Piratedave84 Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Hey, I thought we weren't supposed to teach people in this game? Isn't that what you told me earlier? Guilty
Duvors Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 I think I was pretty clear in my finger pointing. I re-read everything and it seems my vote is best placed with you. I'm suspicious of everyone, I don't know you or who you are and how you 'play'. That's fine mate, that's how this is done, throwing around stuff and seeing what sticks and all that, not really very good at that.That is I'm not very good at that.
Brickelodeon Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 I voted for Jamesn because he honestly seems to be top of my scum chart. He hasn't replied to anything, yet has been active recently. When this whole Duvors thing popped up, the attention went away from him, but he is no less scummy.
Pyrovisionary Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 By the way, earlier you mentioned that you had a really lone list of suspects but you haven't said anything since, will you tell us some more about it? Okay thank you for clearing that up, It's okay now, and thanks for the advice. And this teaches up a valuable lesson, don't metagame or vote due to events outside of the mafia game you're currently playing, it just make people angry. Wow, that took ages to type and no one posted anything while I was doing that. It's probably not my place to give advice so if I was patronizing I'm sorry and thank you for forgiving me . It was a scummy thing to do. And not in the mafia sense. Anyway I've got to sleep so don't generate 12 pages while I'm away!
def Posted October 6, 2014 Author Posted October 6, 2014 Vote: SpiderMan(Goliath) Sorry, didn't see defs post about not saying Spider-Man. Then why wouldn't you fix your vote? Vote: Furry (Jamesn) When scanning the thread, if it's not bold, a vote can be missed. For the host's sake, only bolded votes can count. Vote tally: Jamesn 5 (CutCobra, Goliath, Xenophobic Monoxide, Richila, Brickelodeon) Lord Duvors 7 (Jamesn, Dave, Mencot, Captain Settle, jluckhaupt, Adventurer1, Kintober) Stinky Dave 1 (mostlytechnic) Goliath 1 (Lind Whisperer) Richila 1 (StickFig) (If I missed something, let me know)
mostlytechnic Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 That vote count matches my tally, so I think you're right :)
Lind Whisperer Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Ok, now for all the latest voting. Captain, Lind, Lord, Richila, and Goliath - you've all made votes that were unsupported. Even if you're just voting for someone that many others are and for the same reason they've said, you still need to give your reason. That's critical info for the days ahead. We need to look back and see who voted for who and why. I voted for Goliath because he seemed to be over-eager in his proclamations against people he claimed to consider "suspicious". I am debating that choice, although I still say that he seemed over-eager. It might have just been a new player getting over-excited, or it might be worth noticing. The reason why I am considering a vote against Lord Duvors is because jluckhaupt posted a long list of his quotes, which evidenced a strong tendency towards fluff over actual points. Oh, and as for defending others... People need to pay close attention to WHY defending is being done. For example, when I was defending Goliath during the bandwagon, I was careful to always argue against the bandwagon, not defend the person. It had NOTHING to do with Goliath, everything to do with HOW the votes were happening. Very true. Excellent points.
def Posted October 6, 2014 Author Posted October 6, 2014 *Dammit, forgot about not editing and edited my last post due to a typo. * This will be the single in-game warning about editing. DO NOT EDIT. Future editing will get penalty votes, NO EXCEPTIONS.
Piratedave84 Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Where's StickFig? and Scaevola? Actually, I can see Scaevole watching us; say hi!
Duvors Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Right, I'm off to read the entire thread all over again.
Scaevola Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 After some ample consideration I feel ready to give my vote and current perspective. Goliath has undoubtedly been very irritating to the town, his multitudinous accusations have very much hindered the town with very weak justifications for his suspicions such as getting "bad vibes" and his emotions certainly dictate many of his accusations. However, he seems to be more of a inexperienced interpreter as opposed to scummy, and he has been active. Furthermore, I do concur that Lord Duvors is certainly a decent candidate for the lynch. He has contributed very little besides fluff to this circumstance, and of course his trust in others is very suggestive of scum, as Stinky Dave stated they're the only ones who know each other. Therefore I'll Vote: Lord Duvors (Lord Duvors) I also believe Brickelodeon to be acting very scummy as of late. Brickelodeon seems very eager to follow the majority sentiment, as she changed her vote in post #286 simply because the bandwagon fell apart. Furthermore, Brick stressed want to prosecute against Duvors and the sensibility of his lynching, but nonetheless voted against jamesn merely due to his current inactivity. Brick's little conflict with Duvors is interesting but Speedy did suggest the scum knocking off one of their own member to make themselves less suspicious. Also, as I said prior she did avoid voting for Duvors. I consider Duvors a good lynch, and considering the momentum behind it I will not vote for Brick instead, though I think Brickelodeon is the surest scum at the moment. If the town consolidates enough against Brick I'll gladly change my vote.
Brickelodeon Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Oh my... I will note that I am not the only one who changed my vote from Goliath, I was just the only one to change my vote from Goliath to Jamesn. What is the use of voting for someone who will not be convicted, I would rather use my vote to make a difference.
