Hi all, due to the good reception that I got from my Castle/Historical Ideas support thread, I've decided to maintain one for Pirates too.

The idea is that this thread can be a place to come to find out about current Lego Ideas entries and give them our support in an efficient manner, from the community that loves Pirates the most.

Last Updated: 17th June 2020.

Ending Soon (URGENT VOTES NEEDED):

• Imperial Trading Ship by @Sebeus I.

Nearly There (Needs more votes):

• Caribbean Clipper by Babyteeth.

Aging Entries (Needs a boost):

• Spanish Galleon Warship by Babyteeth.
• Amerigo Vespucci training ship by Mr.Mattoncino.
• The Pirate Wreckers of False Lighthouse Cove by DefrostedPoppy.
• The Sword of the Seas by Bricky_Brick. @paokus The Pirate Bay builder!
• Treasure Cove Water Slide by @siuliano.
• HMS Surprise by Skulls1234.
• The Flying Dutchman by Scarvia.
• Tall Ship by @Sebeus I.
• Pirate Essentials by ChaMi.
• Wreck in the Abyss by Ian Malcolm.
• Tintin - The Unicorn by SaltyFish.
• Simple Ship by LEGObviously.
• Modular Island Fortress by techam.
• The Royal Flagship by Kolonialbeamter.
• The Pirates of Tortuga by Gustavingo.
• Green Coat Trading Fort by hickernator.
• Caribbean Pirate Galleon by Babyteeth.
• Davy Jones by Namirob (creator of the Medieval Blacksmith that's currently in review).
• Soldier Imperial Golden Fort by @Master0889.
• The Unicorn by RynardP.
• The Rolling Dutchman by Störtebricker.
• The Ship Sinker. by Greenflame24.
• Blue Coats Sea Watch Tower by @Master0889.
• Spanish Galleon by SparksBricks.
• The Fruit Pirates by brickster0404 (a bit abstract this one, but I like it).
• Chromed Classics by MinifigInSpace.
• Mini BrickBeard's Bounty by Lionard.
• HMS Legacy by nwisaacson.
• 18th Century Rigged Frigate by Sandal.
• The Voyage of the Dawn Treader by Jcreations912.
• The Kraken by Zectonoid016.
• Pirates Of The Caribbean - Maelstrom Duel by Micro_Model_Maker, aka @legoMoccer.
• The Fortress by @Piraten.
• Return To Volcano Island by Micro_Model_Maker, aka @legoMoccer.
• Jack's adventures - Pirates of the Caribbean by Davy_92.
• Red Coat's Seaside Fortress by Xman.
• Pirates of the Caribbean Kraken Attack by tombungee.
• Fortress Caribbean Imperial by Fedebort.
• Pirates of the Caribbean: The Endeavour by tombungee.
• Seagull Bay Lighthouse Imperial Fortress by Delusion Keeper @Delusion Brick.
• Tribal Village by ThirdKookyUrchin.
• H.M.S. Ideas by Xman.
• Castaway's Sandcastle by Taris120.
• Eldorado Fortress Redux by @LM71Blackbird.
• The Skull's Eye Schooner by Red Spaceman.
• HMS Surprise by Naboo1.
• Imperial Island Fort by BrickHammer.
• The Kraken by steveiuliano. @siuliano.
• Imperial Fort by Cube Brick.
• English Fort by Klarinik.
• The Pirate Raft by DomesticLego.

New Entries: 

• Islanders Spirit Beacon by Sir Archibald.

Edited June 17, 20204 yr by leafan
Added 1

Awesome index!! Thanks!

On 3/4/2019 at 1:45 PM, leafan said:

Hi all, due to the good reception that I got from my Castle/Historical Ideas support thread, I've decided to maintain one for Pirates too.

Heh, I totally missed this yesterday, an excellent index for starts by the way!  

On 3/4/2019 at 1:45 PM, leafan said:

Imperial Brigantine "Dolphin" by LM71Blackbird. (Days left, urgent votes needed!)

P.S. The creator of this project in particular ( @LM71Blackbird ) is here on EB! 

1 hour ago, Digger of Bricks said:

P.S. The creator of this project in particular ( @LM71Blackbird ) is here on EB! 

Thank you, I have added tags to the original post.

1 hour ago, Fraunces said:

Awesome index!! Thanks!

No bother matey. Save me a bottle 'o' rum for when m'watch ends.

@paokus Congratulations on reaching 10k votes on Lego Ideas for your gorgeous moc The Pirate Bay!

