Benicia Bear Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 2 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: But that's what makes it weird. Such a dumb choice on their part. YES, BUT IS it, though? Who did you think would have been a better choice? Answering that question may be helpful. I like your umbrella by the way, umbrellas are very cool. 1 minute ago, Holbrook Horse said: So operating under Benicia's advice, I targeted Corrina. And cleared her. NICE. You asked me and I gave you a range of options. I did not advise one single action. 2 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: Like when I assumed you were the trickster? Did it sting because I hit the mark? SO DEFENSIVE so early in the day. I've not even had my sausages.
Holbrook Horse Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 Sorry yes you didn't TELL me to investigate Corrina, I made the choice but talking to you made me think about the frame/tailor. Just now, Benicia Bear said: I've not even had my sausages. Can share some of mine... you know what they say about horses
Benicia Bear Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 1 minute ago, Holbrook Horse said: Sorry yes you didn't TELL me to investigate Corrina, I made the choice but talking to you made me think about the frame/tailor. HOW DID ME WONDERING about the framer/tailor make you decide to investigate Corrina? Just now, Holbrook Horse said: you know what they say about horses THEY UNEXPECTEDLY end up in a lot of sausages?
Gilford Goat Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 Just now, Benicia Bear said: Who did you think would have been a better choice? Answering that question may be helpful. Anyone but Sheepdog since he was probably a question mark for everyone, but that may be why they killed him. He would've been my choice if my priority was just trying to successfully kill someone. That puts me a bit at ease. 39 minutes ago, Corrina Cow said: or kill a scum and know you had lied. I'm losing count of the ways I've been confirmed. It's very flattering.
Holbrook Horse Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 ket? check barrel? check Holbrook needs his beauty sleep and maybe this will make more sense in the morning.
Benicia Bear Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 1 minute ago, Gilford Goat said: He would've been my choice if my priority was just trying to successfully kill someone. INDEED
Gilford Goat Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 8 minutes ago, Benicia Bear said: I like your umbrella by the way, umbrellas are very cool. IKR? If I make it out of this I'm gonna go stand on a street corner in Fabucity in the rain, drink coffee, and watch the traffic.
Corrina Cow Posted August 27, 2020 Posted August 27, 2020 2 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: I'm losing count of the ways I've been confirmed. It's very flattering. Except it didn't confirm you, a scum could just as easily tell the truth about a result. Do you think Holbrook telling the truth about me confirms him? Nope. And then there is the whole bussing incident, which left me with a blind spot for Parvani. Benicia even pointed that out last night and I could suddenly see it.
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 21 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: No more games, please share win condition, we can make it out of here. Pwetty Pwease?
Benicia Bear Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 4 minutes ago, Corrina Cow said: And then there is the whole bussing incident, which left me with a blind spot for Parvani. Benicia even pointed that out last night and I could suddenly see it. YOU DO ME too much credit, I merely said that it appeared to me that I thought Parvani was scummier than you did.
Corrina Cow Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 Just now, Benicia Bear said: YOU DO ME too much credit, I merely said that it appeared to me that I thought Parvani was scummier than you did. It really made me think though. My initial reaction was that it seemed too bold to be a scum move, but over time it has continued to gnaw at me.
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 Where's that wolf in sheeps clothing? Lmao it was right in front of us all along.
Parvani Poodle Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 4 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: Because you were busy off killing Shainen instead, we know what you're up to. At least the numbers mean it has to be 3-1-2, and it has to be the poodle & lamb who have flown under the radar for far too long. We can still win, even if it's with the trickster. We can do this, a lynch today and a vig in the night. Assuming that you and Corrina who you just investigated are really Town, which is not in any way confirmed, then my take is the following: Gilford can't be Scum based on the Night 1 attempt to kill him, so he must be the Trickster. The only Scum left are Leatrix and Benicia. BUT my initial assumption can easily be false. 4 hours ago, Benicia Bear said: I'M INTERESTED. I commuted my ass out of here last night, as a couple of people know I did, so that'll be why you were unsuccessful. Okay, so at the very least you didn't kill Shainen while you were commuting. Unless I was blocked and you didn't commute at all. 3 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: Or maybe she really did try to belly rub you and Leatrix was off killing Shainen. Or maybe Parvani belly rubbed you AND killed Shainen Or you investigated Corrina and killed Shainen. It's all empty speculation. 3 hours ago, Corrina Cow said: And then there is the whole bussing incident, which left me with a blind spot for Parvani. Benicia even pointed that out last night and I could suddenly see it. What bussing incident?
