Sirius Black Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 I think that our friend the Ventriloquist is our Scum agent. I am the Doctor regardless of what Doll says. In fact, she might be scum for disbelieving me. Riiigghht. Of course Doll must be scum since she doesn't believe your role-claim, even though she has been established as a criminal. Either you or the Ventriloquist is lying in your role-claim, or possibly both, and at this point, you seem the least trustworthy.
Peanuts Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 What do you mean, "it doesn't make sense"? It took me all of ten seconds' thinking to reach the conclusion that it was likely it was a serial killer kill. It makes perfect sense if it was an SK kill. The Riddler claimed Investigator, the SK doesn't want to be found out, so he tries to kill him. The scum don't want to waste a kill, but they don't want to be found out, so they block him. The Doctor doesn't want to lose him, so he protects him. Not only does it make perfect sense, but it means that everyone involved did what was probably the best thing for them to do for them to win. Know your facts and do some thinking before you jump to agree with your accusers. Do you really think the SK would target someone who is propably to be protected and propably to be scumkilled at once? It's a fairly small chance the Riddler would be neither, and both cases would mean a wasted night action. If I was an SK, I'd try to kill people who are less likely to be protected or killed, and leave the known investigator to the agents to care for him. I feel the Ventriloquist is a Undercover Agent, but Bane is also acting suspicious. However we can only lynch one. Personally I think Ventriloquist and it seems so do others. Lets make a list of what roles have been claimed/thought so far: Doctor/Protector Blocker Vigilante Thief (The Late Catwoman) Conversion Janitor Investigator Bus Driver Scum Kill Action I believe this is the list. I hope I haven't missed any. I think the 3 most likely for conversion are: Baby Doll, Creeper and Riddler. Mind Games again! Now look who's speaking up in favor of Bane (yes, not actually in favor of Bane, but a conviction of the Ventriloquist would help Bane a lot though). And thereby looking to be helpful, bringing up some list of claimed night actions, which doesn't help the town one bit. Honestly, I will rather believe Fliwtick to be the busdrivered protector (as it's likely there is a bus driver, considering everyone got an ability, none are passive, a bus driver makes sence, as he's not too useful for the criminals to keep things fair). Bane with his lousy explainations (which are more fuzzy theories and less likely possibilities than actual explains) and with Killer Croc, another suspect, defending him, is now certainly my top suspect. I know where my vote goes to.
Brickdoctor Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Do you really think the SK would target someone who is propably to be protected and propably to be scumkilled at once? It's a fairly small chance the Riddler would be neither, and both cases would mean a wasted night action. If I was an SK, I'd try to kill people who are less likely to be protected or killed, and leave the known investigator to the agents to care for him. But it's less likely that the vigilante or Scum would target Riddler, so the SK makes more sense as the person who targeted Riddler.Though if I am to avoid being a hypocrite, I do admit that that an SK kill makes more sense than the other two, but it doesn't exactly make sense. The same way the soft, bruised apple is better than the rotten ones. But my point there stands. Bane claims it doesn't make sense at all. I'm pointing out that it can make some sense. Even if it doesn't make that much sense. Because it makes more sense than the other choices. Because soft, bruised apples are better than rotten ones.
ADHO15 Posted November 15, 2011 Author Posted November 15, 2011 Bus drivers? You crazy lot are really gonna lose my respect as criminals if you're telling me some of you drive buses to make a living! Anyway, voting is now open! Current vote tally Simon The Pieman (Scorpiox): 5 - 5 penalty votes There are 47 hours left of Day Two.
Masked Builder Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Vote me out if you want. You will only hurt the Town cause. Oh, that is hilarious! Didn't you see Joker's announcement earlier? Baby Doll has been confirmed town criminal! Uh, Doll isn't scum, you might have noticed that our gracious hosts confirmd this. Oh sorry that was my fault. I wasn't paying attention.
Peanuts Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 But my point there stands. Bane claims it doesn't make sense at all. I'm pointing out that it can make some sense. Even if it doesn't make that much sense. Because it makes more sense than the other choices. Because soft, bruised apples are better than rotten ones. It doesn't make sence as in it's something a rational person would do, so it's irrational to do so, and since irrational derives from "ratio, -nis" which means sence, it doesn't make sence. Yet I agree it makes more sence for an SK to kill the Riddler than for the scum or the criminals, but still no rationally thinking SK would do so. On the other hand, where do you find a rationally thinking SK? Are there any rationally thinking people among you psychopaths at all? Let's change the topic, shall we? Not that I mind talking psychology, but I'm afraid you are uncapable of comprehending anything I say. I'm right, you're wrong, okay? Vote me out if you want. You will only hurt the Town cause. Oh sorry that was my fault. I wasn't paying attention. Yeah, it will hurt the town so much to lose a person who'd reasoning makes no sence, who constantly brings up confusing theories and who doesn't read essential stuff. Bus drivers? You crazy lot are really gonna lose my respect as criminals if you're telling me some of you drive buses to make a living! I remember seeing a movie in which a criminal similar to you drove a bus as getaway car. It was called The Dark Knight, I think.
Jedi master Brick Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Ban e looks like prime scum at the moment but I shall not place a vote yet.
TheBoyWonder Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 I'm not defending Bane, rather just saying Ventriloquist was more suspicious to me then. And why would I defend someone who voted for me?
Peanuts Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 I'm not defending Bane, rather just saying Ventriloquist was more suspicious to me then. And why would I defend someone who voted for me? You're right, I didn't think of that. I'm sorry.
