Hinckley Posted May 5, 2019 Posted May 5, 2019 Players (in their anonymous character accounts) only please!!! Rules (Deviations from the EB standard Mafia rules are in bold blue. Modified clauses have been struck through.) 1. Each player will be given a character to play, who will be aligned with either the Villagers (Town) or the Hellions (Mafia) or the Monsters (Mafia). To win the game, the Town must kill off all the Mafia, while the Mafia needs to outnumber the Town Monsters must eliminate the Hellions and control 50% of the village or nothing can prevent this from occurring, and the Hellions must eliminate the Monsters and control 50% of the village or nothing can prevent this from occurring Third-Party (neutral) characters have their own win conditions as outlined in their roles. Mod note: Why the clarification of the win conditions now? The two Scum factions have had this win condition in their role PMs from Day One. The wording in the rules was accurate but purposely vague as this game has a closed setup, meaning the mechanics are not revealed to everyone before the games begins. The trigger in the game for the win condition to be clarified in the rules was the first Scum deaths, so there you go. Carry on... 1a. This is an anonymous game and you may only post in your character account sent to you by the host. Be sure to check before you post that you are in your anonymous account and not in your main Eurobricks account. 1b. Those who are allowed to communicate in private should not reveal their true identities to each other, either. 2. Each day you will be able to vote to lynch a player. Voting should be done in the following format; Vote: Character (Player). Similarly, unvoting is to be done in the format; Unvote: Character (Player). No other format will be accepted. A majority vote is required to lynch a player. 3. A game day will last a maximum of 72 hours. You may not vote in the first 24 hours. The day will end when a majority vote has been reached. A majority being reached will not end the day. The day will continue for the full 72 hours and any majority vote that is reached can be overturned. After the day has concluded, a night stage will commence, which will last a maximum of 48 hours. Night actions must be sent to the host in the first 24 hours of the night stage. 3.5. Players may not target the same player two nights in a row, and may not target themselves. Unless otherwise noted in your role PM, players can target the same player two nights in a row or themselves. 4. The alignment of lynched players, as well as those that died during the night, will be revealed at the beginning of the following day. 5. You may not quote or pretend to quote anything sent to or from you in PM with the game host. This includes all the details of your character and role, as well as any night action results. Role claims and reporting of night action results are acceptable, but in your own words only. Do not attempt to use the structure of your role PM to your advantage. Similarly, you may not directly quote any communications (via PM or writeboard) that were sent to you by other players in the game. If you wish to reveal private communications, these must also be paraphrased. 5a. The Role PM is structured for every player in this way: Character: Character name (player) Affiliation: Villager (Town) or Hellions (Scum) or Monsters (Scum) or third-party (Neutral) Role: [Either the details of a Night Action or] Your weapon is your vote, you have no night actions. 6. Do not play the game outside the thread. Similarly, do not post out of character inside the thread; you must always play the role given to you. Game tactics and roles may only be discussed in the game thread or via PM with other players. Private discussion is done at your own risk and should be treated as part of the game. 6a. Only specific players are allowed to communicate outside of the day thread. These players are only allowed to communicate with each other during the Night phase of the game. As reporting of Night Action results to each other may be hindered by time zones, this allowable communication period will last until voting opens in the Day thread. 7. If you are dead, you may not post in thread or discuss the game with any of the players. Any information you had becomes void, and may not be passed on. 8. You may not edit your posts. 9. You must post in every day thread. 10. If you encounter a problem or have a question, please contact the host via PM. 11. Violation of the above rules will result in a vote penalty of half the required majority against you on your first offence, and the death of your character on your second offence. Violation of rule 7 will have a heavier penalty, including suspension, made at the discretion of the Games Moderator. 12. There are no hints or clues in the day/night images. NPC Schaefer Sheepdog, Lawspeaker Palma Pig, Scribe Pernilla, Badass Sundra Spider, Forest Shaman Characters (7) Bennett Bulldog, Cheftain Brewer Bunny, Trauma Therapist Caldwell Crocodile, Fisherman Ember Elephant, Explorer Haydn Hippo, Dishwasher Leevi Lion, Bricklayer Whitby Walrus, Cook **Occupations are strictly for players to have fun with their characters. Deceased (8) Braxton Bear, Blacksmith, murdered Night One Villager Cleo Cow, Coin Minter, murdered Night One Villager Myrtle Monkey, Seamstress, lynched Day Two Villager Pascha Poodle, Carpenter, murdered Night Two Villager Pierot Parrot, Magistrate, murdered Night Two Villager Huxley Horse, Farmer, lynched Day Three Monster Gracie Goat, Silk Merchant, murdered Night Three Hellion Ronan Rabbit, Bread Merchant, murdered Night Three Villager Day Four has begun. You may not vote during the first 24 hours. Players with the ability to communicate outside of the Day thread may continue to do so until voting begins. Mod note: Quick explanation regarding the cut scenes with characters who do not end up dead. Does their appearance implicate them? No. Does it exonerate them? No. There are no clues in the pictures. The characters appearing in the night pictures are selected the same way I selected everything in this game, randomly. Carry on...
