Kintobor Posted October 9, 2014 Posted October 9, 2014 Looking at the chart above, there's a few things we can discern. 1. Richilla's lack of post more or less reflects her inactivity during the first 24 hours of day 1. She has stated it was because of her computer going on the fritz, which sounds reasonable. 2. Unlike Richilla, Captain Settle only posted 8 times during the first day, and he was present for the first 24 hours. 3. Looking at the chart briefly, it appears Lord Duvors did the most amount of jumping around in terms of his vote, unvoting and voting for jamesn twice, beforehand voting and unvoting for Goliath. Anything else we can discern?
Scaevola Posted October 9, 2014 Posted October 9, 2014 I did some digging and dredged up Lord Duvors's voting posts (Pg. 9, #247) Duvors votes for Goliath, citing that he is annoying. He offers no more justification. A quite obvious clinging to the Goliath bandwagon to go along with the majority, and procure a very early lynch. He then proceeds to unvote Goliath because he claimed doctor. This misconception is cleared up, but he discards the vote (Pg. 11, #265) Lord Duvors votes for jamesn. Duvors cites the fact that other people had voted for him and that there was "an idea floating around that he was scummy," This furthermore testifies to his scummy inclination to masquerade himself by agreeing with the majority, and lynch a townie. (Pg. 12, #300) Duvors unvotes jamesn when prompted by mostlytechnic that his vote is unsupported, and will be suspicious later. This could easily have been to done alleviate suspicion on him, or he was just being sensible. (Pg. 14, #342) Votes for jamesn again as the lynch on jamesn and himself gain momentum. He offers no reason besides "a vibe" that he's scummy. At this time jamesn has 6 votes and Duvors 8, and his very likely reason to vote was to bring jamesn, whose lynch was his savior closer to that objective. I essentially drew from this Duvors' habit of poor justification, and his need to concur with every move the town does, two exceedingly scummy tendencies.
StickFig Posted October 9, 2014 Posted October 9, 2014 Well, I for one am curious about Stickfig and Lind Whisperer both switching their votes after the lynching vote for Jamesn (which was Scaevola) came in? I am sure it looks weird... I explained here. ... 2. Unlike Richilla, Captain Settle only posted 8 times during the first day, and he was present for the first 24 hours. ... As I said yesterday, there is more reason to suspect Captain Settle: both of his votes were simple "get on the bandwagon" posts. There was no reasoning ("he's annoying" for Goliath, nothing at all for Lord Duvors), and no value added.
Brickelodeon Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 This sounds silly, but maybe there are some clues in the actual post that Dr. Def made. Now, I am not pointing any fingers, but here goes: Who would have access to a droid from Star-Wars? Only a Star-Wars character such as Obi-Was, Princess Lea, or Luke Skywalker, right? Supposing it wasn't a real droid that zapped him, who would be small enough to fit in a droid costume? Only a small animal such as a Raccoon, Rocket Raccoon.
Lind Whisperer Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 It's a bit of a stretch, but she's killed by what's effectively a giant joy buzzer. And who exactly is known for his joy buzzers? Of course, it could just be that he was busy and didn't have time to make unique figs. Which, seeing as how he specifically has mentioned having not enough time for anything fancy, might very well be the case.
Piratedave84 Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 This sounds silly, but maybe there are some clues in the actual post that Dr. Def made. Now, I am not pointing any fingers, but here goes: Who would have access to a droid from Star-Wars? Only a Star-Wars character such as Obi-Was, Princess Lea, or Luke Skywalker, right? Supposing it wasn't a real droid that zapped him, who would be small enough to fit in a droid costume? Only a small animal such as a Raccoon, Rocket Raccoon. You have to be kidding! Are you kidding? Is this a serious theory?
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 You have to be kidding! Are you kidding? Is this a serious theory? Obviously not.
Yzalirk Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 There are quite a few theories for the Droid but I agree with Lind Whisperer considering there aren't many ways to show someone getting zapped in LEGO form that would be simple. Unless someone else gets zapped but in a different way, maybe the theory of the Droid belonging to someone should be something to think about?
StickFig Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 I don't think there's any reason to read so much into the theatrical portrayals... this is Mafia, we go on what's been said by players, not by pictures posted by the host of a cosplay party where we are explicitly not the characters we're dressed up as.
jluck Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 This sounds silly, but maybe there are some clues in the actual post that Dr. Def made. Now, I am not pointing any fingers, but here goes: Who would have access to a droid from Star-Wars? Only a Star-Wars character such as Obi-Was, Princess Lea, or Luke Skywalker, right? Supposing it wasn't a real droid that zapped him, who would be small enough to fit in a droid costume? Only a small animal such as a Raccoon, Rocket Raccoon. Umm...no. There are quite a few theories for the Droid but I agree with Lind Whisperer considering there aren't many ways to show someone getting zapped in LEGO form that would be simple. Unless someone else gets zapped but in a different way, maybe the theory of the Droid belonging to someone should be something to think about? Umm...no. I did some digging and dredged up Lord Duvors's voting posts (Pg. 9, #247) Duvors votes for Goliath, citing that he is annoying. He offers no more justification. A quite obvious clinging to the Goliath bandwagon to go along with the majority, and procure a very early lynch. He then proceeds to unvote Goliath because he claimed doctor. This misconception is cleared up, but he discards the vote (Pg. 11, #265) Lord Duvors votes for jamesn. Duvors cites the fact that other people had voted for him and that there was "an idea floating around that he was scummy," This furthermore testifies to his scummy inclination to masquerade himself by agreeing with the majority, and lynch a townie. (Pg. 12, #300) Duvors unvotes jamesn when prompted by mostlytechnic that his vote is unsupported, and will be suspicious later. This could easily have been to done alleviate suspicion on him, or he was just being sensible. (Pg. 14, #342) Votes for jamesn again as the lynch on jamesn and himself gain momentum. He offers no reason besides "a vibe" that he's scummy. At this time jamesn has 6 votes and Duvors 8, and his very likely reason to vote was to bring jamesn, whose lynch was his savior closer to that objective. I essentially drew from this Duvors' habit of poor justification, and his need to concur with every move the town does, two exceedingly scummy tendencies. We should certainly build on the positives from yesterday. While we lost townies, be gathered lots of posts that can be used today in conjunction with the voting record. I was highly suspicious of Duvors yesterday and I still want to hear more on the topic. I hope today we have far less fluff and far more insight. I will look with suspicion on posts just to hear your voice. (That last line should read "I will be suspicious of people who post just to hear their own voice and look active)
Piratedave84 Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Obviously not. you realize that by this thoery, you would have possibly done the kill, right?
