Hi, I just read the rules and they look like lots of fun
I am not on Facebook otherwise I'd "like" it!
I built a fleet a while ago for playing on the floor, check it out here:
http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=47266&view=findpost&p=858545
http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=49275
It was originally made for Evil Stevie's Pirate Game, but maybe I'll give your ruleset a try
When I was a kid I played something similar, albeit far simpler, on the floor, shooting the little cannons and removing any bricks and parts that were hit, it was great fun!
One question: The rules for Ship Island state that a player can shoot the ship that's anchored there and it gets replaced with the next in line; isn't this a cheap tactic to get a better vessel? I mean, why would anyone not use this when buying a new ship?
I'm looking forward to hearing more of this game.
Edit: Also, how is initiative handled? Who moves first, and is there any way to avoid being not able to hit an enemy at all when he sails his ship in a way that puts him outside my arc of fire because he was allowed to move after me?