Capt. Redblade Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Yeah her move was pretty bold, but at the moment it doesn't help us decide who we should vote for. I think we are all in agreement that we must vote for someone, and to get the ball rolling, I'd like to point out that Ra's al Ghul doesn't appear to have said a single word since we got here. Make of that what you will, ladies and gents.
Brickdoctor Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 So whats the dolls angle? Could she be telling the truth or a childish fib. I was under the impression that it was already established that there really is no reason for her to lie about this at this time. The only way I can think of that it would benefit her if she was lying is if she's a Jester. I think we are all in agreement that we must vote for someone, and to get the ball rolling, I'd like to point out that Ra's al Ghul doesn't appear to have said a single word since we got here. Make of that what you will, ladies and gents. It hasn't even been half a Day. I wouldn't think too much of it. (yet)
Peanuts Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 To be honest fellow criminals, I don't know what to make of the dolls insight. I've never heard of a host being able to confirm allegiance without... a lobotomy. I'm not sure either, but I'm inclined to believe her. I'm assume she'd be too scared of being killed for lying a lie that can be proven wrong so easily. But we'll learn if she told the truth tomorrow anyway.
Professor Flitwick Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 To be honest fellow criminals, I don't know what to make of the dolls insight. I've never heard of a host being able to confirm allegiance without... a lobotomy. So whats the dolls angle? Could she be telling the truth or a childish fib. Something is making her act the way she does, something thats giving her an edge, or a reason to have the conclousions that she has presented. May I ask Babydoll, does this identity confirmation have anything to do with your skill or action? Assuming there all unique, it seems logical that her identity is related to her ability. Well, ask you've previously told me, these situations vary from each other. I'm sure peoples abilities can too. Whether she's tellin' a lie, or tellin' da truth, well find out in da mornin'. If either Pengy, or da Joka, confirm Dolly's story, den we'll know fo' sure if we can trust her. An rememba, if she is lyin' it's gonna be a short lived lie, 'cause if they don't confrim her story, den she'd be a prime suspect!
Nightshroud99 Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I think we are all in agreement that we must vote for someone, and to get the ball rolling, I'd like to point out that Ra's al Ghul doesn't appear to have said a single word since we got here. Make of that what you will, ladies and gents. Maybe he's taking a bath in his lazarus pit All jokes aside, your right he hasn't shown up and a quick Google search revealed that those in these types of situations who don't talk, often get axed.
Bob Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Unless I'm mistaken, I do believe we've reached the time where we can now vote. Let us all think carefully before we cast our votes.
Tamamono Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 To be honest fellow criminals, I don't know what to make of the dolls insight. I've never heard of a host being able to confirm allegiance without... a lobotomy. So whats the dolls angle? Could she be telling the truth or a childish fib. Something is making her act the way she does, something thats giving her an edge, or a reason to have the conclousions that she has presented. May I ask Babydoll, does this identity confirmation have anything to do with your skill or action? Assuming there all unique, it seems logical that her identity is related to her ability. Honestly, no scum would try something like that this early in the game. It's probably in her role: Innocent Child or Tree Stump. I think we are all in agreement that we must vote for someone, and to get the ball rolling, I'd like to point out that Ra's al Ghul doesn't appear to have said a single word since we got here. Make of that what you will, ladies and gents. That's true, but as Mask said, it's early days yet. Unless I'm mistaken, I do believe we've reached the time where we can now vote. Let us all think carefully before we cast our votes. Yes, it is. Does anyone have any suggestions?
Peanuts Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Maybe he's taking a bath in his lazarus pit All jokes aside, your right he hasn't shown up and a quick Google search revealed that those in these types of situations who don't talk, often get axed. Maybe he hasn't had time to reply yet? As Mask has pointed out, we weren't here for that long right now. Yet I think it's a good idea to keep an eye on the silent ones, though the paper I read suggested that successful scum tries to be neither too silent nor too active. But let's not panic and overinterprete putative scumtells right now, that's the worst thing we can do on day 1.
