Mafia School: A Bedtime Story - Day Three

[Chromeknight]

Ok. I've had a rough night, no thanks to you lot bouncing around and shaking me awake to tell me something new.

Red. Yes, I can confirm that's what Cindy told you.

But, given Cindy was a ditzy belville-ite and was wrong about wolf. and Pinnochio and Goldie (though yes, I had a hand in that too).

... given Cindy was wrong about so much, I'm not ready to leap into bed with you.

Perhaps I'm getting paranoid in my old age.

On the other hand.

Aladdin, you're a twerp. Your play has been all over the place.

It's no wonder people are lining up to lynch you...

But you know things that make me wonder how you know them.

Odds are you are scum, but currently I have six on my uncleared list so hopefully you can put up some flailing scummy defense that helps narrow down the choices.

We've got time, so cough it up...

[LEGOman273]

Aladdin has been acting Scummy for a while, and Red's PM chain backs this up. Thus I:

Vote: Aladdin (Palathadric)

[Sandy]

Current Vote Tally:

Aladdin/palathadric: 5 (Kadabra, RPGer, JaseTJ, Dakar A, LEGOman273)

[Palathadric]

Alright Little Red, If I'm scum, and you're the town cop as you say, then the scum should know you're the town cop, right? The town cop is the most dangerous role for the scum, right? So in that case, why are you not dead? Sure Cindy was protecting you, that's great, but if I was the scum and I knew that Cindy was the doctor, since she PMed me the message as Puss can confirm, then why wouldn't I, if I really was a scum, have not killed you and just blocked Cindy? You seem to say also that no one knew Cindy was protecting you, so why didn't the scum, if I were one of them, take you down without a second thought. The fact is that you are scum, and the more I think about it, the more I am convinced of your scumminess. Your even being alive is evidence you're a scum.

[Palathadric]

Aladdin you better answer soon or else you shall be lynched!

Some of us are in different time zones than the rest of you.

Anyway, I just realized that I never placed my vote.

Vote: Little Red Riding Hood (Kadabra)

[Dakar A]

Due to recent events, I Unvote: Aladdin (Phalathdric), and Vote: Rapunsel (RPGer). This isn't because I trust Aladdin, I just don't want to (possibly) lynch another townie. I'm on hold till more facts appear.

[JackJonespaw]

Hmmm, interesting that Little Red is claiming role-cop. The fact is that that is true, I think. He is a role-cop, only not the town one. As it turns out, Little Red is almost certainly the scum role cop, because I know the town role cop.

On the first night of investigation, Cindy was investigated, but the role cop was blocked in his/her investigation. Hence, I never really trusted Cindy, until somewhere in day two. Sometime then, Cindy told me that hood had claimed cop, but she didn't trust her, so I casually told Little Red in a PM that we knew that she was a role-cop, although I didn't let on that we were suspecting her of being the scum role-cop. On the second night, I advised my contact, who me and Cindy code-named "Elijah Wood" to investigate Little Red, but Cindy said we should investigate the White Rabbit, code-named "Mushu" instead, since he was at the time the highest on her suspect list. As it turns out White Rabbit is a townie through and through.

However, I am still almost 100% certain that Little Red is scum. How else do you explain Lord of the Fries lurking around. Lord of the Fries was online a lot during the last few days, and he only ever posted weak statements. As soon as Sandy mentioned replacing him, you'll see, he jumped in to say he was confirmed. The fact was that he is scum, if not the scum's role cop. Believe me or not.

Cindy was not supposed to die today. No, that letter she wrote to me, Charming, and White Rabbit, was not supposed to be her suicide note. It was actually, to a certain extent, meant to protect her, because we knew that she was bound to get killed soon, unfortunately, it did not.

Yes, I am admitting that Cindy PMed me to tell me that she was James Bond. Cindy had a reason for that. It was actually a manner of protecting the role cop. Cindy did not protect Little Red last night. I'm not sure who she did, but I'm fairly certain that she protected "Elijah Wood."

Alright Little Red, If I'm scum, and you're the town cop as you say, then the scum should know you're the town cop, right? The town cop is the most dangerous role for the scum, right? So in that case, why are you not dead? Sure Cindy was protecting you, that's great, but if I was the scum and I knew that Cindy was the doctor, since she PMed me the message as Puss can confirm, then why wouldn't I, if I really was a scum, have not killed you and just blocked Cindy? You seem to say also that no one knew Cindy was protecting you, so why didn't the scum, if I were one of them, take you down without a second thought. The fact is that you are scum, and the more I think about it, the more I am convinced of your scumminess. Your even being alive is evidence you're a scum.

