Alex the Great Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 Yes don't lynch him yet, we have to be sure of this first. Don't worry Snow, it won't be Red.
Dakar A Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 The longer we wait, the more chance the Scum have to convince us to vote for a Townie (like Red). Well, our votes are our own. But I probably won't vote for Red today, but she may turn out to be scum. It's still a possibility, however slight.
JackJonespaw Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 The longer we wait, the more chance the Scum have to convince us to vote for a Townie (like Red). But are you sure she's a townie? Based on Aladdin's evidence, and other evidence placed before, it seems to be like she is scum.
Dakar A Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 But are you sure she's a townie? Based on Aladdin's evidence, and other evidence placed before, it seems to be like she is scum. You can't be sure she's scum either. She's OBVIOUSLY one of the two, but going on posts alone, there's no definite alliance as of right now, she's only been playing for one day.
LEGOman273 Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 But are you sure she's a townie? Based on Aladdin's evidence, and other evidence placed before, it seems to be like she is scum. I don't trust Aladdin. I suspect him of being Scum. I did trust Cindy, and from things that we discussed, I believe that Red is Town.
Kadabra Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 Is there any evidence for a lynch more concrete than a Cop investigation? If you wait and don't lynch Aladdin, he'll just try and confuse you more. If he's town, I'm lynched tomorrow. We're not at LyLo yet, so either way to get one Scum for sure.
JaseTJ Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 I think I trust Snow here... Cindy did, and if there was ever one person I trusted I think it was her. Jack, you did seem to say that Red was scummy, right before you voted for Alladin... I may have misheard you again, but I dunno...
JackJonespaw Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 Hm...I suppose I'll UNVOTE: LITTLE RED RIDING HOOD (Kadabra)
Piratedave84 Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 I think I trust Snow here... Cindy did, and if there was ever one person I trusted I think it was her. Jack, you did seem to say that Red was scummy, right before you voted for Alladin... I may have misheard you again, but I dunno... I really don't think I did, i did say that she had contacted me and claimed GG which I was/am still pretty confident of! Hopefully my friends will stand up and defend me, hopefully this mess with Snow will be resolved before end of day
Donut Posted April 16, 2012 Posted April 16, 2012 Is there any evidence for a lynch more concrete than a Cop investigation? If you wait and don't lynch Aladdin, he'll just try and confuse you more. If he's town, I'm lynched tomorrow. We're not at LyLo yet, so either way to get one Scum for sure. Getting one scum, two, or three doesn't matter. If the town can't get all them, the game is over. We cannot think about short term goals. I think I trust Snow here... Cindy did, and if there was ever one person I trusted I think it was her. Jack, you did seem to say that Red was scummy, right before you voted for Alladin... I may have misheard you again, but I dunno... Here you again with mishearing stuff, please provide the evidence. Thanks!
JaseTJ Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Evidence? Of what? Him wording things confusingly?
RPGer Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Wait, what the heck? Why are you all changing your votes from that scumbag? There is no evidence for him.
Piratedave84 Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Wait, what the heck? Why are you all changing your votes from that scumbag? There is no evidence for him. What are you referring to? Charming was the only one to un-vote Red There are still 5 votes for Aladdin
RPGer Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 What are you referring to? Charming was the only one to un-vote Red There are still 5 votes for Aladdin Umm, didn't Puss in Boots change his vote too?
Dakar A Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Umm, didn't Puss in Boots change his vote too? I believe I was the only one to change my vote. The pressure cooker was applied to Aladdin (Votes against him), and he came up and defended himself, just like your friend Goldilocks. She was lynched, and ended up dead. I didn't want a repeat of that, because we cannot affird to vote against someone simply because they are "scumbags". I know that a cop result is good evidence, but Red could be lying.
