Mafia School: The Witchbreed Day III

[Tachyon]

Just got a feeling he is scum. Aslo want to see everyone's reaction to this

[b Vote Master Hale [Halomaster96][/b]

Vote Master Hale {Halomaster96}

[Scubacarrot]

Yesterday, Cecily made a list of her four suspects in the day thread:

The suspects were:

Franklin Holmes

Skip Pudding

Biksie Partsy

and Yulie Yodie

As we all know, two of the people from that list were found out to be scum, and Cecily herself was killed by the witchbreed, with a little logic, one could assume she was killed because she was on the right track, therefore, I ask the two remaining people from that list to defend themselves, as this is quite incriminating.

[Skipper]

Yep people, we can't get complacent just because we got two scum last night. Stay focused.

Skip Pudding- Day two vote for Zam. With some good analysis of why also. Do you still think so? Will you try and sway others?

Depends. I'm waiting on a PM to come in on this very subject.

But for now yes, I still think he's scum. For the same reasons as yesterday, and that he's said some rather incongruous stuff in PMs.

Yesterday, Cecily made a list of her four suspects in the day thread:

The suspects were:

Franklin Holmes

Skip Pudding

Biksie Partsy

and Yulie Yodie

As we all know, two of the people from that list were found out to be scum, and Cecily herself was killed by the witchbreed, with a little logic, one could assume she was killed because she was on the right track, therefore, I ask the two remaining people from that list to defend themselves, as this is quite incriminating.

Alright, let's take a look back at exactly what she said.

I feel like we're at a bit of a standstill here. There are a few people who haven't voted or said anything about who they'd like to vote for since the voting started. Maybe they should come forward with some theories of their own if they don't want to vote for Wully? These are the ones I have in mind (feel free to correct me if I have forgotten something/someone)

Skip Pudding (can't see that he has said a word since voting started)

Yulie Yodie (has not spoken since the voting started as far as I can see)

Biskie Partsy (has only had a short useless statement since voting started)

Franklin Holmes (all I can see is a defense for himself against Dragus' accusation)

Care to add anything interesting to the discussion?

She has no evidence against me except that I hadn't posted since voting started. True. I've explained this before, I'll do it again. I was at school. Now we're on break I'll be able to post more frequently when everyone's are around.

Once I got here I reread logs of past days, and then "came forward with a theory of my own," questioned someone else's motives for a vote, etc . . . not what you'd call a lurker, besides somewhat negating her accusation, although the suspicious evidently remains.

Cecily was a great player though, her accusations seemed on target and she sparked a lot of conversation so I can see why you're still suspicious of me.

[Piratedave84]

As Pirelly wakes up from his long night of sleep

HELLO!?

*Tumble weed rolls through*

Has everybody been killed by withcbreed as I slept?

HELLO?

Man! Talk about conversation killer!

*Snip*

I know there's two scum in the list of people I've just addressed, so odds are, I've poked at least one hornet's nest.

All I can say is, bring it on. I am the day three Darth!

Talk people, Talk!

If you don't answer my questions, expect votes going your way!

I think you scared everyone into hidding!!

Anyways, I'll talk to myself outloud and say this: I have had a small talk with Sir Carrots and it seems my logic was flawed; apologies to the scribe who had to write all that down!!!!

No as ANYONE got ANYTHING to say ...

[yumiyoshi]

Ok, here I am.

I made some research and I think I kinda find a flaw on scums behaviour.

I can't reveal it now, 'cause it's just a theory.

I can just tell that Skip and Pirelly are first in line.

C.Knight, Dragus (60%scum, but I may be angry 'cause he voted me!), are on a grey zone

I kinda defined townie SirCarrot, voltana, wully (of course!),

Where's master hale?

[Skipper]

Ok, here I am.

I made some research and I think I kinda find a flaw on scums behaviour.

I can't reveal it now, 'cause it's just a theory.

I can just tell that Skip and Pirelly are first in line.

C.Knight, Dragus (60%scum, but I may be angry 'cause he voted me!), are on a grey zone

I kinda defined townie SirCarrot, voltana, wully (of course!),

Where's master hale?

Could you at least PM me so I can defend myself? I'd rather not be wrongly lynched without being able to speak against it.

[Piratedave84]

I can't reveal it now, 'cause it's just a theory.

I can just tell that Skip and Pirelly are first in line.

Where's master hale?

