Lind Whisperer Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Good game, everyone, and congratulations to the winners! Dragonfire+Hinckley+Ranger - great playing with you guys, hope we can do it again sometime. I was hoping the heat would go away if I just waited it out. With Hinck on Town Block? Never! Seriously, though, you would have almost certainly been today's lynch, if y'all hadn't won. Don't hide. If you're not playing, you're not playing.
Dannylonglegs Posted September 22, 2015 Author Posted September 22, 2015 As a big Who fan I am absolutely ashamed at myself for not realizing that reference, shame on me. Do you get it now? Because no one's said it yet... ~Insectoid Aristocrat
fhomess Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Worst town ever! I even protected two scum before being vig killed. Congrats to the scum for a breezy victory. I don't think things could've gone much worse for the town. Between my protections, the vig, our tracker claiming to scum, and how free and loose with things the block was, we would've likely lost even with a more balanced game. Hinck... I may have you confused for someone else, but it's entirely possible there are a few folks with that bent out there. There was nothing particularly townie or particularly scummy about your game this time. It just takes a few days to see that.
mediumsnowman Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Worst town ever! I even protected two scum before being vig killed. Who did you protect?
Hinckley Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 I was hidding; not the best thing to do but it sounded like a good idea at the time! I was hoping the heat would go away if I just waited it out. People can play however they want but I have no respect for hiding. That being said, I tried hiding in Bloodbrick II. Hinck... I may have you confused for someone else, but it's entirely possible there are a few folks with that bent out there. There was nothing particularly townie or particularly scummy about your game this time. It just takes a few days to see that. The strongest example I can think of, of a Scum being pissed for being caught for the wrong reasons, was def in Ragnarok II and we were both on his team. That's who I would've thought you had me confused with. And there have been worse Towns. Check Bloodbrick I and Infection.
fhomess Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Yes, I figured Def was who you meant. I protected TPRU and Stig. I really waffled on Stig, and the irony is that at one point or another I had considered any of the three town PR's (including myself) who were killed on night 2. The problem was, everyone was acting kind of scummy. I took the chance on Stig because the code thing seemed too confusing to have been coordinated with a scum team. I figured Tariq was the guy he implied as the tracker, but then WIFOM'd myself into figuring he wouldn't be that obvious. I think Lind was the only person I had a strong and accurate town read on, and I wanted him dead almost from the get go for being so annoying!
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 First off, I (and Minga) take full responsibility for the loss of this game. As I said in the town block PM, if Bob was town and it lost us the game, it's on me. I had tunnel vision on Bob towards the end and saw scum in all his posts. Dave, I never trusted you and my last PM to you was a poorly disguised gambit devised by Hinck. Stig and medium, congrats in surviving and winning your first game Stig, that codes thing made you look town rather than scum. Medium, I suspected you at the end but only due to process of elimination. Great game! My reads suck. At least I was right about trusting mostlytechnic.... Yeah, I feel like I might have botched my replies when Dragonfire told me I was investigated. I was probably a little too trusting of the claim. No, you started fishing! That was initially why we suspected you. I thought Dragonfire was the protector, based on how much the cop seemed to trust him and how heavily involved he was in the town block. So he was really just a vanilla? Yeah, Lind was the protector, inherited it from fhomess (but I thought it was Lady K) As for the cop, Although we had rolecoped her, it was way too easy to figure out who it was and after a day of nagging, Dragonfire gave in last night and admitted Ranger was the cop. So even if we had not cop'ed her, we still would have found out today. I never said that. Even after the game, you're misrepresenting stuff I said. Get out of the scum mindset, mate! When I initially joined the board, I had to count twice to make sure we were in fact 5; from the get go I knew it as a bit unbalanced. Very unbalanced. A third of the players were not town- no wonder we lost! Shoutout to Dragonfire for basically keeping me sane this entire time. Thanks, I had fun working with you too Wow, great game and congratulations to the Blacktron scum team. I can't believe I was rolecoped night one. and that secured my death night two. I blocked Lind night two because I was so sure he was the godfather, never even suspected TPRU at all. Sorry to my team for being so under the radar, it was due to real life and not because I had a PR. Thank you Danny and JJP for hosting an incredibly fun game with great story and awesome pictures! And with the conclusion I really thought you had put a cult in the game. Yeah, me too! Wait, you were blocker? We thought you were the protector.... does that mean Dave was the scum watcher and mostly's comment was pure coincidence....? Actually, you echoed mostlytechnic's points. Dragonfire believed Dave on and off. Every other post in the Town block PM was leaning back the other way on him...even after he watched himself to find a blocker. But I guess the newer generation tries things that are impossible and futile so I'm just too old to understand how much of a Townie move that was. Honestly, had I simply not killed Bob and the Scum had killed Dragonfire (which is what it looked like) Dave would've been toast on Day Five. I've discovered I don't like being led. I'm sure that's a huge surprise to everyone. To be honest, I suspected Dave too, it was only when Bob (my biggest scumread ) started attacking him in thread that I thought he might be town. I was worried that the scum were trying to use your tunnel vision to their advantage....