Corrina Cow Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 13 minutes ago, Parvani Poodle said: What bussing incident? Has there been more than one or are you just playing stupid? You know, that time you swapped Caladon into Gilford's place, making it look like the scum must have wanted to kill Gilford, so you probably couldn't be scum for interfering with it? The red herring we've all been falling for this entire game ... It feels so stupid now when I write it out.
Leatrix Lamb Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 Geeeeeeeez, with two more emancipators dead, I'm surprised we're even aliiiiive. You all got up early again todaaaaaaaaaaay. I'm losing track of how long nights laaaaaaast on this ship. I need my beauty sleeeeeeeeeep. I sent Gilford to a baby dragon marshmellow party. I'm surprised he hasn't yet meeeeeeentioned he went to one though because I was told I was succeeeeeeessful. It also had a chance of "voyeuring" him, but I didn't get a result on that part of the role. 10 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: Or are they just trying to make me think that? Whooooooo's "they"? 7 hours ago, Corrina Cow said: I gave you my list of suspects, in order, and Emeric was first on it. I sent the same information to Benicia. I couldn't just blurt out my role, but I thought it was obviously something important and no one tried to change my order of suspicion, so I went with it. I expected to either fail and we'd have our Trickster confirmed or kill a scum and know you had lied. Sorry, it just seemed right. Emeric wasn't confiiiiiiirmed as an emancipator by Gilford's "not scum" result, but what maaaaaaaade you put him at the top of your list? It was you who argued that our first priiiiioooooooority was getting rid of baby dragon haters before deeeeeaaaaaaling with the trickster. 7 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: I will say though if we were gonna end up with two dead townies then elephant and sheepdog were the best choices. So thanks scum. But that's what makes it weird. Such a dumb choice on their part. "Such a dumb choice on their part"... you can't possibly be part of theeeeeem. 7 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: Because I didn't know Marlowe was town and was then telling the truth about the frame/tailor... I thought he was trying to throw us off his scent, leaving his team with the action. I doubted the trickster would reveal themselves to doubt the claim but in retrospect they dgaf if we lynch an emancipator. The role was a framer/tailor, so if you dooooooooouuuuuuuubted Marlowe's claim, I'm sure you would have reeeeaaaaaaaalised they could just as easily frame an emaaaaaaaaancipator. 9 hours ago, Benicia Bear said: I'M INTERESTED. I commuted my ass out of here last night, as a couple of people know I did, so that'll be why you were unsuccessful. HMMM. BUT IT COULD also be because I commuted my ass out of here, like you knew I was going to. It's out of character for you to jump to conclusions. I'M INTEREEEEEEEESTED to hear who you toooooold and perhaps even more importantly whyyyyyyyyy you told them. 7 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: Or maybe she really did try to belly rub you and Leatrix was off killing Shainen. I never got near the sheeeeeeeeeepdog. I know he'd just bite at my aaaaaaaankles. 7 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: I'm losing count of the ways I've been confirmed. It's very flattering. Help us ooooouuuuuuut here... 6 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: Where's that wolf in sheeps clothing? No wolf underneeeeeeeaaaaaath this wool. I suppose we could organiiiiiiiiize a shaaaaaaaaaving party tonight if you'd like to be sure. We could even make baby geeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep. 5 hours ago, Parvani Poodle said: Gilford can't be Scum based on the Night 1 attempt to kill him, so he must be the Trickster. Because that'd make you scum and that can't possiblyyyyyyy be the case?
