Hinckley Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 puDding perniLLa :wub: dd said… (19 Aug 15, looking at version 2) I never understand why people look at old games while arguing but there must be a reason:Viewing Topic: Baritones 3: The Conclusion Citing precedent! Block precedes kill.
Dragonfire Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Sure... an hour counts as a while ago with a thread this hoppin' I only got online and saw this thread for the first time less than an hour ago (from your post), so as far as I'm concerned it was there the whole time I've done it twice now. It's awesome. Are you thinking of doing it again? I'd love to play an anonymous game
TheLazyChicken Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Are you thinking of doing it again? I'd love to play an anonymous game Count me in too!
Hinckley Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Did happen actuaLLy said… (Yesterday, looking at version 2) To be fair, Pandora, Hink did tell me he shat rainbows. CMP said… (Yesterday, looking at version 2) Congrats, CK. Being a fool of your own volition was the unofficial theme of Day Eight, didn’t you get the memo? Hindsight is 20/20...and I'm still floating different theories. And great game, Pandora! It really is a shame we, again, were not on the same side. We'll win a game together some day. Sorry about lynching you and all.
Tariq j Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Good game everyone! Stunning story as always TPRU!
mostlytechnic Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Wow, what a game! Just ask my wife, even though I've been dead for like a month, it's still consumed many many hours keeping up with all the crazy. And for those too lazy to read the massive deadboard, here's Mostly's rules of EB mafia: 1. Don't claim to Hinck (or def) - sure, it'll probably turn out ok since the odds are they're town, but if they're not, you're totally screwed. 2. If two people are viciously fighting in thread (see day 8 for a perfect example), they're BOTH TOWN. 3. EB mafia players should all toss a few bucks in a pot and buy hinck (and def) some valium when they play :) But seriously, how does the vig get lynched day 1 and not claim? And we were all cheering when solid logic posts got put up. I know ChromeKnight and adam got big kudos on the dead board for sure. Others as well, but they're the two that I remember the most.
Pandora Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 The most important thing is for me to say is thank you to TinyPies. I hate commenting on anything about a game while it's ongoing, but your story, your MOCs, your photography (seriously, wow, your photography) and your sense of humour made this a fantastic game. The icing on the cake would have been to win, but the moment I got my role PM I pretty much thought "I'm ducked". To have lasted to day eleven, and to have fought to the end, well, I'm holding my head up. I'll miss Petrus, he's a character I truly love, and I didn't get as much chance to be the Byzantine Alchemist Pyromaniac as I could have, but Pyromaniac + guilty conscience as SK = bad play, so I left it out. Petrus had his moment of awesome fighting the fire giant, so that makes me happy; thank you. So, hello everyone, sorry for killing most of you. In fact sorry to everyone I killed (or got lynched). Danny, I really did think you were scum. My entire argument around killing you was, perversely, the truth. Sorry dude. Chromeknight, I'm sure it's a kick in the teeth that I killed you after we worked so hard together, and I'm really sorry. You played a great game, and for the record I never thought you were scum, even when people were voting for you. And great game, Pandora! Thank you. Sorry. Great game from you too. A few other brief notes: well done to Tariqj and RangeroftheForest on playing pretty well in your first game. I think Tariq you managed to keep up with what was happening and argue well, and Ranger, never give up. It's pretty much the most important thing about mafia, and when you posted that you thought it wasn't for you I felt quite sad for you. You just have to fight, and keep fighting - it's a team game and if you don't fight you let down your team, and that's no good for anyone. I think you should give it another try at least, as some of the things you said were good. I thought you were town and might have even supported you if I hadn't been the SK but another body was just helpful for me. Same with Tariq. Also mediumsnowman; you were listed as a reserve and I constantly saw you reading the day threads, and that bodes very well for the future, because it shows you're a keen and interested player. I hope to see the three of you playing more in the future.
