iragm Posted April 29, 2024 Posted April 29, 2024 48 minutes ago, Lion King said: I think this set will be retiring by end of this year? I could not find some info on this EOL somehwere but I swear I saw it. This is correct. r/legoleak keeps a spreadsheet of retirement dates. These are taken from the Lego website (they aren't visible to people, only to a script). These dates are generally accurate, and this set retires at the end of this year. Don't wait if you want it. It's a good build and I'd be sorry if I missed out on it, although it's just not as good a set as Barracuda Bay was. Quote
Lion King Posted April 30, 2024 Posted April 30, 2024 17 hours ago, iragm said: This is correct. r/legoleak keeps a spreadsheet of retirement dates. These are taken from the Lego website (they aren't visible to people, only to a script). These dates are generally accurate, and this set retires at the end of this year. Don't wait if you want it. It's a good build and I'd be sorry if I missed out on it, although it's just not as good a set as Barracuda Bay was. Thanks! I’m not sure if I am picky or not but this El Dorado set doens’t scream for me to buy it. I will have to wait for a “perfect” pirate ship like B-Bay ship! Quote
eldiano Posted April 30, 2024 Posted April 30, 2024 3 hours ago, Lion King said: Thanks! I’m not sure if I am picky or not but this El Dorado set doens’t scream for me to buy it. I will have to wait for a “perfect” pirate ship like B-Bay ship! If you want another pirate ship you need a fortress for them to attack, don’t miss out! Hehe Quote
Lion King Posted April 30, 2024 Posted April 30, 2024 8 minutes ago, eldiano said: If you want another pirate ship you need a fortress for them to attack, don’t miss out! Hehe True!! Quote
Captain Pirate Man Posted May 2, 2024 Posted May 2, 2024 Eldorado is an absolute GEM of a set. I bought two of them, and I would LOVE a third (but Barad Dur is on the horizon). Take this however you guys want, but I have either owned or currently own, most of the Pirates and POTC lines, and I would ABSOLUTLY put Eldorado in my TOP 5, over the OG Eldorado AND Imperial Trading Post. Honestly, the ONLY other Imperial set you can argue being better is the BIG Imperial Flagship, all of the rest are a distant third. I would also add that I wouldn't expect ANY new Imperial sets anytime soon after this. I don't think it sold very well, unfortunately, hence the early retirement. Which I also have other info, but thats just anecdotical. Evidence supports that Pirate ships sell, but forts... Not so much. So when a NEW Pirates sets gets released, I'd bet dollars to donuts that it'll be a new Pirate Ship (Hopefully SES). In the meantime, a new Harry Potter ship was leaked, and it looks GREAT, lot's of potential there. Back to the topic, if you LOVE Imperials, don't miss the boat on this one. You'll regret it. Quote
thewatchman Posted May 2, 2024 Posted May 2, 2024 32 minutes ago, Captain Pirate Man said: In the meantime, a new Harry Potter ship was leaked, and it looks GREAT, lot's of potential there. Each to their own. I find this hugely disappointing. Covered in stickers, bland and boring and not really scaled right to anything. Hard pass, which is a shame because I had high hopes for this set. Quote
Captain Pirate Man Posted May 2, 2024 Posted May 2, 2024 9 minutes ago, thewatchman said: Each to their own. I find this hugely disappointing. Covered in stickers, bland and boring and not really scaled right to anything. Hard pass, which is a shame because I had high hopes for this set. Fair enough. I like it though, I think it has potential. Quote
iragm Posted May 2, 2024 Posted May 2, 2024 13 hours ago, Captain Pirate Man said: Take this however you guys want, but I have either owned or currently own, most of the Pirates and POTC lines, and I would ABSOLUTLY put Eldorado in my TOP 5, over the OG Eldorado AND Imperial Trading Post. Honestly, the ONLY other Imperial set you can argue being better is the BIG Imperial Flagship, all of the rest are a distant third. I too own (or have owned) all the original pirates sets and I have built and sold many of the POTC sets as well as the 10210 flagship. The OG Eldorado and Trading Post are of similar quality to this, despite being 30 years older. The raised baseplate takes away a lot of what makes this build tedious, and