1 hour ago, leafan said:

@paokus Congratulations on reaching 10k votes on Lego Ideas for your gorgeous moc The Pirate Bay!

Ya know, unless I'm mistaken, I believe this may be the first Pirate-themed LEGO Ideas project to ever achieve support! 

Thanks @leafan and @Digger of Bricks for the shoutout! It is much appreciated!

Just now, LM71Blackbird said:

Thanks @leafan and @Digger of Bricks for the shoutout! It is much appreciated!

You're most welcome!  

Found another worthy contender:

Pirate's Island by Campistron1984.

Spoiler

 

Also, this beaut:

Imperial Mastership by pick0212.

Spoiler

 

Nice thread.

I do hope some smaller pirate ideas get popular enough, now that the big one hit 10000 super fast.

Edited March 12, 20195 yr by TeriXeri

There's a new ship on the sea's o'Lego maties. Y'arrr.

Pirate Barque by Sebeus:

Spoiler

 

While a nice design, it is a re-release of an earlier project, with a number of boat parts which aren't produced anymore as far as I know.
Too bad he didn't update the cabin windows with 2x2 lattices though. Would look a bit more authentic.

LEGO Ideas - The Pirate Wreckers of False Lighthouse Cove by DefrostedPoppy

On 4/13/2019 at 2:05 AM, Digger of Bricks said:

LEGO Ideas - The Pirate Wreckers of False Lighthouse Cove by DefrostedPoppy

Ha I was just coming here to add this but I should have known m'old matey @Digger of Bricks would have beaten me to it.

Lovely looking moc I might add.

Well, looky here what @paokus has cooked up for submission today... 

LEGO Ideas - The Sword of the Seas by Bricky_Brick

Thanks so much my friend!

9 hours ago, Digger of Bricks said:

Well, looky here what @paokus has cooked up for submission today... 

LEGO Ideas - The Sword of the Seas by Bricky_Brick

Gorgeous! I will add it now.

22 minutes ago, paokus said:

Thanks so much my friend!

No, thank you! Let us know if you're working on any future Historical type projects, or even in general :)

1 hour ago, paokus said:

Thanks so much my friend!

As always @paokus!  Congratulations on already gathering more than 150 supporters!!!  

I consider the pirate theme in Lego one of the best. I like the work of authors and especially designers.

 

Nice index, Imperial Outpost seems to have potential as it evokes sets from the original Pirates theme...

(Should it not be named "Armada Outpost" to be consistent with Armada Sentry and Armada Flagship?)

However, it lacks design innovation and could use more colour.

• The structure should be placed at the rear of the baseplate. The playability takes place at the front of the design, so more water frontage makes sense.
• Needs more red. Observe how Armada Sentry balances the white and green with red accessories and a splash of yellow.
• We've seen plenty square/block architecture in past LEGO Pirate forts, maybe try some curves
• The middle of the outpost should not be walled off, it needs to be open - should have an arched window or some clever architecture to open the space up.
• Needs a sail boat with a second pirate (think Lagoon Lockup)
• Should have a palm tree - this is a staple of sets at this price point.
• Some kind of action feature would make things more interesting.  John Cook is breaking out, so base an action feature around that.
• Even though there are a generous number of accessories, the design still feels a bit empty, although I suspect this is a result due of lack of colour.

Those suggestions aside, this is still a good effort, but it does feel as though I could undergo more refinement.

 

Here's a newly-submitted "Pirates" themed project more in the vein of Lego's more recent homage sets:

LEGO Ideas - Treasure Cove Water Slide by siuliano

Hi @Digger of Bricks, thanks for posting my Treasure Cove Water Slide LEGO idea.

I just joined Eurobricks and saw this post so cheers!

There's some 'incredible' MOCs / builds on here.

@paokus I'm a big fan. I will certainly be buying your pirate bay build when it hits the shelves (fingers crossed).

1 hour ago, siuliano said:

Hi @Digger of Bricks, thanks for posting my Treasure Cove Water Slide LEGO idea.

I just joined Eurobricks and saw this post so cheers!

There's some 'incredible' MOCs / builds on here.

Welcome to Eurobricks @siuliano! 

If you haven't already, please do also check out @leafan's sister topic for this index if you're interested! 

Here's to wishing you best of luck over at LEGO Ideas! 

Great! Thanks a lot!

Here's a newly-submitted Frigate project that's worth mentioning here: HMS Surprise by Skulls1234

LEGO IDEAS - The Flying Dutchman by ZedKay

LEGO Flying Dutchman - Final by ZedKay

Edited April 20, 20204 yr by ZedKay
changed username on LEGO IDEAS