YAY I'm first ... OH NO!! it's not a good thing is it? Why because we dared to speak today! Please elaborate, I'm intrigued!

Could you at least PM me so I can defend myself? I'd rather not be wrongly lynched without being able to speak against it.

Why would she be expected to PM you?

Why would you need to defend yourself in private?

[Skipper]

Why would she be expected to PM you?

Why would you need to defend yourself in private?

I interpreted her post as not wanting to share it in public yet, so I proposed doing it privately as an interim measure so I could defend myself.

But if anyone has any claims against me, I'd be happy to discuss them here or anywhere.

[Chromeknight]

Christos moved like a ghost through the court.

Avoiding the guards, since he had memorized their routine.

Down the stairs to the side and along the passages he went.

The smell ahead grew stronger. He knew that he was close to his goal.

The hunger that was driving him sharpened.

This task must be completed if he was to survive, it would be completed!

He had long planned this, there could be no-one to see him on this daring raid.

No-one to point the finger of blame at him.

He would thumb his nose at the silly little boy-king and his bitchy mother.

Reaching the door, he paused, listening intently.

Faint sounds from the other side, but nothing untoward reached him.

Slowly he lifted the latch and opened the door.

His grin wide in anticipation, drool gathering at the corner of his lips.

With the solid door pushed back enough, he slipped into the room.

There she was, the crown of his steaming fantasies.

Pulling out his knife he tiptoes quietly toward his prey.

The need for stealth is exaggerated. There is no-one else around.

Furtively glancing around one last time he raises the blade over the pale flesh.

A quick stroke down and he slices into the delectable breast.

Beast that he his he lifts the slice to his gaping maw, eager to feast.

As he fills his mouth he cuts another chunk of warm meat.

Precisely then, as he is consummating his filthy criminal deed, the door slams back.

A figure, outlined against the dark hallway beyond lifts a trembling figure.

She screeches in anger and betrayal....

WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO THE KING'S TURKEY?!?!

Happy thanksgiving to all (even those who don't worship the turkey-god!)

Ok, here I am.

I made some research and I think I kinda find a flaw on scums behaviour.

I can't reveal it now, 'cause it's just a theory.

I can just tell that Skip and Pirelly are first in line.

C.Knight, Dragus (60%scum, but I may be angry 'cause he voted me!), are on a grey zone

I kinda defined townie SirCarrot, voltana, wully (of course!),

Voting has opened Yulie. You are allowed to nail your colours to the mast.

But if you've got a theory you'll have to share it with someone so they have a reason to vote for the person you suspect.

What you've posted so far isn't terribly helpful.

By first in line I guess you mean are top of the list of scum suspects.

Where's master hale?

That is indeed a good question.

Perhaps he's caught Gilly's disease (incoherent mumblings about a net being broken)

[Skipper]

No one seems to be very forwards today. I'll put out a vote.

Vote: Dragus (darkdragon)

Why haven't you posted? I see you're "on the net" right now yet you haven't contributed a single thing to our discussion. Please explain yourself.

Looking at past day's records, she has done a great job of lurking without drawing suspicion, I wonder why? This is the total log (I can't quote from a locked topic):

Day One:

1) Oh Dear Lord, the retched Witchbreed walk among us! We must all ask for forgiveness for what we have to do. We must not harm any innocents this day as we sniff out the scum among us.

2)Wait, I missed the eclairs?

I did happen to find a piece of the strange puzzle, and I'm not sure if sharing is right or not but we'll never know what it is unless everyone shows what they have. Right?

So here is my piece of the great puzzle, I hope it is helpful to town.

MAP PIECE PICTURE

For right now, I will Vote: Flanagan, The Whipping Boy (Flare) because he is saying things, just enough to not be the "unhelpful quite people". However, he says nothing of substance. I look forward to hearing his defense.

Day Two

1) *responding to wife of darth* From what I can see, you are not being voted off in a landslide yet, as a matter of fact the last official count lists you in a tie. There is still time left to defend yourself. No votes are final yet, but time is marching along forward as it tends to do.

Day Three:

1) Now that I'm all caught up with the current conversations, here's my take on it.

RE: Wully

I don't like the looks of all of this bandwagon voting for Wully. This is just what happened with Wife of Darth yesterday and look at what a horrible night we had? Yes, Wully has admitted to being a killer - but he has also said he will side with town tonight. If Wully can survive the night and help the town tonight, I think he deserves that chance and we could really use any help we can get.