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 1 hour ago, Leatrix Lamb said: I sent Gilford to a baby dragon marshmellow party. Yeah I got it. Was waiting to hear someone say it. 1 hour ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Whooooooo's "they"? The Spanish Inquisition
Holbrook Horse Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 11 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: why? I'm mad because in retrospect it wasn't the smartest choice. 10 hours ago, Benicia Bear said: HOW DID ME WONDERING about the framer/tailor make you decide to investigate Corrina? You straight up said would I trust any kind of result on Leatrix and I thought I'd play it on the safer side. But that reminds me that Gilford said he had wanted to investigate Leatrix, but didn't. Ugh. 10 hours ago, Benicia Bear said: THEY UNEXPECTEDLY end up in a lot of sausages? 10 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: He would've been my choice if my priority was just trying to successfully kill someone. I'm thinking that since your investigation took the scum question mark from over Emeric's head, he was no longer useful to have around, either as scum or as trickster. Let's have a think about the trickster roles: Leatrix & Parvani seem to have had some useless shite except for the bus driver, so it seems the trickster doesn't trust them. I have had two investigations and a watch plus 1 night as a virgin. Generally good stuff. Gilford has had a vig, 2 investigations and a huntsman. Again, generally good stuff. Benicia has had falsifier, tracker, vengeful tracker and commuter. Only tracker and commuter seem like good roles. Corrina has had a lullaby, a bomb diffuser, a flying pumpkin and now a vig. Aside from the lullaby she's held the power of life and death. If she's the trickster giving herself primo actions that explains why we lost Hyacinth and Emeric, and she must have wasted her bomb diffuser on an unlikely target. It's in the trickster's interest to whittle down the survivors to probably as few as possible, right, in order to win? This fits. Just as well as my Benicia theory. Just as well as the fact Gilford has been playing in a reckless fashion as if he knows something we don't, and he oh-so-conveniently got Mobley out of the picture on the first night. Any of you could be the trickster I guess. As they say, what the shit? 6 hours ago, Corrina Cow said: Has there been more than one or are you just playing stupid? Classic Parvani amirite, clueless about the bomb, looking for clues in pictures, can't remember her own night action. Sowing confusion, scum suspect number one. 1 hour ago, Leatrix Lamb said: whyyyyyyyyy you told them I don't know about anyone else but Benicia told me not to waste my investigation on her because she was going to be out of town. 1 hour ago, Leatrix Lamb said: I suppose we could organiiiiiiiiize a shaaaaaaaaaving party tonight if you'd like to be sure. If we shave just your body and leave your face, tail & feet, you & poodle will look samesies! c'est chic, c'est scum
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 9 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: I don't know about anyone else but Benicia told me not to waste my investigation on her because she was going to be out of town. Yeah same about my protection. She suggested you or Corrina. 14 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: Just as well as the fact Gilford has been playing in a reckless fashion as if he knows something we don't, and he oh-so-conveniently got Mobley out of the picture on the first night. I didn't notice you asked this last night. FWIW I'm not the trickster.
Benicia Bear Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 OH YEAH OH YEAH OH YEAH WE'RE ALL HERE NOW, CAN WE HAVE BREAKFAST? 6 hours ago, Parvani Poodle said: Okay, so at the very least you didn't kill Shainen while you were commuting. Unless I was blocked and you didn't commute at all. OR YOU were blocked anyway, or you were busy doing something else... 1 hour ago, Leatrix Lamb said: I'M INTEREEEEEEEESTED to hear who you toooooold and perhaps even more importantly whyyyyyyyyy you told them. ALRIGHT, ALRIGHT YOU DON'T need to shout! I was offered protection by Gilford, and I declined because it would have been wasted on me because I was commuting, and I was involved in a discussion about investigations with Holbrook and the consideration of confirming town came up, so thought it fair to let him know as part of that to not waste his valuable action on me, as I'd be commuting. 8 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: The Spanish Inquisition I wasn't expecting that. 7 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: You straight up said would I trust any kind of result on Leatrix and I thought I'd play it on the safer side. But that reminds me that Gilford said he had wanted to investigate Leatrix, but didn't. Ugh. NO, I ASKED you to consider whether or not you would trust a "not scum" investigation result on Leatrix, and who you might consider to give a reliable result. We talked about a variety of possibilities. 7 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: Any of you could be the trickster I guess. As they say, what the shit? THIS IS uncomfortably true, but I agree with Giford that scum pose a more imminent threat. 7 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: I don't know about anyone else but Benicia told me not to waste my investigation on her because she was going to be out of town. 3 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: Yeah same about my protection. She suggested you or Corrina. THANK YOU GENTLEMEN.
