[CONTEST] Infamous Steve - Creative Critic Voting - Closed

[Mister Phes]

Creative Critic Voting

Anyone may Vote for the Creative Critic providing their Eurobricks account meets the requirements.

Here is a list of participating Critics.

To Vote for a Creative Critic create a new post in the Creative Critic Voting topic (when it becomes available) and include:

• The name of critic you're Voting for (just one critic please)
• A minimum of one sentence to explain why you've chose that critic.

For example:

Quote

Creative Critic's name

This critic was immensely helpful and provided many great suggestions for improving the build of the entry, not mention delivering the advice in a polite and entertaining manner.

1 Vote = 1 Point

 

Voting: Creative Critic

A  25€ LEGO Set of your choosing is up for grabs to everyone who Votes for the Creative Critic Winner.

Providing you Vote for another Participant

If you Vote for yourself you will forfeit the Rewards.

Voting will take place between August 18 and August 31.

• Everyone³ who Votes for a Critic receives a Ticket in the draw⁴ to WIN a 25€ LEGO set⁶
  • this includes Creative Critics who Vote for another Critic.
  • if you also Vote for the Building Entries you may receive a maximum of TWO Tickets. 
• Building Entrants who Vote another Creative Critic receive an additional 5 Points¹ towards their Vote Score Total for each Entry they've submitted in the Building Categories.
• Creative Critics who Vote another Creative Critic receive an additional 3 Points² towards their Critic Vote Score Total.

 

1. Creative Critic Voting Rules
2. Building Entrant Voting Rules
3. Voting Requirements
4. Participation Prize Selection: Random Draws
5. Participation Prize Selection: Challenges
6. Prize Rules

Voting Requirements

A Eurobricks account with 10 Posts registered prior to the Commencement of Voting which begins on August 18.

• You meet the General Voting Requirements.
• You agree to the Terms of Conditions of this contest.
• Ensure any LEGO sets you wish to claim as Prizes are available on your local LEGO.com.
  Please ensure you've read and understood the Prize Rules.

Got a question or feedback? 

The Voting Topics will close on August 31.

• If you want to discuss a particular Building Entry please do so in the appropriate Entry Topic.
• Have a question, feedback or a concern regarding the Creative Critic Voting process, please share what's on your mind in the Creative Critic Overview topic...

 

[SevenDeadlyStreamers]

It seems I may be the first to vote in this category? This is honestly a harder decision than the building entrants, everyone has been so helpful and kind. However since I must choose only one, I am voting for @Math Wizard 

This Critic was one of the first to write a comprehensive comment on each of my entries. Compliments were appreciated and criticisms helped me (and my daughter) improve our builds! 

[MrMcGraw]

Ahoy mateys, it was a hard decision, but the one that flashed me most was the MOC of @A_Goodman

 

[NOD]

@Horation

He works day and night. Gives good and detailed suggestions for improvement. Sometimes he writes in the replays a lovely poem.

[BrynnOfCastlegate]

I vote for @Autumn  for providing  consistently concise, helpful and natural feedback.

[Marooned Marin]

@Horation

He was tireless, helpful and nonstop present since day one. Unlike builders voting, I can only nominate one here, but my praise goes to other critiques as well, they were all extremely helpful.

[YellowFrog]

@Horation was omnipresent and had such a quantity helpful posts, like many others. But most of all, the work that went into providing running updates of the Creative Critic standings was unparalleled and greatly added to the competitiveness of the contest.

[Jack Sassy]

Even though during this contest I did not keep a keen eye on critics, one that stood out to me most from all of the talented critics was @Math Wizard with his creative constructive cristicism.  So my vote goes to him. 

[Yatkuu]

+1 for @Horation 

For offering fair and to the point honest feedback in a no-nonsense way.

[Elephant Knight]

@Horation His posts were well thought out, and his advice was worth taking.

EKnight

[Horation]

@YellowFrog, for straight-to-the-point feedback, and for participating in every thread, something which few other critics achieved.

On 8/18/2024 at 2:02 PM, MrMcGraw said:

Ahoy mateys, it was a hard decision, but the one that flashed me most was the MOC of @A_Goodman

This is the wrong voting thread, sir. This isn't the place where you vote for the MOC of the user, but rather for creative critique, if you want to vote for  A_Goodman's excellent MOC, you need to go to the building entries voting thread and select at between 3 and 5 small entries and 3 to 5 large entries, and give both the name of the entry and entrant, otherwise we won't be able to count your vote.

Edited August 20, 2024 by Horation
grammatik

[Autumn]

This is even harder than voting for building entries because I can only vote for one person and I can't go back and review everyone's comments like I can with builds.

But, I think I will go for @Math Wizard for being memorable with the character he injected into his comments.

[bingowaldorf]

I cast my vote for @Math Wizard. I really enjoy the piratey language used in their responses.

[Math Wizard]

A tough choice indeed! I had a ton of fun participating as a critic, and in doing so read a lot of the comments from the other critics. I think the comments that were the most thorough and gave the best advice were those of @Autumn . Congrats, you have my vote!

[SpacePolice89]

I vote for @Horation. His feedback is always constructive and honest.

[Captain Braunsfeld]

My vote goes to @Mazin

for understanding purpose and story of my build. Overall I did not enjoy this "boost for critics"-challenge as most of them kept missing the point of my MOC in a very verbose way...

[Sebeus I]

@Horation For displaying dedication in consistently providing on-subject feedback on many entries.

[Andy-Roo]

My vote goes to @Horation While reading the threads on other entries the feedback was consistently insightful.

[A_Goodman]

@Math Wizard

With an absolutely thorough critique of my and many other's builds, nestled within an enjoyable to read 'criticism sandwich' I felt Captain Crit was an excellent critic in this contest.

[-DoNe-]

@Horation get my vote. He made some great straight-to-the-point suggestions on my build that would have improved the MOC.

[MyFirstMOC-Hun]

@Horation
Because he had quite good insights. Good luck to him in the competition.

Edited August 31, 2024 by MyFirstMOC-Hun

[thewatchman]

I think it has to be @Horation

[Quotenotto]

Horation

He was very helpfull in his suggestions how to take a better picture of my creation. Although I wasn‘t able to use his advice for this contest, I‘m gonna keep it in mind for the future.

[Samarth]

Ahoy there! I held off on casting my vote for creative critic for some clarifications, and then the real world got in the way! This is such a tough call as I can only select one… and it’s a toss up between math wizard and horation… but my vote goes to @Horation in the end… although @Math Wizard deserves an honourable mention!

[CaptainDarkNStormy]

I'm voting for @Math Wizard

He had some thoughtful things to say about my entry and I intend to make some changes to it based on their critique.