KotZ Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Just now, Foreman said: Vote: Hera Syndulla (Stickfig) Bob you're safe from me today but if I die at night I'll blame you Also, make sure you bold your vote. I've said it before and I'll say it again. Day 1 votes are a pain. Vote: Wonder Woman (Forresto) I don't trust Fanta drinkers.
Trekkie99 Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Just now, Foreman said: @StickFig, you hear that? say your prayers But remember that a person claiming miller can be one of two things. (1) A actual miller. (2) A mafia scum claiming miller in an attempt to protect himself in the advent there is a investigator.
Foreman Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Vote: Hera Syndulla (Stickfig) Karai are you happy now? Just now, LegoMonorailFan said: But remember that a person claiming miller can be one of two things. (1) A actual miller. (2) A mafia scum claiming miller in an attempt to protect himself in the advent there is a investigator. I know, if voting was optional I'd wouldn't vote yet
Asphalt Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Vote: Superman (Bob) A pirate Superman, that's crazy even for me.
Trekkie99 Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Just now, Foreman said: I know, if voting was optional I'd wouldn't vote yet You can vote at any point you like in the remaining hours of day one. What's important is having your vote cast before the day is over.
Trekkie99 Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Speaking of voting, I'm going to... Vote: Hera Syndulla (Stickfig) Reasons? Her miller claim is all we have to work with at the moment compared to everyone else who we still know nothing about.
Lady K Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Ok, so I got lost, bad navigation system in the Tardis: I was trying to look to the future for answers as to who is who in this room we are trapped in with cold pizza and warm sodas, no luck. Glad I brought my own beverage; Andromeda Galaxy Fizzy with extra lava heath boost.
Khscarymovie4 Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 Oh boy, voting be open. I think our alien girl's miller claim is an interesting point of interest, but it could be very much as the truth, as it could be the lie. I don't trust her but I don't feel she needs to walk the plank as of yet. In fact being the first sunlight of this journey I feel no one should fly beyond the beautiful clouds today. But not let us cease in our discussions and remember to vote as it's good for latter days hard work. I'm going to Vote: The Joker (asphalt) as I just learned what a "bath" is, and oh my blue mother does it sound worse then a thousand British ships seeking to seal your tomb on a cold November's night.
Tariq j Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 3 hours ago, Foreman said: very suspicious Bob, I won't vote you... today I wouldn't say it was that suspicious, it's a common role and it's reasonable to claim. But that's not to say I trust him completely yet.
Asphalt Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 27 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: Oh boy, voting be open. I think our alien girl's miller claim is an interesting point of interest, but it could be very much as the truth, as it could be the lie. I don't trust her but I don't feel she needs to walk the plank as of yet. In fact being the first sunlight of this journey I feel no one should fly beyond the beautiful clouds today. But not let us cease in our discussions and remember to vote as it's good for latter days hard work. I'm going to Vote: The Joker (asphalt) as I just learned what a "bath" is, and oh my blue mother does it sound worse then a thousand British ships seeking to seal your tomb on a cold November's night. Why golly gee mr. sailor man. It was an honor just to be nominated.
Rider Raider Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 I’m going to use my random day one throwaway vote on Ellie Sattler, because I’ve never met a trustworthy paleobotanist. Vote: Ellie Sattler (legomonorailfan)
Tariq j Posted November 9, 2018 Posted November 9, 2018 1 hour ago, LegoMonorailFan said: But remember that a person claiming miller can be one of two things. (1) A actual miller. (2) A mafia scum claiming miller in an attempt to protect himself in the advent there is a investigator. Number 1 would make sense as to not waste a potential investigation and possible get a stable town block. For 2 I feel like it would be a bold move to make this early, I just feel like killing the only person with a potential town role would be a bad move.
Foreman Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 20 minutes ago, Tariq j said: Number 1 would make sense as to not waste a potential investigation and possible get a stable town block. For 2 I feel like it would be a bold move to make this early, I just feel like killing the only person with a potential town role would be a bad move. you're also the only one with a potential Scum role
Trekkie99 Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 14 minutes ago, Foreman said: you're also the only one with a potential Scum role How so?
