def Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 Sorry I'm late, voting is now open. You have about 48 hours to mandatory vote. Vote Tally: Captain Settle 2 (penalty x 2)
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Well, sorry LazyChicken, but I'm voting for you due to the reasons I stated before. My apologies if you are telling the truth and jluck rolled you under the bus, but you're our safest and most-scummy bet at the moment. Vote: TheLazyChicken
Brickelodeon Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 I am still strongly suspicious of Captain Settle, but we really need a lynch, and LazyChicken seems like the next best option. Vote: TheLazyChicken(TheLazyChicken)
Kintobor Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Vote: Brickelodeon Particularly after I was blocked last night after trying to investigating Xenophobic Monoxide. I am the town cop. My Night One investigation was mostlytechnic, who turned up Town, my Night Two investigation was Captain Settle, who turned up Town, and my Night Three investigation was adventurer1, who also turned up town. Someone blocked me last night on my investigation of Xenophobic Monoxide, most likely the last scum. In my opinion, it's either Brickelodeon or Xenomono, or heck, both. TheLazyChicken seems like he got thrown under the bus. There's no reason to lynch him when he seems to have been jluck trying to get a town lynch should he die. Was anyone else confronted by jluck in private? We'd really like to know. Now.
Brickelodeon Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 What the heck? You haven't even investigated me, and you are saying I'm scum. That doesn't make sense. Just the fact that Lord Duvors tried to start a bandwagon against me should prove that I'm town.
Cutcobra Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Vote: Brickelodeon Particularly after I was blocked last night after trying to investigating Xenophobic Monoxide. I am the town cop. My Night One investigation was mostlytechnic, who turned up Town, my Night Two investigation was Captain Settle, who turned up Town, and my Night Three investigation was adventurer1, who also turned up town. Someone blocked me last night on my investigation of Xenophobic Monoxide, most likely the last scum. In my opinion, it's either Brickelodeon or Xenomono, or heck, both. TheLazyChicken seems like he got thrown under the bus. There's no reason to lynch him when he seems to have been jluck trying to get a town lynch should he die. Was anyone else confronted by jluck in private? We'd really like to know. Now. If we lynch TheLazyChicken and it doesn't work, I hope the vigilante kills Brickelodeon so you won't have to worry (unless there's two scum and one blocks Brickelodeon, but if that happens, I suggest to the vigilante to tell us therefore Brickelodeon guilty). Vote: TheLazyChicken.
Captain Settle Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Vote: TheLazyChicken. I'm sorry, Jluck may have just thrown you under the bus, but you're our best lead, and we really need a lynch today to progress.
Yzalirk Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Vote: Brickelodeon Particularly after I was blocked last night after trying to investigating Xenophobic Monoxide. I am the town cop. My Night One investigation was mostlytechnic, who turned up Town, my Night Two investigation was Captain Settle, who turned up Town, and my Night Three investigation was adventurer1, who also turned up town. Someone blocked me last night on my investigation of Xenophobic Monoxide, most likely the last scum. In my opinion, it's either Brickelodeon or Xenomono, or heck, both. TheLazyChicken seems like he got thrown under the bus. There's no reason to lynch him when he seems to have been jluck trying to get a town lynch should he die. Was anyone else confronted by jluck in private? We'd really like to know. Now. I'm going to trust that you are an Investigator and I previously did think Brickelodeon suspicious and with it seemingly like him (or her) and Xenophobic Monoxide trying to lay the blame on TheLazyChicken, I feel that they are scummier. I hope this isn't a bad decision on my part. Vote: Brickelodeon
Kintobor Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 LazyChicken and Stickfig are the only two who haven't voted. If they are town, they'd better make their vote soon.