These are both pretty good points, so, for now, I'm going to VOTE: Little Red Riding Hood (Kadabra).

So, wrong format. I'll VOTE: Little Red Riding Hood (Kadabra).

[Palathadric]

Does it make any sense that Lord of the Fries would reveal that he was the cop to me? There's only two possiblities. Either he revealed it to me before he "investigated me" as LRRH claimed he did, or he revealed it after. If he revealed it before that would be really dumb. Why would the cop give information away like that so freely and so early on and then suddenly decide that he needs to investigate me. If he revealed it after than that's even dumber, as I'm sure you'd all agree. LRRH's tale clearly doesn't hold water. Either Lord of the Fries is seriously dumb, or Kadabra's tale is a lie (clearly the more likely of the two options. Lord of the Fries could not be that dumb.)

[Piratedave84]

WOW!

Was Cindy ever so wrong ... and guess what ... we decided to follow her in her and vote for innocents.

We have to make sure we get 1 scum per day to lynch if we are to survive and it is therefore imperative that we look into every leads we have.

I contacted Red ("new" red that is) on the first day and she assured me she was a GG.

Aladin on the other hand never contacted me, and I never contacted me .... BUT ... just now I received a very interesting letter from Aladin outlining the scum plan for tomorrow (spoiler: It concerns me!). I shared that information with individuals I trust and am waiting on their take on it; here's mine:

Aladin is either:

1) scum and trying to lead me away from him

2) scum and trying to volunteer wrong information to mislead us townines

3) was trusted by scummies and learnt of their plans in the same fahion Cindy trusted scummies and they were privy to some info.

Which is it?

Most people in this castle seem to think it's either 1) or 2), I myself cannot decide just yet and I am NOT going to lynch a townie today!

[LEGOman273]

Due to recent events, I Unvote: Aladdin (Phalathdric), and Vote: Rapunsel (RPGer). This isn't because I trust Aladdin, I just don't want to (possibly) lynch another townie. I'm on hold till more facts appear.

No, we need to focus on one Scum at a time. I don't like Repunzel either, but I trust Red (indirectly, because of conversations that Cindy and I had).

Does it make any sense that Lord of the Fries would reveal that he was the cop to me? There's only two possiblities. Either he revealed it to me before he "investigated me" as LRRH claimed he did, or he revealed it after. If he revealed it before that would be really dumb. Why would the cop give information away like that so freely and so early on and then suddenly decide that he needs to investigate me. If he revealed it after than that's even dumber, as I'm sure you'd all agree. LRRH's tale clearly doesn't hold water. Either Lord of the Fries is seriously dumb, or Kadabra's tale is a lie (clearly the more likely of the two options. Lord of the Fries could not be that dumb.)

LotF never participated. I don't know what he would do.

@All:

1. Cindy was a greater threat to the Scum than Red was because of her "Wall of Text".

2. Scum are smart. They need an alibi.

These are two reasons why the Scum would keep Red alive.

Thus, DON'T LISTEN TO ALADDIN! He is Scum; I have suspected him from Day One.

We need to focus on him, and worry about other Scum tomorrow. (Looking at you, Puss)

WOW!

Was Cindy ever so wrong ... and guess what ... we decided to follow her in her and vote for innocents.

We have to make sure we get 1 scum per day to lynch if we are to survive and it is therefore imperative that we look into every leads we have.

I contacted Red ("new" red that is) on the first day and she assured me she was a GG.

Aladin on the other hand never contacted me, and I never contacted me .... BUT ... just now I received a very interesting letter from Aladin outlining the scum plan for tomorrow (spoiler: It concerns me!). I shared that information with individuals I trust and am waiting on their take on it; here's mine:

Aladin is either:

1) scum and trying to lead me away from him

2) scum and trying to volunteer wrong information to mislead us townines

3) was trusted by scummies and learnt of their plans in the same fahion Cindy trusted scummies and they were privy to some info.

Which is it?

Most people in this castle seem to think it's either 1) or 2), I myself cannot decide just yet and I am NOT going to lynch a townie today!

What were the plans, exactly?

[Piratedave84]

What were the plans, exactly?

