Hinckley Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 Players (in their anonymous character accounts) only please!!! Rules (Deviations from the EB standard Mafia rules are in bold blue. Modified clauses have been struck through.) 1. Each player will be given a character to play, who will be aligned with either the Villagers (Town) or the Hellions (Mafia) or the Monsters (Mafia). To win the game, the Town must kill off all the Mafia, while the Mafia needs to outnumber the Town Monsters must eliminate the Hellions and control 50% of the village or nothing can prevent this from occurring, and the Hellions must eliminate the Monsters and control 50% of the village or nothing can prevent this from occurring Third-Party (neutral) characters have their own win conditions as outlined in their roles. Mod note: Why the clarification of the win conditions now? The two Scum factions have had this win condition in their role PMs from Day One. The wording in the rules was accurate but purposely vague as this game has a closed setup, meaning the mechanics are not revealed to everyone before the games begins. The trigger in the game for the win condition to be clarified in the rules was the first Scum deaths, so there you go. Carry on... 1a. This is an anonymous game and you may only post in your character account sent to you by the host. Be sure to check before you post that you are in your anonymous account and not in your main Eurobricks account. 1b. Those who are allowed to communicate in private should not reveal their true identities to each other, either. 2. Each day you will be able to vote to lynch a player. Voting should be done in the following format; Vote: Character (Player). Similarly, unvoting is to be done in the format; Unvote: Character (Player). No other format will be accepted. A majority vote is required to lynch a player. 3. A game day will last a maximum of 72 hours. You may not vote in the first 24 hours. The day will end when a majority vote has been reached. A majority being reached will not end the day. The day will continue for the full 72 hours and any majority vote that is reached can be overturned. After the day has concluded, a night stage will commence, which will last a maximum of 48 hours. Night actions must be sent to the host in the first 24 hours of the night stage. 3.5. Players may not target the same player two nights in a row, and may not target themselves. Unless otherwise noted in your role PM, players can target the same player two nights in a row or themselves. 4. The alignment of lynched players, as well as those that died during the night, will be revealed at the beginning of the following day. 5. You may not quote or pretend to quote anything sent to or from you in PM with the game host. This includes all the details of your character and role, as well as any night action results. Role claims and reporting of night action results are acceptable, but in your own words only. Do not attempt to use the structure of your role PM to your advantage. Similarly, you may not directly quote any communications (via PM or writeboard) that were sent to you by other players in the game. If you wish to reveal private communications, these must also be paraphrased. 5a. The Role PM is structured for every player in this way: Character: Character name (player) Affiliation: Villager (Town) or Hellions (Scum) or Monsters (Scum) or third-party (Neutral) Role: [Either the details of a Night Action or] Your weapon is your vote, you have no night actions. 6. Do not play the game outside the thread. Similarly, do not post out of character inside the thread; you must always play the role given to you. Game tactics and roles may only be discussed in the game thread or via PM with other players. Private discussion is done at your own risk and should be treated as part of the game. 6a. Only specific players are allowed to communicate outside of the day thread. These players are only allowed to communicate with each other during the Night phase of the game. As reporting of Night Action results to each other may be hindered by time zones, this allowable communication period will last until voting opens in the Day thread. 7. If you are dead, you may not post in thread or discuss the game with any of the players. Any information you had becomes void, and may not be passed on. 8. You may not edit your posts. 9. You must post in every day thread. 