Sirius Black Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Ban e looks like prime scum at the moment but I shall not place a vote yet. And if you feel he is scum, why wouldn't you vote for him? Sheep, I say. You seem entirely too willing to allow someone else to cast the first vote, then join in later when the vote is assured. Vote Bane (Masked Builder) I have no issue with a vote going either against Bane or the Ventriloquist, but Bane seems more likely to be an agent at this point.
Tamamono Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Oh sorry that was my fault. I wasn't paying attention. And what use to the town is a townie who pays no attention? Vote: Bane (Masked Builder) Vote Bane (Masked Builder) I have no issue with a vote going either against Bane or the Ventriloquist, but Bane seems more likely to be an agent at this point. Agreed. There's no unvote limit, so there's no reason to not vote yet.
ADHO15 Posted November 15, 2011 Author Posted November 15, 2011 I remember seeing a movie in which a criminal similar to you drove a bus as getaway car. It was called The Dark Knight, I think. Fair point! Current vote tally Simon The Pieman (Scorpiox): 5 - 5 penalty votes Bane (Masked Builder): 2 - Captain Tamamono, Sirius Black
Brickdoctor Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Oh sorry that was my fault. I wasn't paying attention. It doesn't make sence as in it's something a rational person would do, so it's irrational to do so, and since irrational derives from "ratio, -nis" which means sence, it doesn't make sence. Yet I agree it makes more sence for an SK to kill the Riddler than for the scum or the criminals, but still no rationally thinking SK would do so. On the other hand, where do you find a rationally thinking SK? Are there any rationally thinking people among you psychopaths at all? Let's change the topic, shall we? Not that I mind talking psychology, but I'm afraid you are uncapable of comprehending anything I say. I'm right, you're wrong, okay? Who said the killer was a rational person? There are plenty of sheep and/or misguided, confused people here. Or maybe he's just new to these situations and, for one reason or another, didn't think that the publicly claimed Investigator would be protected.Psychology is defined as "the science of human or animal behavior". In these situations, for many of us, the only way we can attempt to win is by analyzing behavior. Studying behavior is what every good Townie should do, so psychology is a good thing for us. Not to mention that all our mind games can be considered a part of psychology. I remember seeing a movie in which a criminal similar to you drove a bus as getaway car. It was called The Dark Knight, I think. Anyways, let's get this started. I Vote: Bane (Masked Builder).
TheBoyWonder Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 I cannot vote due to not being able to bold on 3DS. Anyway, I wish to say, after checking the speech, my small reptilian brain has shifted my thoughts on to Bane.
Scorpiox Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Okay, I'm convinced now, I Vote: Bane (Masked Builder). I have no fear in voting, as said by others there is plenty of time to unvote if required.
Jedi master Brick Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Ok calm down, now I think Bane is scum for a few reasons such as: *His accusation of Baby Doll, claims to not have been paying attiontion, when you are going to cause someone you check everything . *. I don't think there are 2 doctors So I am going to Vote: Bane (masked builder).
Scorpiox Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Sorry, made a mistake with my voting Vote: Bane (Masked Builder). Even if you revealed to be town, a townie who acts pretty scummy and doesn't help isn't a valuable townie afterall.
Peanuts Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Psychology is defined as "the science of human or animal behavior". In these situations, for many of us, the only way we can attempt to win is by analyzing behavior. Studying behavior is what every good Townie should do, so psychology is a good thing for us. Not to mention that all our mind games can be considered a part of psychology. Hey, don't you explain psychology to me! I did my PhD in that! It's not like I would explain you how drugs work, would I? Although some drugs have an astonishing impact on the psyche. Did you know one of my earlier fear gas formulas contained active substances of drugs? It didn't work out that well, though. Not mayn people know, but you'll be able to read all about it in my biography. And of course every human being is doing a minimum of psychology every day, as we automatically anaylze the behavior of others to a certain extend. Not enough to find the agents, though, so let's attend to psychology again.
Professor Flitwick Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Oh sorry that was my fault. I wasn't paying attention. An'... deres da nail in ya coffin! Vote: Bane (Masked Builder)
Peanuts Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Oh, and I completely forgot to vote over all that talk. Vote: Bane (Masked Builder)
Brickdoctor Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Hey, don't you explain psychology to me! I did my PhD in that! It's not like I would explain you how drugs work, would I? Although some drugs have an astonishing impact on the psyche. Did you know one of my earlier fear gas formulas contained active substances of drugs? It didn't work out that well, though. Not mayn people know, but you'll be able to read all about it in my biography. And of course every human being is doing a minimum of psychology every day, as we automatically anaylze the behavior of others to a certain extend. Not enough to find the agents, though, so let's attend to psychology again. Just pointing that out.
Masked Builder Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Okay so yes I did read that information and yes I did forget it. But that happens to everyone. We're only human. (Okay well some of us aren't.) As should be obvious, I will Vote: The Ventriloquist (Professor Flitwick)
Brickdoctor Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Okay so yes I did read that information and yes I did forget it. Wait. You earlier said you weren't paying attention. (didn't notice) Now you're saying you read it and forgot it. Which one is it?Like I said, fabrication of reasons on the spot. Or lying. Or both. We don't need either.
Masked Builder Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Wait. You earlier said you weren't paying attention. (didn't notice) Now you're saying you read it and forgot it. Which one is it? Like I said, fabrication of reasons on the spot. Or lying. Or both. We don't need either. It's neither. I just forgot about reading over it when I decide to speak.
Bob Posted November 15, 2011 Posted November 15, 2011 Vote: Bane / Masked Builder If something comes up later in time then I'll unvote you, but at this point I'm afraid you're the best lead we have at the moment.
Recommended Posts