Pyrovisionary Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 My favourite character from Sherlock is Irene; she can do great things with a furry panda like me. I like Moriate because he's got a smooth Irish accent like Roy from the IT crowd and Martin Freeman as Watson because I firstly like to imagine watson as a hobbit and secondly I get him confused with Morgan freeman and like to imagine what Morgan freeman would be Like in Sherlock. That would be a good series.
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Cool, we are a go then. How about I go easy on you old man since I have all that skill in my genes due to my dad. Now who told you that the force was in your genes? The prequels clearly explained it's because of the gidi dorians- uh, cidi mori- MIDI-CHLORIANS in your blood.
Brickelodeon Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Don't forget your place Luke. Obi-wan beat your father before he turned evil.
Mencot Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 "All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us" So I don´t see any other way to start this then to come straight out, I am a Miller. And what that means is that I am town and don´t have any powers but if I would be investigate I would turn up scum. Someone that isn´t familir with this role and want to know more can check it up here: Miller Now that that is out of the way and even though I am like that I am not useless in anyway and I will ofcourse help out the best a town can. This day 1 will go pretty much like this, fluff, fluff, fluff and some voting. Hopefuly we will vote good but biggest chance is we will lynch a town.
jluck Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 "All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us" So I don´t see any other way to start this then to come straight out, I am a Miller. And what that means is that I am town and don´t have any powers but if I would be investigate I would turn up scum. Someone that isn´t familir with this role and want to know more can check it up here: Miller Now that that is out of the way and even though I am like that I am not useless in anyway and I will ofcourse help out the best a town can. This day 1 will go pretty much like this, fluff, fluff, fluff and some voting. Hopefuly we will vote good but biggest chance is we will lynch a town. From my limited past experience, a miller claim this early tends to be true. Of course I've only seen it once or twice, but at least this is a starting point.
Brickelodeon Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 *chew* I'm not sure who to *chew* trust here. I don't think I'll trust anybody *chew*, as I usually get burned when I do. All I know *chew* is that I wan't some more of the delicious cupcakes!
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Interesting. The game begins. I'm not sure our host would introduce such a complex role to a simple, Mafia school game. It seems to me that you could be scum, attempting to justify your allegiance early on in the event you are investigated. Of course, I'm not sure a scum would draw attention to himself so quickly either...
Cutcobra Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Movie batman is reasonable, unlike comic Batman or Artic Batman. Is Artic Batman even canon? I think I once got it as a toy for my kids so... STILL MORE CANON THAN MOVIE BATMAN. Interesting. The game begins. I'm not sure our host would introduce such a complex role to a simple, Mafia school game. It seems to me that you could be scum, attempting to justify your allegiance early on in the event you are investigated. Of course, I'm not sure a scum would draw attention to himself so quickly either... I think I agree with you here. The host clearly said if we didn't mind something like a serial killer in case it was too complex and he didn't even mention the Miller. Anyways, I still think I'll see how everyone responds before I start having some suspicions.
Duvors Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 I'm not sure our host would introduce such a complex role to a simple, Mafia school game. It seems to me that you could be scum, attempting to justify your allegiance early on in the event you are investigated. Ummm... wait, you're saying all this as if this is a game... is this some fourth wall thing or something?As for the theory... that's pretty good actually... though killing off someone this early, even based on really good logic, is still most likely going to result in a town death because it's so early that we can't really judge anyone well... after all, it's the first day that will form the basis for deductions, but during the first day we don't really have any basis for... stuff like that.
jimmynick Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 "All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us" So I don´t see any other way to start this then to come straight out, I am a Miller. And what that means is that I am town and don´t have any powers but if I would be investigate I would turn up scum. Someone that isn´t familir with this role and want to know more can check it up here: Miller Now that that is out of the way and even though I am like that I am not useless in anyway and I will ofcourse help out the best a town can. This day 1 will go pretty much like this, fluff, fluff, fluff and some voting. Hopefuly we will vote good but biggest chance is we will lynch a town. Sounds good. Keep in mind that today, we must vote for the most anti-town person. If that person turns out to be a townie, that is no huge deal, because then we shall have separated a goat from the sheep. Or a raccoon from a panda? Or a dog from a cat? I can swing it any way you like it. Xenophobic Monoxide, keep in mind that the Miller is explicitly normal according to the link Dr. def gave. Or are you trying to sow seeds of doubt amongst the town?
