MagPiesRUs Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Take me out to the Black, Tell them I ain't coming back. Thanks for the great game Danny and JJP, it was a lot of fun! I loved the presentation, characters and storyline! I'm almost sad the game ended so quickly. I say almost because I have a feeling we would have lost if it went on any longer. The townies were pretty much all verified at the end there, and it probably would have just been a process of eliminating the remaining unconfirmed claims. Scumbuddies, thanks for being a great team! SirStig and mediumsnowman, you both did great for your first games! Plus, I thought it was fun to guess the tracker based on all of the stuff Sir Stig said. I honestly considered killing Sir Stig because it was just tiring trying to follow his logic. I think Stig made it pretty clear that Tariq was the tracker when he let slip that the tracker contacted him after Stig accused him in public. I was a little afraid of pointing that out though, just in case people thought I was the kiler. TPRU, Dragonfire guessed you as the Godfather at one point because you were "getting too cocky". Yeah, I feel like I might have botched my replies when Dragonfire told me I was investigated. I was probably a little too trusting of the claim. Protector. Oh, does that mean you really were bulletproof? I thought Dragonfire was the protector, based on how much the cop seemed to trust him and how heavily involved he was in the town block. So he was really just a vanilla?
Tariq j Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Danny: Sorry, I was really tired when posting that.
mostlytechnic Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Dang! Way too not awake yet to process everything.... but.... Yes, I really was the vig and I really did forget to submit my last night action to kill bob until Monday morning Dealing with sick kids all weekend and I literally forgot I was the freaking vig and needed to do something! So then I woke up Monday, thought oh crap, saw PMs from the block and the hosts and sent it in really quick. Thanks for a little grace on that one JJP and DLL! Not that it really mattered... Glad I was right on my scumread on Stig and that my scum-tell of splitting the vote still holds true! Now it won't work anymore since the scum team WILL do like Hinck said... but it worked this time. Thanks for a fun game!!! I definitely was more emotionally into it than normal, almost up to Hinck-levels of stress over the game!
JackJonespaw Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Thanks for the great game Danny and JJP, it was a lot of fun! I loved the presentation, characters and storyline! I'm almost sad the game ended so quickly. I say almost because I have a feeling we would have lost if it went on any longer. The townies were pretty much all verified at the end there, and it probably would have just been a process of eliminating the remaining unconfirmed claims. I swear I got a the best chill down my spine when Hannah investigated you on Night 2. I always root for the scum to win, and that was quite lucky.
Flipz Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 I guess I can give a little constructive criticism as an observer: while I loved the characters and the references in their names and designs (Seamus Aaron wins hands-down on both fronts ), the fact that their names were so different from the users' names made it difficult at times to keep track of who was who, especially with the third person speech pattern of Dragonfire's character.
Piratedave84 Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 How am I still alive ... I made 14,326 bad decisions and still managed to keep afloat somehow. I KNEW IT!!! hinck was the SK. I deducted it from a comment Dragonfire made and Hinck's behaviour which was too reckless to be scum (i.e. shooting accusations in all directions) but too bold to be a town PR. Since I was convinced he had a NA for some reason, this left SK as his role. As for the cop, Although we had rolecoped her, it was way too easy to figure out who it was and after a day of nagging, Dragonfire gave in last night and admitted Ranger was the cop. So even if we had not cop'ed her, we still would have found out today. Thanks Hinck for not killing me, also thanks for the feedback and comments in PM, I know I handled my being let out of the town block very poorly. Thanks to JJP and DLL for the awesome game, good story, nice photography and an all around success for your first hosting gig. good job!! When I initially joined the board, I had to count twice to make sure we were in fact 5; from the get go I knew it as a bit unbalanced. Had you guys contacted me instead of Bob, would you have let me achieve my win condition of getting it down to four players? I probably would have objected simply because you were harping on me so bad! Maybe, actually, we discussed CMP also sending you a PM asking you to side with us
Ranger of the Forest Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Might be worth noting that I didn't report "success:" for the cop of Nathan. Just that he was loyal to the federation. Every other investigation resulted as a success. ~Insectoid Aristocrat Are you freaking kidding me? I noticed that but I didn’t want to read into anything... Sorry you guys. Especially to you Bob. You were wrong about Dragonfire but you were right about you being town Your pms just really made it seem like you were scum to me. And I had just investigated Dave too Oh my gosh this game. Shoutout to Dragonfire for basically keeping me sane this entire time. And also to Lind and Hinck for our sort of town block thing at the end. Ah well, we had fun at least I’m going to be thinking about this for the rest of the day, wow Gj to medium and Stig especially, I had town reads on you guys for the majority of the game I’ll be back to post more later but for now that’s all I’ve got. Congrats scum team, sorry again town and Seamus
Tariq j Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Just out of interest what was the thing with code? In still trying to get my head around it!