Professor Flitwick Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I think we are all in agreement that we must vote for someone, and to get the ball rolling, I'd like to point out that Ra's al Ghul doesn't appear to have said a single word since we got here. It hasn't even been half a Day. I wouldn't think too much of it. (yet) That's true, but as Mask said, it's early days yet. I would just like to point out, that if Ra's doesn't turn up to say anything soon, he may not at all. If he doesn't turn up to talk, he can't vote- Meanin' he's gonna get a five vote penalty. Dis might be a good of a reason as any ta vote fo' him. Yes, sir, I was getting to that, sir.
CMP Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I would just like to point out, that if Ra's doesn't turn up to say anything soon, he may not at all. If he doesn't turn up to talk, he can't vote- Meanin' he's gonna get a five vote penalty. Dis might be a good of a reason as any ta vote fo' him. Yes, sir, I was getting to that, sir. A good a plan as any we can come up with today, it seems...I'd still like to wait a few hours, though.
Professor Flitwick Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 A good a plan as any we can come up with today, it seems...I'd still like to wait a few hours, though. I'm only calling it out as a possibility. If we're gonna do dat, den we gotta give Ra's a chance ta speak up first. I'd say, not until at least half of the allotted voting time has past. Wouldn't you agree, sir?
Masked Builder Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 We haven't heard from Quinn in a while either, though she has spoken once.
Brickdoctor Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Wait, what? You think a 5-vote penalty against Ra's might be a reason to vote for him, but you don't want to vote for him until he speaks up? If he speaks up, chances are he'll vote, and won't get the 5-vote penalty.
Tamamono Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I would just like to point out, that if Ra's doesn't turn up to say anything soon, he may not at all. If he doesn't turn up to talk, he can't vote- Meanin' he's gonna get a five vote penalty. Dis might be a good of a reason as any ta vote fo' him. Yes, sir, I was getting to that, sir. I think he'll get five penalty votes tomorrow, not today. A good a plan as any we can come up with today, it seems...I'd still like to wait a few hours, though. Wait, so you're willing to convict someone just because he hasn't spoken yet? How many times do I have to say it, we need to actually use our heads if we want to find an agent today!
CMP Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Wait, what? You think a 5-vote penalty against Ra's might be a reason to vote for him, but you don't want to vote for him until he speaks up? If he speaks up, chances are he'll vote, and won't get the 5-vote penalty. I'd rather not lynch an active player. If he's going to get a 5-vote penalty and get killed anyway, why not just put votes on him so the same doesn't happen to the rest of us?
Professor Flitwick Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Wait, what? You think a 5-vote penalty against Ra's might be a reason to vote for him, but you don't want to vote for him until he speaks up? If he speaks up, chances are he'll vote, and won't get the 5-vote penalty. Yes, if we go on with original five votes, it would make more sense then voting somebody out at random. I wuz sayin', dat if we are gonna vote fo' Ra's (cause he's already got the penalty against him), then we'd better wait and give him time ta turn up an' speak/vote. If he does speak up, then we'd know that we shouldn't vote for him. Yah gettin' dis now?
K-Nut Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 You've actually got a point there! I'll wait until closer to the end of the day to vote. Now where's that bar that Pengy talked 'bout?
Brickdoctor Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I get what you're saying. I still don't think not speaking is enough to lynch someone on, and there are plenty of things in real life other priorities that could be preventing him from speaking, and we don't know much about him, either. But seeing as this is Day 1 and we might not know much else, then maybe it's a possibility.
Nightshroud99 Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 But let's not panic and overinterprete putative scumtells right now, that's the worst thing we can do on day 1. True I'd rather not lynch an active player. If he's going to get a 5-vote penalty and get killed anyway, why not just put votes on him so the same doesn't happen to the rest of us? Same here, if someone is active and helping out, it's kind of dumb to vote them out. It's also kind of a waste.
Tamamono Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I'd rather not lynch an active player. If he's going to get a 5-vote penalty and get killed anyway, why not just put votes on him so the same doesn't happen to the rest of us? You've got a point. I suppose if the day goes on long enough without any other options, we could just vote out Ra's. Yes, if we go on with original five votes, it would make more sense then voting somebody out at random. I wuz sayin', dat if we are gonna vote fo' Ra's (cause he's already got the penalty against him), then we'd better wait and give him time ta turn up an' speak/vote. If he does speak up, then we'd know that we shouldn't vote for him. Yah gettin' dis now? Like I said earlier, he won't get the penalty votes until Day 2. Technically, one has until the very last minute to place a vote (or until a conviction is reached and the thread is locked everyone goes to bed), so it wouldn't make sense for him to be punished for not voting until the next day.
