Fugazi Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 You mean that despite all of his showing off yesterday, Felix could actually not be the real arsonist? In any case we shall see soon enough whether the wand killer is neutral or scum. Ofcourse the only proof I have to support this theory are the words of Fenix (no idea if he was speaking the truth) and the fact that after we found the supposed arson and lynched him, someone else set a house on fire, which is a fact. The words of Fenix (that's a very appropriate play on words!) are probably the least credible piece of evidence that we ever had!
CorneliusMurdock Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Felix knew that his being revealed as Demon Legion would cause confusion. His words were crafted to cause even more. What would he have had to gain by telling us the truth? Nothing. So I wouldn't even bother looking for any clues in what he said. I'm much more worried that the scum seem to know which townies have powers and are taking them out swiftly. Let's talk about that while we wait to condemn Sheldon.
Scouty Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 While Sheldon confessed to being a psycho gunman, or at least possession of a wand., something does not add up. From what I see in today's morning events, Benji attacked Sheldon, as Booker revealed, but I don't see where it says Sheldon, or rather Benji's target, attacked back. It merely dictates that the target was lucky, but Benji was not. Benji looked his killer, not "his target", in the eye, so I cannot be sure that these are related. From today's events, I can't see how we can confirm Sheldon was the one who killed Brigit and Benji. Am I mistaken here? Is there more information from behind the scenes that I'm not aware of that can make the connection? I cannot vote unless I'm sure...
Professor Flitwick Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Glad to see we landed another Legionnaire, but at the loss of Benji and Pennie. I think the latest lead of Sheldon sounds promising, especially with the evil-wand colouring coming into place. So we missed the arsonist? Not necessarily; the Demon Legion could kill via the fires, and thus the role of arsonist could be being passed on. Not only that, but the two convicted Legionaires (felix and Lauren) have both used torches to try and defend themselves as they were marched towards the gallows. I guess we won't know till the conclusion nightmare is over... So Benji was the brown wand killer... He's the one who killed Felix & Wendell... Will his wand be passed on? Actually, it appeared that Wendell died whilst trying to revive Booker. I believe it was the cost of his action.
Scouty Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Not necessarily; the Demon Legion could kill via the fires, and thus the role of arsonist could be being passed on. Not only that, but the two convicted Legionaires (felix and Lauren) have both used torches to try and defend themselves as they were marched towards the gallows. I guess we won't know till the conclusion nightmare is over... Possible, but they might just be for comedic effect, as well. As we all know, there is no distinction between what is a clue and what is a joke, now, so I can only take what happens at the end of the day with a grain of salt. Actually, it appeared that Wendell died whilst trying to revive Booker. I believe it was the cost of his action. But then Benji came and zapped an already dead Wendell.
Professor Flitwick Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 But then Benji came and zapped an already dead Wendell. Whoops, I must've just assumed that was Gods way of saying 'This Character is dead' in picture form. Sorry!
Fugazi Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Am I mistaken here? Is there more information from behind the scenes that I'm not aware of that can make the connection? There was the part about Sheldon seen targeting Benji during the night. I presume that no one else was seen targeting Benji at the same time.
Lord Arjay Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Oh dear. It is very sad that more of us have died, poor Benji and Pennie - they did not deserve such a cruel fate. The fact that they had important abilities is very worrying. On a much lighter note, Felix has died and was scum - although I did expect these fires to die with him. I suppose it may be that Demon Legion are actually killing people using fire, as others have suggested before me. That's the most pausible explanation at least. I cannot vote unless I'm sure... This is a change from previously. The crow has yet again failed to show up, however I maintain my opinion that if Horace was scum then I cannot see the motivation behind claiming like that. Still, I'm no longer as sure as before. Gabby remains unhelpful and suspicious to me. Sheldon's claim of being a paraniod wand owner is quite clearly a lie and he rather obviously doesn't have honest intentions, so I predict that todays vote should be easy enough.
Scouty Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 On a much lighter note, Felix has died and was scum - although I did expect these fires to die with him. I suppose it may be that Demon Legion are actually killing people using fire, as others have suggested before me. That's the most pausible explanation at least. That's what I'm thinking. This is a change from previously. Is it? I didn't vote the first day (everybody withdrew their votes), the second day we voted for Bristol because we didn't want another non-conviction, day three I was late to the voting party and Lauren was already convicted, so I showed my support for the conviction, and yesterday Felix confessed, so that was good reason. Today has just started, so I don't want to be hasty. I don't want to be a stupid sheep following la-di-da-di-da. Somebody has to be the devil's advocate . Poor choice of words in our situation, but you know what I mean. We're all-stars cute, furry animals, we're better than that. We have 72 hours to discuss stuff, what's the hurry? Yesterday we wanted extra time to talk, and all there was, really, was just a dabble. Am I not right? Looking back at today's events, I remember Booker mentioning that he was informed that Sheldon did in fact target Benji... Well, that's that, provided his sources are trustworthy. Moving on. While I was reviewing today's events, I suddenly realized something. Can anyone spot the differences between these two photographs? Is Helen having trouble getting out of bed?
badboytje88 Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Helen indeed appears to be late to the party... Same thing happened to one of the bunnies (sandy) Or maybe she has been kidnapped, petnapped, hipponapped?