Hinckley Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 3. EB mafia players should all toss a few bucks in a pot and buy hinck (and def) some valium when they play :) Nah. I actually have an adverse reaction to it. It makes me hyper and talkative. But seriously, how does the vig get lynched day 1 and not claim? This should be rule 4. Thank you. Sorry. Great game from you too. No need to apologize! I did say (thinking the game was ending after Pie was lynched) that I'd be happy to see you win as SK, especially after you helped me through Unrest. However, I didn't say I'd help you do so if I was still alive and kicking and I had to play my role. My conscience in this game, Cornelius Murdock, who provided me the constant reassurance I need or I will die, said he felt bad for you playing so hard and losing right before the end. Poor guy had to do a lot of "No, I don't think there are three Scum teams." "No, I doubt he was a reverse death miller." He was truly the 24th player of the game. and Ranger, never give up. It's pretty much the most important thing about mafia, and when you posted that you thought it wasn't for you I felt quite sad for you. You just have to fight, and keep fighting - it's a team game and if you don't fight you let down your team, and that's no good for anyone. I think you should give it another try at least, as some of the things you said were good. I second this (and for Tariq and medium too)! Just look at how crazy this game was. It is not a great litmus test for the basics of Mafia. It was pretty nuts and I agree that you played the game pretty well, all things considered. Please join us again! dd said… (12 Aug 15, looking at version 2) My memory might be bad, it is bad, but I think any game where the SK has won was a “win with the town” victory. I came close in def’s game but didn’t win it due to my own mistake. Being one of the last could be the condition, it’s nearly win with town but not quite. I bet hinck has her kill cmp and then she could probably get town to lynch hinck. That would be my guess on the SK winning end (unless it’s win with town). At least it might be an exciting twist to watch. I think there are many examples of SK winning with the Scum. One of def's game (or was it Draggy's?), Me in Unrest in the Forest, Sandy's HP game...
Bob Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 What a game! Excellent storytelling and brilliant photography. I'm rather upset that I missed this one, but it worked out since I wouldn't have been able to devote my time to it (which is good, because Hinckley yells at inactive players) I really thought he was scum though, since he and TPRU seem to mess with each others roles in every game they host, but I was wrong. It's always a different perspective when you're not playing.
Palathadric Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Phew! I've commented so much on the writeboard about this game already, that I feel I am completely drained of words. Town PRs were awesome and if Petrus really had been the vig, that would have been a very quick and very fitting win. I guess I should feel somewhat honoured by being chosen for scum kill on Night 1.
Hinckley Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 That writeboard is awesome. Now to read the Scum one.
Legocity2713 Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Thats one crazy dude. Really love the lighting in all of those photos though, very professional looking. :thumbup:
Hinckley Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 More to come... I hear a rumor that it's Pernilla's story! TheLazyChicken said… (06 Jul 15, looking at version 1) I don’t know, we could kill Hinkley but there’s probably someone defending him out there, so maybe we could go for Pandora since she’s an experienced player. Thoughts? I love that Pandora and I were the first options for kill. What a different game that would've been!
Zepher Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Superb game, followed it off and on but always read the beginning and end of the day - great writing, great photography, great intrigue! A huge thumbs up and congrats from me. (Also read the last few days pretty closely, and seriously, all across the board enjoyable - both host and players alike!).
TheLazyChicken Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 I love that Pandora and I were the first options for kill. What a different game that would've been! We should've killed Pandora, if only we knew no one was protecting her...
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Excellent game, ladies and gentlemen! I thoroughly enjoyed watching it! Hopefully this example will better me in future mafia games.
TheLazyChicken Posted August 23, 2015 Posted August 23, 2015 Excellent game, ladies and gentlemen! I thoroughly enjoyed watching it! Hopefully this example will better me in future mafia games. Looking forward to playing with you in a future game, hope this game will make us improve!
Brickelodeon Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 How ironic that the game should begin with fire (my lynching) and end with fire as well.
Lady K Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 Awesome, Awesome game! Thanks TPRU! I loved the story, photography, MOC's, and Pernilla surviving in the end.......! I am really glad I had the chance to be part of this! Congratulations to Hinckley and Adam for surviving to the end and winning. Hinckley, I am sorry I didn't trust you enough to confide in you my targets. I knew who and when I targeted, but it seem to me you were fishing for too much detailed info and I found that very scummy. I think my role was great and would have been a big benefit to the town if I had been more active in the town block. Then town would have been able to keep a PR a day longer when a PR was killed. I can only add my thoughts for the newbies to what has been said already. Play, Play, Play! Keep at it, every game gets better as you gain more experience and the more players = the larger the game = the more fun and intense it can get. It is so very worth it!.
Hinckley Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 Hinckley, I am sorry I didn't trust you enough to confide in you my targets. I knew who and when I targeted, but it seem to me you were fishing for too much detailed info and I found that very scummy. No worries! Just to share my experience, when you roleclaim you should expect the question "Who were your targets?" A good townie will try to confirm your story and analyze the logic behind who you targeted. Refusing to give targets seemed Scummy to me...obviously. Also, your role was so convoluted, it sounded like you were making it up. Sorry about that.
