Tachyon Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Oh Geez...........It's really hard to pick Day 1 without being accused of bandwagoning. Without any conclusive evidence, there's no reason for me to cast a vote on the highest voted candidate, Anthony although this move could possibly lead me to easily be accused of doing something suspicious and will make me liable for a lynch in the coming days. As I seem to be forced to vote I'll Vote:Doctor Wynn (Tariq j) for the sake of voting. Oh Geez.......
jluck Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 I just had too, if I'm gonna do some first class trolling, I might as well stick with it until the game takes off in earnest. Plus, I've been out a couple games now, so I can't think of a better reentry than picking a fight with Elijah. Oh Geez...........It's really hard to pick Day 1 without being accused of bandwagoning. Without any conclusive evidence, there's no reason for me to cast a vote on the highest voted candidate, Anthony although this move could possibly lead me to easily be accused of doing something suspicious and will make me liable for a lynch in the coming days. As I seem to be forced to vote I'll Vote:Doctor Wynn (Tariq j) for the sake of voting. Oh Geez....... So you only voted because you had to, you voted without any justification of the vote, and you avoided an early bandwagon. Noted.
Tachyon Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Then do you want me to continue the bandwagon on you ? It doesn't bother me in the slightest on whether you die or not. If your'e scum that's bonus. If your not, then I treat it as a day 1 mislynch. Even if I get lynched today, the town doesn't lose anyone important.
mediumsnowman Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Then do you want me to continue the bandwagon on you ? It doesn't bother me in the slightest on whether you die or not. If your'e scum that's bonus. If your not, then I treat it as a day 1 mislynch. Even if I get lynched today, the town doesn't lose anyone important. Are you claiming vanilla?
Bob Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Do you mean 'in all seriousness' in a completely non-serious way, or 'in all seriousness' as in you're taking Anthony seriously but not Elijah? Surely you can't be serious? I'm not serious, and don't call me Shirley. My name is Woodcock, friend! Excuse me, sir, Humphrey would like to know if that was one of your gears malfunctioning, or whether you actually said it I must say, your reply to Foorth's ping was rather peculiar to me! Helpless roleplay, or a subtle questioning of the logic?! Vote: Ray Christiansen (Dragonfire) This doesn't have to be a final vote, but I'm reacting to something I saw and didn't much like! Fantastic!
Tamamono Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 I must say, your reply to Foorth's ping was rather peculiar to me! Helpless roleplay, or a subtle questioning of the logic?! Vote: Ray Christiansen (Dragonfire) This doesn't have to be a final vote, but I'm reacting to something I saw and didn't much like! Fantastic! I actually kind of agree with this.
jluck Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Then do you want me to continue the bandwagon on you ? It doesn't bother me in the slightest on whether you die or not. If your'e scum that's bonus. If your not, then I treat it as a day 1 mislynch. Even if I get lynched today, the town doesn't lose anyone important. If you think I'm the best candidate and you have reasons to vote for me, do it. If you have reasons for your voting for doctor Wynn, share them. I just want you to contribute to the conversation in a useful manner. Day 1 is hard enough to get right without mindless voting.
mediumsnowman Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Is no one else going to talk about the fact that Perce effectively claimed vanilla on Day 1? That seems to me a very non-town move when he's not really in danger of being lynched right now. The job of vanillas is to try and get the scum to kill them at night instead of PR's, right? Of course he could be throwing WIFOM to get the scum to ignore him but then he runs the risk of being tracked doing something, which after claiming vanilla he'd practically be an auto-lynch... Am I making any sense? I don't think it's enough to get me to change my vote to him right now but it's definitely something to consider.
Tariq j Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Oh Geez...........It's really hard to pick Day 1 without being accused of bandwagoning. Without any conclusive evidence, there's no reason for me to cast a vote on the highest voted candidate, Anthony although this move could possibly lead me to easily be accused of doing something suspicious and will make me liable for a lynch in the coming days. As I seem to be forced to vote I'll Vote:Doctor Wynn (Tariq j) for the sake of voting. Oh Geez....... For the sake of voting?! We still have a (fair) amount of hours in the day left and there you are throwing away your votes on Random people. Sure, on Day One there is little to go on (only 3 pages in this case) but surely there must be some reasoning behind your vote other than you not wanting to vote on a bandwagon. Laziness or trying to bandwagon against me?
