MAP Tec Posted August 31, 2023 Posted August 31, 2023 All cool creations! Main Building Category UCS Jolly Roger By hatchpattern Caribbean shipyard By Cincinnati 31109 Pirate Ship Creator 3 in 1 revisited By eldiano The Hurricane By Marooned Marin Skulls Eye Schooner remake (6286) By Quotenotto Mini Set Building Category Spy Dinghy Mini-Set By Brendan McGnarley Cannibals (Mini Set) By Valdeirus 1747 Treasure Surprise Remake: Rum Rock By Fraunces Caribbean River Soldiers (Mini Set) By Rogue Redcoat 6500 A Promiscuous Sailor Captain (Mini Set) By JopieK
Elephant Knight Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 Here's my votes. I had a fun time entering this contest! Main building category: 1. 6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate 2. 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up Revisited by CaptainLocke 3. 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir 4. 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 5. 6281 Pirate's Perilous Pitfall Remake 2023 by Slegengr Mini set category: 1. Fortune Idol by Oky 2. Hidden Cache by LetsBrick 3. 6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy 4. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin 5. 1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w EKnight
Dr3w Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 It was difficult to choose from so many great creations, but here's a list of my personal favourites: Main Building Category:Sailor's Hideout by SlegengrArmada Fortress by Elephant Knight6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate6265 Sabre Island Redux by YatkuuSkulls Eye Schooner remake (6286) by QuotenottoSmall Building Category:King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by KritchShipwreck of Avedo by TayayaSloop Windy by Marooned MarinFailed Raid by SNobleJRShipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6 Best of luck to you all!
Horation Posted September 1, 2023 Posted September 1, 2023 (edited) I'm quite tired, so I'll do one part of the vote today and another later (maybe tomorrow) Main Building category 6269 Islander palace by BrynnOfCastlegate (the best entry, in my opinion) The Hurricane by Marooned Marin Skull's eye schooner by Quotenotto Imperial trading outpost by aex383 Rock Island refuge by CaptainDarkNStormy Mini set category 1872 imperial guard camp remake by Rogue Redcoat Caribbean River soldiers by Rogue Redcoat King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by kritch Edited September 2, 2023 by Horation Formatting changes and added some votes
GabKremo Posted September 2, 2023 Posted September 2, 2023 Main Building Category 6279 Skull Island Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6254 Rocky Reef by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6246 Crocodile Cage by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6259 Broadside’s Brig by MyFirstMOC-Hun 1873 & 6258 Pirate Treasure & Smuggler's Shanty by MyFirstMOC-Hun Mini Set Building Category Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6 Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte Treasure Found by Valdeoris Treasure Found by JopieK 1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy
crusader9576 Posted September 2, 2023 Posted September 2, 2023 My votes: Main Building Category 1. 6269 Islander Palace by Brynn of Castlegate 2. Caribbean Brig - better known as the Ironram by Stoertebricker 3. 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 4. Short Pork Island by Yoggington 5. 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers' Tavern Remake by Aanchir Mini Set Building Category: 1. Shark Cart by TomSkippy 2. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin 3. 1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn by Elephant Knight 4. 6234 Renegades Raft Remake by Janhansson 5. Pirate's Dock by Elephant Knight
Danny_Boy4 Posted September 2, 2023 Posted September 2, 2023 My votes Main building category 6269 Islander PalaceBy BrynnOfCastlegate 6273 Rock Island Refuge Remake By CollinsAnimationStudio 6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/ Castaway's Raft Remake By _R_R_ Short Pork Island By Yoggington Mini building category King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat By kritch Treasure Island By Oky 6235 Buried Treasure remake By janhansson Shipwreck of Avedo By Tayaya
CJCx3_Legos Posted September 2, 2023 Posted September 2, 2023 Thank you all for the creative Entries! I learned a lot and look forward to another contest! Main building Governor Broadside's Garrison BY US_Army_Tom The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop Imperial Guard Tower by Elephant Knight Sin Island by Marooned Marin Rock Island Refuge by CaptainDarkNStormy Mini set Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte Great Pirate Treasure by Xoona Treasure Island by Oky Hidden Cache by LetsBrick 1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w