10. If you encounter a problem or have a question, please contact the host via PM. 11. Violation of the above rules will result in a vote penalty of half the required majority against you on your first offence, and the death of your character on your second offence. Violation of rule 7 will have a heavier penalty, including suspension, made at the discretion of the Games Moderator. 12. There are no hints or clues in the day/night images. NPC Schaefer Sheepdog, Lawspeaker Palma Pig, Scribe Pernilla, Badass Sundra Spider, Forest Shaman Characters (5) Bennett Bulldog, Cheftain Brewer Bunny, Trauma Therapist Ember Elephant, Explorer Haydn Hippo, Dishwasher Whitby Walrus, Cook **Occupations are strictly for players to have fun with their characters. Deceased (10) Braxton Bear, Blacksmith, murdered Night One Villager Cleo Cow, Coin Minter, murdered Night One Villager Myrtle Monkey, Seamstress, lynched Day Two Villager Pascha Poodle, Carpenter, murdered Night Two Villager Pierot Parrot, Magistrate, murdered Night Two Villager Huxley Horse, Farmer, lynched Day Three Monster Gracie Goat, Silk Merchant, murdered Night Three Hellion Ronan Rabbit, Bread Merchant, murdered Night Three Villager Caldwell Crocodile, Fisherman, lynched Day Four Hellion Leevi Lion, Bricklayer, murdered Night Four Villager Day Five has begun. You may not vote during the first 24 hours. Players with the ability to communicate outside of the Day thread may continue to do so until voting begins. Mod note: Quick explanation regarding the cut scenes with characters who do not end up dead. Does their appearance implicate them? No. Does it exonerate them? No. There are no clues in the pictures. The characters appearing in the night pictures are selected the same way I selected everything in this game, randomly. Carry on...
Haydn Hippo Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 One night kill. Hmm. There are a handful of theories to explain that. One, maybe two, town left between the four of you. Let us see what the day brings. Day 1 Final Vote Tally Braxton Bear: 7 (Haydn Hippo, Myrtle Monkey, Gracie Goat, Ronan Rabbit, Caldwell Crocodile, Huxley Horse, Brewer Bunny) Haydn Hippo: 2 (Braxton Bear, Bennett Bulldog)Myrtle Monkey: 3 (Leevi Lion. Whitby Walrus, Cleo Cow)Huxley Horse: 2 (Pascha Poodle, Pierot Parrot)Gracie Goat: 1 (Ember Elephant) Day 2 Myrtle Monkey: 7 (Pierot Parrot, Ember Elephant, Whitby Walrus, Gracie Goat, Ronan Rabbit, Leevi Lion, Huxley Horse)Ronan Rabbit: 1 (Myrtle Monkey) Caldwell Crocodile: 1 (Brewer Bunny) Leevi Lion: 1 (Pascha Poodle) Ember Elephant: 1 (Haydn Hippo) Non-voters: 2 (Caldwell Crocodile, Bennett Bulldog) Day 3 Caldwell Crocodile: 1 (Ronan Rabbit)Huxley Horse: 7 (Bennett Bulldog, Leevi Lion, Haydn Hippo, Caldwell Crocodile, Brewer Bunny, Ember Elephant, Gracie Goat) Haydn Hippo: 1 (Whitby Walrus) Bennett Bulldog: 1 (Huxley Horse) Day 4 Caldwell Crocodile: 6 (Leevi Lion, Ember Elephant, Bennett Bulldog, Haydn Hippo, Brewer Bunny, Whitby Walrus)Brewer Bunny: 1 (Caldwell Crocodile) Dammit I left my pretty colour pencils at home.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 2 town 1 Hellion and 2 monsters, no? Brewer who did you block? Anyone going to step up and claim Inventor, or was that Leevi? I didn’t get anything last night. Obviously my argument is based on my knowing I’m town, so take it with a grain of salt, but with only 5 left I don’t see how Ember and Brewer can both be town. Either Brewer is a scum blocker for the Monsters or Ember has been playing me. She claimed no action but there’s nothing to prove that since I haven’t seen any watcher/tracker type roles emerge. We also have to be careful because if we lynch the last Hellion today Monsters will control 50% of the town and win. We need to lynch a monster to keep this thing going.
Whitby Walrus Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 2 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: Anyone going to step up and claim Inventor, or was that Leevi? I didn’t get anything last night. . The only reason I'm slightly concerned about the Inventor is why didn't they try to counterclaim when Myrtle claimed Inventor during Day 2? Presumably they didn't know Myrtle's role. So unless they were a scum inventor there would be no reason not to counterclaim right. The only other option is that the 2nd Inventor is a backup one to Myrtle and gained the ability when she was lynched.
