I think the burning tree might mean that the serial killer is an arsonist, though I'm not really sure how that helps.

Wilkerson, if you are really the vigilante, on what suspicions did you kill Steven Gordon?

Wilkerson, if you are really the vigilante, on what suspicions did you kill Steven Gordon?

Not many people seemed suspicious to me, and I had a gut feeling. Unfortunately, I was wrong.

That's a pretty good summary. Maybe we need to look back and where the previous incorrect accusations have come from and try to look for a pattern.

For easy of reference I've copied down the votes from the town meetings as well as the night deaths. (bold are the ones no longer with us.)

Day 1

Brickme / Susan Webb: 11 (Millacol88, Striker, YG-49, Hewkii9, Dannylonglegs, Jim Butcher, Ricecracker, JCC1004, Sandy, Shadows, Big Cam)

Striker / Lois Jackson: 3 (Zapper brick, Brickme, The Crazy One)

Non-voters: 8 (Quarryman, Simonjedi, , Eskallon, Whitefang, TinyPiesRUs, Inconspicuous, Forresto)

Day 2

Forresto/Leanne: 11 (Hewkii9, Sandy, JimButcher, dannylonglegs, Inconspicuous, YG-49, Shadows, Dragonator, Eskallon, Quarryman)

Millacol88/Mike Johnson: 1 (Simonjedi)

YG-49 / Martin Jackson: 1 (Zapper Brick)

Non-Voters: 9 (Zapper Brick, The Crazy One, Whitefang, Ricecracker, TinyPiesRUs, Millacol88, JCC1004, Forresto)

Day 3

N/A

Day 4

Ryan Alberts / Quarryman: 1 (Sandy)

Matthew Right / Sandy: 9 (Quarryman, Inconspicuous, Zapper Brick, The Crazy One, Big Cam, Ricecracker, Shadows, Dragonator, WhiteFang)

Franklin P. White / Zapper Brick: 1 (Hewkki9)

Dr. Ernie Wilkerson / Ricecracker: 1 (JimButcher)

"Sorry we're late!" said Sarah Wolf / Tiny Pies R Us

Trailing her was John Wilder / Big Cam, and Jimmy Palmer / Simonjedi

"We're here as well." said Rhonda Falzone / Dragonator.

Following her was Robbie Willis / WhiteFang and Dr. Ernie Wilkerson / Ricecracker.

I'm thinking that Sarah Wolf, John Wilder, and Jimmy Palmer are on the same side, as they arrived together. And the same would go for Rhonda, Robbie, and Wilkerson. There should be no doubt that one of these people have to be voted off today. It's just a matter of deciding who is on which side.

Alright, down to business. Mr. Right was innocent, I tried to tell you, but none of you listened. The first vote of the day was from Mr. Right on Ryan, but no one seemed to like that idea. Yes, he did throw votes around a lot, but was Ryan really under pressure? He defended himself voting for her, but she clearly was a townie, so I have no doubt in my mind that Ryan and his goons have taken advantage of your reluctance to follow Mr. Right to sway the vote on yet another townie.

And like I said, it was really obvious that Mr. Right was innocent. If he was a mobster, don't you think he would've kept quiet instead of making himself ridiculously obvious while throwing all those votes around? Wouldn't his fellow mobsters help him out when he was about to die?

Next, the fairly obvious piece of evidence that Sarah so kindly pointed out yesterday, is that Ryan is a drinker, even under these Prohibition laws set by the government. No, it is not water. I have never in my life known someone to carry around a wine glass in the middle of the street filled with water. It is most definitely booze. And then there's the trash can. He carries it everywhere with him, even during the fire just a few moments ago you could see it in his hands. What's he hiding in there? Surely not meaningless trinkets, why would he carry those around with him. Is there a weapon, a gun, perhaps, in there?

And lastly, Ryan has been "following the bandwagons" every day, taking advantage of a townie's mistake, or the lead set by a fellow scum, since every day has been a day where a townie has died. And Ryan knew this. All while flying under the radar.

Due to all of these "pieces of evidence", if that's what you need, I therefore

Vote: Ryan Alberts/ Quarryman

Alright, down to business. Mr. Right was innocent, I tried to tell you, but none of you listened.

None of us? What with the generalization? I held off voting because I had some faith in him. My gut feeling was right. He wasn't scum, but enough of that. Alberts does have a lot against him. Will he let us verify that he isn't drink booze? Perhaps to smell his breath or the glass? What is in the can that he carries around? Lets see if he'll let us throw something away. Also he sleeps on the streets. He'd be easy for the mobsters to kill. Either he's not a threat or one of them. I find it hard to believe that he can sleep through all of this. I'm not voting for now. This is the day this town could be destroyed if we the townies don't make the right decision.

Are we really going to accuse someone because he may or may not drink?

Either he's not a threat or one of them.

I personally do not think he is Mafia. He'd be better off if he was.

Are we really going to accuse someone because he may or may not drink?

I personally do not think he is Mafia. He'd be better off if he was.

The host of this game of life has confirmed that the scum provide the illegal liquor. So anyone drinking is likely associated with the scum.

Are we really going to accuse someone because he may or may not drink?