those sets don't have printing issues with the minifigures. (The printing issues are wildly overstated in this thread, they don't really bother me, but I can see why the original figures are printed on white torsos). I would love to hear your reasoning for what puts this set in the top 5. B-Bay and most of the original ships are more visually impressive. This is a good set, I do recommend it, but it's flawed in many ways. More interesting angles like the Lion Knight's castle had, molded doors, more secrets and more variation in techniques used in the rock baseplate, more detail in the interiors, and finishing off the governor's office would have all gone a long way towards making this an excellent set. Quote
BrickMatit Posted August 21, 2024 Posted August 21, 2024 Just finished some days ago to build Eldorado Fortress... this is, simply, amazing I've never had a lot of Imperials & Pirates sets, only two little ones from 2009 (Kraken attackin' and Cannon Battle) -so I've nothing to compare Eldorado to - but this theme always enchanted me. Now this set... I built it with my brother and we had a lot of fun! Probably there is something minor fixes to do and in the future I could decided to modify the set, but for me it's already perfect as it is. Now it's almost time, near my birthday, to open and build my present: Pirate Ship 3 in 1. In the future I wouldn't mind some new sets with Imperials & Pirates: another ship or a pirate cove or a treasure island. Quote
Governor Mister Phes Posted August 21, 2024 Author Governor Posted August 21, 2024 3 hours ago, BrickMatit said: In the future I wouldn't mind some new sets with Imperials & Pirates: another ship or a pirate cove or a treasure island. How do you feel about BrickLink Designer sets? Quote
BrickMatit Posted August 23, 2024 Posted August 23, 2024 On 8/21/2024 at 2:52 PM, Mister Phes said: How do you feel about BrickLink Designer sets? I've seen it now, I'll probably leave a message in the other thread. Quote
Yperio_Bricks Posted August 28, 2024 Posted August 28, 2024 So I jumped over my shadow as we say in Germany and ordered 2 of the Governor's torsos with my latest PAB order. Now that i have the torsos in my hands I can say that the printing quality is abysmal as expected and I detest them. This "white" color looks so so bad Quote
Arjo Posted August 30, 2024 Posted August 30, 2024 Not the best to say the least… and prices have increased (at least in my region). I wanted to get a handful of governor’s hats but at 2.50+ each I am yet to pull the trigger. Quote
Governor Mister Phes Posted August 30, 2024 Author Governor Posted August 30, 2024 5 hours ago, Arjo said: Not the best to say the least… and prices have increased (at least in my region). I wanted to get a handful of governor’s hats but at 2.50+ each I am yet to pull the trigger. They await you right here. Quote
Yperio_Bricks Posted August 30, 2024 Posted August 30, 2024 Yikes, the price for the governor's hat is 2.95€ here. Is the hat dual-molded? Quote
TalonCard Posted August 30, 2024 Posted August 30, 2024 I don't think so, it feels like black printing on a white hat. You can buy the white hats separately too. Quote
Lion King Posted August 30, 2024 Posted August 30, 2024 Will it stay here around until next year? I still haven’t decided to buy it or not…. Quote
Arjo Posted August 30, 2024 Posted August 30, 2024 Good to see I am not the only one who didn’t pull the trigger… it’s a useful piece for sure but for the same price you can put together a fully decked out minifig of other designs I like. On a related note, I believe 10320 is retiring by year-end/while stocks last but I have never seen it discounted anywhere. Quote
Horation Posted August 30, 2024 Posted August 30, 2024 On 5/2/2024 at 11:45 AM, iragm said: I too own (or have owned) all the original pirates sets and I have built and sold many of the POTC sets as well as the 10210 flagship. The OG Eldorado and Trading Post are of similar quality to this, despite being 30 years older. The raised baseplate takes away a lot of what makes this build tedious... Well, out of curiosity, what would your top 5 look like? As for the older sets you mention, I have to disagree, they feel objectively worse to me ; they have far less detail, and no interior caves under the baseplate. on top of that, and while building with the baseplates is much faster, you literally can't put a figure on the ramp without it sliding down or falling, and that alone is enough to make me prefer the newer set, even if is more "tedious" (this isn't the colisseum, it's only a total of 700-800 parts that you build for the baseplate, and there is some variety). Quote