Brewer Bunny Posted May 5, 2019 Posted May 5, 2019 Well that went rather well for us! I had doubts about the lynch and thought it may turn out bad for the town, but I am very gladly proven wrong. Also good too see another scum taken out during the night. Interesting to note that it seems Huxley and Gracie were not on the same team. Sad to hear we lost a loyal rabbit last night but we shall avenge her. Day 1 Final Vote Tally Braxton Bear: 7 (Haydn Hippo, Myrtle Monkey, Gracie Goat, Ronan Rabbit, Caldwell Crocodile, Huxley Horse, Brewer Bunny)Haydn Hippo: 2 (Braxton Bear, Bennett Bulldog)Myrtle Monkey: 3 (Leevi Lion. Whitby Walrus, Cleo Cow)Huxley Horse: 2 (Pascha Poodle, Pierot Parrot)Gracie Goat: 1 (Ember Elephant) Non-voters: 0 Day 2 Myrtle Monkey: 7 (Pierot Parrot, Ember Elephant, Whitby Walrus, Gracie Goat, Ronan Rabbit, Leevi Lion, Huxley Horse)Ronan Rabbit: 1 (Myrtle Monkey)Caldwell Crocodile: 1 (Brewer Bunny)Leevi Lion: 1 (Pascha Poodle)Ember Elephant: 1 (Haydn Hippo)Non-voters: 2 (Caldwell Crocodile, Bennett Bulldog) Day 3 Final Vote Tally Caldwell Crocodile: 1 (Ronan Rabbit)Huxley Horse: 7 (Bennett Bulldog, Leevi Lion, Haydn Hippo, Caldwell Crocodile, Brewer Bunny, Ember Elephant, Gracie Goat)Haydn Hippo: 1 (Whitby Walrus)Bennett Bulldog: 1 (Huxley Horse) I said yesterday that Huxley Horse, Gracie Goat, and Ronan Rabbit had all voted for the main lynch for days one and two. Seeing as how they have all died and two of them were scum it seems I was right in my thought that we should have kept an eye on them. While I had Caldwell at the top of my suspect list yesterday, he did seem to be annoyed with the fact not a lot of animals were looking at Huxley, and thus I get the impression he is not a monster. Could possibly be a hellion I suspect. I don't know if I would say this is suspicious but I looked back at the words written of yesterday and our friend Ember said very little. Well that itself would not be too bad, but his 3 post did not were not very helpful. Quote Seems our exceptionally anti-Monsters friend has died, which is not the best news to receive. Perhaps it wasn't the best idea to openly share this in thread. I'm willing to bet he was killed by a Monster, since he advertised himself as particularly anti-Monster. That just leaves wondering why the Hellions went after Pascha Poodle. Did she strike a nerve when she voted for Leevi Lion? Leevi was one of the people who voted to lynch Myrtle. Still, it's unfortunate out of the five dead that none were scum, especially with two scum teams and with the scum presumably trying to strike out and target each other. We could try to operate under the assumption that there's two teams of three when it comes to the scum, which means that the town are already outnumbered, six to four. Unless something crazy has happened. I'm in the same boat as you are, despite our previous disagreements. I have no idea what's going on. Quote Vote: Caldwell Crocodile I'm not sure how to feel about Caldwell. I voted for him the other day for fluffy posts and I think I'm on the right track. Quote Four votes against Huxley Horse in such quick succession. A bit odd, I think, especially since he was only sitting at one vote for awhile. With five hours left and I suppose in the interest of a lynch, I can: Unvote: Caldwell Crocodile Vote: Huxley Horse I don't know how I feel about this. Not much discussion of the days events and instead a post about a possibility about what happened in the night, a vote for Caldwell for fluffy post (I agree with the vote but no mentions of his actions on that day), and then another vote for Huxley just to get a lynch. There is nothing relating to any of the discussions that took place on day 3. A lot happened yesterday, and I find it odd Ember did not mutter anything of relevance. After Huxley slid by almost unnoticed, maybe we should go after the ones who don't talk much. Ember I found you suspicious on day 2 but thought Caldwell was being scummier. You are now beeping up my radar a bit. At the very least I would love more thoughts from you today with relevance to current topics.