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 you realize that by this thoery, you would have possibly done the kill, right? Yes, and he's clearly joking. The pictures don't have clues- this is made obvious.
Piratedave84 Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Yes, and he's clearly joking. The pictures don't have clues- this is made obvious. Why you no stop speak for him?
Brickelodeon Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Oh, I wasn't joking... I knew it was a long shot, hence the: This sounds silly, but... line. But I was just trying to bring i a few alternatives. I'm trying to look in places where people wouldn't expect someone to look.
Mencot Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Good thing Dave clearing those newbies out! You have anything else to add to the discussion? First mafia lesson all should learn is, The images the host uses has no hidden clue, if he/she doesn´t say so!
Piratedave84 Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Good thing Dave clearing those newbies out! You have anything else to add to the discussion? First mafia lesson all should learn is, The images the host uses has no hidden clue, if he/she doesn´t say so! What? I don't understand what you mean? Clearing them as in they are town? As far as I'm concerned you're all scum. Do you care to tell us what you were up to last night?
StickFig Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Do you care to tell us what you were up to last night? Sleeping? What were you to last night?
Piratedave84 Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Sleeping? What were you to last night? I don't even know how to explain ... I'm going in the corner to cry ...
StickFig Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 up to* I don't even know how to explain ... I'm going in the corner to cry ... You don't seem to be very good at explaining yourself....
Mencot Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Sorry Dave, I will use an other word because clearing is understood a bit differently in mafia and should be used with carefulness. Good thing Dave that you sorted the newcomers out about the images. Dave if you don´t have anything better to come with than that,then it is better to be silent. I asked you to be with us and help town. I was actually sleeping but what did you do? Do you know anything who killed mostly?
def Posted October 10, 2014 Author Posted October 10, 2014 Well, discussion has died down. I suppose that means you've come to your conclusions. Voting is open. You have 48 hours to lynch someone. Vote Tally: Pyrovisionary 4 (penalty x 4)
Mencot Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Well, discussion has died down. I suppose that means you've come to your conclusions. Maybe their sleeping Okay (not ok-ey) so here goes, I haven´t come to any big conclusions based on today and yesterday. It has been quiet and all info is pretty much based on speculation. But to start somewhere, there is the list in my first post and then the players that have been named by others today that we should look into more closely. I start with voting for Vote: Stinky dave (piratedave) Why, because he is been like an enigma, raising more question rather then answering any. I don´t trust him, he is hidding something and is not really willing to be helpful. If not considering sarcasm and on purpose trying to missunderstand others etc. as helping town out. I am not convinced about his Great plan that he has and the fact that he threatens to use it on people who didn´t see his actions as helpful. And btw I would like to hear more from the players that are looking scummy based on the Jamesn and Mostly´s suspisions and also the ones that has only left 1 or 2 comments in the last 24 hrs. Speak up people, not only in the shadows (PMs) Btw 2, an lesson for the newbies and also for the more experienced. Be careful of what you say and to whom when talking to someone in PM, it is a great way of communication but it can be very deadly foir oneself and also for town. Trust me, I know!
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 I definitely think Stinkydave is suspect, but I'm not ready to cast my vote for him yet. At the moment, I would say he and Captain Settle look the most suspicious. I'm mainly trying to figure out why the scum would consider mostlytechnic a threat?
jluck Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 (Snip) Btw 2, an lesson for the newbies and also for the more experienced. Be careful of what you say and to whom when talking to someone in PM, it is a great way of communication but it can be very deadly foir oneself and also for town. Trust me, I know! I second this comment, we lost the last game because I trusted speedy far too early, and the good dr def turned out to be far from good This is a good time to start making friends, but always play with suspicion!
Brickelodeon Posted October 10, 2014 Posted October 10, 2014 Here are my thoughts: Why doesn't Duvors get a voting penalty? He edited (albeit accidentally) one of his posts, right? Also, Cutcobra completely disappeared after he got accused of scumminess, and he has only made 1 post in this thread, and it was just re-stating stuff we already new. I was quite convinced jamesn was scum and now it just seems my super detective bat skills aren't working.Yesterday, jamesn and mostlytechnic each posted who they were suspicious of. As others said, we should look toward these people. I'm specially interested in Captain Settle, who mostlytechnic was suspicious of and who barely posted anything in day 1. He is on the top of my watch list, as he seemed pretty scummy early on, then just stopped posting after people pointed it out. I may change later, but for now. Vote: Cutcobra(Cutcobra) I might also point out that he said that he was suspicious of Captain Settle, who mostlytechnic was suspicious of. Basically just going along with a future band wagon that he sees coming.
Recommended Posts