michgeld Posted September 3, 2023 Posted September 3, 2023 Main Building Category 1. 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 2. Short Pork Island by Yoggington 3. The Indigo Chief's Palace (set 6269) by BrynnOfC 4. Cutless Reach by Letsbrick 5. Sin Island by Marooned Marin Mini Set Building Category 1. 6235 Buried Treasure remake by janhansson 2. 6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy 3. 1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w
ildottore Posted September 3, 2023 Posted September 3, 2023 Main Building Category "The Lost Lagoon" by The Brick Stop "Caribbean Clipper" by TomSkippy "Saber Island 2023" by TomSkippy "6273 Rock Island Refuge Remake" by CollinsAnimationStudio "Base Imperiale" by Omby54 Mini Set Building Category "Shark Cart" by TomSkippy "Treasure Island" by Oky "King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat" by Kritch "A Promiscuous Sailor Captain" by JopieK "Fortune Idol" by Oky
dilligan Posted September 4, 2023 Posted September 4, 2023 Some fantastic designs by everyone. I found it very hard to narrow it down to just 5 in each category In the end, I picked sets that I feel looked more like sets Lego would design, rather than ones that felt more like Ideas sets. Main Building Category "Short Pork Island" by Yogginton "6269 Islander Palace" by BrynnOfCastlegate "6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern" by Aanchir "6277 Imperial Trading Post Remake" by Rogue Redcoat "6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake" by Danny_Boy4 Mini Set Building Category "Fortune Idol" by Oky "Captain's Cabin" by MontyMatte "Sloop Windy" byMarooned Marin "Treasure Found" by JopieK "6235 Buried Treasure" by Janhansson These are the sets I would probably buy if available: Spoiler carribean shipyard by Cincinnati Base impériale by omby54 The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop Sin Island by Marooned Marin Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383 Sloop Windy byMarooned Marin
Damon20 Posted September 4, 2023 Posted September 4, 2023 My picks: Main building category: Governor Broadside's Garrison BY US_Army_Tom The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop Base impériale by omby54 Soldier’s Armory by Eldiano Sin Island by Marooned Marin Mini set building category: 1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy Buried Treasure 6235 - Remake by Omby54 6235 Buried Treasure by Janhansson
The Reader Posted September 4, 2023 Posted September 4, 2023 So many phantastic entries. It's realy hard to pick only five in each category ... Special thanks to @Mister Phes and team for organizing this superb contest! Here are my votes: Main Building Category Sailor's Hideout by Slegengr Fort Broadside by Alexandrina Armada Fortress by Elephant Knight 6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir Mini Set Building Category Fortune Idol by Oky Treasure Island by Oky Rum Rock by Fraunces 1872 Imperial Guard Camp by Thewatchman 6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy
Captain Pirate Man Posted September 5, 2023 Posted September 5, 2023 Good Luck EVERYBODY!!! I'll be talking about this contest on my YouTube Show "The Brick Chat" tomorrow. Here are MY PICKS: Main Category: 1. The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop 2. Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati 3. Caribbean Clipper by Amedeo 4. Rock Island Refuge by Collins Animation Studio 5. Imperial Trading Post by Rogue Redcoat Mini Category: 1. Imperial Guard Camp by The Watchman 2. Cannibals by Valdeirus 3. Caribbean River Soldiers by Rogue Redcoat Here is a link to my LIVE STREAM. A video will follow.
Barba Ross Posted September 6, 2023 Posted September 6, 2023 Main set: Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati 6259 Broadside's Brig - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun Big Kahuna's Atoll by Yatkuu 6279 Skull Island - Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383 Mini: Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6 Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte
Tibcsi83 Posted September 6, 2023 Posted September 6, 2023 My votes: Main Building Category 1492 Battle Cove - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun 1873 & 6258 Pirate Treasure & Smuggler's Shanty - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6279 Skull Island - Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6254 Rocky Reef - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun 1872 Imperial Guard Camp - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun Mini Set Building Category Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6 Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte 1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w Buried Treasure 6235 - Remake by Omby54 King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch Good luck to everyone!
