates you tonight Jimbob, in order to tell us if you are ok they have to reveal their role... Which means death probably.
swils Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Yeah, what if one of them was a investigator? Besides even if someone investigates you tonight Jimbob, in order to tell us if you are ok they have to reveal their role... Which means death probably. Now there's something that even I hadn't really considered yet. Unless we're dealing with a single lowlife scumbag in our midst, it is entirely possible that there are plans in motion to draw out the investigator, with Jimbob as their scapegoat, taking one "for the team." It would certainly explain why he keeps drawing attention to himself. It seems terribly elaborate, but, honestly, it at least has a little credibility to it. I still don't have any idea who's guilty here or not, but I'm just not comfortable with killing someone because they were off practicing their act weren't all that talkative today. Sorry, Jimbob, but in my eyes, you're the only one with anything close to a real case against them right now, however much of a stretch it may be, and I need to put my vote *somewhere* again. I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob (Jedi master Brick)
Jedi master Brick Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 If you do chose to vote me out, take my last advice, watch out for Tora
UsernameMDM Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Simpleton idi-otas! Any a fool can a say "No no no, it a wasn't a me!" We a Bena-zini Brothas do not a dee cowering or the boo hoo hoo hoos when a faced with a dee danger. We a Bena-zini Brothas stand proud! (+gibberish, mustache rubbing and general curly chest-haired machismo) /strikes pose HIP-YIP-HO! I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob(Jedi master Brick) (+ gibberish)
Fred Fred Burger Posted October 20, 2011 Posted October 20, 2011 Though it seems to late as the Benzi Brothers are already convicted (for almost no reason I might add.) I will still vote for the person I fell is scum(I really think I've stated my reasons enough.) I read the Basics lesson post and I would like to vote: Jimbob (Jedi master Brick)
Recommended Posts