Eskallon Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 That doesn't make grammatical sense, moron. I know what you're getting at though, good job telling everyone. Feel free to vote for me, I don't mind, but you'll only be losing a potentially useful villager. More useful than our illiterate novelist over there. Your loyalty to your staff is... remarkable to say the least, chief. Hmmm, well this is fun, isn't it? More cock, anyone, or is it time for lunch? Well it does because, village is what my role said was my side (can't think of a better word), I assume yours said werewolf so you don't know that. Anyway Adam was always my favourite.
Dragonator Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Yeah but what happens then when he is innocent and a villager dies, that makes two deaths which is still worse than one. Same thing that happens when I'm found innocent, sir.
Rick Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I don't quite understand why you can't vote, but I agree with your logic... Mostly. I don't understand either why I'm not allowed to vote. I do know it's a bloody disgrace though how this town treats a retired admiral. But yes, Daniel, it's time to realize that a conviction will always give us some information. Doing nothing will surely give us nothing.
iamded Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Hmm, it is nearing lunch. Penelope, Fiona, could you clear away the breakfast table and start preparing lunch? I'll give you a hand, I don't want you two overworked. I feel we will have some busy days ahead of us, with all this food preparing and cleaning up after out guests... What for lunch? It seems sausages, wieners, rooster and applesauce are rather popular...
Admiral Ron Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Baron! some mutton would be simply delightful! Some very interesting things have been said these past couple of hours. I am not sure if they can convince me to vote for anyone, but if anyone has anything new, I am all ears.
Shadows Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Why is it Sebastian, Harriet, and Dacius seem to be the only people openly accusing Zed? Harriet really started the campaign against him, Sebastian and Dacius are the only ones to yet vote for him. They seem kind of...eager. I'm not even really accusing, I'm just taking the little indication we have so far to try for something logical. God has threatened us if we fail to vote and I don't really want to piss him off so soon. Like I say, if someone has anything better, please present it, but day 1 is always the same, a guessing game based on appearances. It's just the way it is. I hereby choose to remain impartial on this matter. Oh, you're one of those.
Lord Arjay Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 That doesn't make grammatical sense, moron. I know what you're getting at though, good job telling everyone. I shall not be voting for Zed for now. I contacted him and asked him about that earlier, to which he replied village. I have checked over previous days and at no point do I see this mentioned. Until I can think of a reasonable way for a werewolf to know about this, I shall not be voting. I don't really see why he has so many supporters though, so I think one of them is probably a werewolf and shall be placing my vote there when I have more time.
Dragonator Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I shall not be voting for Zed for now. I contacted him and asked him about that earlier, to which he replied village. I have checked over previous days and at no point do I see this mentioned. Until I can think of a reasonable way for a werewolf to know about this, I shall not be voting. I did the same test with several people as well, Arianna, I certainly wouldn't call it conclusive. You can even ask our dear novelist if you like, he queried me about it too, although I'm not sure how willing he'll be to vouch for me considering the current situation.
Shadows Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 to which he replied village. I have checked over previous days and at no point do I see this mentioned. It's been mentioned, I'm pretty sure I did at least once (which means someone else had first or I wouldn't have said it), and I know that privately it's been discussed so anyone could know that by now. Including you, of course.
Quarryman Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 My oh my you adults are a chatty bunch. Retire to my corner to study for a while and come back to this sort of heated discussion. Anyway, I'd just like to say that not voting is equal to idly standing by doing nothing and letting the werewolves tear us apart one by one. However, I'm not quite ready to vote for anyone in particular just yet, but I'll be sure to do so before the end of the day. Yes, I realize I'm not adding particularly much here, but at the moment I'm afraid I don't have very much to add. I'll pay close attention though.
MagPiesRUs Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I was ever forced to revealing any information to save my megablocks, in a play I wrote, rather, I was killed the very night of it. I refuse to comment either way. I'm dead meat even if I don't get convicted, I'm almost certain the werewolves will target me tonight to make my accusers look all the more guilty. I have given up. Either kill me today and have another villager killed during the night, or save me to be killed during the night and have only one villager killed. If you reveal your role at least there's a chance you'll survive the night. I'm sure we've got someone here who'd be willing to protect you if you do. Besides, you've already revealed too much. If you've been telling us the truth, the scum now know already that you have an important role.
Hinckley Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I know you did, it was the moment you said Zed slipped up for the first time. But he slipped up again by saying the words my husband chose were overly formal. Yes, I'm agreeing with you. I think it's a great point you raise as well. Furthermore, Zed keeps saying that werewolves would be aware of the other factions. I do not believe this is true. I read in one of his books, "The One I Didn't Play But Vaguely Heard About in Passing" that there was a hidden third faction that surprised everybody. There's an odd group of people trying to defend him behind the scenes. I've never seen anything like it and it's not terribly convincing what they're telling me.
Fugazi Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Lunch is almost ready! There's still plenty of cock to be had, but why not leave that for tomorrow? Our guests will likely enjoy some variety: we have Swedish meat balls, turkey breast with grilled nuts, and for desert our mouthwatering spotted dick pudding! Now, for the serious matter at hand... Mr Phillips does not strike me as a killer, and his poorly chosen words may have been just that, a slip-up. Of course, at this stage in the game, we can't expect very strong evidence either way to surface. I doubt that those who are voting for Mr Phillips right now are killers themselves, it would be foolish to precipitate things and attract attention like this from the first day. However, there are many people defending Mr Phillips quite strongly, and they must have a good reason to do so: Mr Phillips must have convinced them of his innocence one way or another. That, of the scum are desperate to save one of their own. Since I'm not party to those back stage exchanges, I will encourage Mr Phillips or his supporters to talk to me -- or better, to all of us. I am not a stubborn woman, if I hear good reasons to change my vote I will. Vote: Zed Phillips (Zepher)
badboytje88 Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Vote: Zed Phillips (Zepher) If Zed reveals his night action and it turns out he's important, I will remove my vote. So if he won't get evicted today, I would suggest that the investigator use their magic on him to try and find out where his loyalty lies.