RE: Flanagan

I am sorry to have voted for him, even though in the end it didn't matter. I wish he would have given a defense of some kind, it is truly sad another town was murdered in the night.

RE: Wife of Darth

It really breaks my heart that nearly everyone jumped on the bandwagon to lynch her yesterday. Yes, she was acting crazy and drawing a lot of attention. I think we can all agree on that. Instead of jumping on the next bandwagon of voting for the first person we see, maybe we should think back to yesterday and who started the nudging of the votes towards a townie.

Today I think it would be better for us to lynch a scum then to lynch a neutral, though I admit that either of those is better than lynching another townie.

Based on what was discussed yesterday, it seems to me that Franklin Holmes started the landslide against Wife of Darth. I could have misunderstood what he was saying, but that is the way it looks to me.

Vote: Franklin Holmes, The Manciple (fhomess)

I look forward to hearing your defence, sir.

2) Thank you, Franklin Holmes, for giving back some decent non-panicked information in your defense. I'm currently leaning towards unvoting you, but I just need to weight all the everything (facts, conjecture, guesses, etc) first. I also need to vote for someone, so before I unvote you I have to figure out who else might I vote for. I honestly do not feel that Wully should be lynched today.

There are some ideas rattling around in my mind, but I must wait a bit before I mention them. I do not want to pop off with every little idea and create another unfounded landslide, that is the last thing we need right now. I will be back a little later today with some ideas and reasoning behind them.

3)Unvote: Franklin Holmes, The Manciple (fhomess)

Vote: Yulie Yodie (Yumiyoshi)

I'm voting Yulie because she says things that don't a lot of sense and it's hard to follow her logic. For instance, and I realize this has already been brought up, she wants to attack people for not speaking up and then turns around and attacks people for speaking up. I don't think my vote this late will really change things today, but I hope it will open up some more talking and thinking for tomorrow.

I hope we catch a scum today and Wully catches one tonight.

---

Not much. And maybe more importantly, nothing committing. She did accuse Franklin (a confirmed scum) yesterday, but as it was a very transient attack I am inclined to believe it was just a ploy to publicly distance themselves.

[Darkdragon]

Ok, hello. It's been a long day(s). I am caught up on today's conversation finally.

I admit to not being very helpful since this day started. I have had a lot of other things going on that I had to take care of and really didn't know what to say here to add to the information. As we have learned already, I think voting someone just because he or she is not posted yet is a bad reason. It's the third day and I don't think we should be grasping at straws like that anymore.

Why did I change my vote yesterday? I changed it because I had accomplished all I could with that vote and it was time to move on and get more information from someone else who hadn't been voted yet at all. I am glad that Yulie was able to see through Franklin's defense and take him out (I'm just trusting that she isn't lying about doing it and nobody has stepped up to say they did it, so no reason to doubt).

Based on what was said early today I am suspecting Pirelly. I am currently not ready to cast my vote because I have been very busy and need to rethink things that have happened the last two days. I do not want to make a voting mistake like I did on the first day (though my vote didn't make a difference for poor Flanagan, I still feel bad that I suspected him and cast the vote).

I am not Witchbreed Scum, I am a loyal member of the town.

This is all I have to say for the moment, but I will be back in a couple hours to say more and cast a vote.

[Wuntin]

Well done, Skip! An accusation built on a reasonable argument and backed

up with a vote.

What have the rest of you managed to produce? Two half-arsed suspicions,

an accusation that can't be revealed, one set of statistics with accompanying

suspicion of everyone, one misconception, a whole lot of silence and a vote

based on the thoroughly convincing "I've got a feeling" argument.

I want you to ask uncomfortable questions! I want you to point fingers! I want

you to cast votes! I want to see solid arguments! I want to see seven of you

go "Hey, those two look rather suspicious..."

Not pointing fingers? Not casting votes? Not providing arguments? Then you're

running the risk of having that thing you're obviously not using replaced with a

light pearl gray flail come nightfall...

Ugh, you people are hard to please. Store's closed.

[Chromeknight]

Vote: Skip Pudding (Skipper)

Since the recap of days seems to be the way to go

Day 1.

Shows up late.

Leads a vote on Flanagan late in the vote after Flanagan reveals he has information.

When the vote falters in the face of the Darth bandwagon who shows up vapourised? Flanagan.

Then he changes to Wife of Darth.