MstrOfPppts Posted September 6, 2023 Posted September 6, 2023 Main category: 6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/ Castaway's Raft Remake by _R_R_6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake by Aanchir6271 Imperial Flagship Redux by Elephant Knight6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop Mini category: 1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn by Elephant Knight1872 Imperial Guard Camp Remake by thewatchman6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack SassyFortune Idol by OkyKing Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by kritch My comments: Spoiler Main category: 6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/ Castaway's Raft Remake by _R_R_ - Maybe doing a remake of two very likeable classic sets was not such a bad idea after all. The entry came out very pleasing and there were quite some improvements according to suggestions.6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake by Aanchir - A very nicely designed set with keeping all the proportions and details from the original with smartly using the newer parts and colors as well as adding some great details. I must admit that the original set is not that nostalgic to me and maybe therefor just the brick built sail almost cost you the top 5!6271 Imperial Flagship Redux by Elephant Knight - The best ship of this competition in my eyes without any unneccesary complications that would make the ship look bulky or otherwise out of proportions. A clear remaster of an old classic and although a bit too similar to the orginal on closer inspection the more modern parts and techniques can clearly be seen.6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 - Clearly my number one pick for this category! Very faithfull to the original and clearly remastered in the LEGO style. Also quite some changes were made according to the suggestions to make the set really stand out! If it was represented as a leak, it would of fooled me for sure!The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop - A great new set using the very classic style of the Islanders theme. It looks phenomenal and all the play features are also great. This is clearly how TLG would make a UCS or a 18+ set back in the good old days and I would drool over it until it got discontinued! Main category runners-up: 6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate - Another great new set in the classic islanders scheme. I think that quite some of us were asking ourselves if maybe we missed memorizing one of the sets from the past! And although I think that TLG might do it exactly like this, I think it feels a tad bit empty hee and there.6273 Rock Island Refuge Remake by CollinsAnimationStudio - The original was a beast and even choosing to remake this set in particular does half of the job. This entry beats the other of a same set remake by the more green in the rockwaork and the niceboxart presentation, though both look a bit unfinished at the top of the base.Short Pork Island by Yoggington - A wonderfull design with a more modern islanders approach. Maybe just a little bit over the border to pass as a real LEGO set with too parts intensive techniques and too dense details. Would love to see it take a chance on LEGO ideas or the bricklink designer program though! Mini category: 1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn by Elephant Knight - A wonderful remake which also upgrades the original for an actual lookout feel! It might look very simple yet you really need some feeling to put a few pieces together and make a great rockwork which is the base of the whole build. Also the author took advice and did some redesigns to make it come out even better!1872 Imperial Guard Camp Remake by thewatchman - This is a very interesting approach in the remake and I like it! It might seem that there was too much artistic freedom in it, but it just shows how much more is possible with the modern parts when LEGO used to just throw in a few pieces not knowing if it's a rock, a wall or a ruin. The statue is a nice build and because of everything added to it it's instantly recognizable.6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy - Another simple yet very well designed remake of a small classic set that is not on top of everyone's memmory when it comes to classic Pirates. I really like the updated minifig design here using appropriate modern parts for an upgraded feel of that exact minifigure!Fortune Idol by Oky - The best entry of the contest in my opinion! A very nice statue design with a genius functional mechanism for excellent play feature. Just what LEGO is all about. And all thet with the piece count limit - priceless!King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by kritch - This set is very nicely designed and especially unique. Everything from the choice of the vessel it represents to the execution and also the choice of the turtle stands out from every other set! Mini category runners-up: Hidden Cache by LetsBrick - Another great example of a unique build and a nice play feature idea. I can't really put my finger on it, but for the top 5 it just misses some charm? Maybe the minifig is too basic and the setting for presentation is a bit lacking too.Pirate gun cart revisited by Vdog - A very smart remake design of an unusual set using a lot of advice given. If only the unnecessary plates were skipped from the final version with maybe some better or none image editing for presentation ...Treasure Island by Oky - Very visually appealing set on the first glance. On closer inspection the palm tee is not one of my favorite designs and the minifig although great, uses some for Pirates inappropriate parts. Could have also been picked in the top 5, but I wanted to distribute my votes a bit.
