[MOC] My LEGO Renfe S-130

[zephyr1934]

5 hours ago, Imanol said:

The problem is that all of the bricks that I used as a child were from 2005 to 2014 and I´ve never seen this phenomena occurring so I don´t understand why it´s happening now. Also I´m not happy to sell instructions for a train whose bricks will develop several cracks.

I'm just saying it is an old problem. Any flaws in the bricks are not your fault and unless you are doing any extreme stress on the parts in your build you should not let Lego's faults keep you from selling instructions. If you start looking at your built sets or MOC's that have been around for a few years you will start seeing these fractured 1xN here and there

[Hod Carrier]

I'm not sure that I completely discounted the manufacturing process as the cause, although I was unaware of the issues caused by changes to the molding processes as described. I just couldn't see any other plausible explanation once misuse was ruled out. But now that we can see that this cracking has affected many others, I think we can see where the issues come from.

Given that your bricks were new and cracked almost immediately rather than as a result of degrading over time, I would still recommend that you take a full inventory of damaged parts and complain to LEGO, especially for those parts that came directly from them, asking for replacements.

Just to say that I think you've got yourself a great looking consist there now. All that hard work has really paid off. Congratulations!!

Edited April 28, 2024 by Hod Carrier

[Imanol]

9 hours ago, Hod Carrier said:

I'm not sure that I completely discounted the manufacturing process as the cause, although I was unaware of the issues caused by changes to the molding processes as described. I just couldn't see any other plausible explanation once misuse was ruled out. But now that we can see that this cracking has affected many others, I think we can see where the issues come from.

Well, for now I want to build a bigger case and I will try to contact other train moc builders that have done bigger and complex models in order to find the extent of the problem as I can´t seem to see this problems in other builds posted on the Internet.

9 hours ago, Hod Carrier said:

Given that your bricks were new and cracked almost immediately rather than as a result of degrading over time, I would still recommend that you take a full inventory of damaged parts and complain to LEGO, especially for those parts that came directly from them, asking for replacements.

Once I rule out any other reason I will initiate a complain with LEGO about the issue but I don´t know if they will answer for the bricks sold by other people even though they advertised them as new.

9 hours ago, Hod Carrier said:

Just to say that I think you've got yourself a great looking consist there now. All that hard work has really paid off. Congratulations!!

Thanks, the idea is to finish it this summer with the addition of another powercar and the 2 "Turista" cars but first I wan´t to solve this issue

[Imanol]

Well, I have bad news (again).

I have found the first major crack on a piece in the cafe car. For those who are not aware the cafe car was the last part of the train that I ´ve built and it was made with pieces from other sellers. The crack is in a 1x3 block located on the middle of the car (see render). This brings again my initial question, could this be (at least in part) caused by a structural problem in the train.

Crack Cafe car by Imanol, en Flickr

This idea comes from the fact that all of the external factors are different the train car was not subjected to any forces other than it´s own weight as I have not removed the roof, also as I previously said. The possibility that it is caused by a defective batch can be ruled out as the pieces were bought two months after the first order and from different sellers who listed them as new.

Currently I´m very busy with exams so I don´t have found yet the time to inspect all of the train in search for more cracks or any other problem so I can at least know the extension of the issue.  

If anyone has any other theories feel free to say it as I need to sort this as soon as possible because I have several orders for instructions of my trains and I don´t want to include what might be a critical error in the design.

Imanol

[Hod Carrier]

Another vertical crack...? Where on the brick does it occur?

From what I can see from the outside I can see no reason why the crack would have appeared, but it's hard to see if there's any structural weakness inside. Does the completed car flex? Does the car look straight when you look along the side? If the answer is "no" I would say that it's not a structural problem but that you've just been unlucky with the parts you've had.

[Imanol]

21 minutes ago, Hod Carrier said:

Another vertical crack...? Where on the brick does it occur?