iragm Posted August 31, 2024 Posted August 31, 2024 5 hours ago, Horation said: Well, out of curiosity, what would your top 5 look like? My favorites: B-Bay Skull's Eye Imperial Trading Post Eldorado BSB 6271 OG Imperial Flagship Enchanted Island [Eldorado redux somewhere around here] Caribbean Clipper Rock Island Refuge I like the simplistic charm of the original sets. I wasn't really into them as a kid, I got into them as an adult after completing 80s/90s castle stuff and looking for similar things to scratch the itch of guess what sets are in bulk lots on the goodwill sites. I don't consider pirates as good as castle (I know what forum I'm on, fight me!) but they share a lot of techniques and designers (Daniel August Krentz gets a special mention for also doing my favorite space set, Message Intercept Base). Quote
Horation Posted August 31, 2024 Posted August 31, 2024 4 minutes ago, iragm said: I don't consider pirates as good as castle (I know what forum I'm on, fight me!) but they share a lot of techniques and designers I quite like castle as well, and I guess I can understand the nostalgia towards those older castle sets influencing you towards older sets, but I really feel like that's clouding your opinion a little, newer sets are more detailed across the board (from 10305 to 10320, and even when you compare old town sets with newer city sets), which generally looks nicer. Then again, older stuff does have a charm to it, so I can see where you're coming from. Personally : Pirates of Barracuda Bay Imperial Flagship New Eldorado Fortress Original Barracuda Skull Eye's Schooner Imperial trading outpost Quote
SpacePolice89 Posted August 31, 2024 Posted August 31, 2024 3 hours ago, Horation said: I quite like castle as well, and I guess I can understand the nostalgia towards those older castle sets influencing you towards older sets, but I really feel like that's clouding your opinion a little, newer sets are more detailed across the board (from 10305 to 10320, and even when you compare old town sets with newer city sets), which generally looks nicer. Then again, older stuff does have a charm to it, so I can see where you're coming from. Personally : Pirates of Barracuda Bay Imperial Flagship New Eldorado Fortress Original Barracuda Skull Eye's Schooner Imperial trading outpost For me Pirates and Castle feel very equal in terms of design quality. I prefer the 80s and 90s style of sets from both themes because I feel many modern sets are too polished and have too many round pieces/specialized pieces that makes them to look less like building toys and more like non building toy scale models. But that is my personal preference and I think that the new sets like Barracuda Bay and Eldorado Fortress 2 are great, it's just that I prefer the older design language and parts. My favorite Pirates sets are: 6272 Eldorado Fortress 6271 Imperial Flagship 6285 Black Seas Barracuda 6279 Skull Island 6270 Forbidden Island 6278 Enchanted Island 6267 Lagoon Lock Up 6277 Imperial Trading Post 6286 Skull's Eye Schooner 6274 Caribbean Clipper Honorable mention: 6268 Renegade Runner , 6263 Imperial Outpost and 6289 Red Beard Runner Now I'll have to stop, otherwise I'll mention all Pirates sets Quote
The Reader Posted August 31, 2024 Posted August 31, 2024 Does anybody know if set 10320 Eldorado Fortress is EOL in 2024? I have been to some Lego stores in southern Germany recently where it hasn‘t been on the shelves. The store staff told me that it can only be ordered online. Quote
Yperio_Bricks Posted August 31, 2024 Posted August 31, 2024 13 minutes ago, The Reader said: Does anybody know if set 10320 Eldorado Fortress is EOL in 2024? Yes, that is correct. EOL December 2024. Quote
The Reader Posted August 31, 2024 Posted August 31, 2024 (edited) 2 hours ago, Yperio_Bricks said: Yes, that is correct. Thank you! 2 hours ago, Yperio_Bricks said: EOL December 2024. Hm … shall I get it? Edited August 31, 2024 by The Reader Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.