mostlytechnic Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Do you get it now? Because no one's said it yet... ~Insectoid Aristocrat I'm going with the Ood from Dr Who - you're so subtle with the hints there...
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Most embarrassing post of the year 2015: So, are we absolutely sure about Bob? I really think the game balance is razor thin right now. I think those PMs paint a pretty Scummy picture but I'll look over them again for signs of Town–Bob. Yes, I am. I was fairly sure at the end of yesterday, almost completely sure when Nemo flipped town, and now, after those PMs came up, I'm sure. If we lose the game because of the kill on Bob, I'll take full responsibility. He's obviously trying to manipulate a newer player into being paranoid and suspecting me, when the Scum only figured out Ranger's identity due to my stupidity. Telling Ranger is the townie move and would get her off his back. Bob wants to get suspicion off of him, now that the balance is shifting towards the Town and he knows the cop suspects him.
Dannylonglegs Posted September 22, 2015 Author Posted September 22, 2015 I'm going with the Ood from Dr Who - you're so subtle with the hints there... I pride myself on my subtlety. I am not a proud man. ~Insectoid Aristocrat
Piratedave84 Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 I never said that. Even after the game, you're misrepresenting stuff I said. Get out of the scum mindset, mate! Ahem .... Dave, If you're town you need to tell me one vital fact. Exactly who have you told via PM about your suspicions as to the investigator's identity (tl;dr, who have you told that Ranger is the investigator) ?? I'd like a list of all the people's names, please. Thanks, Dragon That is an admission in my book.
Hinckley Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Most embarrassing post of the year 2015: Not embarrassing at all. I agreed with you. Bob's PMs seemed really Scummy. I analyzed them! Dragonfire, sometimes your tl;drs are longer than what you said in the first place.
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 That is an admission in my book. Not really in mine. I should have picked up that Ranger wasn't the only one yet to post You slipped and accidentally outed Stig and Medium as scum.... but nobody picked up on it
Piratedave84 Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Not really in mine. I should have picked up that Ranger wasn't the only one yet to post You slipped and accidentally outed Stig and Medium as scum.... but nobody picked up on it How? that if I did was a slip!
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 How? that if I did was a slip! yup ... just checked logins and I would bet you anything Ranger is the cop. It'll take as much time for scum to figure it out. Congrats, you threw the game ^^ Stig and Medium hadn't posted either yet you only focused on Ranger because you knew the other two were scum.
Hinckley Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 I should have picked up that Ranger wasn't the only one yet to post Did you miss me saying this: Make sure enough time has passed that nobody can guess the investigator's identity by time zones.