TheLazyChicken Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Here is what was said in the PM's: I need to get the rest of the PM's yet. Those were all the PM's we sent to each other, as you can see, he PMed Mencot and Adventurer1, which both got killed during the night. We also know Captain Settle and Lind Whisperer are town. Cutcobra is also probably town as Jluck said that I should keep an eye on him, which wouldn't be something scum would want town to do on another scum. Vote: Brickelodeon Particularly after I was blocked last night after trying to investigating Xenophobic Monoxide. I am the town cop. My Night One investigation was mostlytechnic, who turned up Town, my Night Two investigation was Captain Settle, who turned up Town, and my Night Three investigation was adventurer1, who also turned up town. Someone blocked me last night on my investigation of Xenophobic Monoxide, most likely the last scum. Well, we have a confirmed townie now, if you are telling the truth. So you got blocked for trying to investigate Xenophobic Monoxide? Interesting... I am starting to believe he might actually be scum, but Jluck kinda eager of killing him is weird as well. But also Xenophobic Monoxide couldn't block you if he was scum either, Brickelodeon does fit this category well too. Probably Jluck chose to classify Brickelodeon as slight scum lead so I wouldn't guess him as scum, reverse physiology, what he was probably trying to do. He would've probably trying to put some scum in the scum section of his thoughts, so that if he died, the people he suspected would've made me think they were town. Also since I am not going to vote for myself and Brickelodeon seems suspicious, I declare my vote for him. Vote: Brickelodeon (Brickelodeon) If you do something that strikes me as town, I will unvote for you. Also, where is Stickfig, he hasn't talked for a while.
StickFig Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 LazyChicken, all of this "I'm gonna get lynched" and "I'm a goner for sure" talk just makes you sound more and more like a scum who's trying to subconciously beg not to get lynched. That's what Lord Duvors was doing, when he was all like "oh just kill me now I have no way to defend anyways". Yep, and we let Duvors off the hook for two days because of it. Not falling for that again. Particularly after I was blocked last night after trying to investigating Xenophobic Monoxide. So you got blocked for trying to investigate Xenophobic Monoxide? Interesting... But also Xenophobic Monoxide couldn't block you if he was scum either, Brickelodeon does fit this category well too. I think I must not understand how the blocking thing works. Does the blocking person block the cop from being investigated, or from investigating? And since no one has counter-claimed cop and we've all spoken up, I think it's good to assume Kintobor is telling the truth. And I think Kintobor should be sharing as much as possible in PM to as many people as you trust, because it's likely you've just sealed your fate tonight if we don't lynch the right person. Also, where is Stickfig, he hasn't talked for a while. Sorry, was asleep. I'm back now, but will be at work for almost a 12-hour shift today probably. I don't think we got enough votes to lynch Brickelodeon, so vigilante you know what to do. If several votes change in the next 24 hours, we'll work a new plan, but for now I'm still good with this one. And if TheLazyChicken comes up town tomorrow, XenoMono is next on our list. Vote: TheLazyChicken (TheLazyChicken) Day Five Xenophobic Monoxide votes TheLazyChicken (1) Brickelodeon votes TheLazyChicken (2) Kintobor votes Brickelodeon (1) Cutcobra votes TheLazyChicken (3) Captain Settle votes TheLazyChicken (4) Goliath votes Brickelodeon (2) TheLazyChicken votes Brickelodeon (3) StickFig votes TheLazyChicken (5)
TheLazyChicken Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 I think I must not understand how the blocking thing works. Does the blocking person block the cop from being investigated, or from investigating? Sorry, was asleep. I'm back now, but will be at work for almost a 12-hour shift today probably. Yes, the person can block someone from investigating someone that night. And are you always asleep?
def Posted October 23, 2014 Author Posted October 23, 2014 I only have a moment to post, but I have to step in to say, posting screen grabs is completely unacceptable behavior in a mafia game. It is not explicitly stated in the rules, but it is against the spirit of the game, attempting to use "photographic evidence" instead of claiming what was said. Let this be a massive warning to all: do not do this. When you reply to a PM, you can quote it. Copy-paste that.
TheLazyChicken Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 I only have a moment to post, but I have to step in to say, posting screen grabs is completely unacceptable behavior in a mafia game. It is not explicitly stated in the rules, but it is against the spirit of the game, attempting to use "photographic evidence" instead of claiming what was said. Let this be a massive warning to all: do not do this. When you reply to a PM, you can quote it. Copy-paste that. Oh, ok, sorry, my bad, I didn't know I couldn't do that. Thanks for letting me know. Hey, Brickelodeon was on and didn't say anything during the time she was on, she didn't even say what she thought on what Jluck said. But maybe she just didn't have to say anything useful.