Duvors Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Xenophobic Monoxide, keep in mind that the Miller is explicitly normal according to the link Dr. def gave. Or are you trying to sow seeds of doubt amongst the town? Uhhh... do you all have access to information I don't? But if Millers are... normal... that might be what he's doing... you never know the first day.
Scaevola Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 "All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us" So I don´t see any other way to start this then to come straight out, I am a Miller. And what that means is that I am town and don´t have any powers but if I would be investigate I would turn up scum. Someone that isn´t familir with this role and want to know more can check it up here: Miller Now that that is out of the way and even though I am like that I am not useless in anyway and I will ofcourse help out the best a town can. This day 1 will go pretty much like this, fluff, fluff, fluff and some voting. Hopefuly we will vote good but biggest chance is we will lynch a town. The miller claim certainly sounds suspicious. I concur with Xenophobic Monoxide that the role is indeed quite advanced for a Mafia School. Furthermore, it would be a very sensible method for a scum to claim such a role as it is of course difficult to decipher whether he is telling the truth. The earliness of the claim should be heeded, but in any case, it seems Mencot ought to be under scrupulous surveillance for a time.
Duvors Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 The miller claim certainly sounds suspicious. I concur with Xenophobic Monoxide that the role is indeed quite advanced for a Mafia School. Furthermore, it would be a very sensible method for a scum to claim such a role as it is of course difficult to decipher whether he is telling the truth. The earliness of the claim should be heeded, but in any case, it seems Mencot ought to be under scrupulous surveillance for a time. Well... you can just kill him and find out... but if he is town then that would be a bad thing... so darn.
Cutcobra Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Xenophobic Monoxide, keep in mind that the Miller is explicitly normal according to the link Dr. def gave. Or are you trying to sow seeds of doubt amongst the town? How is asking himself if the guy was telling the truth "sowing the seeds of doubt amongs the town"? Seriously, save your finger pointing for later and "voting for the least cute and fluffy" for later.
Lind Whisperer Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Movie batman is reasonable, unlike comic Batman or Artic Batman. Is Artic Batman even canon? Weak Artic Batman from puny The Batman WB cartoon series. Hulk SMASH! Puny Batman! How is asking himself if the guy was telling the truth "sowing the seeds of doubt amongs the town"? Seriously, save your finger pointing for later and "voting for the least cute and fluffy" for later. It fascinating question. How can group of all very suspicious people figure out who most suspicious? Hulk head hurt.
Captain Settle Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 I think I once got it as a toy for my kids so... STILL MORE CANON THAN MOVIE BATMAN. Hmm, did that toy make millions of pounds on its first weekend? Gandalf's claim seems a bit weird. My bat-deduction skills say we shouldn't trust him.
jimmynick Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Uhhh... do you all have access to information I don't? But if Millers are... normal... that might be what he's doing... you never know the first day. Roles which are explicitly Normal include: Vanilla Townie, Sane Cop, Doctor, Vigilante, Roleblocker, Mason, Innocent Child, Jailkeeper, Tracker, Watcher, Gunsmith, Miller, Bodyguard, Role Cop, Doublevoter, Hider, Neighbor,Neighborizer, Jack of All Trades, Serial Killer, Mafia Encryptor, Mafia Strongman, Mafia Goon, Mafia Traitor, Mafia Godfather, Mafia-aligned or SK-aligned versions of above roles Nope. No special information. I just did the "assigned reading", so to speak. ... the role is indeed quite advanced for a Mafia School... I'm not sure our host would introduce such a complex role to a simple, Mafia school game. How is asking himself if the guy was telling the truth "sowing the seeds of doubt amongs the town"? Seriously, save your finger pointing for later and "voting for the least cute and fluffy" for later. I understand that people who claim miller on Day One tend actually to be millers, because scum like to fly under the radar and not draw attention to themselves. It is pointless to suggest that some roles are "too advanced" for a Mafia School, since Dr. def gave a list of roles (quoted above) from which our roles are drawn. The miller is in that list. Furthermore, the first time I went to Mafia School, the scum had a Framer which, according to mafiawiki, is explicitly not normal. To play WIFOM with a Day One miller claim is to introduce doubt without actually being helpful. So those of you who doubt there could be a miller in this game have either not done their reading or are scum.