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Did you miss me saying this: I'd already said it Someone should change my title to "Worst Town Block Leader of the Year 2015"
Piratedave84 Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 ^^ Stig and Medium hadn't posted either yet you only focused on Ranger because you knew the other two were scum. Burn! I did not think about this at all as I did not bother to look up scum's logins! Good eye! I'd already said it Someone should change my title to "Worst Town Block Leader of the Year 2015" Don't be too hard on yourself, I nearly cost us the game once as a masson by litterally telling EVERYTHING to the scum team ... so yeah, it happens. Being in charge and leading town is a hard job, that's why I leave it up to others! Plus when you have Speedy/Def and Hinck vying for the lead it gets REALLY good!!!!!!
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Don't be too hard on yourself, I nearly cost us the game once as a masson by litterally telling EVERYTHING to the scum team ... so yeah, it happens. Hinck actually referred to that in the town block PM and compared it to what I was doing this game I guess I can give a little constructive criticism as an observer: while I loved the characters and the references in their names and designs (Seamus Aaron wins hands-down on both fronts ), the fact that their names were so different from the users' names made it difficult at times to keep track of who was who, especially with the third person speech pattern of Dragonfire's character. Oh yeah, posting as Minga was really fun Sucks she's dead now, cause I can't speak in the third person anymore
fhomess Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Oh yeah, posting as Minga was really fun Sucks she's dead now, cause I can't speak in the third person anymore What? Why? I still see green space dragons...
Dragonfire Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 What? Why? I still see green space dragons... Where??
Lady K Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 I almost included while writing on our typewriters by candlelight, but then I remembered that happened much more recently. You should have because writing responses on a typewriter by candlelight and faxing them to the host is the way to go..... and asterisks look great in low light.... :grin:.
Darkdragon Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 You should have because writing responses on a typewriter by candlelight and faxing them to the host is the way to go..... and asterisks look great in low light.... :grin:. That was one fast title change.
Sir Stig Posted September 22, 2015 Posted September 22, 2015 Sorry about the intro, anyone confused. It's a troll and means nothing... Apart from that I spent money to purchase 10 fly figures. godfather. ~Insectoid Aristocrat Yay! 10 fly figures! Is the intro a hint at the next mafia you will host? First I want to thank Dannylonglegs and JackJonesPaw for a brilliant game. It's been a nervewrecking blast. Dave told me to "play this as town. Be active, don’t overreact, consult us when not sure, have fun!!!!". So I played as a noob townie. I did realize as the game went on that a lot of the noobishness were truer than I had measured myself up to be. The story have been fun and the pictures and SFXs superb. I loved the uniform design of all the conference rooms Plus, I thought it was fun to guess the tracker based on all of the stuff Sir Stig said. I honestly considered killing Sir Stig because it was just tiring trying to follow his logic. Heheh, sorry for dragging you down that hole . I'm almost sad the game ended so quickly. I say almost because I have a feeling we would have lost if it went on any longer. The townies were pretty much all verified at the end there, and it probably would have just been a process of eliminating the remaining unconfirmed claims. Scumbuddies, thanks for being a great team! SirStig and mediumsnowman, you both did great for your first games! I also think we would have been rooted out and lined up to the gallows, given the town had gotten a day, or tops two more. Thanks for showing me the ropes Just out of interest what was the thing with code? In still trying to get my head around it! It wish I could visit a parallel dimension to read how it would have gone if I had been killed that night. Since I would have been revealed as scum it would probably have been dismissed. But I think Hinckley would have lost his mind.Nothing personal There was supposed to be meaning to the code, but I'll admit I totally lost track of it myself. It worked better than I could ever hope for as a distraction though. It also had a major flaw incriminating CMP and TPRU. Sorry guys, luckily we got a quick end. But also because we are awesome. I apologize for digging your grave Tariq J, but that's what happens when you claim to scum. I understand completely. I have an unhealthy dislike for you as a person right now. Sorry... It will pass... Although if you die Night One in the next game, I have a killing role, period.When's the next game. Let's go. I want to kill Dave. Yeeees.... kill dave. kill dave. kill dave. not me.
Recommended Posts