Captain Pirate Man Posted September 6, 2023 Posted September 6, 2023 Here is my video on the contest!! Good Luck EVERYONE!!
Edward Kenway Captain Posted September 7, 2023 Posted September 7, 2023 Nice building! 6279 Skull Island Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6254 Rocky Reef by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6246 Crocodile Cage by MyFirstMOC-Hun 6259 Broadside’s Brig by MyFirstMOC-Hun 1873 & 6258 Pirate Treasure & Smuggler's Shanty by MyFirstMOC-Hun
durazno33 Posted September 7, 2023 Posted September 7, 2023 (edited) Here are my picks: Main Category: 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake by Aanchir Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy Rock Island Refuge (Now Finished) by CaptainDarkNStormy Mini Entries Category: Caribbean River Soldiers (Mini Set) by Rogue Redcoat Shipwrecked Survivor (Mini set) by nyugvo6 Shark Cart by TomSkippy Captain's Cabin (Mini set) by MontyMatte 1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake (Mini Set) by Dr3w My Comments Here: SpoilerI put together a couple videos to talk about which sets I liked the most and my process in narrowing down to just 5 per category. Main category: Mini category: Edited September 8, 2023 by durazno33
Aanchir Posted September 8, 2023 Posted September 8, 2023 Wow, what an amazing slate of entries in every category! There are even a few i had missed while the entry period was open, some of which I'll definitely be giving feedback for in their respective topics after I finish submitting this reply. My votes go to: Main Building CategoryThe Lost Lagoon by The Brick StopCaribbean Brig by StoertebrickerCross Bone Clipper Remake UPDATED! by Elephant KnightCaribbean Clipper by TomSkippy6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 Mini Set Building CategoryShipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6Shark Cart by TomSkippy1872 Imperial Guard Camp by ThewatchmanRenegades Raft by Thewatchman6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy
ed4becky Posted September 8, 2023 Posted September 8, 2023 Main Building Category Sin Island by Marooned Marin Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383 Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati Mini Set Building Category Shipwrecked Survivor by Nyugvo6 A Promiscuous Sailor Captain by JopieK 1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy
Marooned Marin Posted September 10, 2023 Posted September 10, 2023 Main Building Category: 6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati 6281 Pirate's Perilous Pitfall Remake 2023 by Slegengr 6254+6258 "Remastered" - Atolls by Amedeo Mini Set Building Category Fortune Idol by Oky Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte Caribbean River Soldiers by Rogue Redocat 6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy 1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn by Elephant Knight
Lyichir Posted September 10, 2023 Posted September 10, 2023 Main Building Category 1. "Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldier's Tavern Remake" by Aanchir 2. "The Lost Lagoon" by The Brick Stop 3. "Enchanted Island Remake" by Danny_Boy4 4. "Pirate's Perilous Pitfall Remake" by Slegengr 5. "Saber Island 2023" by TomSkippy Mini Set Building Category 1. "Fortune Idol" by Oky 2. "Captain's Cabin" by MontyMatte 3. "The Jellyfish Raft" by MarcoLego 4. "Imperial Guard Camp Remake" by thewatchman 5. "Shark Cart" by TomSkippy
hatchpattern Posted September 11, 2023 Posted September 11, 2023 (edited) Excellent Work Everyone; Ya'll are all So Inspiring :) Main Building Category 1. The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop 2. Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati 3. Sin Island by Marooned Marin 4. Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 5. UCS Jolly Roger by me ;p Mini Building Category 1. Shark Cart by TomSkippy 2. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin 3. 6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by HAL-9001 4. Treasure Island by Oky 5. Captains Cabin Mini Set by MonteMatte Edited September 11, 2023 by hatchpattern Names Are Difficult to Type
Recommended Posts