Chromeknight Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 (edited) Chromeknight, I'm sure it's a kick in the teeth that I killed you after we worked so hard together, and I'm really sorry. You played a great game, and for the record I never thought you were scum, even when people were voting for you. No hard feelings at all! It was kind of a relief to be dead, to get the answers finally and not be involved in the argy-bargy that was day 11. Though as Adam pointed out, and I think he might've been right, a better play for you would've been to kill Hink and have Adam take the fall for it. If you'd've sworn you didn't kill him I probably would've believed you. Ah hindsight. Hink. Sorry for that block night 10. Paranoia brain fritz out. I shoulda blocked Pandora. Hopefully now you've seen me play a bit, my style is less weird seeming. Edited August 24, 2015 by Chromeknight
Captain Nemo Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 Great game for all those involved. As a spectator, it was very interesting to watch, even without knowing the behind the scenes stuff (which at some points must have been hilarious). From my perspective the tactics of the scum team were seriously crazy; especially the calls for the traitor to come forward; so I was surprised to see how long the game lasted. Going by how ridiculous the scum were acting, it really seemed like it should have ended way earlier--then all of the sudden it was day eleven and there were only four players left! So checking the forms each day to see yet another day was really surprising again and again. And congrats to Pandora, Hinckley, and Adam for such a tense last day. You're all winners in my book!
Hinckley Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 Hink. Sorry for that block night 10. Paranoia brain fritz out. I shoulda blocked Pandora. Hopefully now you've seen me play a bit, my style is less weird seeming. No worries at all! If anyone understands brain fritz, it's me... For a little while, I actually really thought the Scum's only Action might be to turn a player into a bomb. I loved playing with you! This is the first time we've worked so closely and I really enjoyed it. I liked working with the entire Town block even though Pandora was a liar and Pie lost his shit! This game was a blast because of you guys! I did think the same thing TPRU said about it being like Ragnarok I where the Town almost lost it assuming it was too easy to steamroll a bumbling Scum team. From ... when was that? ... Day Eight onward! Anyway, we targeted each other. I was shocked you were killed but not necessarily surprised you blocked me. I honestly didn't expect a Day Eleven, though. After you and Pie were gone, whenever I started suspecting Adam, Pie's parting request echoed in my head, "lynch Petrus". So, I'm glad my first instinct was influenced by what you guys were able to see and I could not before that. I'm also relieved that the paranoia didn't set in until later in the day and after Pandora went to sleep. Who knows what would've happened if it ended up in my control in the waning hours... I sent TPRU a PM that said "What if I was redirected off of Pandora onto the vig??" and "OMG, Adam was the traitor. Have I killed my Pernilla? " I wanted Pernilla to have an elaborate sub–plot and sent TPRU, almost, a script.
Darkdragon Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 Thanks for a great game, TPRU. Sorry I got sick at the start of day 2 and couldn't participate, I figured I'd die that night for not voting. It sucked. I was looking forward to getting lynched for my role. Sorry! There was a WIFOM in it that needed to be tested. Well from other things that were said in the threads, i think you and pandora were planning to kill me anyway, and you never gave me a chance. probably would have been better to have just ignored my initial PM in the first place really. I do feel very annoyed that you really think I am THAT stupid that I'd have used my name accidentally on the traitor writeboard. I told you I was the SK target that night! I think there are many examples of SK winning with the Scum. One of def's game (or was it Draggy's?), Me in Unrest in the Forest, Sandy's HP game... My comment was more about winning with a team, scum or town..rather than an SK winning on his/her own. I think I mentioned that in a later comment on the writebaord.
Hinckley Posted August 24, 2015 Posted August 24, 2015 Well from other things that were said in the threads, i think you and pandora were planning to kill me anyway, and you never gave me a chance. probably would have been better to have just ignored my initial PM in the first place really. I do feel very annoyed that you really think I am THAT stupid that I'd have used my name accidentally on the traitor writeboard. You were my tracking target, so I did not plan to kill you until that happened. And no, I don't think you're dumb. It is easy to login from a phone and not realize your name sticks from the last board you posted from on that device but it needed to be tested either way. The comment that was trashed was the smartest question they asked if that makes you feel any better. I told you I was the SK target that night! If only I would've listened! My comment was more about winning with a team, scum or town..rather than an SK winning on his/her own. I think I mentioned that in a later comment on the writebaord. The SK win should be alone, I believe. The only reason I killed Foog in Unrest was because I was (incorrectly) told I would beat both teams if I did. Despite some missteps in hosting in the past, that is how I would set it up if I was to host again, only one faction can win.
Recommended Posts