Ranger of the Forest Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Also thank you DLL and JJP for being amazing hosts! Really enjoyed playing, and the pictures were fantastic
TheLazyChicken Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Great game everyone! Really enjoyed playing it. I actually believed Piratedave84's role...
Xenophobic Monoxide Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Well, great game everyone! Though my time was short, I had a blast. Thanks for hosting this, Danny.
TheLazyChicken Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Also, great job DLL for the great story and JJP for the amazing photos!
Bob Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Dumbasses, I told you it was Dragonfire and Lind Whisperer. What? They came up as town? Damn. Especially to you Bob. You were wrong about Dragonfire but you were right about you being town Your pms just really made it seem like you were scum to me. Sometimes people just get tunnel vision (see above, where I thought Dragonfire and or Lind were scum for the entire game) CMP PM'd me and asked if I could win with the scum, presumably guessing that I was the serial killer, so I forwarded that on to you because he revealed you as the investigator. I wanted to tell you that there was a hole in the town block (of course I thought it was Dragonfire) Just out of interest what was the thing with code? In still trying to get my head around it! I was involved in it, and I don't even know what happened. I think Stig pulled a MT and invented an asinine code to confuse the town. Amazing game though, I had a blast with all the prank actions! I was initially given the night option to send poetry to the hosts, but on Night One I instead told them I wanted to cut up a fruit salad with my new sword and dump it all over Lind. Then night two I cut off her hair and stole her helmet. Night three I went back to my fruit salad roots on Ranger and last night I tried hiding under my bed. And the conclusion title is Serenity, though I have none right now.
mediumsnowman Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 First of all, thanks for the awesome game DLL and JJP! Hinckley, were you bulletproof or protected? We tried to kill you Night 3 but it didn't go through. If Lind inherited Doctor, who was it first? Fhomess?
Lady K Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Wow, great game and congratulations to the Blacktron scum team. I can't believe I was rolecoped night one. and that secured my death night two. I blocked Lind night two because I was so sure he was the godfather, never even suspected TPRU at all. Sorry to my team for being so under the radar, it was due to real life and not because I had a PR. Thank you Danny and JJP for hosting an incredibly fun game with great story and awesome pictures! And with the conclusion I really thought you had put a cult in the game.
Hinckley Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Yes, I really was the vig and I really did forget to submit my last night action to kill bob until Monday morning Nope. Scum. I probably would have objected simply because you were harping on me so bad! I understand completely. I have an unhealthy dislike for you as a person right now. Sorry... It will pass... Although if you die Night One in the next game, I have a killing role, period. And you can thank Dragonfire and his stupid clothes–switching role for me not killing you. I thought it was an indication of a redirector and thought I'd end up killing myself if I killed you since I broadcasted that scenario in–thread on Day Two. When's the next game. Let's go. I want to kill Dave.
Dannylonglegs Posted September 22, 2015 Author Posted September 22, 2015 The Neutral Night Killer recieved a 1-shot bulletproof before night one when I began to realize my game was unbalanced. Since I viewed the SK's win-conditions as a balancing mechanism almost, I figured that making it a stronger role would assist the Town against the 5 scum. After I began to realize that my setup favored the Mafia, I began making some decisions that were designed to make the game a little fair-er for the Town, such as not reporting success upon investigating the godfather, and blatantly saying "MyLo" on day 3. ~Insectoid Aristocrat
Captain Nemo Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Short but fun game. Thanks for hosting Danny and JJP!
Dannylonglegs Posted September 22, 2015 Author Posted September 22, 2015 When's the next game. Let's go. I want to kill Dave. Darkdragon will be hosting quite soon. I gave her a heads up that mine was going to be short due to my own incompetence. ~Insectoid Aristocrat
mediumsnowman Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Dannylonglegs said… (20 Sep 15, looking at version 1) Medium(when you read this in post game): when the game is over, I will explain to you why I might not let your prank go through tonight. It’s not for the reason I told you in the PM. Eh?
Dannylonglegs Posted September 22, 2015 Author Posted September 22, 2015 Eh? Because It was the conclusion, and I didn't want Prometheus to tarnish it! ~Insectoid Aristocrat
mediumsnowman Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 I see. On a side note, I didn't notice any member titles given out this game?