Ricecracker Posted March 23, 2011 Posted March 23, 2011 Hmm, I thought Felix was definitely the arsonist. Perhaps, like it was suggested, fire is the Demon Legion's weapon of choice? Edgar, are you positive that the arsonist is neutral?
WhiteFang Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 Edgar, are you positive that the arsonist is neutral? Yes, unless you tell me that arsonist or serial killer (mafia terms) can be classified under the act/role of scum. I suspect that the powers of the arsonist could be Felix initally, but ultimately converted to demon, resulting his arsonist power being transfered to the demons to keep the flame going, despite Felix's conviction. Unless, otherwise we could assume too much of what Felix had said earlier and gave us the assumption that he was an arsonist to confuse our minds further. However, I could probably going for the first assumption.
Scouty Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 Hmm, I thought Felix was definitely the arsonist. Perhaps, like it was suggested, fire is the Demon Legion's weapon of choice? Edgar, are you positive that the arsonist is neutral? I don't see how this all adds up. Not that you're wrong, but it doesn't quite fit. So, Felix had fire, he had the kerosene can. This mysterious creature today had a kerosene can too, no doubt with evil intentions. It can't have been transferred from Felix to a DL because Felix's skeleton ran off with the kerosene can. Maybe I'm reading it too literally? I doubt that the arsonist allied himself with the DL, unless the DL were actively seeking the arsonist. Even that seems unlikely as post mailing everybody saying "Are you the arsonist? We're the scum team. Wanna join? We've got cookies" would be pretty stupid. So this leaves Felix playing with fire (or, as far as we know is part of the Demon Legion) and a mysterious creature playing with fire. It seems most likely to me that the arsonist is still out there and Felix was just a DL chess piece that had the ability of fire, or something. Make sense? Felix being Felix, I don't really trust much of what he says said.
Hinckley Posted March 24, 2011 Author Posted March 24, 2011 You may now vote. You have 48 hours to reach a conviction. With 16 players left, it takes 9 votes to lynch. The frog says: The Riddle of Superstitious King Lazlo LionKing Lazlo Lion was incredibly superstitious. He build his castle with no corners so no ghosts could get trapped. He made sure none of the measurements were multiples of 13. He banned ladders from the premises and didn't allow anyone to keep black cats as pets. One day he hired Benji Bulldog as his night watchman. King Lazlo Lion had a large stock of gold to protect and it was Benji's job to keep watch over it at night. Benji Bulldog was oblivious to superstition. It drove King Lazlo Lion nuts! One morning, King Lazlo greeted Benji Bulldog and noticed Benji had spilled salt and not bothered to throw any over his left shoulder! Another morning, King Lazlo found Benji playing under a ladder with a black cat! The nerve! Why, he should have the bulldog beheaded for this! On yet another morning, Benji Bulldog said to King Lazlo, "Last night I dreamed that all of your gold was stolen!" Well, that was the last straw! King Lazlo could take no more. King Lazlo Lion had Benji Bulldog beheaded. Why did King Lazlo have Benji Bulldog beheaded? Use your role PM to answer the frog and you will be able to speak with him.
Dragonator Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 The polls are open, and as I am confident in the information I have, as well as the clear indication in the opening post of the colour of the wand and the way it relates to the previous wand killer, I will vote: Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman). Personally, I think this is the most conclusive lead we have right now.
Fugazi Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 Looks like the village has gone silent... Vote: Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman)
I Scream Clone Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 I also agree on the facts and news I have heard in regards to Sheldon. He seems scummy to me and his story doesn't really ring true. Hopefully the roll continues for us townies. Vote: Sheldon/Quarryman
Ricecracker Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 I trust booker, and he hasn't been wrong yet. Therefore, I will: Vote: Sheldon (Quarryman)
Rick Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 It's the clearest lead we have. The MO (blown to pieces) is the same as the wand killer that killed Brigit, which clearly was not an act of self-defense (paranoid wand owner) as no one was seen targeting Brigit. And Sheldon so far hasn't come up with a plausible explanation for this... Vote: Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman)
CorneliusMurdock Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 I will also Vote Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman). Your defense was pitiful at best. Hopefully we'll know more about what's really going on with the demon worshippers once we know what your allegiance is.
WhiteFang Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 As of now, I believe this is the best conclusive lead we got and hope to avenge our dear Benji... I will follow the rest in this vote too. Vote: Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman)
Inconspicuous Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 I trust Booker at this point, and the whole paranoid wand owner thing sounded fake. Vote: Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman)
Scouty Posted March 24, 2011 Posted March 24, 2011 Well, Sheldon, it's too bad you can't tell the truth. Vote: Sheldon Sheepdog (Quarryman)
Recommended Posts