Karie's Cosplay Mafia: Day Three

[KotZ]

2 hours ago, Kintobor said:

Current Vote Count:
Raphael (Sir Stig): 2 votes (Trekkie99, KotZ)
Newt Scamander (KotZ): 6 Votes (Sandy, jimmynick, Sir Stig, Tariq j, Khscarymovie4, Bob)

With 8 players remaining, a majority of 5 is needed to lynch. 3 hours remains.

Edited 2 hours ago by Kintobor

Do you get two penalty votes tomorrow? 

[jimmynick]

19 hours ago, Trekkie99 said:

Your gonna lynch one of your suspects who is also being lynched by two of your suspects???

Very astute point.

9 hours ago, Sandy said:

That's our point. If he found out Tauriel is scum yesterday, he should've indicated it somehow to someone, or at least acted upon it sooner during the day if he had nobody to trust.

But he had nobody to tell, and if he announced in public then he's just blowing his load to the scum's benefit.

16 hours ago, KotZ said:

On Night 2, I investigated Bob, and received a scum role.

If the result gave you reason to doubt your sanity, why didn't you go straight to Bob? I mean, if you're a cop and you find someone is town, you don't hold back from PMing them because "they might be godfather" or "I might be insane" or "I might be naive" or "they might have been tailored". This is the sticking point for me, which is why I am leaving my vote on you.

3 hours ago, Sandy said:

How could you have had worries of being an insane cop on Day 2 if nothing in your night action results alluded to that? It would be a far stretch for a game this size to have such a rare role...

That's not what he's saying, though. What KotZ says is fairly clear:

Assume Hinck is town and KotZ is a cop who got a scum result. Scum know that Hinck is town, so if KotZ announces his result then the scum know something is up with the investigation ability. Now, that wouldn't be my first concern about going public on Day Two with an investigation result, but it's a valid line of reasoning.

and wow a lot of stuff happened when I was at work! Glad Kinto hasn't closed the thread so I could get my two cents in.

1 minute ago, jimmynick said:

If the result gave you reason to doubt your sanity

I don't mean just the result but also Tauriel's flip.

11 hours ago, Tariq j said:

Although if you got an investigation result that Hinkcly was scum. Why was this not mentioned yesterday? Bearing in mind you didn't know you were going to receive incorrect results.

So Tracer and Kylo have both asked why the purported cop didn't out himself on Day Two. Good going, guys. Not that we should believe ol' Newt, but this isn't the sharpest take you could have on the situation.

 

5 hours ago, KotZ said:

Gauging reactions, and it would confirm my worries of me being an insane flavor of investigator.

tho you should't yourself be worried about sanity on Day Two.

[Kintobor]

Final Vote Count:
Raphael (Sir Stig): 2 votes (Trekkie99, KotZ)
Newt Scamander (KotZ): 6 Votes (Sandy, jimmynick, Sir Stig, Tariq j, Khscarymovie4, Bob)

With 8 players remaining, a majority of 5 is needed to lynch. KotZ has been lynched. Night has begun. You have 48 hours to get night actions in.