This:

You are going to by lynched tomorrow because of Sandy's writing that an axe killed Mr. Bear. My sources tell me that you will be tomorrow's target for Hood's (the bad guy cop) investigation and it's going to come back scum, just like I have. It's a fix to take town down from the inside. Watch your step, mate!

Which according to Aladin means that LRRH is not the role cop, so she will "investigate you" and "find out" that you are scum,

What do you guys think?

[LEGOman273]

This:

You are going to by lynched tomorrow because of Sandy's writing that an axe killed Mr. Bear. My sources tell me that you will be tomorrow's target for Hood's (the bad guy cop) investigation and it's going to come back scum, just like I have. It's a fix to take town down from the inside. Watch your step, mate!

Which according to Aladin means that LRRH is not the role cop, so she will "investigate you" and "find out" that you are scum,

What do you guys think?

Why would the Scum tell you that you will be killed? That would incriminate the person who told you.

Sounds like a Scum tactic to get us to lynch our Cop. Not going to work.

[JaseTJ]

So, Jack, they're not planning on killing you? Because they seem to think you're one of them? Or did I mishear you?

[Sandy]

Current Vote Tally:

Aladdin/palathadric: 4 (Kadabra, RPGer, JaseTJ, LEGOman273)

Red Riding Hood/Kadabra: 2 (palathadric, Jackjonespaw)

Rapunzel/RPGer: 1 (Dakar A)

Non-voters: 4 (Piratedave84, Chromeknight, Alex the Great, Donut)

[Piratedave84]

So, Jack, they're not planning on killing you? Because they seem to think you're one of them? Or did I mishear you?

Hum ... yes you did!

The plan seems to be to "investigate" me, then publicly claim the "results" as scum (where I'm in fact town) and have me lynched!

So you would indirectly wind up killing me!

Clear enough?

Oh, I forgot ... and here's hoping we don't lynch another town,

I Vote:Aladdin/palathadric

[LEGOman273]

Hum ... yes you did!

The plan seems to be to "investigate" me, then publicly claim the "results" as scum (where I'm in fact town) and have me lynched!

So you would indirectly wind up killing me!

Clear enough?

Oh, I forgot ... and here's hoping we don't lynch another town,

I Vote:Aladdin/palathadric

I still don't know why they would tell you their plans.

[LEGOman273]

Let me break the Scum plan down for you:

What was said:

Jack says that the Scum contacted him, and told him that they would say that he is Scum. Jack says that Red sent him the message.

Jack says that Red is the Scum Role-Cop; pushes for her lynch. Says that if Red were Town, she would be dead.

Aladdin is obviously Scum, and many people voted for him.

Jack then accuses Aladdin, and helps lynch him.

When Aladdin comes up Scum, Jack will be thought to be a Townie.

The plan (and the flaw):

Scum keeps Red alive because 1. Cindy is more of a threat, 2. They need Red alive for the next part of the plan.

Red states that Aladdin is Scum, but Jack says that Red is Scum. Jack is trying to discredit Red's results. By keeping Red alive, the Scum are able to accuse her. Not so if she were dead. By accusing her, they could convince people to lynch her. We lose our Cop, and our only Scum-killing opportunity.

Warning! Major Flaw In Scum's Plan Approaching!

Jack then votes for Aladdin.

If Red were Scum, and thereby her results were incorrect, why would Jack vote for Aladdin?

Because Aladdin is as good as dead. When he is lynched, he will come up Scum. When he comes up Scum, those who voted for him will be considered Town. Jack is hoping that the Town will forget his earlier comment.

We did not.

All this being said, we need to focus on lynching Aladdin. We can worry about Jack and Rapunzel tomorrow.

[LEGOman273]

Sorry. Aladdin was the one to send Jack the message, not Red. The point is still valid, though.

[Kadabra]

Er, no. I'm pretty sure Jack is town. Aladdin sent him a PM saying that he was town and being framed by me, and that Jack was next. Aladdin is the one saying I'm the Scum role-cop and is pushing for my lynch.

[Piratedave84]

*SNIP*

OMG!

You are funny!

Let me break this down for you!

Jack says that the Scum contacted him, and told him that they would say that he is Scum. Jack says that Red sent him the message.