Chromeknight Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Ok. I've been a bit absent. Sorry everybody. Man your fighting takes some sifting. But the good news is its made who is on whose side clear. Currently, Aladdin vs RedRidingHood is a game of he said she said. People are somewhat swayed by Aladdins claims, enough to doubt whether lynching his is the best thing for town. But not so convinced that anyone really wants to vote for Hood, just in case she's telling the truth and actually is the cop. As a preamble, I really thought Cindy's plan would work. And it didn't. Why? I can think of two reasons. Either the scum didn't care, thought they could take the heat, or they thought they could use Cindy's plan to lynch a townie. So, my thought is if I don't want to risk lynching the town cop but want to test her claim, lynch tole person that is so aimlessly vocal about her trustworthiness. Snow White. And not just to test hood but because, frankly princess you seem to have come off the rails. Aladdin tells jack a plan he's heard to kill jack tomorrow. You reply Why would the Scum tell you that you will be killed? That would incriminate the person who told you. Sounds like a Scum tactic to get us to lynch our Cop. Not going to work. clearly you've grasped that Aladdin, if scum, has no reason to spill his scum-buddies' secrets and make lynching Jack harder. But then you step off the logic train and say that if Jack dies that incrimates the person who warned him?Why do you reject the revelation of this plan? Our answer is just a post or two later. 1. I corrected myself when I saw that I had made a mistake. 2. I wouldn't tell you (a Scum) my plan. 3. Many Townies? There is a group of Townies with mutual trust large enough to lynch someone. 4. I'm not Scum. As I mentioned before, there is a large group of Townies that would defend me. 5. I did not out myself. Accusing someone who is acting Scummy is outing oneself? You accused Aladdin; you must be Scum. Look at point two. Ignoring the name calling, you all but admit its your plan. You previously made comment about the axe and how it pointed to Jack, the same detail that Aladdin refers to. You are defending Red, the investigator, who has already said he planned to investigate Jack. Now that the plan is in the open you resort to name calling and threats of 'we'll get you tomorrow'Let's put your other numbered claims to the test. Yes there is a group of townies who trust each other, but honey you're not in it. Cindy cut you out. Said you had issues with keeping your mouth shut. ie, blabbing her secrets... As for a large group who'll defend you? You sure about that. I'm sure hood will. Possibly Puss in boots. And another friend to make a tidy group of four? Mermaid perhaps? And point five... Ah. The old OMFGUS. I called someone a scum, you defended them, you must be scum! Convenient. Now for those watching. I freely admit I might be wrong on this. I don't think so, If I am, we'll have lost only one more day andthe true scum will be unmasked, Aladdin and the guys he is trying to protect and make seem innocent. We'd have a clear run of lynch targets with no doubts about. On the other hand, if Snow is scum, we can roll up her cronies and put the game to bed. Since we're cautious about voting Red, let's see what happens with Snow. And don't forget. Money where your mouth is. vote:Snow White(LEGOman273) A dollar says I get an OMFGUS from snow.
Dakar A Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Yes there is a group of townies who trust each other, but honey you're not in it. Cindy cut you out. Said you had issues with keeping your mouth shut. ie, blabbing her secrets... As for a large group who'll defend you? You sure about that. I'm sure hood will. Possibly Puss in boots. And another friend to make a tidy group of four? Mermaid perhaps? And point five... Ah. The old OMFGUS. I called someone a scum, you defended them, you must be scum! Convenient. I've been suspicious of her ever since Cindy left her out of our group PM and she started asking questions why. I believe that she was either thought to be the Town cop by Cindy, or was being used as bait, seeing if she could draw the scum away from her by making it seem like she was the cop. If the latter is true, then that means the leak was outside of Akaddin, Charming, White rabbit, AND Snow, because all of them were informed that Cindy would be protecting Snow, and nothing else. Unless, of course, the scum either A. Already knew who the Cop was, and decided to kill the doctor first, or B. They decided that even though it would be better to kill the doctor, because she also happened to be a leader of the Town, effectively killing two birds with one stone, rather than killing the cop ( maybe due to INACTIVITY). That's my musings, see fit to use them as you wish.