Haydn Hippo Posted May 5, 2019 Posted May 5, 2019 Add to that, Gracie said she knew my theory about scum not voting first was wrong. She could have been just lying, but since Ronan was on my list and I was wrong about him, clearly a scum did vote first. For Gracie to know, it would have had to happen in days one or two. That's Ember, Leevi or Brewer. Ember voted for Gracie, which would have made it a day one 1 vote bus. Entirely possible. *uses tunnelvisionscope to review events of day one* Ember voted Caldwell, unvotes Braxton with revoting then late votes Gracie. I said yesterday I did not think scum would do that, it would draw too much attention. But then, I have not been right about much these last days.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 5, 2019 Posted May 5, 2019 2 minutes ago, Haydn Hippo said: For Gracie to know, it would have had to happen in days one or two. That's Ember, Leevi or Brewer. Ember voted for Gracie, which would have made it a day one 1 vote bus. Entirely possible. I know for a fact Ember and Gracie are not on the same team. That’s because Ember and I are Anti-Hellion Masons. All we know is that the other is not Hellion - but they could be Monster. We were given a writeboard and a one-shot recruit that would fail if we were blocked or targeted a Hellion. We successfully recruited Ronan Night 1, who is no longer with us. Last night I received a one-shot protection action. I don’t know how, or why, but it suggests the existence of a second Inventor. I protected myself last night. I believe Pierrot was indicating his belonging to an anti-Monster masonry on Day 2 which is why some of us were confused and some of us knew what he was talking about.
Whitby Walrus Posted May 5, 2019 Posted May 5, 2019 30 minutes ago, Bennett Bulldog said: Last night I received a one-shot protection action. I don’t know how, or why, but it suggests the existence of a second Inventor. I protected myself last night. That's interesting. Now Myrtle said she was a day Inventor whereas you seem to have been targeted by a Night (regular) one. Perhaps there was a backup inventor which inherited the action when Myrtle died? But otherwise it seems we have a 2nd Inventor. Question is Who have they targeted on previous nights?