Wrong Aladin contacted me :

Aladin on the other hand never contacted me, and I never contacted me .... BUT ... just now I received a very interesting letter from Aladin outlining the scum plan for tomorrow (spoiler: It concerns me!). I shared that information with individuals I trust and am waiting on their take on it; here's mine:

Jack says that Red is the Scum Role-Cop; pushes for her lynch. Says that if Red were Town, she would be dead.

What I ACTUALLY said (and first time I ever mentionned Red-besides voting for her on day 1):

We have to make sure we get 1 scum per day to lynch if we are to survive and it is therefore imperative that we look into every leads we have.

I contacted Red ("new" red that is) on the first day and she assured me she was a GG.

Aladdin is obviously Scum, and many people voted for him.

Jack then accuses Aladdin, and helps lynch him.

When Aladdin comes up Scum, Jack will be thought to be a Townie.

Jack voted for Aladin seeing that Aladin sent him a very very strange letter! Jack is definitely town and can be verified by some individuals.

The plan (and the flaw):

Scum keeps Red alive because 1. Cindy is more of a threat, 2. They need Red alive for the next part of the plan.

Red states that Aladdin is Scum, but Jack says that Red is Scum. Jack is trying to discredit Red's results. By keeping Red alive, the Scum are able to accuse her. Not so if she were dead. By accusing her, they could convince people to lynch her. We lose our Cop, and our only Scum-killing opportunity.

Warning! Major Flaw In Scum's Plan Approaching!

Jack then votes for Aladdin.

If Red were Scum, and thereby her results were incorrect, why would Jack vote for Aladdin?

Because Aladdin is as good as dead. When he is lynched, he will come up Scum. When he comes up Scum, those who voted for him will be considered Town. Jack is hoping that the Town will forget his earlier comment.

We did not.

Your logic here baffles me! How did you get that from what I said?

Also why did you ask me for the PM chain letters between Aladin and I?

You're scum!

You never contacted me before ther was a need for you to prove my guilt, I on the other hand have it from many townsfolks that you are suspected scum and in my opinion, you sealed the deal!

thank you for outing yourself!

[LEGOman273]

OMG!

You are funny!

Let me break this down for you!

Wrong Aladin contacted me :

What I ACTUALLY said (and first time I ever mentionned Red-besides voting for her on day 1):

Jack voted for Aladin seeing that Aladin sent him a very very strange letter! Jack is definitely town and can be verified by some individuals.

Your logic here baffles me! How did you get that from what I said?

Also why did you ask me for the PM chain letters between Aladin and I?

You're scum!

You never contacted me before ther was a need for you to prove my guilt, I on the other hand have it from many townsfolks that you are suspected scum and in my opinion, you sealed the deal!

thank you for outing yourself!

1. I corrected myself when I saw that I had made a mistake.

2. I wouldn't tell you (a Scum) my plan.

3. Many Townies? There is a group of Townies with mutual trust large enough to lynch someone.

4. I'm not Scum. As I mentioned before, there is a large group of Townies that would defend me.

5. I did not out myself. Accusing someone who is acting Scummy is outing oneself? You accused Aladdin; you must be Scum.

[Piratedave84]

I feel that I do not need to defend myself more than has been done seeing that I feel enough townies support/believe me.

You on the other hand ... I don't think you get the whole picture, but it's ok, you'll get it one day!

Go ahead, lynch me ... my soul is at peace, I have nothing to add, I'm a good guy.

If it takes my death to prove it, then so be it!

I would now like to point out that should I die;

Snow White started it, Snow White accused me and condemned me, remember it!

[LEGOman273]

Don't listen to the raving lunatic. We'll worry about him tommorow. Let's get one more vote for Aladdin, lynch him, and end the day.

[Dakar A]

Don't listen to the raving lunatic. We'll worry about him tommorow. Let's get one more vote for Aladdin, lynch him, and end the day.

Two votes. Why so quick to end him, though? I know the general consensus is that he's scum, and voting for your accuser didn't help goldilocks any, but look how she ended up aligned. I think we need to comb over the facts more, and find a more definite lynch. If we don't get a scum tonight, we're as good as sunk.

[LEGOman273]

Two votes. Why so quick to end him, though? I know the general consensus is that he's scum, and voting for your accuser didn't help goldilocks any, but look how she ended up aligned. I think we need to comb over the facts more, and find a more definite lynch. If we don't get a scum tonight, we're as good as sunk.

The longer we wait, the more chance the Scum have to convince us to vote for a Townie (like Red).