LEGOman273 Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 Ok. I've been a bit absent. Sorry everybody. Man your fighting takes some sifting. But the good news is its made who is on whose side clear. Currently, Aladdin vs RedRidingHood is a game of he said she said. People are somewhat swayed by Aladdins claims, enough to doubt whether lynching his is the best thing for town. But not so convinced that anyone really wants to vote for Hood, just in case she's telling the truth and actually is the cop. As a preamble, I really thought Cindy's plan would work. And it didn't. Why? I can think of two reasons. Either the scum didn't care, thought they could take the heat, or they thought they could use Cindy's plan to lynch a townie. So, my thought is if I don't want to risk lynching the town cop but want to test her claim, lynch tole person that is so aimlessly vocal about her trustworthiness. Snow White. And not just to test hood but because, frankly princess you seem to have come off the rails. Aladdin tells jack a plan he's heard to kill jack tomorrow. You reply clearly you've grasped that Aladdin, if scum, has no reason to spill his scum-buddies' secrets and make lynching Jack harder. But then you step off the logic train and say that if Jack dies that incrimates the person who warned him? Why do you reject the revelation of this plan? Our answer is just a post or two later. Look at point two. Ignoring the name calling, you all but admit its your plan. You previously made comment about the axe and how it pointed to Jack, the same detail that Aladdin refers to. You are defending Red, the investigator, who has already said he planned to investigate Jack. Now that the plan is in the open you resort to name calling and threats of 'we'll get you tomorrow' Let's put your other numbered claims to the test. Yes there is a group of townies who trust each other, but honey you're not in it. Cindy cut you out. Said you had issues with keeping your mouth shut. ie, blabbing her secrets... As for a large group who'll defend you? You sure about that. I'm sure hood will. Possibly Puss in boots. And another friend to make a tidy group of four? Mermaid perhaps? And point five... Ah. The old OMFGUS. I called someone a scum, you defended them, you must be scum! Convenient. Now for those watching. I freely admit I might be wrong on this. I don't think so, If I am, we'll have lost only one more day andthe true scum will be unmasked, Aladdin and the guys he is trying to protect and make seem innocent. We'd have a clear run of lynch targets with no doubts about. On the other hand, if Snow is scum, we can roll up her cronies and put the game to bed. Since we're cautious about voting Red, let's see what happens with Snow. And don't forget. Money where your mouth is. vote:Snow White(LEGOman273) A dollar says I get an OMFGUS from snow. 1. The Scum know who their team-mates are. They would not tell any secrets to a non-Scum. Thus, the information that was told to Jack cannot be trusted. 2. How did I admit that this was my plan? I have a plan, not a Scum one, and I do not intend to tell anyone what it is. 3. I don't "resort" to "name-calling". I am accusing suspected Scum. Scum, when under constant pressure, will (most of the time: especially n00bs) crack and incriminate themselves. 4. In what way did I not keep my mouth shut? I was intentionally vague with any plans that I knew about. 5. Who did you call a Scum that I defended? 6. I was mocking him. I'm sorry that I didn't insert a . He said that I had outed myself because I accused him. I was pointing out how foolish that was. 7. I repeat: I am not Scum. Investigate me, if you want. I have nothing to hide. In fact, I would like it if you did, as then you would trust me. 8. No OMFGUS from me. I trust you, as I did before, and will continue to do so until you do something Scummy. Dollar, please.
Sandy Posted April 17, 2012 Author Posted April 17, 2012 Current Vote Tally: Aladdin/palathadric: 5 (Kadabra, RPGer, JaseTJ, LEGOman273, Piratedave84) Red Riding Hood/Kadabra: 1 (palathadric) Rapunzel/RPGer: 1 (Dakar A) Snow White/LEGOman273: 1 (Chromeknight) Non-voters: 3 (Alex the Great, Donut, Jackjonespaw) You have about 15 hours to reach a conviction, or the day will end without a lynch.
RPGer Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 I believe I was the only one to change my vote. The pressure cooker was applied to Aladdin (Votes against him), and he came up and defended himself, just like your friend Goldilocks. She was lynched, and ended up dead. I didn't want a repeat of that, because we cannot affird to vote against someone simply because they are "scumbags". I know that a cop result is good evidence, but Red could be lying. But she has to be lying, it's quite unlikely.
LEGOman273 Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 But she has to be lying, it's quite unlikely. How so? We didn't know who the Town Cop was until Red started participating. Noone claimed; noone gave any information. Only Red. Who do you think is the Town Cop.
Dakar A Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 But she has to be lying, it's quite unlikely. I agree, one of them had to be lying, but that still doesn't signify that she is scum. She could be lying for some as-yet-unknown alterior motive. But highly unlikely.
JaseTJ Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 You should all keep in mind, that if we don't lynch a scum tonight, we're screwed... Which means we need to lynch somebody. Take your time, but make sure you vote before the day is out.
LEGOman273 Posted April 17, 2012 Posted April 17, 2012 You should all keep in mind, that if we don't lynch a scum tonight, we're screwed... Which means we need to lynch somebody. Take your time, but make sure you vote before the day is out. We all know what we need to do.
Recommended Posts