Lady K Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 3 hours ago, fhomess said: You're right about all of this. Yet you don't really address the case against Ellie. Anyway, let me walk through the notion that scum are likely to be splitting their votes. Assume for a moment that there are 3 scum remaining (I don't care too much about the neutral... that's just speculation), then it's LYLO. We lynch a scum or we lose. If a townie is lynched, we enter the night with 3 scum and 3 non-scum. If there's a neutral, the scum have won as they outnumber us. If not, then all they need to do is have their night kill be successful and/or survive the night. If we lynch no one, then the scum simply have to be successful at night and survive to win. That's why I think Barbossa's shock at the extra night kill is of particular interest. Assuming there are 2 scum remaining, then it's entirely possible they have split their votes, but at this point, the scummiest folks are all on Barbossa and Superman. Sure, the miller may be the issue, I'm willing to deal with that later. However, if there are only 2 scum remaining, then I think we can afford a mislynch in order to address the 3 scum remaining scenario. Thank you for addressing my concerns. I haven't addressed the case against Ellie for two reasons. The first is that I really find Barbossa far more suspicious which is why I placed my vote there. Ellie has just been my second choice, however, I never had a problem voting for Ellie if that is the direction of town. Her most concerning post today is given below. 11 hours ago, LegoMonorailFan said: Well Superman is the scummiest person in this room IMO. Vote: Superman (Bob) Reasons? For pursing ,and for encouraging the town to pursue, a lynch which is highly illogical. I honestly don't have the best scum reads on most of the people in this room, but I do however have a fairly good town read on @Khscarymovie4. I also had, and many would probably say the same, a fairly high scum read on KotZ. So for @Bob to say that Barbossa pushed for KotZ's lynch, and that if KotZ flips town then Khcarymovie4 must be scum, makes me think that Bob is scum and is chasing what he views as an easy lynch. He's even seemingly ordered the vig to kill one of his select choices ( I know I'm not scum, and while @Asphalt has been rather lackluster in his commentary, I'm willing to give him a pass based on the fact that Bob ordered for him to be killed). Then all he has to do is kill one of the remaining townies and he's won. I find this concerning due to the fact that she states the lynch being pursed by Superman as highly illogical and then gives a good townie read on Barbossa. Like she is trying to save Barbossa from a lynch, or even trying to distance herself from Superman. So yes, I do believe the case against her. This then leads the questions of who is she trying to protect if flipped scum tomorrow, Barbossa or Superman (or even both)? 36 minutes ago, Bob said: I've got no problem voting for Sattler. Unvote: Barbossa / Khscarymovie4 Vote: Ellie Sattler / LegoMonorailFan Interesting that you're coming out against Sattler. Perhaps in a hope to look innocent tomorrow when she flips scum. We'll see. A reason would be appreciated, I would like to hear what you have to say. I have given my reasons above so: Uvote: Hector Barbossa (Khscarymovie4) Vote: Ellie Sattler (LegoMonorailFan) However, I do want a closer look taken tomorrow at Barbossa. I still feel he is one of the scummy.
Khscarymovie4 Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 6 hours ago, fhomess said: That said, Barbossa's reaction to the night kills suggests he knew scum targeted Batgirl. It's entirely possible that Doc Brown was the scum kill and Batgirl was a vig or SK kill. Barbossa doesn't consider this at all. You are confident enough in your vote for Superman and your read of Dr. Who OVER Ellie that you do not wish to vote for Ellie. Noted. You're calling out Superman for note switching to Ellie, but you're doing the same thing, essentially. Fair point about me on the kills. While I do think that Dr. Brown being the vig kill is more likely I do suppose I'm being to certain about that speculation. 9 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said: Then change your vote like your so willing to do instead of complaining that were not getting anywhere! Also I asked you what you found scummy about Ellie specifically and yet no answer has arisen. So I ask you again, why do you find Ellie Sattler suspicious enough to vote for her? No I'm not calling out Superman just based off of him not voting for Ellie, but the fact that he complained about the votes being split and yet could easily change that himself. I don't have too much of a scummy feel for you but I honestly think your just twisting my words here. 1 hour ago, Bob said: I've got no problem voting for Sattler. Unvote: Barbossa / Khscarymovie4 Vote: Ellie Sattler / LegoMonorailFan Interesting that you're coming out against Sattler. Perhaps in a hope to look innocent tomorrow when she flips scum. We'll see. Any reasons at all? Town members please keep in mind this fake pirates lack of a reason even though many have asked him to provide one for tomorrow. So Ellie, our plant girl shall be lynched. I sure do hope she is a scum. Or else were in a heap of trouble. Superman my eyes won't leave your sight until something is done with you. I had suspicions at the beginning of the day but your responses have made you look mighty fishy today.
Kintobor Posted December 5, 2018 Author Posted December 5, 2018 Final Vote Count for Day Five Superman (Bob) 2 Votes- (Khscarymovie4, LegoMonorailFan) Ellie Sattler (LegoMonorailFan) 5 Votes (Stickfig, fhomess, Asphalt, Bob, Lady K) With a majority of four reached, Ellie Sattler is Lynched. Day Five is now over. You have 48 hours to send in your night actions. The day conclusion will be up shortly.
Kintobor Posted December 7, 2018 Author Posted December 7, 2018 The group pushed LegoMonorailFan, cosplaying as Ellie Sattler, to the front, jabbing their fingers in the accused's direction. "I-I don't know what any of this means! Why would you accuse me? There's no real correlation between the votes on Day One and today! Any scientist could tell you that!" LegoMonorailFan pleaded their case, but Kintobor merely tutted his head in dismay. "Nothing you do or say is going to get you out of this one, Dr. MonorailFan. Now then, I do believe it's time to proceed with the traditional end of day lynch!" Kintobor hovered his finger over the button on the console, it's big red button flashing. He swiftly pushed it- only to have LegoMonorailFan still in one piece. "Um... well, this is awkward." Kintobor replied, clearly unimpressed. "That's what I get for buying these nanobots and head-exploding modules on the cheap." "So... am I free to go?" LegoMonorailFan asked. Kintobor's laugh shot down any hope for LegoMonorailFan's safety. "Pfft. No. Sakura? Can you handle this?" Kintobor asked his assistant. Nodding gingerly, Sakura pulled out a revolver from her schoolbag and aimed it directly at LegoMonorailFan! BANG!!! Sakura silently giggled to herself as LegoMonorailFan's corpse hit the ground, blood pooling out from their head. "Well, you'll all figure out if you nabbed a scum tomorrow. For now, go get some shut eye!" Kintobor waved his players off as they shuffled to bed.
Recommended Posts