Brewer Bunny Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 I blocked Whitby Walrus last night, as looking back he was middle of the road-ish on day 3 and did not end up voting for Huxley. Thought maybe blocking him would be a good idea. My block was once again successful. We still had a kill last night, though only one. I will try to say more latter.
Ember Elephant Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 8 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: Either Brewer is a scum blocker for the Monsters or Ember has been playing me. She claimed no action but there’s nothing to prove that since I haven’t seen any watcher/tracker type roles emerge. Sadly I'm worried of the exact same thing - that you might be a monster after all. If we're both town, however, that means everyone else here is scum. I have no idea how we're going to win this if the two of us are already outnumbered by scum.
Ember Elephant Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 Does the last Hellion want to stand up so we can lynch one of the two Monsters today? I promise we won't lynch you in the future. Actually I don't think there's a way for the town to win if I'm honest. The last Hellion can just kill Bennett or I tonight and the last Monster can kill me. Then there's a parity like in the last game. Brewer blocked Whitby last night, I think it's safe to assume he can go today. The question is will his teammate join us? What if he's the last Hellion and then we lynch him? Then the final two Monsters can just kill me tonight and win the game. Or Bennett, provided he isn't a Monster in disguise and has been lying to me the whole time. This has been something I've been considering since the very start of the game. Is he actually a monster? This is something I guess I'll find out at the end of the game in the Conclusion. I've got a feeling that this is the last day today.
Haydn Hippo Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 7 hours ago, Brewer Bunny said: I blocked Whitby Walrus last night, as looking back he was middle of the road-ish on day 3 and did not end up voting for Huxley. Thought maybe blocking him would be a good idea. My block was once again successful. We still had a kill last night, though only one. I will try to say more latter. Thanks Brewer, that is helpful. 7 hours ago, Ember Elephant said: Sadly I'm worried of the exact same thing - that you might be a monster after all. If we're both town, however, that means everyone else here is scum. I have no idea how we're going to win this if the two of us are already outnumbered by scum. You know what's a real shame? Ronan is dead. He was town, he could have collaborated your story. Three town block would have been much more useful than two unconnected town. From where I sit, it is entirely possible that Ronan and one of you were the original mason pair. Then you killed him to pretend that the monster pair of you were the millers. Ronan is dead, he can't contradict you. Then you play the "are you scum? Are you scum?" obfuscation through to game end. One good thing from your lies, You made it possible for the villagers to win. 7 minutes ago, Ember Elephant said: Does the last Hellion want to stand up so we can lynch one of the two Monsters today? I promise we won't lynch you in the future. If you have been paying attention Whitby is the last Hellion, which I'm sure he will confirm. He will want to keep his game alive.
Haydn Hippo Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 13 minutes ago, Ember Elephant said:The last Hellion can just kill Bennett or I tonight and the last Monster can kill me. Then there's a parity like in the last game. Brewer blocked Whitby last night, I think it's safe to assume he can go today. The question is will his teammate join us? What if he's the last Hellion and then we lynch him? Then the final two Monsters can just kill me tonight and win the game. Or Bennett, provided he isn't a Monster in disguise and has been lying to me the whole time. This has been something I've been considering since the very start of the game. Is he actually a monster? This is something I guess I'll find out at the end of the game in the Conclusion. I've got a feeling that this is the last day today. I will have to read the pirate book you speak of. We are now at a point where none of the three groups can win by their own making, but only with the cooperation on the other two. Here is how I think today will go. I will vote Bennett. Frankly it is either or with you two. Bennett immediately yells OMFGUS! you must die! And votes me (again!) Whitby, the last hellion votes anybody but himself, but feels the pressure. If he votes wrong he loses the game for his team. Eventually he decides that I am right and votes Bennett. Now comes the dicey part. Ember, trying to keep his villager cover for one last round vaccinates between voting me to stand with a Miller mate who has been outed as a monster, voting on said monster to try to eke out a villager win or causing a no lynch and sending the game into sudden death overtime. Brewer is, I hope, the town blocker. If she is not, you're right, it's all over. But as town, she would hopefully vote Bennett, lynching a monster and sending us to a night phase. In the night phase you and Whitby try to kill each other in order to eliminate the other team. Failing to kill the other scum team will hand them the win. It's the only play that makes sense. If you kill a villager and the other kills you, you lose. If you both kill villagers, both scum teams lose. Edit for clarify middle part. I tag Bennett. There are three cases. Bennett is monster, with Ember. Brewer is town. Ember follows Bennett and votes me, Brewer votes Bennett. Bennett is lynched, villagers can win. Bennett is monster with Brewer. Ember is town. Brewer piles on me with Bennett, Ember votes Bennett, see above Bennett is not monster. Either we're lucky and Bennett votes Ember instead of me, or I will have just lost him and I the game. A two in three shot is the best I can figure. But certainly not Ember level hopelessness.
