[CONTEST] Vote for the WINNERS! (VOTING CLOSED)

[Woody Orsat]

Many great creations, was hard to choose favorites. My votes goes to:

Main Building Category
The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop
Sin Island by Marooned Marin
Forbidden Island II by BrickCommander9
Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy
6262 King Kahuka’s Throne Remake by SevenDeadlyStreamers

 

Mini Set Building Category
Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6
Cannibals by Valdeoris
Hidden Cache by LetsBrick
Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

6235 Buried Treasure by Janhansson

[Cincinnati]

Congratulations to everyone, it was really difficult to choose 

 

Main Building Category

- Sin Island by Marooned Marin

- 6254+6258 "Remastered" - Atolls by Amedeo

- Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383

- Pirate's Perilous Pitfall Remake by Slegengr

- 6265 Sabre Island Redux by Yatkuu

Mini Building Category

- King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch

- Fortune Idol by Oki

- Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

 

Edited September 12, 2023 by Cincinnati

[GeoBrick]

About time to vote. 't Was difficult to wittle down on the Main Building Category, and I'm still not sure I made the right decisions.

Main Building Category:

• Skulls Eye Schooner remake by Quotenotto
• Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4
• Short Pork Island by Yonggington
• Imperial Guard Camp by MyFirstMoc
• Saber Island by TomSkippy

Mini Set Building Category

• Pirate gun cart revisited by Vdog
• Fortune Idol by Oky
• 1747 Treasure Surprise Remake: Rum Rock by Fraunces
• Shipwreck of Avedo by Tayaya
• King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by kritch
   

[mrblue]

quite a difficult choice, many more deserve a point, but these are the one I prefer.

 

Main Building Category

Imperial Trading Post    by    aex383
31109 Pirate Ship Creator 3 in 1 revisited   by   eldiano
Big Kahuna's Atoll   by   Yatkuu
6267 Lagoon Lock-up/Soldiers' Tavern Remake   by   Aanchir
6254 Rocky Reef Remake   by   MyFirstMOC-Hun

Mini Set Building Category

Captain's Cabin   by   MontyMatte
Remake of 6234 Renegade’s Raft   by   SevenDeadlyStreamers
1795 Imperial Cannon Remake   by   CaptainDarkNStormy
Sloop Windy   by   Marooned Marin
Fortune Idol   by   Oky

 

[MontyMatte]

Main Building Category:

6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate

6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4

Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati

The Hurricane by Marooned Marin

SIN ISLAND: Keg & Cutlass Inn + Comic book by Marooned Marin

 

Mini Set Building Category

Fortune Idol by Oky

Sloop Windy (Mini Set) by Marooned Marin

Caribbean River Soldiers by Rogue Redocat

6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy

1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn by Elephant Knight

[HAL-9001]

Main Building Category
Eldorado Bastion by Stoertebricker
Le Scorpion by Jansued
6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4
6279 Skull Island - Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun
Armada Fortress by Elephant Knight

Mini Set Building Category
Fortune Idol by Oky
Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte
Shark Cart by TomSkippy
Buried Treasure 6235 - Remake by Omby54
1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy

[SNobleJr]

All right, here it goes:

 

Main Building Category
"The Lost Lagoon" by The Brick Stop
"6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake" by Aanchir
"Caribbean shipyard" by Cincinnati
"6262 King Kahuka’s Throne Remake" by SevenDeadlyStreamers
"Saber Island 2023" by TomSkippy

Mini Set Building Category
"King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat" by kritch
"Captain's Cabin" by MontyMatte
"Shipwrecked Survivor" by nyugvo6
"1872 Imperial Guard Camp Remake" by thewatchman
"6232 Skeleton Crew Remake" by Jack Sassy

 

Best of luck to everyone!

[CaptainDarkNStormy]

Main Category:

The Lizard - CaptainDarkNStormy (no I’m not being a dork and voting for myself. My son made this one)

Short Pork Island - Yogginton

Sin Island - Marooned Marin

Sabre Island 2023 - TomSkippy

Rock Island Refuge Remake - CollinsAnimationStudio

Mini Category:

Rum Rock - Fraunces

King Kahuna’s Outrigger - Kritch

Skeleton Crew Remake - Jack Sassy

Cannibals - Valdeoris

Treasure Island - Oky

 

 

This contest was so fun and I enjoyed seeing everyone else’s entries. I hope all of y’all keep building new pirate MOCs!

 

 

[nyugvo6]

 Main Building Category
"Saber Island 2023" by TomSkippy
"6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake" by Danny_Boy4
"1872 Imperial Guard Camp - Remake 2023" by MyFirstMOC-Hun
"6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake" by Aanchir
" Forbidden Island II" by BrickCommander9

Mini Set Building Category
"Captain's Cabin" by MontyMatte
"Shark Cart" by TomSkippy
"Failed Raid" by SNobleJr
"King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat" by Kritch
"Sloop Windy" by Marooned Marin

It was very hard to choose at times.