"Waah! its a frame job. Why would I be so blantant!"

It is a frame job? or is it meant to look like a frame job so that no one would suspect him?

Day 2.

First statement

"Oh shit. So many dead, even our now confirmed roleblocker."

Forgive me, but as far as I know, Darth was confirmed town, his role claim was not proved.

Unless you have secret scummy information we don't know about?

Then there's

Interesting. With that in mind I need to go back and read Day One (again).

Since if we lynch Wully and he turns out town then we know Voltana is scum (thus he is unlikely to lie on such a verifiable claim), I'm inclined to act on this tonight.

"Not town" means Witchbreed right, Voltana? It's a little thing, but could you clarify? I'd hate to think there's another faction.

Why would the idea of 'another faction' cross your mind unless you thought you already knew all the scum?

Then follows some discussion with Voltana, which could be read as an encouragement to get here to divulge her source, exposing the cop.

Shows up to vote, then... oh "I need more time"

Seeing a move on Gilly, to save Wully does Skip vote either? no he goes for Zam Kuric.

Why? Because he had penalty votes on day one and his scum buddies saved him from the lynch...

Now he can claim "I didn't vote for the wully plan" and can claim "I didn't lynch the innocent Gilly"

Sigh.

Day three.

I get a PM message from him saying it was good to keep Wully.

Way to jump on after it's rolling...

Then in PM he's still banging on about Zam.

What have you got against the guy, Skip?

I spin him some tosh about Carrots (who is also in with Zam and Voltana) and he's

"I agree with you on Sir Carrots"

Sure you do, any attention directed somewhere else is good.

When is his first post? after voting has opened.

what does he say?

oh "I need more time"

No wonder he was on Cecily's list. The list that got her killed.

And now a requote of Dragus' posts.

He can't point to anything suspicious other than not contributing.

And he's driven to accuse by the echoing silence of town waiting for the scum to show their hand.

Well, there it is...

[Skipper]

Alright, let's break this down shall we?

Vote: Skip Pudding (Skipper)

Shows up late.

Leads a vote on Flanagan late in the vote after Flanagan reveals he has information.

When the vote falters in the face of the Darth bandwagon who shows up vapourised? Flanagan.

I'm done explaining why I get here later than a lot of you, if you still need to know maybe you should start paying attention to the thread.

Yes I voted for Flanagan, on the same grounds that a lot of people are voting for me: apparently unhelpful posts. He did some random roleplaying shit and never gave us any information. And then he told us that he had cracked the map and still didn't show us after directly prompted to. It's hard to look at that record and not think scum. And it would be a really clumsy move for a scum to kill the person he was accusing in the day thread, that just makes them really obvious.

Then he changes to Wife of Darth.

"Waah! its a frame job. Why would I be so blantant!"

It is a frame job? or is it meant to look like a frame job so that no one would suspect him?

First off, that's not what I said, not once did I mention a frame job. Here you go:

Well, since my previous vote towards Flanagan won't do anything, I think Zam Kuric is innocent, and I think that Darth is scum, I'll change my vote in case THis someone decides to unvote Zakura again.

Unvote: Flangan (Flare)

Vote: Wife of Darth (Darth Nihilus)

This is the last time I'll be able to vote today.

At that time I was utterly convinced Darth Nihilus was a scum, and as the votes were somewhat close I decided to add some "insurance" that he would be lynched before I went to sleep (and thus couldn't monitor the thread) and the day ended.

Day 2.

First statement

"Oh shit. So many dead, even our now confirmed roleblocker."

Forgive me, but as far as I know, Darth was confirmed town, his role claim was not proved.

Unless you have secret scummy information we don't know about?

Then there's

Interesting. With that in mind I need to go back and read Day One (again).

Since if we lynch Wully and he turns out town then we know Voltana is scum (thus he is unlikely to lie on such a verifiable claim), I'm inclined to act on this tonight.

"Not town" means Witchbreed right, Voltana? It's a little thing, but could you clarify? I'd hate to think there's another faction.

Why would the idea of 'another faction' cross your mind unless you thought you already knew all the scum?

Most of the time, when a person dies and they are proved to be townie, you can assume they never lied in-thread. From there was the basis of my first post.

I would think the second thing is obvious. First off, I've never played a mafia game before. I've done some research since on how hosts reveal people's roles to the cop, but when you're new to the game and the result comes up with a non-specific "not-town," you wonder why.

