Palathadric Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 At least Guts is up front about his baldness. There is a reason some of us prefer fighting from the back row. Quote
Brickdoctor Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 I'd always imagined that without the hood, Boomingham looked like a bearded Grand Moff Tarkin. Quote
Scubacarrot Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Random question of an unspecified time period! Actually, two questions. If all Heroes were to fight each other, one on one, who would win. In roleplaying terms? And in actual game terms (not arena rules)? I think in roleplaying, I would consider Tesni to be the hero that is the strongest in terms of fighting right now. As for gameplay wise, I would say Nyx, Dyric or Skrall would have good chances to win. Quote
Palathadric Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 (edited) Monk Pretzel rulez all! Why is Arthur so convinced one of the veterans is working with the Wolfgang? It's scummy scumsters that told him that, and they may have been lying to try to lure him to their side. Well, I guess it's better to be safe. Edited May 30, 2013 by Palathadric Quote
Brickdoctor Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Assuming he can stick around long enough to wait until only the Assassins are left, Docken could do quite well. Otherwise I think he'd finish somewhere around last. Doesn't roleplay, and regular game rules have heroes being much more powerful than enemies on offense and much weaker than enemies on defense. Quote
Palathadric Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Random question of an unspecified time period! Actually, two questions. If all Heroes were to fight each other, one on one, who would win. In roleplaying terms? And in actual game terms (not arena rules)? I think even a relatively low-leveled hero could beat a veteran, it just depends on who attacks first, if you're not using the arena rules. Quote
Zepher Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Random question of an unspecified time period! Actually, two questions. If all Heroes were to fight each other, one on one, who would win. In roleplaying terms? And in actual game terms (not arena rules)? I think in roleplaying, I would consider Tesni to be the hero that is the strongest in terms of fighting right now. As for gameplay wise, I would say Nyx, Dyric or Skrall would have good chances to win. Well, it also depends on a few other things. Is it tournament style, or like, fighting pit style? Aka, are they all one on one bracketed, or are they all dropped in a pit and told to fight to the death? Because the second one would also consider which hero has the most friends, and who would die for who, etc. Furthermore, in the RP version, would their willingness to fight be considered? I think Arthur faced with killing a hero might not be able to do it, whereas Althior, Atramor, Hybros or Sylph might be more than willing to kill another hero. Quote
Capt.JohnPaul Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Yes my Allanoid! Atta boy! Go get 'em! :moar: Daddy's watching! Quote
Scubacarrot Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Let's assume every hero would be willing to fight everyone else and every hero had to fight every other hero, most victories win. Quote
Palathadric Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Benji vs. Left Leg> Damage Critical Hit (15x2=30+30=60+3=63x2=126x2=252 x2 =504 damage! no instakill) Benji vs. Right Leg> Critical Hit Miss (15x2=30+30=60+3=63x2=126x2=252 x2 =504 damage! no instakill) Quiver of Poisoning (permanent Poisoned effect; backwear), [borrowed from Flare] Umm...what's the meaning of this? Quote
Shoker86 Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Alexander, having nothing to say, follow the rest of the party through the dark door, not before he embraced his bow more firmly. The Dark Side is felt Thalion, the power of the Dark Side Tomorrow I will at Bruce Springsteen's concert, therefore I will return saturday afternoon, Obelix to you the command. I want to go to the Boss concert, you're lucky man. Have a good time http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0t2TdQ-d5OA Quote
Brickdoctor Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Let's assume every hero would be willing to fight everyone else and every hero had to fight every other hero, most victories win. Going through the Statistics topic, I see a lot of lower-Level heroes that were they enemies I would feel confident calling a victory for Docken. Problem is that being heroes, because of the way the rules of Damage calculations are set up, they could go either way. Some of the heroes ten Levels lower have higher WP than I do. And then there are the heroes who are totally unfair to face in 1-on-1 hero vs. hero battle, like Atramor, whose Pheles Rod has no downsides in such a situation. Conclusion: Docken is not built for hero vs. hero combat. Quote
Flipz Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Well, in RP terms I imagine Arthur as rather hard to hit--he'd generally fight with Calibor's staff and the Cloak of Deception on at all times, and since it'd be an RP-only fight he'd wear the Jester's Hat too just to make it even harder for someone to hit him. Why is Arthur so convinced one of the veterans is working with the Wolfgang? It's scummy scumsters that told him that, and they may have been lying to try to lure him to their side. Well, I guess it's better to be safe. Simple: because they weren't supposed to let him know that. Did you see how quickly Violetta shushed Donny? Dead giveaway that that was the truth. "You three have proven to be strong and capable, and the Wolfgang would be proud to have you as our allies. Trust us, you wouldn't be the first ones in your organization to gain our trust... We have even bonded with one of your Veterans, hehe." "Donny, watch your mouth! These people aren't on our side yet. What do you say? Money, fame and fortune with the Wolfgang, would that sound like a bad future to you guys?" Quote
