So why dosen't it have it's own forum?

I think you'll run into a lot of people who disagree with the "it's better than other non-system themes" :-D

But in reality it doesn't get enough topics to warrant a sub-forum IMO

isnt it one of the best selling themes?

jifel

Over 36,000 members from one website think so.

I totally don't agree that it's better than the other non-System themes.

But just as Star Wars doesn't have it's own forum, so should not Bionicle.

One bad year and blammo... a dead forum. Ah! Unless that forum encompasses ALL non-System themes!

Over 36,000 members from one website think so.

Hardly relevant when they're not members on this website ;-) (I'm sure that if there was a large, active part of this website's members dedicated to quality discussion about Bionicle it would have it's own subforum.) And I also disagree about Bionicle being better than the other non-system themes. ;-)

Personally I think if any theme from "non-system" gets it's own theme it should be technic. Why?

1. It is very different from other themes

2. It has been around for over 20 years, longer than many other themes

3. Bionicle could then be a sub-theme of it, because that is how bioncle started out anyway...

Even so, I can't see any reason for change. It isn't like it is hard to find Technic releated threads anyway. Besides, I think Bionicle will be gone in a few years. The last two lines went on sale very fast in my local stores.

So why dosen't it have it's own forum?

...

Over 36,000 members from one website think so.

Sounds like a good place for someone to start a Bionicle forum ... another website.

My thought is that bionicle should be a sub forum to non-system themes since most posts in that forum is about bionicle and it can't be compared to technic.

Besides i know that there are people who couldn't care less about technic, just like i feel about B but i'm getting tired of seeing threads that seem to be speculations about the storyline. Separate bionicle so the forum gets less crowded, or move it all to BZP as others suggest

Edited August 11, 200717 yr by EyesOnly

Yeah, I'm trying to get storyline speculations confined to one thread.

Unfortunately, it sometimes feels like threads are made just in the hopes there'll be high post counts and delusionally, popularity from it. :-|

I do sympathize with the non-Bionicle crowd. It does get a bit much.

Personally I think if any theme from "non-system" gets it's own theme it should be technic. Why?

1. It is very different from other themes

2. It has been around for over 20 years, longer than many other themes

3. Bionicle could then be a sub-theme of it, because that is how bioncle started out anyway...

Even so, I can't see any reason for change. It isn't like it is hard to find Technic releated threads anyway.

I think this is the best idea do far.

Besides, I think Bionicle will be gone in a few years. The last two lines went on sale very fast in my local stores.

I don't think so about this though.

How many times are we going to have that discussion :-|

Lets answer it as clearly as possible: NO. Bionicle will NOT have its own forum !!

Topic closed !!

*yoda*