Then follows some discussion with Voltana, which could be read as an encouragement to get here to divulge her source, exposing the cop.

When you say what I say, quote exactly what I say, ok? Important part in bold.

All right, why are you so ready to trust your source? You don't have to reveal them/their name, only give us a good reason/evidence why you believe that person when they say they're cop. Because if you've been duped and then we do what I think is the best plan with the information that you've given us, then this will happen: . . .

Shows up to vote, then... oh "I need more time"

Seeing a move on Gilly, to save Wully does Skip vote either? no he goes for Zam Kuric.

Why? Because he had penalty votes on day one and his scum buddies saved him from the lynch...

Now he can claim "I didn't vote for the wully plan" and can claim "I didn't lynch the innocent Gilly"

Yes, you know why I needed time? I just read through the whole thread, you don't make good judgements in two seconds.

WHy did I vote for Zam Kuric? What you said, only you left out the uselesness of his posts.

Why didn't I vote for Gilly? He was already ahead, and I thought it best to spread out the votes. Having too many people piled on one person doesn't help when you're trying to analyze votes in later days (for example, the Wife of Darth).

Day three.

I get a PM message from him saying it was good to keep Wully.

Way to jump on after it's rolling...

Then in PM he's still banging on about Zam.

What have you got against the guy, Skip?

I've explained why I didn't vote Gilly to save Wully earlier in the thread. Another point why is because I had no other leads, so killing someone claiming to be an SK couldn't be worse than a random kill.

What did I have against Zam? Maybe what I outlined in the thread.

I spin him some tosh about Carrots (who is also in with Zam and Voltana) and he's

"I agree with you on Sir Carrots"

Sure you do, any attention directed somewhere else is good.

Why would I be trying to redirect you to Sir Carrots if you hadn't revealed your suspicion of me to me at that time?

For the same reason (I trusted you at the time) I believed you when you "spun some tosh" to me against Carrots. Nothing in mafia is known for fact, I was going off of what people (you) told me.

When is his first post? after voting has opened.

what does he say?

oh "I need more time"

No wonder he was on Cecily's list. The list that got her killed.

Well, there it is...

Of course I needed more megablocking time, as I said I was waiting on a PM. And I don't see you target all the people who didn't even bother to post . . . or answer your list of questions.

And now a requote of Dragus' posts.

He can't point to anything suspicious other than not contributing.

And he's driven to accuse by the echoing silence of town waiting for the scum to show their hand.

Well, there it is...

"Can't point to anything suspicious other than not contributing, " is this not what people have been doing to me constantly throughout these three days?

And I also was suspicious of that little stint with Franklin holmes.

And why on Earth would a scum want to break the silence? Everyone's been happy to lie low the whole day which I consider a shit strategy, that's why I brought up an accusation. As you yourself have said many times, we need to talk to out the scum.

[Darkdragon]

Well done, Skip! An accusation built on a reasonable argument and backed

up with a vote.

I'm not sure how Skip's accusation is built on a reasonable argument at all. Someone who doesn't have a lot of time to talk, suddenly gets more time and then starts attacking others with the same argument that he was being attacked with - and that he was saying is nonsense to accuse people with that excuse. How does this make any sense?

C.Knight, Dragus (60%scum, but I may be angry 'cause he voted me!), are on a grey zone

I can see by your actions last night you must be on the town side. If all we have to go by is conversation and actions, I must apologize for voting you yesterday. Sometimes I think we have language barriers that make it more difficult to understand others. I totally understand why you are feeling angry with me today, but I hope it doesn't cloud your judgement on finding some true scum.

Looking back through today's small amount of discussion so far, Pirelly you seem scummy to me. You were attacked and you defended yourself, that much I can understand (after all, I had to defend myself today too). However, what looks bad is how much you seem to be 'freaking out' in your defense. You are really coming off as paranoid and a little too defensive to be innocent.

Vote: Pirelly Dabito The Shipman (Piratedave)

[Skipper]

I'm not sure how Skip's accusation is built on a reasonable argument at all. Someone who doesn't have a lot of time to talk, suddenly gets more time and then starts attacking others with the same argument that he was being attacked with - and that he was saying is nonsense to accuse people with that excuse. How does this make any sense?

Well, I see a distinction between the two of us.

I don't get online for the time that I don't post, and when I do I try to help as much as possible.