Foreman Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 I meant Stickfig because of her that's a scummy claim if I ever saw one
Trekkie99 Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 1 minute ago, Foreman said: I meant Stickfig because of her that's a scummy claim if I ever saw one Oh, I see. well it's worth keeping an eye naturally, but I wouldn't consider it lynch worthy. I prefer not to have a lynch on day one anyway
KotZ Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 1 hour ago, Asphalt said: Why golly gee mr. sailor man. It was an honor just to be nominated. This made me laugh. I love it.
jluck Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 9 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said: Yes, back a long time ago when seas were blue and sky's were grey. We had a Miller claim. I believe it was the missing Legolas Who told the tale of the miller the last time I went to our admirals little party. It was true it was. This one could be a fib or a truth. Good to keep an eye out. Both, unless your Moody. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Miller Yep, I’ve seen these Miller claims for many years now and not once has it turned out to be a scum lie. Not saying this isn’t the first time, but I’m inclined to let it pass for now. In the interest in poking the bear I’ll Vote: elli Satler (legomonorailfan) she just seems to be a little zealous right now...
fhomess Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 8 hours ago, KotZ said: I don't trust Fanta drinkers. /shakes head disapprovingly 6 hours ago, Rider Raider said: ... because I’ve never met a trustworthy paleobotanist. /nods head in agreement 6 hours ago, Foreman said: I meant Stickfig because of her that's a scummy claim if I ever saw one /cocks head to one side with an eyebrow raised. 29 minutes ago, jluck said: Yep, I’ve seen these Miller claims for many years now and not once has it turned out to be a scum lie. Not saying this isn’t the first time, but I’m inclined to let it pass for now. In the interest in poking the bear I’ll Vote: elli Satler (legomonorailfan) she just seems to be a little zealous right now... There will be a first time for it, but I haven't seen it yet, either. The thing that the folks voting for Hera need to figure out is whether or not they have reason to think the miller claim is a lie. What does Hera gain in comparison with what she loses. If Hera's a townie, then it's the right move. I think by now we can rest comfortably with the notion that no one else is coming forward to counter-claim. To me, miller is a bit of a dangerous claim for scum because if they have a night action, they can be discovered as not a miller in multiple ways and they have little way of knowing if the town possesses any of those abilities. Vote: Ellie Sattler (LegoMonorailFan) She is easily the most scummy to me at this point, which is saying something for so early in the game. 7 hours ago, LegoMonorailFan said: Speaking of voting, I'm going to... Vote: Hera Syndulla (Stickfig) Reasons? Her miller claim is all we have to work with at the moment compared to everyone else who we still know nothing about. 5 hours ago, LegoMonorailFan said: Oh, I see. well it's worth keeping an eye naturally, but I wouldn't consider it lynch worthy. I prefer not to have a lynch on day one anyway This doesn't sit well with me... seems contradictory.
Trekkie99 Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 6 hours ago, jluck said: Vote: elli Satler (legomonorailfan) 6 hours ago, fhomess said: Vote: Ellie Sattler (LegoMonorailFan) Well it's good to finally see some finger pointing. 6 hours ago, jluck said: Yep, I’ve seen these Miller claims for many years now and not once has it turned out to be a scum lie. Not saying this isn’t the first time, but I’m inclined to let it pass for now. I've had two or three lives before this one, and I believe there was a miller claim in one of those. I never paid attention to it then because I wasn't completely sure what their role was, but @StickFig put it so simply, and I quote: I am town, but I show up as scum when investigated. To me that sounded like a great place for a scum to hide. And since it's only day one I thought it would be the best place to put my vote in order to get some discussion going. 7 hours ago, jluck said: she just seems to be a little zealous right now... I just enjoy teaching new players. 6 hours ago, fhomess said: This doesn't sit well with me... seems contradictory. In my post where I cast my vote, I never implied that I wanted to lynch her. Like I've said above, I just thought it was a good place to cast my vote in order to create some discussion. My post which clarifies that I don't want a day one lynch was mostly me coaching are new player @Foreman.