Leevi Lion Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 7 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: I know for a fact Ember and Gracie are not on the same team. That’s because Ember and I are Anti-Hellion Masons. All we know is that the other is not Hellion - but they could be Monster. We were given a writeboard and a one-shot recruit that would fail if we were blocked or targeted a Hellion. We successfully recruited Ronan Night 1, who is no longer with us. Last night I received a one-shot protection action. I don’t know how, or why, but it suggests the existence of a second Inventor. I protected myself last night. I believe Pierrot was indicating his belonging to an anti-Monster masonry on Day 2 which is why some of us were confused and some of us knew what he was talking about. Too bad you didn't protect Ronan. I think this confirms that Myrtle was indeed blocked, since you were able to receive the action. So either you, Ember, or both of you could be monsters. Is anyone still alive from Pierot's anti-Monster masonry? Was there any indication that you could or could not recruit from the opposite masons? Ember voted for Gracie, but Gracie was a Hellion, so that doesn't clear him from being a monster. Given that you've both been able to chat with each other in private, I'm very curious what your thoughts are on each other. Looking back at Day 2, the only people who came out publicly to confirm the concept of being particularly anti-Something all appear to be in your anti-Hellion mason group. Haydn and Brewer were the two most vocally questioning the concept, which suggests to me neither of them were a part of either group. FWIW, I'm not either. Pascha also seemed to think that there wasn't much to it, but it's not clear if she didn't know about it or was trying to pass it off as unimportant... to distance herself from it. 8 hours ago, Haydn Hippo said: Add to that, Gracie said she knew my theory about scum not voting first was wrong. She could have been just lying, but since Ronan was on my list and I was wrong about him, clearly a scum did vote first. For Gracie to know, it would have had to happen in days one or two. That's Ember, Leevi or Brewer. Ember voted for Gracie, which would have made it a day one 1 vote bus. Entirely possible. *uses tunnelvisionscope to review events of day one* Ember voted Caldwell, unvotes Braxton with revoting then late votes Gracie. I said yesterday I did not think scum would do that, it would draw too much attention. But then, I have not been right about much these last days. Yesterday you had a whole post where you analyzed yourself in the third person while including yourself in a group of possible people to look at. That was weird. Today, you list all the first voters but leave yourself out. That's kinda weird.
Haydn Hippo Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 27 minutes ago, Leevi Lion said: Too bad you didn't protect Ronan. I think this confirms that Myrtle was indeed blocked, since you were able to receive the action. So either you, Ember, or both of you could be monsters. Is anyone still alive from Pierot's anti-Monster masonry? Was there any indication that you could or could not recruit from the opposite masons? Ember voted for Gracie, but Gracie was a Hellion, so that doesn't clear him from being a monster. Given that you've both been able to chat with each other in private, I'm very curious what your thoughts are on each other. Looking back at Day 2, the only people who came out publicly to confirm the concept of being particularly anti-Something all appear to be in your anti-Hellion mason group. Haydn and Brewer were the two most vocally questioning the concept, which suggests to me neither of them were a part of either group. FWIW, I'm not either. Pascha also seemed to think that there wasn't much to it, but it's not clear if she didn't know about it or was trying to pass it off as unimportant... to distance herself from it. Yesterday you had a whole post where you analyzed yourself in the third person while including yourself in a group of possible people to look at. That was weird. Today, you list all the first voters but leave yourself out. That's kinda weird. I analysed myself in the third person just as a way of speaking. Now I left myself out of the list. (Because I am not going to ponder if I am, in fact a villager, I know I am). but you seem to be having it both ways. If I examine myself, it is weird, if I do not examine myself, it is weird. Finally though I have an explanation for Pierots comment. Clearly yes, I have no animals I am chatting with behind the scenes. If the mason groups were two with a third to recruit, is it a reasonable hypothesis that the scum groups are the same size?
Ember Elephant Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 4 hours ago, Haydn Hippo said: If the mason groups were two with a third to recruit, is it a reasonable hypothesis that the scum groups are the same size? That's something that I've considered, and I think I mentioned that on a previous day. It's why I think we might be outnumbered. If the scum team was indeed bolstered up to three each, that would make two Monsters, two Hellion, and three town. There's always a chance that one of their recruits might have failed. Our recruit ability had three possible chances of failure: 1) If the target was a Hellion. 2) If we were blocked. 3) The player is another mason. Since we successfully recruited Ronan on Night One, we knew that he was not a Hellion or a mason, which could have left him being a Monster. We know today for sure that he is town. 5 hours ago, Leevi Lion said: So either you, Ember, or both of you could be monsters. Is anyone still alive from Pierot's anti-Monster masonry? Was there any indication that you could or could not recruit from the opposite masons? Ember voted for Gracie, but Gracie was a Hellion, so that doesn't clear him from being a monster. Given that you've both been able to chat with each other in private, I'm very curious what your thoughts are on each other. I've been naturally suspicious of Bennett throughout the game, particularly since I don't know his exact allegiance, only that he's not a Hellion. However I've grown to trust him as the days have gone on. One of my major fears was that Bennett invited Ronan to our special team because he was his Monster scum buddy and it might pacify me towards both of them. As I said, now we know that Ronan was town. Bennett was the one who suggested that we recruit Ronan, which makes me believe that he is town. Therefore, I am reasonably certain that Bennett is a villager and I know that I am a villager. If each scum team was up to three, and just lost one each, that would mean there's one more villager out there besides the two of us. I don't know if Pierot's mason friend is still alive or if they were able to successfully recruit someone at night. Please let us know if you're alive.