Ember Elephant Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 Just now, Haydn Hippo said: Now comes the dicey part. Ember, trying to keep his villager cover for one last round vaccinates between voting me to stand with a Miller mate who has been outed as a monster, voting on said monster to try to eke out a villager win or causing a no lynch and sending the game into sudden death overtime. Why are you so adamant that I'm scum? I'm not. Operating under the assumption that Bennett is town, it's got to be you, Brewer, and Whitby. Obviously Brewer is almost certainly the scum blocker. Judging by your hopes towards her and your comments, she's probably on your team. Whitby, if you're the last Hellion, say so. That way we can lynch either Haydn or Brewer. Unless Bennett is doing the long con on me. It's entirely possible that's he's responsible for killing Ronan even after being the one who suggested recruiting him, and not killing me since he thought I'd be pacified with being on his team. If Bennett is the last town with me, and we lynch him, then the remaining scum can kill at night, probably killing both me and someone else, presumably one of the monsters. If Bennett is a monster, which is entirely possible because I know he's only not a Hellion, then that means that there's one Monster, one Hellion, and two town. (myself, and someone else) We're all reasonably certain that Whitby is scum, in fact almost entirely sure considering that there was only one scum kill last night. Bennett claims there's an inventor out there. It's entirely possible that there is no inventor and he's just making up receiving things. I'm becoming increasingly paranoid towards pretty much everyone. I know I'm town. There's got to be one other town out there somewhere. 58 minutes ago, Haydn Hippo said: If you have been paying attention Whitby is the last Hellion, which I'm sure he will confirm. He will want to keep his game alive. How do you know this? What if the Monsters were blocked from killing last night and the Hellions killed someone? Surely Caldwell's kill ability was passed on to the last Hellion. What if Whitby is actually a Monster and was blocked last night? If you're so sure that Brewer is town, then she wouldn't have had a bias and could've blocked either side. I think it's likely, as I said, that you and Brewer are on the same team (Monsters), which is probably why you're sticking up for her and you apparently know that she definitely blocked a Hellion. (Whitby) Otherwise you wouldn't know which team was blocked last night, right?