Hinckley Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 sorry again town and Seamus Totally not your fault. Like TPRU said, if we had one more day we'd start mowing them down as they were all lined up and you were a big part in gathering all of that info. Just out of interest what was the thing with code? In still trying to get my head around it! Let us never speak of that again. I actually believed Piratedave84's role... You weren't the only one. CMP PM'd me and asked if I could win with the scum, presumably guessing that I was the serial killer, so I forwarded that on to you because he revealed you as the investigator. I wanted to tell you that there was a hole in the town block (of course I thought it was Dragonfire) Ahem... Here's my responses to the posting of your PMs in the Town block PM: If you want me to get meta on you, fine. This is your second game on Eurobricks. I'm not going to try and screw you over this badly just so I can win a game on an internet forum. I'm town and I'm trying to help. I'm going to deride metagaming...and then metagame you. Since it's only your second game, I would never lie to you. ??????? That's the biggest thing about Bob's PMs to Ranger: If he has "evidence" there's a mole in the town block, why focus that discovery only on her? Why not...post it in the day thread where people are just about to finalize a lynch on CallMePie? So other townies can be worried about the infiltration? You run a gambit to expose the Scum, not demonstrate to one person (who everyone knows to be the investigator, and no–it's not as poorly kept a secret as me being the Serial Killer, ) that the Town block isn't to be trusted, either a. for being Scum or b. making too many mistakes and accidentally giving too much info to Scum and somehow both at once. I just came up with an idea: if you guys have me kill Bob, I'll submit another funny kill so you guys will know it's me. I'll knit him an blanket and then strangle him with it or something. Ooops, yes. The idea to abuse the host's kindness of letting us pull pranks was my idea. Sorry. And then I concluded: This is Bob's message, according to Ranger. “I know you don’t trust me and find me suspicious, but you need to hear me out. The scum know you’re the investigator. I just got a PM from CMP telling me you’re the investigator and asking me if I can win with them. (Confirming he’s scum basically) Why would CMP answer his claim to be the Serial Killer with "Ranger is the investigator."? He thinks I’m the serial killer, which I’m not. You don’t have to tell me who you revealed your role to or whatever, but know that there’s a leak in your town block and somebody knows that you’re the the investigator. I’m going to see what else I can get out of CMP." Somebody? It's CMP. He just said that. “Like I said, if you’re really the investigator, please be careful. You’ve suspected me the entire game, that’s fine and all, but you need to trust me now. "The Scum know you are the investigator because a leak told somebody but I don't know that because I'm an innocent Townie but trust me until we kill you, OK?" Hindsight is 20/20. We should've had you pretend to buy this and then post at the end of the day "A friend has convinced me that I've trusted the wrong people. I'm the investigator but the Town block is full of liars! Someone help me! " If you’ve only told Dragonfire that you’re the investigator, as I suspect, then he really is scum like I’ve suspected. It’s entirely possible he suggested you investigate CMP to bus a scum buddy.” And back to knowing that you're the investigator and on to trying to get Dragonfire lynched. Yes, this is Scummy. I'm trying to imagine it as a Town gambit. What I would do. I would go and pretend to be the Serial Killer and then just go undermine the Town block. No, I'd pretend to be the Serial Killer to learn more. If he told me he knew who the investigator was, I'd ask how he knew or he'd tell me there's a leak in the Town block??? Wait, no. None of that would happen because everyone would be too cautious. The very last thing CMP would do as Scum to a Serial Killer claim would be to say "We know who the investigator is!!!! Can you win with us?" He'd play framed Town for a while until he was sure he could believe the SK claim. So, it all sounds like megablocks right there. But even Bob's point of view. If...if... I was running a fake SK gambit and the Scum instantly believed me and told me he knew who the investigator was (which, by the way, is what Dave was trying to prove to me earlier...same argument, Dragonfire is sloppy Town and devious Scum all at the same time. They're not even saying either or, but I digress...for now) I would contact the investigator to let them know, but I'd probably mention all the fishing for the investigator identity Dave has already been doing and then I'd move on from the subject of trusting the Town block and find out how to further manipulate the Scum into revealing information. His gambit had no end game except for scaring Ranger into believing Dragonfire was Scum. Little did I know CallMePie actually did just PM Bob out of the blue and say "Ranger is the investigator". First of all, thanks for the awesome game DLL and JJP! Hinckley, were you bulletproof or protected? We tried to kill you Night 3 but it didn't go through. If Lind inherited Doctor, who was it first? Fhomess? Bulletproof. I'd still like to know who the real vig was. I blocked Lind night two because I was so sure he was the godfather, See, the Town hated the Town so we were kind of at a disadvantage there too. And I forgot about this one: Double Post: I've been trying to lay off Dave today...meaning in the last 24 hours... ... but here are three things worth noting. 1. Once Dragonfire called him out for lying, he hasn't responded. 2. He was online yesterday and was composing a post, then disappeared. 3. He was on today, read the thread, went to personal messenger, then left without posting. Yeah, I stalk people. That’s because he was too busy sending me gems like this: Cop Cop Cop Coppedy Cop Dave, you weren't even trying to be Town anymore at that point. And I wasn't Scum-vising you in PM, I was trying to get you to give more away. Little did I know the megablocking game was over. Regarding you: Double Post: Again, I think he's acting Scummy on purpose to draw NAs...
Dannylonglegs Posted September 22, 2015 Author Posted September 22, 2015 I see. On a side note, I didn't notice any member titles given out this game? Just look at mine... ~Insectoid Aristocrat
Recommended Posts