Creative Critic

Classic-Pirates runs this challenge to promote good, constructive feedback and discussion about entries.

• What do I do?
  
• First, you need to express an interest in participating, by posting in this thread. You don't have to build anything: just the time and effort required.
  
• Then, evaluate what you like and dislike about a contest entry and relay the information objectively to the builder. The important point is to express honest opinions in a helpful manner, whether good or bad. If you can do that creatively at the same time, you just might have what it takes to win the fabulous prize.
  
• The best Creative Critics will provide ongoing feedback, so it's not necessarily a "critique once and then wait until contest's end to receive your result". Find ways to continually provide feedback and you'll have a definite advantage.
  
• Go the extra mile. Providing reference pictures/links (either Lego or otherwise) as a clarification/explanation would be an example of taking that extra step to help the builder improve their MOC.
  
• A high post count alone will not assist you in winning the Creative Critic award and excessive, short, or unhelpful posts may result in disqualification. If your idea of a good comment is: "That MOC looks awesome", you may find yourself in a spot of bother. Quality first, then quantity.
  How will it be judged?
  The staff will assess the Creative Critic Award on the following criteria:
  
• The usefulness of the information provided.
  
• The professionalism in which the information is conveyed.
  
• Correct spelling, grammar and punctuation (we will be lenient if English is your second language)
  
• The volume of quality creative criticism you provide.
  

Can I put my name down here, even if I'm not sure I'll have the time necessary? I think I will, though I'm unsure.

I shall join

This should prove interesting... You can count me in!

Can I put my name down here, even if I'm not sure I'll have the time necessary? I think I will, though I'm unsure.

Yes, I'm pretty sure you can.

I'm definitely interested, if I can find the time.

Sign me up!

Can I put my name down here, even if I'm not sure I'll have the time necessary? I think I will, though I'm unsure.

Yep, no harm in trying it out.

I'm down!

I'll try.

At the time you read this, I've signed up!

Count me in

I'm in!

Amazing prize - good good job on that (and the entire competition)

Sound's like fun, I'm in it, to win it!

I've already sort of started... I didn't know there was an official entry thing. Anyhow, I'd like to join!

I would join, btw my main language is the portuguese ... since i live in brazil

I will join. Yarr!

*Picks up quill pen, realizes there is no ink, cuts arm, writes name in own blood*

I'm going to try this.

Ok, I express an interest in participating.

Stick my name down, i'll give it a bash.

I'll see what I can do I don't know how much time I will get in the future but if it's enough I will definetely try to give some good feedback.

I'll give it a shot!

I would like to creatively critique.

I'll give it a go.

I seriously need to brush up on my spelling and grammar, so I figure this is a great way to get motivated

Greetings! If it is possible, I would like to join this competition to help people make their future MOCs better by giving them constructive criticism and to grasp a better understanding of competitions held by Classic-Pirates!

Edited September 27, 200915 yr by Bricknave

I'll be a critic

*Gives into Peer Pessure*

I'll give it a whirl.