Tariq j Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 12 hours ago, LegoMonorailFan said: Oh, I see. well it's worth keeping an eye naturally, but I wouldn't consider it lynch worthy. I prefer not to have a lynch on day one anyway You don’t consider it Lynch worthy and prefer not to have a lynch, but have voted for her anyway? I feel like we’re reading into the Miller claim too much, as well as trying generate a discussion for Day One, the Miller claim could save time later in the game. Say Hera hadn’t claimed and the investigator investigates her later in the game, He/She gets a scum result back, they reveal it in the day thread and we spend the day discussing it and lynching her. That’s a whole day wasted. By having the claim now we can avoid that scenario. Vote: Ellie Sattler (Legomonorailfan) Just now, LegoMonorailFan said: To me that sounded like a great place for a scum to hide. And since it's only day one I thought it would be the best place to put my vote in order to get some discussion going. I get where you’re coming from with that, but then to claim this early, Hera would have to tread on egg shells for the rest of the game in order to make herself town. There are so many roles like the tracker, watcher, etc. That could catch her out here.
Forresto Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 Day one voting is always erratic as there is very little information or evidence to go off of. Claims of people acting scummy today are strange to me. How dumb would scum have to be to act scummy today? If we vote someone out today let’s be honest with eachother and know it’s an arbitrary vote. The question is do we vote someone out? I usually am for it because even if we vote our someone innocent we narrow our field of suspects down. Plus it gives a better record of how people voted because a vote to eliminate ends with consequences, there’s intent in it as opposed to the typical meaningless ones scattered about just to not get a vote penalty.
StickFig Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 16 hours ago, Foreman said: I meant Stickfig because of her that's a scummy claim if I ever saw one Thanks, Foreman. I would vote right back for you, but I don't think you've ever seen one, so I'm just chalking it up to inexperience. Vote: Legolas Twinleaf (jluck) @jluck, your vote for LegoMonorailFan seemed to come at the perfect point for a scum: early enough (and follow-able enough) to start a bandwagon on an active Day 1 player. I may be giving you too much credit since you were the second vote, so perhaps I will change to @fhomess (the third vote). And hey, @LegoMonorailFan has been active enough to draw suspicion. Yes, I realize I've just called out three people who defended my miller claim. Plenty of time for scum to trip up.
Kintobor Posted November 10, 2018 Author Posted November 10, 2018 Current Vote Count: Hera Syndulla (Stickfig): 2 Votes (Foreman, LegoMonorailFan) Wonder Woman (Forresto): 1 Vote (KotZ) Superman (Bob): 1 Vote (Asphalt) The Joker (Asphalt): 1 Vote (Khscarymovie4) Ellie Sattler (LegoMonorailFan): 4 Votes (Rider Raider, jluck, fhomess, Tariq j) Legolas Twinleaf (jluck): 1 Vote (Stickfig) It takes a majority of 8 votes to eliminate a player. 5 hours remain. "A brief reminder that voting is mandatory, and those who do not vote will be slapped with a 5 vote penalty the following day, or enough to constitute them being two votes away from being lynched."
Foreman Posted November 10, 2018 Posted November 10, 2018 5 hours ago, LegoMonorailFan said: I just enjoy teaching new players. In my post where I cast my vote, I never implied that I wanted to lynch her. Like I've said above, I just thought it was a good place to cast my vote in order to create some discussion. My post which clarifies that I don't want a day one lynch was mostly me coaching are new player @Foreman. Hey, I don't need hand holding, I've played Mafia before, just not on eurobricks, and not with mandatory voting 5 hours ago, Tariq j said: You don’t consider it Lynch worthy and prefer not to have a lynch, but have voted for her anyway? I feel like we’re reading into the Miller claim too much, as well as trying generate a discussion for Day One, the Miller claim could save time later in the game. Say Hera hadn’t claimed and the investigator investigates her later in the game, He/She gets a scum result back, they reveal it in the day thread and we spend the day discussing it and lynching her. That’s a whole day wasted. By having the claim now we can avoid that scenario. well I've wouldn't vote her yet if voting was optional, the only reason I'm voting is because it's mandatory
Recommended Posts