From what I can see from the outside I can see no reason why the crack would have appeared, but it's hard to see if there's any structural weakness inside. Does the completed car flex? Does the car look straight when you look along the side? If the answer is "no" I would say that it's not a structural problem but that you've just been unlucky with the parts you've had.

The crack is like the others, it starts in the middle and covers the lower half. 

The car appears to be straight but I will check it later more thoroughly.

There are two points of concern:

- The attachment for the bogie is located in the upper part so the car is hanging from it

- This piece is located under the point where the two window parts join, this was used using the cheese slope technique but for some reason the window is larger than the frame and it comes outwards a little bit.

Apart from this area cracks are starting to appear in the other 1x3 that is in the image.

I hope this will help determine the problem.

Thanks, Imanol

[Hod Carrier]

I can't imagine that it is a consequence of your design. The 1x3 brick you highlighted is held at the bottom by three layers of plates, two of which cover the entire length of the brick.

OK, so I would normally try and support everything from underneath rather than from the top, but that's really just so that the action of gravity pushes the parts together rather than pulling them apart, but the clutch power of LEGO parts should be sufficient that it shouldn't really make such a big difference. It would be a major redesign, but if it worries you you could have the bogie attachments linked to a sturdy chassis using Technic L-shape liftarms and then build the bodies on top of those. This is what I did with the railcar, but that was forced onto me because of the way that the body sections were attached which meant that there would have been no other supporting structure.

[Imanol]

23 hours ago, Hod Carrier said:

I can't imagine that it is a consequence of your design. The 1x3 brick you highlighted is held at the bottom by three layers of plates, two of which cover the entire length of the brick.

OK, so I would normally try and support everything from underneath rather than from the top, but that's really just so that the action of gravity pushes the parts together rather than pulling them apart, but the clutch power of LEGO parts should be sufficient that it shouldn't really make such a big difference. It would be a major redesign, but if it worries you you could have the bogie attachments linked to a sturdy chassis using Technic L-shape liftarms and then build the bodies on top of those. This is what I did with the railcar, but that was forced onto me because of the way that the body sections were attached which meant that there would have been no other supporting structure.

For now, redesigning the entire car is discarded as I don´t think it will be worth it but I will see it in the future. 

As I said in my previous message there is another possibility which is that the window is pressing it and producing the damage even though the tile on top is perfect it may be transferring the forces onto the brick below and causing the cracks but this is all suppositions.

I think that for the other pieces broken I´m going to try to strengthen the union between the two sides of the car which is for now the only idea that comes to mind although there are several cracks on the window frames that I can´t explain for now

Do you think if this could be the cause of the problems?

Thanks for all the help, Imanol

[Hod Carrier]

On 6/11/2024 at 12:06 PM, Imanol said:

I think that for the other pieces broken I´m going to try to strengthen the union between the two sides of the car which is for now the only idea that comes to mind although there are several cracks on the window frames that I can´t explain for now

Do you think if this could be the cause of the problems?

The truth is that I don't know. I've never experienced this myself and I can see nothing wrong with the images you've posted.

[Imanol]

On 6/29/2024 at 12:56 PM, Hod Carrier said:

The truth is that I don't know. I've never experienced this myself and I can see nothing wrong with the images you've posted.

Well, I´ve finally found time to work with the train again and I have discovered what I think is the main cause of the cracks.

The two areas marked in this photo are the main critical points on the car as they are not properly connected:

In this other image you can see the connection points (apart from the upper area:

This is what I think is happening, the arrows signal the forces involved. The bricks marked are the ones which have developed cracks so the theory checks up.

Now comes the second part, which is how to solve this. Frankly I don´t have any idea. I knew from the start that this could be a problem but I wasn´t sure how to solve it but I didn´t imagine it could cause all of this.

It might be a good idea to start thinking on a complete redesign of this areas changing the bogie connection from the top to the bottom.

If anyone has another idea feel free to say it.

And of course there is another problem as unfortunately I will be away from my home several days so I won´t be able to test anything on the real model.

Thanks, Imanol