Whitby Walrus Posted May 10, 2019 Posted May 10, 2019 33 minutes ago, Haydn Hippo said: Bennett is monster, with Ember. Brewer is town. Ember follows Bennett and votes me, Brewer votes Bennett. Bennett is lynched, villagers can win. I think Bennett is monster. But I don't think that Bennett and Ember are both monsters. Becuase in which case why ou them on a separate masons team to begin with anyway? 33 minutes ago, Haydn Hippo said: Bennett is monster with Brewer. Ember is town. Brewer piles on me with Bennett, Ember votes Bennett, see above This is the one I can get behind. I too think Bennett could be a Monster along with Brewer. 8 minutes ago, Ember Elephant said: Bennett claims there's an inventor out there. It's entirely possible that there is no inventor and he's just making up receiving things. I'm becoming increasingly paranoid towards pretty much everyone. I know I'm town. There's got to be one other town out there somewhere. This is what I was saying earlier. If there is a second inventor out there why did they not counter claim when Myrtle claimed on Day 2. The only reason they wouldn't is if they were scum. If I was the town inventor and someone who was on the verge of getting lynched also claimed Inventor I would be seriously suspicious of the claim. 52 minutes ago, Haydn Hippo said: We are now at a point where none of the three groups can win by their own making, but only with the cooperation on the other two. How so? The villagers can only win if they eliminate all the mafia.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 Lots going on here. Lots to take in. It’s reasonable to think Whitby is the last Hellion. If Brewer is the Monster blocker, they’ve already won since they can block Whitby’s kill tonight with no repercussions. Unfortunately I think lynching Ember might be the best way to go today. Even in best case scenario, where Brewer is town blocker, town has already lost no matter who we lynch.
Ember Elephant Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 2 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: Unfortunately I think lynching Ember might be the best way to go today. Even in best case scenario, where Brewer is town blocker, town has already lost no matter who we lynch. That doesn't make any sense. How is lynching me, a member of the town, the best way to go? I didn't hit a nerve when I laid out my case as to why you could be a Monster, did I? Haydn said he would vote for you when the time comes in just a few hours. I didn't want to, since I wanted to believe you were town, but if it's a you or me scenario, it will be you.
Brewer Bunny Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 21 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: 2 town 1 Hellion and 2 monsters, no? Brewer who did you block? Anyone going to step up and claim Inventor, or was that Leevi? I didn’t get anything last night. Obviously my argument is based on my knowing I’m town, so take it with a grain of salt, but with only 5 left I don’t see how Ember and Brewer can both be town. Either Brewer is a scum blocker for the Monsters or Ember has been playing me. She claimed no action but there’s nothing to prove that since I haven’t seen any watcher/tracker type roles emerge. We also have to be careful because if we lynch the last Hellion today Monsters will control 50% of the town and win. We need to lynch a monster to keep this thing going. If we go with 2 town, 2 monsters, and 1 hellion being the current predicament then I think one of you would have to be a monster, but it would also mean that the other is definitely town as the anti-hellion group would be quite pointless if not. Either that or Haydn's theory about both of you faking masons is true, which I don't fully believe. 5 hours ago, Ember Elephant said: Whitby, if you're the last Hellion, say so. That way we can lynch either Haydn or Brewer. Unless Bennett is doing the long con on me. It's entirely possible that's he's responsible for killing Ronan even after being the one who suggested recruiting him, and not killing me since he thought I'd be pacified with being on his team. Do you really believe Whitby is just going to come out and admit he's scum? I guess Caldwell did so that yesterday, but I would not put too much faith into that happening again. Especially if he is the last of his team. 19 hours ago, Whitby Walrus said: The only reason I'm slightly concerned about the Inventor is why didn't they try to counterclaim when Myrtle claimed Inventor during Day 2? Presumably they didn't know Myrtle's role. So unless they were a scum inventor there would be no reason not to counterclaim right. The only other option is that the 2nd Inventor is a backup one to Myrtle and gained the ability when she was lynched. 5 hours ago, Ember Elephant said: Bennett claims there's an inventor out there. It's entirely possible that there is no inventor and he's just making up receiving things. I'm becoming increasingly paranoid towards pretty much everyone. I know I'm town. There's got to be one other town out there somewhere. OK now this is something I am very interested in. So far Bennett is the only one who seems to have been given a inventor action. It also happened to be a protection action that he used on himself. Whitby brings up a good point questioning why the inventor never claimed on day 2 once Myrtle claimed. Maybe there was never another inventor and Bennett is making it all up. Possibly throwing the scent towards somewhere else for the other team to go after? It makes somewhat sense. As a brave man once said we are in the Endgame now (sorry). At this point I think Whitby is something, monster or hellion I am not sure but he is bad none the less. There has got to be a scum in the anti's somewhere, and obviously they have to be a monster. That would make the other town as the like I said above the anti-team would be useless if they are both scum. That leaves Haydn to also be a scum based off of the process of elimination. The monsters are closest to winning so I would very much prefer to take one of them out today. Haydn and Whitby could be either one of the teams and thus I don't want to lynch them today. However the scum in the anti-hellion group must be a monster, so I would very much prefer to lynch them today. I think the inventor theory above is possible and a lot of us would be OK with lynching Bennett as shown above. So when the time comes I will vote for him.