MagPiesRUs Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Oh Geez...........It's really hard to pick Day 1 without being accused of bandwagoning. Without any conclusive evidence, there's no reason for me to cast a vote on the highest voted candidate, Anthony although this move could possibly lead me to easily be accused of doing something suspicious and will make me liable for a lynch in the coming days. As I seem to be forced to vote I'll Vote:Doctor Wynn (Tariq j) for the sake of voting. Oh Geez....... Why Dr. Wynn? Did you just pull his name out of a hat? How does this benefit anyone? If you're going to make a random day one vote, at least pretend there's a reason behind it. By saying upfront that your vote is random, you're immediately undermining your vote and giving Dr. Wynn no reason to take it seriously. Even if I get lynched today, the town doesn't lose anyone important. You seem a little too eager to reveal that. For now, I will Vote: Perce Triggs (Tachyon)
Tariq j Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Apologies for my absence, I was so busy making sure that we had enough supplies for the journey that I forgot about all of you... Who is this "Jluck" person you keep speaking of, Anthony? But whoever he is, there's no way he's been acting fishy as you have so far today. Your posts genuinely baffle me, and I find you more suspicious than anyone else thus far. But considering it's day one, that's not saying much. So for now I'll Vote: Anthony Dixon (Jluck) This is almost certainly subject to change, especially if we need to get a lynch, but I might as well go with my gut for the present. Honestly, Jluck hasn't actually pinged me that much, he posts haven't been normal for sure but I see it as his role playing personality than scummy posts. But what I do find suspicious is you quickly jumping on the easiest bandwagon. So for that reason: Vote: Delwyn Couch (Ranger of the Forest)
Dragonfire Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Yep, that's why I'm following through on all my talk to show I was most definitely not joking and voting for the one confirmed scum-o. vote: Elijah (def) #jluck'sb***ch Can you elaborate please, are you legitimately convinced he is scum or is this just a "reaction test" vote? Humphrey is curious... Our dear gardener Elijah makes a good point here. I don't like how quiet TPRU and RoTF are being right now, but that can be chalked up to their play style. I don't think there's enough good evidence to lynch either def or jluck right now. I'll withhold my vote for now. I really don't like this post, you're being both non-committal and unhelpful to town. As Elijah said, unvotes are allowed. Voting for someone now gives reactions and can help catch scum, and you're not helping with this. It's interesting that as soon as Elijah calls you out, you immediately do a U-turn and vote at once. You can unvote. Vote now, change it later if you must. No waffling. *singsong* Bandwagon... Third on the wagon is a nice spot for the scum to hide. Coupled with your suspicious silence, I'm comfortable enough to Vote: Delwyn Couch (Ranger of the Forest) This vote is subject to change, especially if we need a lynch by the end of today. Just going to point out that Delwyn was only second on the wagon.... Vote: Mike Johnson (mediumsnowman) Oh Geez...........It's really hard to pick Day 1 without being accused of bandwagoning. Without any conclusive evidence, there's no reason for me to cast a vote on the highest voted candidate, Anthony although this move could possibly lead me to easily be accused of doing something suspicious and will make me liable for a lynch in the coming days. As I seem to be forced to vote I'll Vote:Doctor Wynn (Tariq j) for the sake of voting. Oh Geez....... Big ping. I must say, your reply to Foorth's ping was rather peculiar to me! Helpless roleplay, or a subtle questioning of the logic?! Vote: Ray Christiansen (Dragonfire) This doesn't have to be a final vote, but I'm reacting to something I saw and didn't much like! Fantastic! You're entitled to your own opinion, but I (and Humphrey) can reassure you that it was merely roleplay referring to Foorth's robot-ness (is that a word?). Why Dr. Wynn? Did you just pull his name out of a hat? How does this benefit anyone? If you're going to make a random day one vote, at least pretend there's a reason behind it. By saying upfront that your vote is random, you're immediately undermining your vote and giving Dr. Wynn no reason to take it seriously. Exactly.
JackJonespaw Posted December 12, 2015 Author Posted December 12, 2015 Current Votes: 1 Vote for Ewan Breckenride: (def) 1 Vote for Elijah: (jluck) 2 Votes for Anthony Dixon: (Lady K, RangeroftheForest) 2 Votes for Delwyn Couch: (mediumsnowman, Tariq J) 1 Vote for Molly Tolbert: (Tamomono) 1 Vote for Doctor Wynn: (Tachyon) 1 Vote for Ray Christiansen: (Bob) 1 Vote for Perce Triggs: (TinyPiesRUs) 1 Vote for Mike Johnson: (Dragonfire) WIth 17 players, it'll take a majority of 9 votes to complete a lynch.