Dannylonglegs Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 (edited) Random question of an unspecified time period! Actually, two questions. If all Heroes were to fight each other, one on one, who would win. In roleplaying terms? And in actual game terms (not arena rules)? I think in roleplaying, I would consider Tesni to be the hero that is the strongest in terms of fighting right now. As for gameplay wise, I would say Nyx, Dyric or Skrall would have good chances to win. Well, it'd be a hero capable of casting scrolls, I think. The scroll casters and those immune to blind would be left at the end, because blind is one of the best tools against a hero, as I myself demonstrated. Those who have better chances to blind, like Arthur, would likely do the best. I really want Arthur's goggles. I Can haz? Well, it also depends on a few other things. Is it tournament style, or like, fighting pit style? Aka, are they all one on one bracketed, or are they all dropped in a pit and told to fight to the death? Because the second one would also consider which hero has the most friends, and who would die for who, etc. Furthermore, in the RP version, would their willingness to fight be considered? I think Arthur faced with killing a hero might not be able to do it, whereas Althior, Atramor, Hybros or Sylph might be more than willing to kill another hero. Yes, if it's not obvious, Sylph would kill another Hero. He sees himself as a causer of great good, and therefor, it would be a great evil to let himself die. He doesn't like killing, but he justifies it to the point that he doesn't hesitate to kill. ~Insectoid Aristocrat Edited May 30, 2013 by Dannylonglegs Quote
Palathadric Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Simple: because they weren't supposed to let him know that. Did you see how quickly Violetta shushed Donny? Dead giveaway that that was the truth. Bah! They're just good actors and fooled Arthur. Quote
Flipz Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Well, it also depends on a few other things. Is it tournament style, or like, fighting pit style? Aka, are they all one on one bracketed, or are they all dropped in a pit and told to fight to the death? Because the second one would also consider which hero has the most friends, and who would die for who, etc. Furthermore, in the RP version, would their willingness to fight be considered? I think Arthur faced with killing a hero might not be able to do it, whereas Althior, Atramor, Hybros or Sylph might be more than willing to kill another hero. You know, sometimes I wonder how different Quests might have gone differently with different parties. Like if Nur had gone on Quest 7, or Cronk on 48. Quote
Palathadric Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 I doubt Cronk going on 48 would have made a huge difference. Quote
Scorpiox Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Yes my Allanoid! Atta boy! Go get 'em! :moar: Daddy's watching! Argh, I'm going to get that beast if it takes my last breath! You know, sometimes I wonder how different Quests might have gone differently with different parties. Like if Nur had gone on Quest 7, or Cronk on 48. I don't, to be honest. Although the QM has their stories planned out, the real events are written as they take place, on the day. The heroes make the quest, after all. Quote
Flipz Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Knowing who Sylph is and Cronk's general demeanor...I disagree. I don't, to be honest. Although the QM has their stories planned out, the real events are written as they take place, on the day. The heroes make the quest, after all. But that's exactly it--with a different party, the story might take a completely different direction. What would Heroica have been like if three more loyal Heroes had gone on Quest 6 and killed Donny? Or if a more competent Mage had helped Violetta escape, or if a different group of Heroes had decided to side with Reno instead of Nemo? I like thinking about what might have been... Quote
Brickdoctor Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 But that's exactly it--with a different party, the story might take a completely different direction. What would Heroica have been like if three more loyal Heroes had gone on Quest 6 and killed Donny? Or if a more competent Mage had helped Violetta escape, or if a different group of Heroes had decided to side with Reno instead of Nemo? I like thinking about what might have been... Yeah, if Docken had been Party Leader for Quest 6, Donny would've been killed then. (Assuming Sandy let him be killed.) Quote
Cutcobra Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 "Dammit! Jeaux, hold yourself, no man is getting left behind. No man, or no thing? . Quote
Endgame Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Perhaps it'd be worth mentioning to the houses to stop worshipping wolf idols if they feel compelled to? Quote
Brickdoctor Posted May 30, 2013 Posted May 30, 2013 Soothing Slippers - (Suitable for ether uses, Meditate restores 5 ether, footwear). Cronk needs those. Not only because he always seems to roll Meditate, but because they'd go perfectly with the Fluffy Pillow he already has. (roleplaying-wise, not mechanically) Quote
JimBee Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Random question of an unspecified time period! Actually, two questions. If all Heroes were to fight each other, one on one, who would win. In roleplaying terms? And in actual game terms (not arena rules)? I think in roleplaying, I would consider Tesni to be the hero that is the strongest in terms of fighting right now. As for gameplay wise, I would say Nyx, Dyric or Skrall would have good chances to win. I would actually say Hybros could win against Dyric: permanently hastened, pseudo-perma-lucky, actually more lucky, and immune to more things. Plus, Hybros has the Bladerang which he could demolish a good amount of heroes with. And although immune to all elements, Hybros would be weak to the likes of hard hitters like Skrall and Guts. So I would say Docken, Guts, Hybros, Tesni, Nagure, and Skrall would be the ones to win gameplay-wise. As for RP-wise, Guts is getting old it seems, so I would agree on Tesni. Nagure, Skrall, or even Thothwick might be good candidates as well. And strong with ether are Cinna, Nyx, and Arthur. Well, it also depends on a few other things. Is it tournament style, or like, fighting pit style? Aka, are they all one on one bracketed, or are they all dropped in a pit and told to fight to the death? . Hmm, sounds like a good quest idea. Oh wait. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.