Hinckley Posted May 11, 2019 Author Posted May 11, 2019 Voting is now open. With 5 players left, it take 3 votes to lynch. There are approximately 48 hours left in Day Five.
Haydn Hippo Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 5 hours ago, Whitby Walrus said: How so? The villagers can only win if they eliminate all the mafia. Sigh. Villagers can eliminate mafia by lynching them. As it stands there are only two of us, we do not have the numbers to carry the lynch today. each of the scum team members need to vote for scum from the other team. If the hellion votes for town, they will lose. Vote: Bennett Bulldog
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 I am town. Voting for me is handing Monsters the victory. The more I think about it the less sure I am that Brewer is the town blocker. Best case he is, means Ember is monster and despite my earlier suspicions I’m having a hard time reconciling that. She would have had plenty of chances to mislead or kill me throughout the game and I haven’t really seen that happen. And if Brewer is the town blocker that doesn’t even mean Whitby has to Hellion. We’ve been assuming Monsters killed last night but what if they didn’t? Vote: Brewer Bunny If town can’t win, don’t let the Monsters win.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 I realize now that last line sounds weird since I’m town and I can’t win I so I shouldn’t care who wins between Monsters and Hellions. The point I’m trying to make is we should be trying to stretch this as long as possible by lynching Monster today. Who knows what might happen or what mechanics are still in play? For example I still don’t know where my protection action came from.
Whitby Walrus Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 The two immediate votes for Bennett make me feel that Bennett and Haydn are not on the same team. And likewise, Bennett and Brewer are not on the same team either. But then I don’t think Bennett and Ember are both monsters so it’s a sticky wicket. Day 2 is particularly insightful as a lot of the players currently alive voted for one another in the first few hours of that day. Bennett went for Haydn and Brewer went for Ember. Makes me think they’re also unlikely to be on the same teams. Bennett was the first vote on Huxley on Day 3 but I could see Huxley giving permission for Bennett to bus him since Huxley knew he wasn’t going to be that active anyway. Vote: Bennett Bulldog
Ember Elephant Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 It's tough, because as the last person to vote I know that if Bennett is a monster, his monster pal has already decided to throw him under the bus when they could have voted for someone else. Not to mention that I've been Bennett's mason friend the entire game. I think it's unlikely to be Haydn having led the charge against him, but I can't say for certain. Vote: Bennett Bulldog I'm not sure how this will go, but I suppose that I'll find out soon. Perhaps there's only one left on each team after all and the Monsters were unable to recruit an extra person. After all, I know that there are several ways in which you could fail to recruit from my anti-Hellion mason instructions - being blocked, the player being a Hellion, or if the target is a mason. I assume the criteria are the same for the Monster team. From what I've gathered from his comments Pierot was the anti-Monster mason, so he would have been unable to be recruited, as would his partner. Perhaps it's worth noting that Pierot could have been killed by his mason friend in order to silence him. Maybe each mason team had one scum and one town. Pierot could have been killed by the Hellion's since his partner would have been on that team being anti-Monster. Bennett, on the other hand, used a different strategy from the Hellion team and decided to keep me alive rather than kill me because he figured I would be likely to side with him. I'm not sure if any of this makes sense to other people besides just me in my head.