I personally do not think he is Mafia. He'd be better off if he was.

Thank you, at least someone has the sense to look past the sillyness of my glass and trashcan. You're all welcome to check my glass and the trashcan, any time. We're in serious trouble here people, and voting me off is not the way to solve it, then you'd all be doomed as the scum would outnumber you. Still, I won't make the same mistake as I did yesterday and reply to a vote with a vote, yesterday it cost us the DA, today we could lose the town. So I won't vote for you Lucy, as I sincerely believe you're innocent.

None of us? What with the generalization? I held off voting because I had some faith in him. My gut feeling was right. He wasn't scum, but enough of that. Alberts does have a lot against him. Will he let us verify that he isn't drink booze? Perhaps to smell his breath or the glass? What is in the can that he carries around? Lets see if he'll let us throw something away. Also he sleeps on the streets. He'd be easy for the mobsters to kill. Either he's not a threat or one of them. I find it hard to believe that he can sleep through all of this. I'm not voting for now. This is the day this town could be destroyed if we the townies don't make the right decision.

As much as I'd like to, the parameters of this game... of life do not include "actions" like those in mystery novels of life.

The host of this game of life has confirmed that the scum provide the illegal liquor. So anyone drinking is likely associated with the scum.

Exactly, thanks for pointing that out, Chief.

Thank you, at least someone has the sense to look past the sillyness of my glass and trashcan. You're all welcome to check my glass and the trashcan, any time. We're in serious trouble here people, and voting me off is not the way to solve it, then you'd all be doomed as the scum would outnumber you. Still, I won't make the same mistake as I did yesterday and reply to a vote with a vote, yesterday it cost us the DA, today we could lose the town. So I won't vote for you Lucy, as I sincerely believe you're innocent.

I appreciate your sincerity, but that's thing. Is it reverse psychology? Am I supposed to feel sympathetic towards you since you refuse to vote for me? That's the question I've been asking myself. But after the events of yesterday, I am faced with a tough decision. My vote is subject to change, of course...

The host of this game of life has confirmed that the scum provide the illegal liquor. So anyone drinking is likely associated with the scum.

This does dent Ryan's credibility quite a bit

Vote: Ryan Alberts/ Quarryman

The name of this game ... of life ... is Prohibition, a time without booze. The town has one drunk despite how he wants to claim he's drinking something else (please, we can all see the truth), and he just happens to have been instrumental in the death of the loyal district attorney. He's even gone so far as to privately claim to be the loyal investigator, but mysteriously hasn't found any scum despite how much the town has begged for any help at all. Instead, he's just voted for townies.

Mr. Right was right on this one, I just wish we hadn't been tricked into ignoring it.

Vote: Ryan Alberts / Quarryman

People, you are making the situation worse. This is our last day if we vote wrong, so I must take necessary action.

I am the loyal investigator. Ryan Alberts and I are undercover BOI agents, and we will now try to take the situation into our hands. On Night One, I investigated Ryan back and found the result to be loyal. I am a sane investigator. Last night, I investigated Officer John Wilder and found him to be scum. I had already been suspicious of him, so I trust the results 100%. We must vote John out today. If you vote out Ryan, the town loses.

Right now, the numbers are 6 loyal townies, 6 scumbags, and 2 neutral players to my knowledge. If we vote out John today, we can take one Mafia hit and still have equal numbers and survive another day. Don't lose hope everyone. The scum are beginning to reveal themselves, and if we make the right choices we can get rid of them.

Vote: Officer John Wilder / Big Cam

Please, follow my lead. If you don't, us townies are good as dead.

I've been investigating ryan for a while, and have kept an eye on him, I'm glad the town is finally starting to see what I have suspected for a while, it was an unfirtunate mistake the DA but it did get us the information needed for this convivtion.

Vote: Ryan Alberts / Quarryman

Vote: John Wilder / Big Cam

I am the loyal investigator. Ryan Alberts and I are undercover BOI agents, and we will now try to take the situation into our hands. On Night One, I investigated Ryan back and found the result to be loyal. I am a sane investigator. Last night, I investigated Officer John Wilder and found him to be scum. I had already been suspicious of him, so I trust the results 100%. We must vote John out today. If you vote out Ryan, the town loses.

Right now, the numbers are 6 loyal townies, 6 scumbags, and 2 neutral players to my knowledge. If we vote out John today, we can take one Mafia hit and still have equal numbers and survive another day. Don't lose hope everyone. The scum are beginning to reveal themselves, and if we make the right choices we can get rid of them.

I highly doubt that. Two completely sane investigators who know each other? Yeah, right. It is very clear at this moment that the both of you are scum, pathetically attempting to try to spread confusion. If you really are both sane investigators, why did you both investigate John last night??

None of us? What with the generalization? I held off voting because I had some faith in him. My gut feeling was right. He wasn't scum, but enough of that. Alberts does have a lot against him.

I didn't vote for him either

I don't know what to think now I've suspected you Roy since day 2, I seriously doubt that your a BIO agent, didn't they all die or run away on day 1

and since Alberts just jumped to your side immediately, I think it's safe for me to assume that your both shcum, I don't know... just my thoughts.