You, to use today specifically as an example were online nearly the entire day, reading/posting in other threads but never bothered to come in here. And when I asked you about it, you said "I forgot." And to generalize to past days, if we look at the log I posted above you don't really say much.

Make of it what you will. Keep in mind half of the motive behind my vote (besides the 50% that believes you are scum) is to provoke some conversation, as we've had a lack of it today. Although apparently now doing that marks you as scum.

[Scubacarrot]

Right. I have thought this over and my current suspicion lies with Christos Knight.

He contacted me pretty early in the game, and since then we have been talking a little bit.

After the Wife of Darth had been lynched, I told him that she had been suspecting Wully and Franklin, Christos Knight was very quick to dismiss the claims against Franklin, but jumped on the accusation of Wully (mind you, this was before the investigation results from wully).

I did not think much of it at the time, but since this morning, this is of course very suspicious.

The other reason for me to believe Christos Knight is scum, is that I know Cecily was mainly talking to two people as far as I know: me and Christos Knight.

I had pretty good conversation with Cecily, sharing suspicions and the like, so I have no reason not to believe that.

Now, I know Christos Knight and Cecily were working on a list of who was scum, I do not know if this list was any different than the one she showed yesterday.

Bottomline is: Cecily was killed, and I like to believe there was a reason why the scum killed her and not anyone else. And since I can not find a good reason to do so in the day threads (again, except for that list) It must be because of conversation.

I contacted Christos Knight before if he had something to say for himself, and he did not. Think of this what you want.

In the day threads I can not really find anything exceptionally implicating, except he has a tendency to recap and sum things up, making him appear more active than he actually is.

For the reasons above, I Vote: Christos Knight (Chromeknight). I could be way off, feel free to try and prove it so.

[def]

Vote Tally:

Master Hale(Halomaster96) 1 : zakura

Dragus (darkdragon) 1 : Skipper

Skip Pudding (Skipper) 1 : Chrome Knight

Pirelly Dabito The Shipman (Piratedave) 1 : darkdragon

Christos Knight (Chromeknight) 1 : scubacarrot

A five-way vote! Intriguing... Maybe 27-28 hours left in the day.

[Fred Daniel Yam]

I must confess that I think that Master Hale is being really quiet and only checking in to vote. Therefore I will Vote Master Hale (halomaster96)

[Chromeknight]

He contacted me pretty early in the game, and since then we have been talking a little bit.

After the Wife of Darth had been lynched, I told him that she had been suspecting Wully and Franklin, Christos Knight was very quick to dismiss the claims against Franklin, but jumped on the accusation of Wully (mind you, this was before the investigation results from wully).

I did not think much of it at the time, but since this morning, this is of course very suspicious.

Have I made mistakes in this game? sure.

Did I suspect Franklin? not really. didn't trust him fully either.

That's why I suggested to the investigator that he be investigated.

Now it turns out he wasn't just scum but the Godfather.

So someone's going to trot out the whole "it was a complicated plan" thing.

Without proof..

The other reason for me to believe Christos Knight is scum, is that I know Cecily was mainly talking to two people as far as I know: me and Christos Knight.

I had pretty good conversation with Cecily, sharing suspicions and the like, so I have no reason not to believe that.

I've also been speaking to a lot of people via PM. that's what I've been doing to help town.

That and provoking discussion in the thread.

Carrots conveniently forgets that I approached him. I suggested he speak to cecily.

Surely if I was scum I'd fracture relationships since I'd want to keep track of who was saying what to whom.

Now, I know Christos Knight and Cecily were working on a list of who was scum, I do not know if this list was any different than the one she showed yesterday.

Bottomline is: Cecily was killed, and I like to believe there was a reason why the scum killed her and not anyone else. And since I can not find a good reason to do so in the day threads (again, except for that list) It must be because of conversation.

Aside from you, I haven't been on any list of possible scum.

No one else has suspected me.

Either I'm a really good scum or I'm simply a townie working hard on the game.

I contacted Christos Knight before if he had something to say for himself, and he did not. Think of this what you want.

I might be way off but at the moment YOU are my main suspect. Anything to say for yourself before I make this public?

That post? Way to bring up a list of grievances.

Since my conscience was clear, I wasn't leaping to defend myself from vague suspicion.

My reply was measured. Sure I didn't say anything to you. I didn't think I really need to.

I think I can kind of see where you're coming from.

And you're welcome to publish whatever you like on the thread.