Piratedave84 Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Brick's little conflict with Duvors is interesting but Speedy did suggest the scum knocking off one of their own member to make themselves less suspicious. Where and when was that said? Do you know who else is missing from this party? TheLazyChicken! Voting pattern so far looks like this: StickFig votes Richila (1) Mencot Votes Goliath (1) Kintobor votes Goliath (2) XM votes Goliath (3) Lind Whisperer votes Goliath (4) Cutcobra votes Jamesn (1) Jamesn votes Lord Duvors (1) Brickelodeon votes Goliath (5) Captain Settle votes Goliath (6) MT votes Dave (1) Goliath votes Jamesn (2) Lord Duvors votes Goliath (7) Jluckhaupt votes Goliath (8) Lord Duvors unvotes Goliath (7) Mencot unvotes Goliath (6) Dave votes Lord Duvors (2) Mencot votes Lord Duvors (3) XM unvotes Goliath (5) votes jamesn (3) Captain Settle unvotes Goliath (4) votes Lord Duvors (4) (Ties vote) Richila votes Jamesn (4) (3 way tie) Lord Duvors Vote Jamesn (5) Jluckhaupt unvotes Goliath (3) votes Lord Duvors (5) (break tie, lead to Duvors) Adventurer1 votes Lord Duvors (6) Kintobor unvotes Goliath (2) votes Lord Duvors (7) Bricklodeon unvotes Goliath (1) votes Jamesn (6) Pyrovisionary votes Lord Duvors (8) Pyrovisionary unvotes Lord Duvors (7) Lord Duvors unvotes Jamesn (5) Scaveola votes Lord Duvors (8) In red are votes that have yet to be re-cast and TheLazyChicken has yet to vote
jluck Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 I voted for Goliath because he seemed to be over-eager in his proclamations against people he claimed to consider "suspicious". I am debating that choice, although I still say that he seemed over-eager. It might have just been a new player getting over-excited, or it might be worth noticing. The reason why I am considering a vote against Lord Duvors is because jluckhaupt posted a long list of his quotes, which evidenced a strong tendency towards fluff over actual points. Very true. Excellent points. I'd love to take credit for it, but I simply filled in some commentary, piratedave alerted us all to the actual posts I think we have roughly 24 hours left and there's still a lot to decide. Let's look long and hard at the posts and votes so we can be sure we get the 10 votes needed for a lynch.
Scaevola Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Where and when was that said? Do you know who else is missing from this party? TheLazyChicken! Voting pattern so far looks like this: StickFig votes Richila (1) Mencot Votes Goliath (1) Kintobor votes Goliath (2) XM votes Goliath (3) Lind Whisperer votes Goliath (4) Cutcobra votes Jamesn (1) Jamesn votes Lord Duvors (1) Brickelodeon votes Goliath (5) Captain Settle votes Goliath (6) MT votes Dave (1) Goliath votes Jamesn (2) Lord Duvors votes Goliath (7) Jluckhaupt votes Goliath (8) Lord Duvors unvotes Goliath (7) Mencot unvotes Goliath (6) Dave votes Lord Duvors (2) Mencot votes Lord Duvors (3) XM unvotes Goliath (5) votes jamesn (3) Captain Settle unvotes Goliath (4) votes Lord Duvors (4) (Ties vote) Richila votes Jamesn (4) (3 way tie) Lord Duvors Vote Jamesn (5) Jluckhaupt unvotes Goliath (3) votes Lord Duvors (5) (break tie, lead to Duvors) Adventurer1 votes Lord Duvors (6) Kintobor unvotes Goliath (2) votes Lord Duvors (7) Bricklodeon unvotes Goliath (1) votes Jamesn (6) Pyrovisionary votes Lord Duvors (8) Pyrovisionary unvotes Lord Duvors (7) Lord Duvors unvotes Jamesn (5) Scaveola votes Lord Duvors (8) In red are votes that have yet to be re-cast and TheLazyChicken has yet to vote I was referring to posts #290 and 294 Oh my... I will note that I am not the only one who changed my vote from Goliath, I was just the only one to change my vote from Goliath to Jamesn. What is the use of voting for someone who will not be convicted, I would rather use my vote to make a difference. That's not my scruple. It is scummy that you cited no reason to change your vote, but simply because you wanted to follow the majority, which is quite a scummy thing to do as they want to agree with the town to avert suspicion and latch onto bandwagons. Furthermore, you conveyed the message you wanted to avoid completing a lynch, which is very essential by avoiding Duvors (even though you said you thought his lynch was sensible) and voting for jamesn, whose lynch isn't likely to pick up votes.
TheLazyChicken Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Well the reason I haven't voted yet is because I am still not so sure of who to vote. Lord Duvors hasn't contributed much and Jamesn seems the most suspicious but I guess Jamesn is the most scummiest person so I guess my vote goes to him. Vote: Jamesn (Jamesn) I will change my vote if Lord Duvors gets the majority votes.
mostlytechnic Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 Well the reason I haven't voted yet is because I am still not so sure of who to vote. Lord Duvors hasn't contributed much and Jamesn seems the most suspicious but I guess Jamesn is the most scummiest person so I guess my vote goes to him. Care to give any REASON for that vote? Just saying someone is "the scummiest" isn't a reason.