ADHO15 Posted November 11, 2011 Author Posted November 11, 2011 I'm terribly sorry, my friends! I was having far too much fun with Bats down at the town hall and completely lost track of time! I'll just confirm that voting has now begun and there are just under 48 hours left in the day. I'm sure you have lots to discuss so I'll leave you to it. Oh Pengy! Where are you?...
CMP Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I'm terribly sorry, my friends! I was having far too much fun with Bats down at the town hall and completely lost track of time! Ooooh! Did he mention me? Is he angry about that scar I gave him last week?
Peanuts Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 I get what you're saying. I still don't think not speaking is enough to lynch someone on, and there are plenty of things in real life other priorities that could be preventing him from speaking I agree with that. And while we're talking about priorities, I haven't even maintained my journal today. Also, we shouldn't forget Ras isn't the only one to be silent. The Mad Hatter also has spoken up only once, without adding any substance to anything. Private Notes of Dr. Jonathan Crane, Day 1:We were today finally told what the big plan was, we're obviously heisting a nuclear weapon from the military base. I'm not sure what to make out of this plan, on teh one hand it sounds crazy, on the other hand it could provide me enough money to finance my studies forever. Oh, and we've started to look for the rats among us. With my knowledge of psychology it won't take long to find them, I'm sure about that. If those other idiots wouldn't be in my way! Some of them are really trying to do a "slightly-educated-guess", as they call it. Yet I'm sure the scum is already scared shitless of me. Need to find a better term, "shitless" doesn't sound very scientifical. Baby Doll has claimed to be proven town by tomorrow, I'm curious if that's true. I'd be surprised if it wasn't though. I'm terribly sorry, my friends! I was having far too much fun with Bats down at the town hall and completely lost track of time! I'll just confirm that voting has now begun and there are just under 48 hours left in the day. I'm sure you have lots to discuss so I'll leave you to it. Oh Pengy! Where are you?... Joker, how nice you turned up. There's a question I have to ask you, what exactly happens if we're tied below the 50% mark? Will there still be a conviction? And I hope you've left me enough Bats for the next time I meet him.
Brickdoctor Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Also, we shouldn't forget Ras isn't the only one to be silent. The Mad Hatter also has spoken up only once, without adding any substance to anything. Though reading about experiences of characters very similar to myself with characters similar to the Mad Hatter has taught me that he does that a lot.
def Posted November 11, 2011 Posted November 11, 2011 Maybe he hasn't had time to reply yet? As Mask has pointed out, we weren't here for that long right now. Yet I think it's a good idea to keep an eye on the silent ones, though the paper I read suggested that successful scum tries to be neither too silent nor too active. But let's not panic and overinterprete putative scumtells right now, that's the worst thing we can do on day 1. Normally, I think that's the way to go, but with the cowardly crew we assembled here, I have a feeling at least some of the scum agents will try to do the under the radar thing. Furthermore, I think waiting to vote is far more dangerous. We have (less than) 48 hours to vote, and if we leave it to the end, we can't let the potential lynchee defend themselves, and we can't unvote, since it will be too late. This is just an informal list of the people who I think were either not speaking much, or not saying much when they did speak. (Please keep in mind that this is only my second opportunity to speak, and that I had to just peruse what everyone said, and may have missed some details.) Clayface/WhiteFang Deadshot/Rumble Strike Harley Quinn/Alopex Hush/Mrlegoninja Killer Croc/JediAnakin Man-Bat/Sirius Black Mr Freeze/Oky Mr Zsasz/Nightshroud99 Ra’s Al Ghul/Fred Fred Burger Simon The Pieman/ Scorpiox The Mad Hatter/Jedi master Brick Two-Face/K-nut In the interest of getting people to vote early, so we can actually see things, I do this: Vote: Killer Croc(JediAnakin) Nothing person, Greenie, just trying to feel the water
Recommended Posts