Caldwell Crocodile Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 Love reading the previous day with knowledge of a now dead scum(s). Will hopefully get back to you all shortly. (busy morning)
Brewer Bunny Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 15 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: I know for a fact Ember and Gracie are not on the same team. That’s because Ember and I are Anti-Hellion Masons. All we know is that the other is not Hellion - but they could be Monster. We were given a writeboard and a one-shot recruit that would fail if we were blocked or targeted a Hellion. We successfully recruited Ronan Night 1, who is no longer with us. Last night I received a one-shot protection action. I don’t know how, or why, but it suggests the existence of a second Inventor. I protected myself last night. I believe Pierrot was indicating his belonging to an anti-Monster masonry on Day 2 which is why some of us were confused and some of us knew what he was talking about. That's interesting and makes sense. Though I do hope you understood why me and a few other animals were confused by all the anti comments on day two. 6 hours ago, Leevi Lion said: So either you, Ember, or both of you could be monsters. Is anyone still alive from Pierot's anti-Monster masonry? Was there any indication that you could or could not recruit from the opposite masons? Ember voted for Gracie, but Gracie was a Hellion, so that doesn't clear him from being a monster. Given that you've both been able to chat with each other in private, I'm very curious what your thoughts are on each other. Would it make sense for them too be both monsters though? What would be the point of the team in that case? The only way this works is if they are lying about the whole anti-hellion role, which I don't think they are as Pierot seemed to be apart of a similar anti-monster group.
Hinckley Posted May 6, 2019 Author Posted May 6, 2019 Voting is now open. With 7 players left, it take 4 votes to lynch. There are 52 hours left in Day Four.
Leevi Lion Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 10 hours ago, Haydn Hippo said: I analysed myself in the third person just as a way of speaking. Now I left myself out of the list. (Because I am not going to ponder if I am, in fact a villager, I know I am). but you seem to be having it both ways. If I examine myself, it is weird, if I do not examine myself, it is weird. Maybe I just think you're weird. Most of the time, people at least acknowledge when they fall into a group they're analyzing and make some platitude about how they're town. Yesterday you went into great detail in third person. That's weird. Today you went 100% the opposite direction and ignored yourself completely. That's also weird. Hence, you're weird. Weird, weird, weird. Plus, you're a hippo. 10 hours ago, Haydn Hippo said: If the mason groups were two with a third to recruit, is it a reasonable hypothesis that the scum groups are the same size? I think that's reasonable, particularly since they have to bump each other off. What do you propose that we do if we make that assumption? 3 hours ago, Brewer Bunny said: That's interesting and makes sense. Though I do hope you understood why me and a few other animals were confused by all the anti comments on day two. From my perspective, anyone calling out how confused they are looks scummy. Town don't have information, so the default position should be that of curiosity and trying to understand where the new information comes in. Pierot would not have shared information as he did unless he felt it would add to the conversation and provide some insight into what's going on here. My initial assumption at the time of Pierot's posting was that he was an investigator who could only determine one type of Mafia, and that there would be another one out there who could determine the other type. I couldn't see why either Mafia team would share that information unless they were trying to merge. That would have been an extremely blatant approach to it that could've gone south pretty quickly. The other interesting thing about it was that multiple people confirmed that it seemed reasonable. Bennett went so far as to call it out as legit. Ember also confirmed it. Of course, they're both in the same masonry, if you believe them. The business about Ronan can no longer be confirmed, and Bennett's declaration of the masonry came as a soft defense of Ember. I have an opinion on whether or not the masonry claim is real and whether or not they are both Hellion, but I'd like to hear Bennett's take on Ember and the rest of this discussion first. There wasn't anyone else who seemed particularly interested in confirming the anti-something bent, so at this point, we can only guess who may have been Pierot's partner(s) unless someone comes forward. Haydn, Brewer, and I are all out (so we claim). I don't see any reason for any of us to lie about that. It's risky if there is someone still in that group alive. That just leaves Caldwell and Whitby as possibilities.