Duvors Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 That's not my scruple. It is scummy that you cited no reason to change your vote, but simply because you wanted to follow the majority, which is quite a scummy thing to do as they want to agree with the town to avert suspicion and latch onto bandwagons. Furthermore, you conveyed the message you wanted to avoid completing a lynch, which is very essential by avoiding Duvors (even though you said you thought his lynch was sensible) and voting for jamesn, whose lynch isn't likely to pick up votes. Strangely enough, I agree with this completely, and I do think the way she avoided voting for me is strange, are you using reverse psychology to get me lynched Brickolodeon?
Piratedave84 Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 I'm re-reading Jamesn's posts and I can't quite figure out what you guys are referring to when you say he is scummier than Lord Duvors BUT I did find that he was odd; more precisely he has been attacking Cutcobra a LOT but yet voted for Duvors; I don't get that. I've been talking to Duvors behind the scenes and he is giving me the impression he is giving up which is not a very scummy thing to do; I'm starting to second guess my vote ...
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 6, 2014 Posted October 6, 2014 I'm re-reading Jamesn's posts and I can't quite figure out what you guys are referring to when you say he is scummier than Lord Duvors BUT I did find that he was odd; more precisely he has been attacking Cutcobra a LOT but yet voted for Duvors; I don't get that. I've been talking to Duvors behind the scenes and he is giving me the impression he is giving up which is not a very scummy thing to do; I'm starting to second guess my vote ... When I brought up the possibility of Mencot not being miller, jamesn attacked be and Cutcobra, saying that we were trying to sow seeds of doubt among the town or we were just "bad town". Merely for bringing up the possibility that there might not be a miller in this game. After I said he was being very accusatory, and might be trying to distract us from himself, he became very quiet. That is why I think he's scummy. As for Duvors, perhaps he's trying to make you think that he's giving up? Or maybe he's giving up because the vote is leaning towards him?
StickFig Posted October 7, 2014 Posted October 7, 2014 Where's StickFig? Awake (a little earlier today, because work!) and back. I have scanned everything (6 pages!) that happened while I was asleep, but not done a lot of thorough analysis. Here's my thoughts right now. Unvote: Richila (Richila) because she replied (finally) and while I still am not sure I trust her, I don't think she's the most suspicious right how. Having thought a little more, I am suspicious of Goliath, since he tried to say Lind Whisperer said something he didn't say, but I'm inclined to believe that it was just a mistake for now. I am going to do more reading on Duvors and jamesn; seems like a lot of people are calling Duvors out for posting fluff but there were people with at least as many posts as him (XenoMono, Pyrovisionary, Lind, etc when I compiled my list ~10 hours ago) so I don't know if that's suspicious. When I brought up the possibility of Mencot not being miller, jamesn attacked be and Cutcobra, saying that we were trying to sow seeds of doubt among the town or we were just "bad town". Merely for bringing up the possibility that there might not be a miller in this game. After I said he was being very accusatory, and might be trying to distract us from himself, he became very quiet. That is why I think he's scummy. This possibility intrigues me, but I'm not ready to vote jamesn yet. Getting ready to leave for the aforementioned work now; I should be able to post in a couple of hours when I get my lunch break.
Duvors Posted October 7, 2014 Posted October 7, 2014 I have to leave for now, I'll be back tomorrow. (Well tomorrow for me anyway.)
TheLazyChicken Posted October 7, 2014 Posted October 7, 2014 Care to give any REASON for that vote? Just saying someone is "the scummiest" isn't a reason. When Xenophobic Monoxide said that Mencot could not be the miller, he attacked him and Cutcobra. Thats what I found suspicious about him.
Richila Posted October 7, 2014 Posted October 7, 2014 I am here; I am reading and thinking but can't think of anything useful to add.
jimmynick Posted October 7, 2014 Posted October 7, 2014 Vote: Furry (Jamesn) No real reason, I just can't bring myself to vote for Goliath at this point. That's rubbish. I'm going to rename you Fluffy; see below: Aww, but I'm the cutest and fluffiest panda in the room! Give him time; he's gone to the scumboard! My feeling may be because Jamesn played to the slimy furry stereotype in the confirmation thread. That's called roleplay, and your vote is rubbish. See above. Why not speak up Jamesn? Like I said about 25 hours ago, just because I am logged into the thread doesn't mean I am reading or paying attention to the game. I have, for the most part, been attempting to read on my phone today but, because of the sheer number of posts, it isn't terribly practical to do so. This is revenge for Quest #100. That's rubbish. I will change my vote if Lord Duvors gets the majority votes. "I will change my vote if to do so will come at a time when changing my vote is irrelevant and unimportant" more precisely he has been attacking Cutcobra a LOT but yet voted for Duvors; I don't get that. Cutcobra seems to be deliberately dense and misinterpreting the things I say very clearly. That said, I don't at the moment believe he's scum. Call it a vibe.
Recommended Posts