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 Going back thru my messages, I kinda feel responsible for Elephants death since I should have paid more attention to Cow's suspect list, and suggested Lamb or Poodle more strongly as targets. For whatever reason I don't think vig was on my mind as a potential role you might have. 7 minutes ago, Benicia Bear said: I wasn't expecting that. Naturally. Because obviously no one expects the Spanish Inquisition, but more importantly you were expecting scum because what the hell else would I be talking about right @Leatrix Lamb?
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 Anyways, I don't think anything could change my suspects today nor is there time to do so. If Bear, Cow or Horse are scum instead of Lamb and Poodle then GG. You could maybe do something about that baby dragon hating though.
Covam Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 To late! Your time has come! Send blood flying everywhere! Body lifeless as a chair! Goodbye my dear mama! Why did you go?! Why'd you leave us all behind to faaaaaaaaace the haters?! MAMAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!! OOH! OOH! OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH! I don't wanna rely! On my own self to get around!
Leatrix Lamb Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 1 hour ago, Gilford Goat said: The Spanish Inquisition 28 minutes ago, Benicia Bear said: I wasn't expecting that. Noooooooobody does. Meanwhile, nothing goooooooooood has come out of all those "useful" roles and yet the claims all cheeeeeeck out. Eeeeeeeevery single night. We've been picking them apaaaaaaart, with no inconsistencies to be foooouuuuuund. No "scum" investigation reeeeeesult, not a single tracking or watching aaaaaaaaaction catching scum killing or blocking. Doesn't that sound just a bit too conveeeeeeeenient? 28 minutes ago, Benicia Bear said: WE'RE ALL HERE NOW, CAN WE HAVE BREAKFAST? Horse meat sausages? 28 minutes ago, Benicia Bear said: OR YOU were blocked anyway, or you were busy doing something else... Or, by having Parvani claim to have targeted you, you were giving your fellow baby dragon hater an aaaaaaaaalibi so he would be free to kill Shainen? 12 hours ago, Benicia Bear said: HMMM. BUT IT COULD also be because I commuted my ass out of here, like you knew I was going to. It's out of character for you to jump to conclusions. Taaaaaaaaalk about jumping to conclusions. Hooooooow would Parvani know? 28 minutes ago, Benicia Bear said: I was offered protection by Gilford, and I declined because it would have been wasted on me because I was commuting, and I was involved in a discussion about investigations with Holbrook and the consideration of confirming town came up, so thought it fair to let him know as part of that to not waste his valuable action on me, as I'd be commuting. You were giving the Spanish Inquisition baby dragon haters valuable informaaaaaaaation so they didn't have to waaaaaaaaaaste a block on you and make sure their kill would go through. If you're not a baby dragon hater yourseeeeeeelf, I can only see that benefiting the trickster.
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 8 minutes ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Taaaaaaaaalk about jumping to conclusions. Hooooooow would Parvani know? That was in reply to the Horse who was replying to Poodle who was saying she was unsuccessful in sending a belly rub to Bear who was commuting. 13 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: Quote Poodle: In case anyone is interested, I tried sending a Dwagon Bewwy Wub to Benicia last night, but was unsuccessful. Because you were busy off killing Shainen instead, we know what you're up to. I am curious about this though. If you knew about Bear commuting why say this? Are people still assuming it's not possible for scum to perform their scum actions and their actions given to them by the trickster? That'd make it way to hard for scum IMO.
Gilford Goat Posted August 28, 2020 Posted August 28, 2020 25 minutes ago, Leatrix Lamb said: You were giving the Spanish Inquisition baby dragon haters valuable informaaaaaaaation so they didn't have to waaaaaaaaaaste a block on you and make sure their kill would go through. If you're not a baby dragon hater yourseeeeeeelf, I can only see that benefiting the trickster. I'm can't stop reading everything you say as "I know you are but what am I?" Guess that's all scum can resort to now.
Recommended Posts