Hinckley Posted May 11, 2019 Author Posted May 11, 2019 Vote Tally Bennet Bulldog: 4 (Haydn Hippo, Brewer Bunny, Whitby Walrus, Ember Elephant)Brewer Bunny: 1 (Bennett Bulldog) With 5 players left, it take 3 votes to lynch. As it currently stands, Bennett Bulldog will be lynched. There are approximately 38 hours left in Day Five. 9 hours ago, Haydn Hippo said: Vote: Bennett Bulldog 9 hours ago, Brewer Bunny said: Vote: Bennett Bulldog 7 hours ago, Bennett Bulldog said: Vote: Brewer Bunny 1 hour ago, Whitby Walrus said: Vote: Bennett Bulldog 18 minutes ago, Ember Elephant said: Vote: Bennett Bulldog
Whitby Walrus Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 3 hours ago, Ember Elephant said: It's tough, because as the last person to vote I know that if Bennett is a monster, his monster pal has already decided to throw him under the bus when they could have voted for someone else. Not to mention that I've been Bennett's mason friend the entire game. I think it's unlikely to be Haydn having led the charge against him, but I can't say for certain. This is why I’ve become slightly weary of Bennett being scum. I can’t figure who is other partner would be. I don’t think it’s Haydn. As well as building up a solid case against him Bennett voted for him on Day One when he could have easily helped hammer Braxton who we know was town. I don’t think it’s you (Ember) either after Bennett said “All we know is that the other is not Hellion - but they could be Monster.” yesterday. There wouldn’t be much point in you having that information if both of you were Monsters anyway. And I know I’m not aligned with Bennett. That only really leaves Brewer. But if he is Bennett’s monster partner why the hell has he voted for him instead of spreading the vote out potentially buying Bennett an extra day? Same goes for Haydn too. If there are two monsters left all they would have to do is convince one of us to vote for whoever they wanted to lynch. So it wouldn’t make sense for them to vote for their own teammate. For all we know there could only be one Monster left and everything I’ve just said is rubbish. But I have my doubts here.
Ember Elephant Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 Just now, Whitby Walrus said: This is why I’ve become slightly weary of Bennett being scum. I can’t figure who is other partner would be. I don’t think it’s Haydn. As well as building up a solid case against him Bennett voted for him on Day One when he could have easily helped hammer Braxton who we know was town. I don’t think it’s you (Ember) either after Bennett said “All we know is that the other is not Hellion - but they could be Monster.” yesterday. There wouldn’t be much point in you having that information if both of you were Monsters anyway. And I know I’m not aligned with Bennett. That only really leaves Brewer. But if he is Bennett’s monster partner why the hell has he voted for him instead of spreading the vote out potentially buying Bennett an extra day? Same goes for Haydn too. If there are two monsters left all they would have to do is convince one of us to vote for whoever they wanted to lynch. So it wouldn’t make sense for them to vote for their own teammate. For all we know there could only be one Monster left and everything I’ve just said is rubbish. But I have my doubts here. Brewer makes the most logical sense in being Bennett's scum partner. We can't discount that it's actually Haydn trying to trick us. You're obviously the last Hellion, of course. It's tough.
Bennett Bulldog Posted May 11, 2019 Posted May 11, 2019 Search your feelings, fellow animals. You know this to be wrong. Does it not concern you how quickly these votes piled up? If I were Monster I would probably would have recruited a scumbuddy to the anti-Hellion masonry then killed Ember. But I didn’t. I recruited Ronan and had nothing to do with his death. Remember? Caldwell claimed credit for Ronan’s demise. I agree with Whitby’s vote analysis that Brewer/me, Haydn/me and Ember/Brewer are not the same team. I disagree that voting for Huxley and having him flail about and latch on to my inability to receive an invention means we were bussing each other. He was grasping at straws to at least put up some sort of coherent defense and name an alternate lynch. There’s still time to turn this around and lynch Brewer. Ember and I are town. Whitby is the last Hellion. Haydn and Brewer are monster killer and blocker, respectively. Final answer. Time is up.
Recommended Posts