Leevi Lion Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 Check that... Ronan did confirm the anti-something bent, too. That means all three of the folks in the anti-Hellion group made public comments on it.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 I am perfectly neutral towards Ember. In my opinion the masonries in this village are considerably weaker than in other villages due to the two scum teams and we haven't had a lot of behind the scenes discussion. All I know is he (or she, you never can tell with elephants) is not Hellion, and if we're going to lynch Ember it should not be on the basis of being "teammates" with Gracie, because that at least is not true. In that sense yes my declaration acts as a soft defense. I claimed today because it seemed we were trending towards the Ember/Gracie theory for todays lynch and with Ronan's death I didn't want to risk not having anybody to back up the masonry declaration if Ember or I died, since we're at a crucial point where keeping information now is doing more harm than good.
Leevi Lion Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 Thanks for that. Did you and Ember discuss the public claim before you posted it? FWIW, I believe the claim. I think it lines up very well with the day 2 discussion and with the private chat guidelines that Shaefer has given us. I also don't think you're both monsters.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 I posted on the writeboard I was going to claim but it wasn’t really discussed. More of “hey heads up I’m doing this”
Leevi Lion Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 Vote: Caldwell Crocodile I'm reasonably convinced that Caldwell is a Hellion. If you look back at Day 3, Gracie consistently tried to push the lynch away from Caldwell and on to Huxley. In the end, it worked, but Gracie getting taken out at night made it possible to start making those connections. Caldwell was also quite eager, right after Haydn, to join us on the bandwagon to vote out Huxley. The only person who didn't seem particularly interested in that bandwagon, but voted on it, was Ember. FWIW, I also think Whitby is a Monster. He deliberated on Huxley earlier in the day, but didn't want to commit to a vote on him. That, plus some reads on other folks gets me here. I'm voting Caldwell for now because that's my strongest read. One of the interesting aspects now, from a voting perspective, is who do the mafia teams go for. At this point, we have no indication of any 3rd killer unless some teams can't kill at night. Gracie didn't seem to think that was a line of thinking worth pursuing yesterday, and she would know. So do the mafia try to take each other out and reduce the chance of getting killed at night by the opposite faction?
Whitby Walrus Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 I can assure you right now I am not a monster or a Hellion. I am as a great animal once said “The Towniest of the towns”. 1 hour ago, Leevi Lion said: FWIW, I believe the claim. I think it lines up very well with the day 2 discussion and with the private chat guidelines that Shaefer has given us. I also don't think you're both monsters. This conversation has gone far too smoothly for my liking. I agree that Ember and Bennett are definitely Anti hellions but what makes you so sure they’re not Monsters? Looking back at yesterday’s thread something did stand out to me. Specifically Huxley’s vote at the end for Bennett. It’s a common scum tactic, particularly if you know you’re on the verge of getting lynched, to vote for a fellow scum player so that player can then look Town the next day. Huxley vote for Bennett wasn’t even that strong either. Something about him being scummy because of his inability to receive an invention. That said I’m willing to give him the benefit of the doubt here.
Whitby Walrus Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 One thing I forgot to mention. Leevi towards the end of yesterday you said this: ”I’m a bit surprised that everyone followed me to Huxley and no one added on to Caldwel” What exactly did you mean by this? It feels like a subtle way of getting someone to unvote for Huxley and vote for Caldwell. Possibly allowing Huxley to survive. Hear me out, Caldwell has not been the towniest of the towns. But it’s an unusual comment to make.