I highly doubt that. Two completely sane investigators who know each other? Yeah, right. It is very clear at this moment that the both of you are scum, pathetically attempting to try to spread confusion. If you really are both sane investigators, why did you both investigate John last night??

We didn't. I did. And what my fellow BOI agent there is saying is quite correct, except for the part about him being an investigator, I'm the brains, he's the muscle, or something, but we had agreed that if we had to go out openly with this he would do it because he could take the coming heat at Night better than me. Anyway. This is where it ends it seems, we've all been played for fools.

I do not trust the dual investigator story at all. Alberts is drinking, this is the time of prohibition. He started the bandwagon on the good DA and he has contributed very little in this game of life other than to vote for townies from time to time.

Vote : Ryan Alberts/Quarryman

People, you are making the situation worse. This is our last day if we vote wrong, so I must take necessary action.

I am the loyal investigator. Ryan Alberts and I are undercover BOI agents, and we will now try to take the situation into our hands. On Night One, I investigated Ryan back and found the result to be loyal. I am a sane investigator. Last night, I investigated Officer John Wilder and found him to be scum. I had already been suspicious of him, so I trust the results 100%. We must vote John out today. If you vote out Ryan, the town loses.

Hmm, how do you know you're a sane investigator? Was the third person you investigated yourself? I admit I've found both Ryan and John Wilder suspicious. Don't rule out the possibility Ryan is the mafia godfather though, who is usually immune to investigations. Not to mention that from the information from Day 1 and the "sign-up thread" of life, there seems to be some sort of informant within the BOI.

Until we get a meaningful explanation from him, I'll Vote: Ryan Alberts

The way things are going, there's no hope. Let me try again and explain what's really going on.

Ryan is the real investigator. He investigated me and found loyal. We know he's a sane investigator. On Night Two, he investigated Lucy Gordon and found loyal but corruptible. He contacted her claiming he was the investigator, but she has been corrupted and has now joined the real mob against him. On Night Four, he investigated John, who was scum, and who happened to be investigating me.

I'm sorry for the confusion caused, but Ryan made a mistake in contacting Lucy and now our plan has failed. The way things are going, the town will lose when Ryan is gone. There's no more hope, since the mob has been strong. I still implore you to vote for John Wilder, but with such a lost cause, it's unlikely.

And as a final word before we all die, you played a great game of life, Jimmy Palmer, John Wilder, Lucy Gordon, and the other scum who I suspect are Andrew Gordon, Alfred Winder, and Chris Wilder.

I am the loyal investigator.

Odd considering that he told someone else that he was the loyal investigator. Can't have two loyal investigators, I wouldn't think.

You scum should come up with a story and stick to it or mistakes like that happen. Bad move.

Right now, the numbers are 6 loyal townies, 6 scumbags, and 2 neutral players to my knowledge.

Now there are two neutrals to go with the two loyal investigators? It's just a serial killer and loyal investigator spree around here, isn't it?

Shame neither of you ever managed to find a single scum to identify until AFTER you'd been revealed for the scum that you are. Isn't that a lucky coincidence for you?

The scum are beginning to reveal themselves

Yes you are.

I am the loyal investigator.

Ryan is the real investigator.

Nice little change of story, there. 32 minutes, really impressive.

He investigated me and found loyal. We know he's a sane investigator. On Night Two, he investigated Lucy Gordon and found loyal but corruptible. He contacted her claiming he was the investigator, but she has been corrupted and has now joined the real mob against him.

And, in the magical fairy world you live in, the mafia killer did not decide to target the person who revealed to a member of the mafia that he was the loyal investigator. Of course.

Ryan is the real investigator. He investigated me and found loyal. We know he's a sane investigator.

Then why, oh why did you just say you were the investigator?

On Night Two, he investigated Lucy Gordon and found loyal but corruptible. He contacted her claiming he was the investigator, but she has been corrupted and has now joined the real mob against him.

I'm sorry for the confusion caused, but Ryan made a mistake in contacting Lucy and now our plan has failed. The way things are going, the town will lose when Ryan is gone. There's no more hope, since the mob has been strong. I still implore you to vote for John Wilder, but with such a lost cause, it's unlikely.

Right there. Everyone, remember what he just said. He claims that I am scum now. Really? So that's why I've been so very talkative this game, and that's why I was the only one who defended Mr. Right while I could've easily followed the bandwagon without getting noticed. AND, I was suspicious of Ryan since Day 2.

And please define corruptible. Almost anyone is corruptible in these games... of life. A turner on the scum side chooses someone on the town to turn, and that person turns into scum, and it usually works unless there is a special circumstance.

Vote: Ryan Alberts

Ever since Roy Orborson suddenly decided to start trusting my story, I've been suspicious of him. He changed his mind so fast, that someone must have told him that they should leave me to live. The person who told him was probably his boss, the head of the mafia. Then, once the DA was killed they could place the blame on me, and kill two birds with one stone.

Now, once Ryan has been accused, he has started to furiously defend him, disregarding the fact that in his confusion, he forgot to have his lies make sense.

I have reliable intel that John Wilder is a townie, anyway.