Lady K Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Odd that we have so many suspects and Gale graced us with an appearance and didn't leave any thoughts or even one opinion for us......as a matter of fact he hasn't even sung once for us since this day has begun.
jluck Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Can you elaborate please, are you legitimately convinced he is scum or is this just a "reaction test" vote? Humphrey is curious... (Snip) It's because I wanted to get past the small talk and get something to talk about. Nothing better than going after Elijah to jump start conversation. Also...I wanted the title of Elijah changed to Jluck's B***ch but that seems to have stalled
KotZ Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Journal entry about water. Please don't let this hurt. That will just make me sweat more. Or maybe that's a good thing. #jluck'sb***ch What? Honestly, Jluck hasn't actually pinged me that much, he posts haven't been normal for sure but I see it as his role playing personality than scummy posts. But what I do find suspicious is you quickly jumping on the easiest bandwagon. So for that reason: Vote: Delwyn Couch (Ranger of the Forest) I think I see your point. My only worry is that if his personality is like this, who's to say it's not a way to ignore him or for the scum (if he's not one) to place blame on him? I won't vote for him just because it does seem personality based but it might be worth it to keep an eye on him. Then do you want me to continue the bandwagon on you ? It doesn't bother me in the slightest on whether you die or not. If your'e scum that's bonus. If your not, then I treat it as a day 1 mislynch. Even if I get lynched today, the town doesn't lose anyone important. That seems like a pretty weird way to claim. Could be neutral. Maybe you're vanilla, but claiming that early seems a weird move. It doesn't register right with me. Vote: Perce Triggs (Tachyon)
mediumsnowman Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 I really don't like this post, you're being both non-committal and unhelpful to town. As Elijah said, unvotes are allowed. Voting for someone now gives reactions and can help catch scum, and you're not helping with this. It's interesting that as soon as Elijah calls you out, you immediately do a U-turn and vote at once. Just going to point out that Delwyn was only second on the wagon.... Vote: Mike Johnson (mediumsnowman) You can look at the timestamps, I didn't see his post asking me to vote until after I had finished my post. There's no way I could have finished writing my post in 1 minute. Looking back, she was 2nd on the wagon. I can't count today.
Lady K Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Then do you want me to continue the bandwagon on you ? It doesn't bother me in the slightest on whether you die or not. If your'e scum that's bonus. If your not, then I treat it as a day 1 mislynch. Even if I get lynched today, the town doesn't lose anyone important. I have to say that this is a pretty anti-townie thing to say. It is a bit rough to just say 'hey if your a townie you don't matter it just a bad call for day 1'. And why would you offer yourself up so easily? A vanilla townie can still vote and that is important.
Dragonfire Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 It's because I wanted to get past the small talk and get something to talk about. Nothing better than going after Elijah to jump start conversation. Also...I wanted the title of Elijah changed to Jluck's B***ch but that seems to have stalled You seemed almost 100% sure he was scum. Voting to get people to talk and move the day along doesn't look like how you voted..... You can look at the timestamps, I didn't see his post asking me to vote until after I had finished my post. There's no way I could have finished writing my post in 1 minute. Looking back, she was 2nd on the wagon. I can't count today. My bad; however, your non-committal attitude is still scummy, and you still did a U-turn (from not wanting to vote, to voting Delwyn). So my vote stands. Humphrey disapproves.
Tariq j Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 I think I see your point. My only worry is that if his personality is like this, who's to say it's not a way to ignore him or for the scum (if he's not one) to place blame on him? I won't vote for him just because it does seem personality based but it might be worth it to keep an eye on him. I think that's the hardest thing about personalities, it can be hard to distinguish between a loud personality and a scummy poster. I'm giving Mike the benefit of the doubt here. Odd that we have so many suspects and Gale graced us with an appearance and didn't leave any thoughts or even one opinion for us......as a matter of fact he hasn't even sung once for us since this day has begun. That's an interesting point, Gale, you haven't shown up at all in the whole day - what are your thoughts on the matter? I've also noticed there seem to be a lot of other members who've ducked the ball - Ewan, Delwyn.
KotZ Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 I think that's the hardest thing about personalities, it can be hard to distinguish between a loud personality and a scummy poster. I'm giving Mike the benefit of the doubt here. I agree. Seems like a good reason just to take note of him and see what happens tomorrow and what he says. There's a difference between a loud personality and being scummy. Difficult but it is possible. That's an interesting point, Gale, you haven't shown up at all in the whole day - what are your thoughts on the matter? I've also noticed there seem to be a lot of other members who've ducked the ball - Ewan, Delwyn. It's been a relatively quiet first day. It would be nice to hear from some people.
mediumsnowman Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 I think that's the hardest thing about personalities, it can be hard to distinguish between a loud personality and a scummy poster. I'm giving Mike the benefit of the doubt here. Me? I thought Quincy was talking about jluck here.
Tariq j Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Me? I thought Quincy was talking about jluck here. Sorry, I meant Jluck, I got the wrong name here
KotZ Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Me? I thought Quincy was talking about jluck here. Sorry, I meant Jluck, I got the wrong name here Yup, I should have corrected that when I replied. Sorry for that.
mediumsnowman Posted December 12, 2015 Posted December 12, 2015 Hey Delwyn, I see you're here, so what are your thoughts? I also see you haven't defended yourself or even acknowledged the fact that you've garnered 2 votes so far.
Recommended Posts