Kintobor Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 As much as this breaks the rules... this does make TheLazyChicken look town. jluck was clearly trying to look good, and by conversing with and defending you he made you look suspicious. It's a scummy move on his part.
Brickelodeon Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 You are right Kintobor. I have to admit that even though it was against the spirit of the game, it really changes my opinion of you. However, we need a lynch. Don't think that I'm not changing my vote because I want to stay alive, the Vig will kill me tonight, so I have nothing to gain. When I say "you" I mean LazyChicken, my bad.
def Posted October 23, 2014 Author Posted October 23, 2014 Thread temporarily locked to make some hard decisions.
def Posted October 23, 2014 Author Posted October 23, 2014 I've made the decision to remove The Lazy Chicken from the game. This thing about posting PM screen shots is explicitly ruled on many mafia website, but hadn't been done here because, frankly, I don't think anybody has ever done it. Screen grabs can be faked, and private conversations can be faked (I have had fake conversations in the past few mafia where I was scum), but there is a difference of copy-pasting text (where you have the freedom to fake things) versus showing reputedly verified evidence. It's simply not mafia. Normally, mafia school has a pass/fail system, but The Lazy Chicken will get an N/A. There will be no lynch this day, but I will give you all to the end of normal day hours (with an extension, if requested) to discuss and consider what you will do for night five, and day six. It's all unfortunate.
StickFig Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 Not sure what to say at this point - not sure that there is much left to say. Yes, the person can block someone from investigating someone that night. Yes, but does the blocker block the cop, or block the person being investigated? Kintobor makes it sound as if they blocker was blocking XenoMono, so when Kintobor tried to investigate, she couldn't because XenoMono was blocked. If that's the case, then XenoMono is scum, but that's not how I understand blocking to work. Not that that exonerates XenoMono, but.... And are you always asleep? Only when everyone else is awake, it seems.
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 Is it possible that the blocker is trying to frame me, so that the rest of you will believe I'm scum? Remember jluck tried to lynch me fervently- he wouldn't target, or scummify his last mafia buddy.
Kintobor Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 Sorry for any confusion, I was blocked last night. I would've been blocked no matter who I investigated, but considering what happened yesterday and my vote against Brickelodeon, I have a feeling it's Brickelodeon.
Cutcobra Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 So, if Brickelodeon is not scum tommorrow I'll think Kintobor is scum and faking being cop or maybe Xenophobic is.
Brickelodeon Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 As much as I want to argue with Kintobor's logic, I do seem scummier that XM. After all, Jluck did vote for him over me.
Brickelodeon Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 Just for the record, since I will be departing from this illustrious game tonight, there are several people of whom I am suspicious. Captain Settle - I know Kintobor said he turned up town, but there most likely is a godfather in this game, and if it's anyone, it's Captain Settle. I have been trying to get him lynched for a couple days now, but nobody seems to think he is as suspicious as I do. Goliath - He barely escaped getting lynched the first day, but then he just stopped talking and now he's totally off the hook. Pretty scummy in my opinion. Then he totally is trying to get me lynched, and just saying "no" to all of the logical arguments I give in my defense. Cutcobra - He seems to have formulated the perfect plan to get 3 townies killed in one night. Think about it, he could be winning the entire game for the scum by having the vig kill me, there would only be 3 town left to fight the unknown number of scum (one or two). He also said that I wasn't the scummiest on his list, then he voted for me anyway. The perfect "I thought he was town but we needed a lynch" spiel. To be honest, I don't find XM all that scummy, he just seems a bit bewildered. And StickFig - All he does is give stats. That is like, the number one sign of scum. Then he goes and "sleeps" for 18 hours while we are lynching someone. He comes back just in time to join the bandwagon against some townie. I think he is just slipping under the radar and laughing at us for not noticing him.
Cutcobra Posted October 23, 2014 Posted October 23, 2014 How is that a "perfect plan" to kill townies? How do you even know if TheLazyChicken was town? Now I don't know about you, but he seemed the scummiest and that's why I wanted him lynched. Then there's you who some of us still think is scum. And if you could provide what a better kill for the vig was other than you then that would be great. (by the way, you only seem to state your suspicions now instead of earlier. I only suggested to the vig that he kill you since you were the second scummiest on my list, I didn't tell him to).
Recommended Posts