Your suspicion is off base, but it'll be good to thrash it out in public.

Thank you for the polite heads up though.

In the day threads I can not really find anything exceptionally implicating, except he has a tendency to recap and sum things up, making him appear more active than he actually is.

How am I supposed to defend myself here? You're calling me out and have to admit that you can't find anything implicating.

Let's see if you've convinced anyone else.

[Piratedave84]

Looking back through today's small amount of discussion so far, Pirelly you seem scummy to me. You were attacked and you defended yourself, that much I can understand (after all, I had to defend myself today too). However, what looks bad is how much you seem to be 'freaking out' in your defense. You are really coming off as paranoid and a little too defensive to be innocent.

Vote: Pirelly Dabito The Shipman (Piratedave)

I understand your vote, and as I said bofre, I was over-enthusiastic early today and it amde me talk A LOT ...

You know who else talked a lot? Wife of Darth ... and she got killed ... and was town

You know who else talked a lot? Cecily ... and she got killed ... and was town

You know who else talked a lot? Cuzlo Mizzle ... and he got killed ... and was town

Talking a lot, defending yourself at that, does not make you scum IMO

Now talking little, very little, at this point to me means you deserve to be lynched hence:

Vote: Master Hale (halomaster69)

Vote: Master Hale (halomaster69)

Wrong username, lets try this again:

Vote: Master Hale (halomaster96)

[halomaster96]

I will probably be lynched tonight because I haven't said anything useful, so this is probably the point where I tell everyone my special role, but at this point you all know I have none. But I will tell you this, I am not scum. I know that nobody will believe me so if I die tonight I want everyone to know I was just another innocent quiet person. Though I don't want to die so I will vote for the person who started the person who started this bandwagon against me.

Vote: Yulie yodie (Yumiyoshi)

[def]

Vote Tally:

Master Hale(Halomaster96) 3 : zakura, volcanicpanik, piratedave

Dragus (darkdragon) 1 : Skipper

Skip Pudding (Skipper) 1 : Chrome Knight

Pirelly Dabito The Shipman (Piratedave) 1 : darkdragon

Christos Knight (Chromeknight) 1 : scubacarrot

Yet to vote: Wuntin, yumiyoshi, halomaster96

Mod note:

Three hours left in the day. Really, after 24 hours, there is no excuse not to have voted, other than that you aren't fully playing. A goal is to vote early so we can have discussion about the votes. Waiting until the last minute is not "town". It's much better to place a tentative vote than none at all.

All in all, this has been an unexciting day. With five candidates, it should have been the most exciting one

[yumiyoshi]

Master Hale, probably you'll be lynched 'cause you forgot about bold....

If the reason for killing me is just because I was the one that first did it to you, it's really childish.

Don't you have any reason for anyone here?

It's utterly suspicious that you don't want put your brain at work.

You've never said anything useful, and often stayed on Franklin side, since the beginning.

The only one that has helped so little as you is Zam (and he wanted to lynch Wully even after he was confirmed SK)

To me, I'm re-reading everything once again.

There must be something.

I got suspects but I can't sum them up so I need a major study!

If I'm wrong, please correct.

We're 10 still alive,

with 2 scums left according to the puzzle.

8 townie.

Who were the one investigated, and still alive?

Who is the cop?

On the very first day, Franklin accuse the Wife just after her accusations toward SirCarrot. Why? Where they tied?

And on the second day, he stated the same thing, withouth saying why he liked Sir so much to defend him.

SirCarrot, gotta something to say?

Yesterday I was ready to call you townie, and now I'm back to accuse you, or better to convince me you're town.

Pirelly Dabito The Shipman is another one of my suspects.

And I have a question: How many of you have been talking to C.Knight?

Vote: Zam Kuric, The Clerk (zakura)

[Wuntin]

I will probably be lynched tonight because I haven't said anything useful, so this is probably the point where I tell everyone my special role, but at this point you all know I have none. But I will tell you this, I am not scum. I know that nobody will believe me so if I die tonight I want everyone to know I was just another innocent quiet person. Though I don't want to die so I will vote for the person who started the person who started this bandwagon against me.

Vote: Yulie yodie (Yumiyoshi)

Yes, you are being lynched because you haven't said anything

useful. Facing that, you decide to vote for the only person who

we can all agree is town. Was that supposed to convince us

that you're a townie?

Vote: Master Hale (halomaster96)