Ember Elephant Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 Vote: Caldwell Crocodile I support this lynch one hundred percent. Make of it what you will, but Caldwell's alignment will tell us a bit about other people in the village.
Leevi Lion Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 1 hour ago, Whitby Walrus said: I can assure you right now I am not a monster or a Hellion. I am as a great animal once said “The Towniest of the towns”. This conversation has gone far too smoothly for my liking. I agree that Ember and Bennett are definitely Anti hellions but what makes you so sure they’re not Monsters? Looking back at yesterday’s thread something did stand out to me. Specifically Huxley’s vote at the end for Bennett. It’s a common scum tactic, particularly if you know you’re on the verge of getting lynched, to vote for a fellow scum player so that player can then look Town the next day. Huxley vote for Bennett wasn’t even that strong either. Something about him being scummy because of his inability to receive an invention. That said I’m willing to give him the benefit of the doubt here. I'm not at all sure there isn't a monster between them. I actually think there is and have an opinion on which one, I just don't think that they're both monsters. 40 minutes ago, Whitby Walrus said: One thing I forgot to mention. Leevi towards the end of yesterday you said this: ”I’m a bit surprised that everyone followed me to Huxley and no one added on to Caldwel” What exactly did you mean by this? It feels like a subtle way of getting someone to unvote for Huxley and vote for Caldwell. Possibly allowing Huxley to survive. Hear me out, Caldwell has not been the towniest of the towns. But it’s an unusual comment to make. I found it disconcerting that the Caldwell lynch, which gathered a few votes quickly, stagnated abruptly. Right now, my assumption is that folks like Gracie and whoever else are their teammates (assuming I'm right about Caldwell being a Hellion) didn't want to jump on it. The Huxley bandwagon did grow quickly after my vote. I assume the Hellions were eager to have that vote take Caldwell's place, and that the monsters weren't too eager to defend a teammate who wasn't contributing much.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 6, 2019 Posted May 6, 2019 Vote: Caldwell Crocodile Got to run but I’ll be back with more thoughts later. Huxley’s argument is BS since I got an invention last night. I agree it’s a common tactic to vote for a teammate but I don’t think it applies here. Huxley just needed anybody he could make a halfway coherent argument for on his way out.
Hinckley Posted May 7, 2019 Author Posted May 7, 2019 Vote tally Caldwell Crocodile: 3 (Leevi Lion, Ember Elephant, Bennett Bulldog) With 7 players left, it takes 4 votes to lynch. There are 43 hours remaining in Day Four. If you are a player with the ability to communicate outside of the day thread, you must now stop. (And should have at the 24 hour mark. You know I'm traveling. ) You will be allowed to communicate again once the Night Phase begins. Thank you! 10 hours ago, Leevi Lion said: Vote: Caldwell Crocodile 9 hours ago, Ember Elephant said: Vote: Caldwell Crocodile 8 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: Vote: Caldwell Crocodile
Caldwell Crocodile Posted May 7, 2019 Posted May 7, 2019 7 hours ago, Leevi Lion said: Haydn, Brewer, and I are all out (so we claim). I don't see any reason for any of us to lie about that. It's risky if there is someone still in that group alive. That just leaves Caldwell and Whitby as possibilities. I'm not in a mason group either. 5 hours ago, Leevi Lion said: Vote: Caldwell Crocodile I'm reasonably convinced that Caldwell is a Hellion. If you look back at Day 3, Gracie consistently tried to push the lynch away from Caldwell and on to Huxley. She did? All I remember is Gracie going ham on Ronan's ass lol. 5 hours ago, Leevi Lion said: Caldwell was also quite eager, right after Haydn, to join us on the bandwagon to vote out Huxley. I had already stated I thought Huxley could be scum because I thought Brewer was scum, and that Huxley was her scum mate because I thought she was detracting from him and focusing on me.
Caldwell Crocodile Posted May 7, 2019 Posted May 7, 2019 4 hours ago, Ember Elephant said: Vote: Caldwell Crocodile I support this lynch one hundred percent. Make of it what you will, but Caldwell's alignment will tell us a bit about other people in the village. Ha fake.
Recommended Posts