Scaevola Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Well... you can just kill him and find out... but if he is town then that would be a bad thing... so darn. We'll have to see how it plays out. He's a delectable choice for the scum if he's town (they could jump on a town bandwagon if the town's verdict is that he is scum), but he could just as easily have been a scum who took a risk to alleviate suspicion if he is investigated, like Xenophobic said previously. I'm very interested to see what Mencot has to say in defense.
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Well... you can just kill him and find out... but if he is town then that would be a bad thing... so darn. I don't wanna point fingers at what is probably just speculation, but it sounds like you're dropping hints that we should lynch this guy.
Lind Whisperer Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Gandalf's claim seems a bit weird. My bat-deduction skills say we shouldn't trust him. Hulk think it too big role for simple game. But there no way to prove or disprove without risk.
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Nope. No special information. I just did the "assigned reading", so to speak. I understand that people who claim miller on Day One tend actually to be millers, because scum like to fly under the radar and not draw attention to themselves. It is pointless to suggest that some roles are "too advanced" for a Mafia School, since Dr. def gave a list of roles (quoted above) from which our roles are drawn. The miller is in that list. Furthermore, the first time I went to Mafia School, the scum had a Framer which, according to mafiawiki, is explicitly not normal. To play WIFOM with a Day One miller claim is to introduce doubt without actually being helpful. So those of you who doubt there could be a miller in this game have either not done their reading or are scum. Unfortunately, I was not aware our host had posted any such list. If this is the case, I apologize for doubting our (probably) miller.
Pyrovisionary Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Weak Artic Batman from puny The Batman WB cartoon series. Hulk SMASH! Puny Batman! It fascinating question. How can group of all very suspicious people figure out who most suspicious? Hulk head hurt. You're not actually the hulk, this is a fancy dress party not bloody Disneyland. So stop talking like that. It's annoying. I agree that Miller being Explicitly normal means that having a Miller come out one day one isn't very suspicious. You could overthink it but hey, we don't have a lie detector.
Scaevola Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 Nope. No special information. I just did the "assigned reading", so to speak. I understand that people who claim miller on Day One tend actually to be millers, because scum like to fly under the radar and not draw attention to themselves. It is pointless to suggest that some roles are "too advanced" for a Mafia School, since Dr. def gave a list of roles (quoted above) from which our roles are drawn. The miller is in that list. Furthermore, the first time I went to Mafia School, the scum had a Framer which, according to mafiawiki, is explicitly not normal. To play WIFOM with a Day One miller claim is to introduce doubt without actually being helpful. So those of you who doubt there could be a miller in this game have either not done their reading or are scum. I agree this makes the claim more relevant, time to scan that reading...
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 You're not actually the hulk, this is a fancy dress party not bloody Disneyland. So stop talking like that. It's annoying. I agree that Miller being Explicitly normal means that having a Miller come out one day one isn't very suspicious. You could overthink it but hey, we don't have a lie detector. While this is true, there are other roles specified in the Explicitly Normal category. Many other roles. Surely too many for all or even most to be present in this game. So, just because we CAN have a miller, doesn't necessarily mean we DO.
Lind Whisperer Posted October 5, 2014 Posted October 5, 2014 We'll have to see how it plays out. He's a delectable choice for the scum if he's town (they could jump on a town bandwagon if the town's verdict is that he is scum), but he could just as easily have been a scum who took a risk to alleviate suspicion if he is investigated, like Xenophobic said previously. I'm very interested to see what Mencot has to say in defense. Hulk think we should not hurt strange Wizard who claim to be Miller. Hulk also think that people who don't like being in character miss have fun playing game on two levels.
Recommended Posts