11. Magneto's Awesome Helmet Zepher

12. Flash's Lightning Cowl

13. Joker's Silly Green Hair mostlytechnic

14. Superman's Pompadour

15. Mary Jane's Locks Fhomess

16. Iron Patriot's Helmet

17. War Machine's Similar Helmet

18. Egon's Proton Pack

19. The Lone Ranger's White Hat jluck

20. Storm's Lightning Lego Spy

How could I resist?

11. Magneto's Awesome Helmet Zepher

12. Flash's Lightning Cowl

13. Joker's Silly Green Hair mostlytechnic

14. Superman's Pompadour

15. Mary Jane's Locks Fhomess

16. Iron Patriot's Helmet

Mencot

17. War Machine's Similar Helmet

18. Egon's Proton Pack

19. The Lone Ranger's White Hat jluck

20. Storm's Lightning Lego Spy

Lets try that.

Well, since mostlytechnic stole my glorious green mane...

11. Magneto's Awesome Helmet Zepher

12. Flash's Lightning Cowl

13. Joker's Silly Green Hair mostlytechnic

14. Superman's Pompadour

15. Mary Jane's Locks Fhomess

16. Iron Patriot's Helmet

Mencot

17. War Machine's Similar Helmet Tamamono

18. Egon's Proton Pack

19. The Lone Ranger's White Hat jluck

20. Storm's Lightning Lego Spy

11. Magneto's Awesome Helmet Zepher

12. Flash's Lightning Cowl Walter Kovacs

13. Joker's Silly Green Hair mostlytechnic

14. Superman's Pompadour

15. Mary Jane's Locks Fhomess

16. Iron Patriot's Helmet

Mencot

17. War Machine's Similar Helmet

18. Egon's Proton Pack

19. The Lone Ranger's White Hat jluck

20. Storm's Lightning Lego Spy

Yeah! Got my cowl. Hopefully it helps.

You missed my choice, Flash...

Tammo and I must have posted pretty close to each other. War Machine's helmet should be gone from my list. That only leaves two items (Egon's pack and Superman's hair).

Since we are coming up on voting time, I suppose we should start talking about how to go about voting.

As usual, this will be a messy and almost baseless Day 1 lynch. There has been very little idle chit-chat, which usually is what Day 1 lynches are based on. With everyone focused only on their headgear, we are left with less to go on than a typical Day 1 start. This has to favor the scum among us.

The only thing I can think of is who selected which items. But since all of the items have unknown properties, I can't see how that would help. preference for one item over another won't be significant until we get a feel for which items have the cool abilities.

There was jLuck's trying to grab two items. I guess that could be construed as suspicious. Or just not understanding the rules.

Crap. Strike that. It was Lind Whisperer who tried to double up. Greedy bastard.

Sorry jluck, didn't mean to drag your good name through the mud.

Tammo and I must have posted pretty close to each other. War Machine's helmet should be gone from my list. That only leaves two items (Egon's pack and Superman's hair).

Yeah, and we're only waiting on StarLord and Superman to choose an item.

As usual, this will be a messy and almost baseless Day 1 lynch. There has been very little idle chit-chat, which usually is what Day 1 lynches are based on. With everyone focused only on their headgear, we are left with less to go on than a typical Day 1 start. This has to favor the scum among us.

Yes. However, it is kind of balanced by the fact that a lot of townies will probably have power roles tonight (since townies have to choose items)

There was jLuck's trying to grab two items. I guess that could be construed as suspicious. Or just not understanding the rules.

Crap. Strike that. It was Lind Whisperer who tried to double up. Greedy bastard.

I looked at Lind Whisperer's Mafia record - only one game (a Mafia School). So he's fairly new. Could be a newbie mistake, but then again, it could be an over-eager Scum.

Tammo and I must have posted pretty close to each other. War Machine's helmet should be gone from my list. That only leaves two items (Egon's pack and Superman's hair).

Since we are coming up on voting time, I suppose we should start talking about how to go about voting.