[zack-ta]

Hello, new to the site, but thoughts I'd start my presence here with some votes

Main building category

1. Lost Lagoon by the Brick shop 

2. Pirate's inn by Elephantknight

3. 6267 Lagoon lockup revisited by CaptainLocke

4. Cross bone Clipper remake by Elephantknight

5. Armada Fortress by Elephantknight

For the mine set building category

1. Shark Cart by Tomskippy

2. 6232 Skeleton crew remake by Jack Sassy

 3. 1802 Tidy treasure-remake by Dr3w

4. Pirates Doc by Elephantknight (Legit had to question myself if that was a real set)

5.Treasure island by Oky

[Piraten]

Main building Category

Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy
Sin Island by Maroon Marin

Skull Island by Glowboy
Armada Sentry Remake by Brickshipyard

Mini Set Building Category

Sloop Windy Marooned Marin
Shark Cart by TomSkippy
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by kritch

River Soldiers by Rouge Redcoat
 

[PettyOfficerFirstClassHook]

Main Building Category
1. The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop

2. Cutless Reach by LetsBrick

3. Rock Island Refuge by CaptainDarkNStormy

4. Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy

5. The Hearty Cutlass by Thats No Moon

 

Mini Set Building Category
1. Hidden Cache by LetsBrick

2. Shark Cart by TomSkippy

3. King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch

4.The Jellyfish Raft  by MarcoLEGO

5.Renegade's End by Johnnyopies

[Brickshipyard]

Wow! What a great contest this has been in almost all regards (expect for that obvious pirate rigging on some votes)! Otherwise a total pleasure and thank you to some kind voters for sending a few votes my way. Warms my ole' Lego Pirate's heart. :)

Below is my collection of votes to cast. I carefully chose them for a mix of excellent build qualities (nostalgic feelings rank very high for me) and underdog qualities. There may have technically been a few better builds in each category, but I don't automatically vote for them because they get enough votes already and quite often in the main building category are just the biggest builds so they have everything like a catch all playset. Nothing inherently wrong with that strategy, I just prefer a more targeted and smarter build on a remaking a classic pirate set. The mini build category was really tough to narrow down, all entries were rather charming!

 

Main Building Category:

1. Rock Island Refuge Remake by CollinsAnimationStudio

2. Imperial Trading Post Remake by Rogue Redcoat

3. Eldorado Bastion by Stoertebricker

4. Pirate's Perilous Pitfall Remake 2023 by Slegengr

5. Armada Fortress by Elephant Knight

Mini building category:

1. Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6

2. A Promiscuous Sailor Captain by JophieK

3. Imperial Guard Camp by Thewatchman

4. Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy

5. Cannibals by Valdeoris

[zinnn]

I hope some of the designers that registered here only to submit their entries will hang around for longer / join in discussions. Overall, @MyFirstMOC-Hun is my personal MVP of this competition, all of his designs were incredible, and it was hard for me to pick my fav. However the fact that a bunch of suspicious accounts showed up here casting votes for him only threw a shade on his fantastic builds. Anyway...

 

My picks, not in order (well done everyone!)

Main Building Category:

6279 Skull Island - Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun

Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy

Short Pork Island by Yogginton

1873 & 6258 Pirate Treasure & Smuggler's Shanty - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun

6246 Crocodile Cage - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun

 

Mini building category:

Fortune Idol by Oky

Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte

King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch

Treasure Island by Oky

1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w

 

[Retrocity]

So many great entries in this.  It's hard to pick just 5 per category.

 

Main Building Category:

1. Rock Island Refuge by CaptainDarkNStormy

2. Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati

3. The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop

4. Cutless Reach by LetsBrick

5. Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy

 

Mini Building Category:

1. Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6

2. Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte

3. Buried Treasure 6235 - Remake by Omby54

4. Fortune Idol by Oky

5. King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch

[Duck]

What a wonderful summer of pirates we have had! All the entries have been amazing, and it's been hard to narrow it down to just five per category, but here are the ten that have won my heart with their take on what LEGO Pirates is all about!

Main Building Category
Enchanted Island Remake by Dannyboy4
Imperial Trading Post Remake by Rogue Redcoat
Rock Island Refuge Remake by Collinsanimationstudio
Caribbean Clipper by TomSkippy
Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy

Mini Set Building Category
A Promiscuous Sailor Captain (Mini Set) by JopieK
Caribbean River Soldiers by Rogue Redcoat
Sloop Windy (Mini Set) by Marooned Martin
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat (Mini Set) by Kritch
Captain's Cabin (Mini set) by MonteMatt

[TomSkippy]

Main Building Category

Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy

6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate

6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4

Short Pork Island by Yogginton

 

Mini Building Category

Shark Cart by TomSkippy

Treasure Island by Oky

[Glowboy]

Main Building Category:

6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4

Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383

Caribbean Brig by Stoertebricker

6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/ Castaway's Raft Remake by _R_R_

Mini Building Category:

Fortune Idol by Oky

 

 

 

[CollinsAnimationStudio]

It has been a pleasure participating in this contest and seeing all of the wonderful builds made by the talented members of this community! Best of luck to all!

Main building category:
6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake By Aanchir
6269 Islander Palace By BrynnOfCastlegate
Short Pork Island by Yoggington
6273 Rock Island Refuge By CollinsAnimationStudio
6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake By Danny_Boy4

Mini building category:
Captain’s Cabin By MontyMatte
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat By kritch
1872 Imperial Guard Camp Remake By thewatchman
1795 Imperial Cannon Remake By CaptainDarkNStormy

Edited September 17, 2023 by CollinsAnimationStudio
Wrong formatting

[Mister Phes]

VOTING CLOSED!!!

Click Here for Voting Tallies