JimBee Posted February 3, 2011 Author Posted February 3, 2011 What evidence do you think we will get? God has told us we would be punished if we don't vote someone out. Rules: - There may be certain punishments for not reaching a conviction during the day. Said punishments are final, and are to be obeyed.
Alopex Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Vote: Zed Philips (Zepher) Until we find anything better this will be my opinion... And anyway we have to do something even if there's only a chance something bad will happen.
def Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Assuming I understand the rules correctly (and I may not), there will already be a conviction, unless everybody decides to unvote. But if you want to add insult to injury with poor unpublished Zed...
Hinckley Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I shall not be voting for Zed for now. I contacted him and asked him about that earlier, to which he replied village. I have checked over previous days and at no point do I see this mentioned. Until I can think of a reasonable way for a werewolf to know about this, I shall not be voting. Zeb had private conversations with other villagers before that who foolishly revealed to him the nature of their allegiance. It would be very easy for him to have gained that information before you spoke with him. You seem rather crafty to me and I am surprised you couldn't come up with that possibility on your own. I don't really see why he has so many supporters though, so I think one of them is probably a werewolf and shall be placing my vote there when I have more time. You think Zed is innocent but that one of his supporters is a werewolf? Where's the logic in that? My oh my you adults are a chatty bunch. Are you just going to sit around and comment at how much people talk? That's been so helpful in past lives. Aren't you the former life host who thinks that villagers whine for evidence too much and don't try to figure things out on their own? What shall it be Quinn? Shall we not ask for evidence, yet sit here quietly and work things out? How can we do both? I do hope you'll prove helpful in this lifetime.
def Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 You think Zed is innocent but that one of his supporters is a werewolf? Where's the logic in that? A heck of a lot,in my opinion.
Hinckley Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 A heck of a lot,in my opinion. Thank you. That's very clever deduction. I seem to remember that kind of happening to Jesus in a former life... OK, now I find it even more odd that Arianna is defending Zed Phillips, and then accuses Zed's defenders. Silly non-cleavage broad.
Walter Kovacs Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I understand Dacius' zeal in obtaining a conviction. If we do nothing, and the werewolves strike during the night, where does that leave us in the morning? Exactly where we are today, staring at each other with no clue on who to trust or what action to take. That being said, I can't in good conscience vote against Zed today. It sounds to me too much like an honest mistake, and I'd hate to be voted on over an honest mistake. Unfortunately, I don't have another good suspect in mind, either. I seriously doubt Harriet or Dacius are werewolves, unless they feel Zed's slip of the tongue would give them an easy conviction without much fear of reprisals. That doesn't seem to be the case. So for now I will withhold my vote. But I will be following the precedings very carefully.
Sandy Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Vote: Zed Phillips/Zepher Sorry I couldn't do that earlier, I had businesses to run before the sun goes down. Of course I still do not know for sure if Zed is telling the truth or lying his bottom off, but his slip-ups do make it more likely that he is not one of us Villagers.
WhiteFang Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 A lot of surprising revelations has been found in just a day! I find this a surprise as normally we could be scaling towards others who are plain reckless or annoying but to have something derive based on different factions is a surprise. Even though, I know there is a high possibility that the end of the day that we might convict one wrongly to be an innocent party instead but to get things going, we ought to narrow down our lists of suspects. Unfortunately, like what my wife, Angela has voted, I will also follow with the majority's decision into this and pray that we hit the jackpot. Vote: Zed Phillips/Zepher
Lord Arjay Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 It's been mentioned, I'm pretty sure I did at least once (which means someone else had first or I wouldn't have said it), and I know that privately it's been discussed so anyone could know that by now. Including you, of course. This is the earliest public mention of it that I can find: It could very well be a simple mistake, but we cannot afford such mistakes if you are a member of the Village. I am sorry, but this is the best lead so far. By which point Zed had already answered me. If it was mentioned earlier feel free to correct me. I can't comment on any private communications. Zeb had private conversations with other villagers before that who foolishly revealed to him the nature of their allegiance. It would be very easy for him to have gained that information before you spoke with him. You seem rather crafty to me and I am surprised you couldn't come up with that possibility on your own. I guess I didn't take into account the possibility of people acting like idiots. OK, now I find it even more odd that Arianna is defending Zed Phillips, and then accuses Zed's defenders. It's perfectly sensible logic, as Daniel has pointed out. Furthermore I at least have reasoning behind my not voting Zed, regardless of what you think about its validity. The defenders I'm suspicious of are those who are defending with little reason, instead insisting that they don't think voting anyone on the first day is a good idea. Furthermore, Zed keeps saying that werewolves would be aware of the other factions. I do not believe this is true. I read in one of his books, "The One I Didn't Play But Vaguely Heard About in Passing" that there was a hidden third faction that surprised everybody. Did you know that the leader of that fourth faction was based entirely upon me? Except that the fictional character was a man of course. Mr Philips has a suprisingly similar face to him.
Bob Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I'm not entirely sure of Mr. Phillips guilt. I'm just not entirely sure...I don't know. I'll refrain from voting for Mr. Phillips, but it would appear that my vote wouldn't change anything. He's still going to be voted off.
Recommended Posts