As usual, this will be a messy and almost baseless Day 1 lynch. There has been very little idle chit-chat, which usually is what Day 1 lynches are based on. With everyone focused only on their headgear, we are left with less to go on than a typical Day 1 start. This has to favor the scum among us.

The only thing I can think of is who selected which items. But since all of the items have unknown properties, I can't see how that would help. preference for one item over another won't be significant until we get a feel for which items have the cool abilities.

There was jLuck's trying to grab two items. I guess that could be construed as suspicious. Or just not understanding the rules.

Crap. Strike that. It was Lind Whisperer who tried to double up. Greedy bastard.

Sorry jluck, didn't mean to drag your good name through the mud.

Really today it looks like everyone is just choosing their item based on what they want to match their costume. Mine was taken so I couldn't complete the savvy look I wanted so I choose this really adventurous looking hat.

I understand how you came to choose your hat. The one you wanted wasn't available. But what about those whose items were available but they didn't choose it? Or chose off of the first list, when their item was destined to be on the second? Is there any significance to that? Probably not, but there might be.

Crap. Strike that. It was Lind Whisperer who tried to double up. Greedy bastard.

I didn't see the one costume rule. I thought that each player was going to get a hat and an accessory.

Just curious, but why not choose your own hat?

Just curious, but why not choose your own hat?

Diversity

Adventure

Loving pirates

For the hell of it

Because I felt like it

...

Why not?

You missed one Dave,

Because your scum

amiright?

Just curious, but why not choose your own hat?

I just wanted to try something different. And it was a chance to make an eagles reference.

You missed one Dave,

Because your scum

amiright?

That's kind of a strong accusation to make this early in Day One...

You missed one Dave,

Because your scum

amiright?

Undoubtedly!

I looked at Lind Whisperer's Mafia record - only one game (a Mafia School). So he's fairly new. Could be a newbie mistake, but then again, it could be an over-eager Scum.

It could be a newbie scum mistake as well. Everything is guilty until proven innocent in this game.

(Although it's probably just a newbie mistake. )

I understand how you came to choose your hat. The one you wanted wasn't available. But what about those whose items were available but they didn't choose it? Or chose off of the first list, when their item was destined to be on the second? Is there any significance to that?

I think you're reading too much into that, mate.

Voting starts in a few hours, right? How should we play this? A no-lynch (considering we have basically no evidence)?

Eh, maybe something will happen between then and now.

It could be a newbie scum mistake as well. Everything is guilty until proven innocent in this game.

(Although it's probably just a newbie mistake. )

I think you're reading too much into that, mate.

Voting starts in a few hours, right? How should we play this? A no-lynch (considering we have basically no evidence)?

Eh, maybe something will happen between then and now.

A no-lynch will give no more info than we have now.

A no-lynch will give no more info than we have now.

But a random lynch has an extremely large chance to cut down our numbers.

I think it's always to the town's advantage to lynch someone. It's our only way to narrow down our search.

A no-lynch will give no more info than we have now.

I think it's always to the town's advantage to lynch someone. It's our only way to narrow down our search.

On the one hand, I agree with you, but after my mistake, I'm probably the person most likely to be lynched - unless, like you said

But a random lynch has an extremely large chance to cut down our numbers.

There's a difference between a Day One lynch and a random lynch. Some people might vote randomly, but that doesn't mean that that's the right way to go.

We're lynching today, and we'll do so off of behavior.

, something happens between now and later.

(That sentence would have been written better, except I pressed "Post" instead of "More Reply Options". Not my lucky day...)

I think it's always to the town's advantage to lynch someone. It's our only way to narrow down our search.

I agree with this thinking 100%...except...

I'm just wondering, in this type of game, do we have more than usual night roles? Remember, a constume dies with its owner, so a lynch does more than remove a player.

If that is the case, the person we lynch should always tell us what their costume does before they die. That is, if they are town.

I agree with this thinking 100%...except...

I'm just wondering, in this type of game, do we have more than usual night roles? Remember, a constume dies with its owner, so a lynch does more than remove a player.

It is something to consider, but at this point we don't know what they do. That will take time to figure out.