Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Eeth's death was unorthodox (I mean, it would have made more sense to kill someone that was more active, like Coryn or Master Corobb, wouldn't it have? Maybe the Scum thought they would have protection, I guess I don't know.) Like I said before, the scum like to baffle the town with their first kill (even though I still think this was the work of the SK). In any case, the scum would have had a hell of a time trying to kill one of us last night.
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Still, it is something to consider. We still don't have a hard-tacks Night Action result from any of our Power Roles, so that means that our best suspect is Master Monn, as a result of his strange speech and filler words. I guess we will see how things play out as the Day progresses. So it no longer makes Barriss a suspect; now it's just "something to consider", and you decide that you'd rather take what others have said and switch over to making Voolvif your main suspect?
Dannylonglegs Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Ah, I disagree with Jedi Kellyns, I don't believe this was a Serial Killer's doing, I believe it was a Sith's work, and that the use of droids masks the identity of the Sith even further than a dark silhouette would. I could be wrong, but I hope I'm not; I will be a very, very happy Jedi if I'm right. " I see, a fair thought. I still think it could be either Sith or Serial Killer, but if you've received new info, I'd love to hear it. (like conformation that the SK was blocked or something) The droid must have been controlled by a Sith, remotly, like those Battle Droids were a decade ago. I'm glad that two deaths did not happen last night, because even though it could have been a Sith, there is a larger chance of a Jedi being killed instead. And, Master Moudama, I believe that Master Koth was a male. Not "must have," unless you know something I don't. This whole statement sounds like you know something I don't. Except that last part which is kinda useless. Like I said before, the scum like to baffle the town with their first kill (even though I still think this was the work of the SK). In any case, the scum would have had a hell of a time trying to kill one of us last night. I'm inclined to buy your Serial Killer theory, because, again, from my experiences in the archives, silent people are easy SK targets.
Sisco Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Okay, I'm back. I've been tied up with some surprise family visits that began right in the middle of day one. Every time I logged on, I'd be called away for a picture or a family game or something of the like. But they're back in Georgia now. I'm here and ready to make up for lost time! One sith down! But I will mourn Master Koth. He was always nice to me when he passed by. So, Voolvif Monn eh? What's this nonsense about gender?
MacK Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Okay, I'm back. I've been tied up with some surprise family visits that began right in the middle of day one. Every time I logged on, I'd be called away for a picture or a family game or something of the like. But they're back in Georgia now. I'm here and ready to make up for lost time! One sith down! But I will mourn Master Koth. He was always nice to me when he passed by. So, Voolvif Monn eh? What's this nonsense about gender? Nice of you to show up. Do you have anything useful to say? Until you do you will retain my FoS.
Dannylonglegs Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 One sith down! But I will mourn Master Koth. He was always nice to me when he passed by. So, Voolvif Monn eh? What's this nonsense about gender? I understand your silence, but this statement seems relatively useless. If you really need clarification, Voolvif corrected someone who accidentally called Koth a she. But really, it's such a non-issue that it's almost suspicious that you'd make something of it.
Kadabra Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Okay, I'm back. I've been tied up with some surprise family visits that began right in the middle of day one. Every time I logged on, I'd be called away for a picture or a family game or something of the like. But they're back in Georgia now. I'm here and ready to make up for lost time! One sith down! But I will mourn Master Koth. He was always nice to me when he passed by. So, Voolvif Monn eh? What's this nonsense about gender? "Click chirp chirp." (Avoiding responding to your accusers, I see. As far as the SK vs. Scum debate, and the possibility of a Town vig, here's the possibilities as I see them: A. We have a vigilante and no SK. Either the scum or vig was blocked last night, their target had Doc protection, or he was Bulletproof. Highly unlikely, considering yesterday's discussion. B. We have a SK and no vig. Either the scum or SK was blocked last night, their target had Doc protection, or he was Bulletproof. Quite possible. C. We have a SK and a vig. Either the scum, SK or vig was blocked last night or their target had Doc protection. One of the other two was blocked/thwarted by a Doc/their target was Bulletproof. Possible. D. We have both. The Scum converted instead of killed last night, one of the two killing actions was thwarted. Possible. E. We have both. The SK has to flip a coin for killing priveleges, and came up tails last night. One killing action was thwarted. Possible. I'm inclined to go with B. or D. Thoughts?)
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Okay, I'm back. I've been tied up with some surprise family visits that began right in the middle of day one. Every time I logged on, I'd be called away for a picture or a family game or something of the like. But they're back in Georgia now. I'm here and ready to make up for lost time! One sith down! But I will mourn Master Koth. He was always nice to me when he passed by. So, Voolvif Monn eh? What's this nonsense about gender? While your excuse is definitely excusable, I don't like how briefly you summed everything up. First you just make the obligatory "Yay, we got a scum, but someone died!" post, and then follow it up with useless roleplaying. That's not even the worst part, though - you then commented on one of our suspicions in such a rushed and awkward sort of way that I think you're very likely to be scum. If nothing else comes up, I think I'd like to lynch you today.
Sisco Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Nice of you to show up. Do you have anything useful to say? Until you do you will retain my FoS. While your excuse is definitely excusable, I don't like how briefly you summed everything up. First you just make the obligatory "Yay, we got a scum, but someone died!" post, and then follow it up with useless roleplaying. That's not even the worst part, though - you then commented on one of our suspicions in such a rushed and awkward sort of way that I think you're very likely to be scum. If nothing else comes up, I think I'd like to lynch you today. I'm sorry for summing up in a rushed manner. I just feel bad for being away from the action lately, and I'm so tired that I'm not thinking clearly. I think I'll turn in, and come back later when I can think clearly and contribute to the conversation.
Flipz Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Click chirp chirp." (Avoiding responding to your accusers, I see. As far as the SK vs. Scum debate, and the possibility of a Town vig, here's the possibilities as I see them: A. We have a vigilante and no SK. Either the scum or vig was blocked last night, their target had Doc protection, or he was Bulletproof. Highly unlikely, considering yesterday's discussion. B. We have a SK and no vig. Either the scum or SK was blocked last night, their target had Doc protection, or he was Bulletproof. Quite possible. C. We have a SK and a vig. Either the scum, SK or vig was blocked last night or their target had Doc protection. One of the other two was blocked/thwarted by a Doc/their target was Bulletproof. Possible. D. We have both. The Scum converted instead of killed last night, one of the two killing actions was thwarted. Possible. E. We have both. The SK has to flip a coin for killing priveleges, and came up tails last night. One killing action was thwarted. Possible. I'm inclined to go with B. or D. Thoughts?) "There's another possibility: the SK was successfully treated and turned into a Townie. (Remember, the reason we know there is a SK is because we have a Shrink. ) I'm waiting on confirmation, though, and now that I think about it, Master Koth's murder does smell like a SK kill. I'll still hold out hope that we managed to get rid of the SK already. "
Kadabra Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "There's another possibility: the SK was successfully treated and turned into a Townie. (Remember, the reason we know there is a SK is because we have a Shrink. ) I'm waiting on confirmation, though, and now that I think about it, Master Koth's murder does smell like a SK kill. I'll still hold out hope that we managed to get rid of the SK already. " "Chirp chirp, chirp chirp." (Ah, true. A possibility, but an unlikely one. I doubt we'd be so lucky as to cure our SK and get a Scum lynched last night. The optimism is nice, but I don't find it likely.)
badboytje88 Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Click chirp chirp." (Avoiding responding to your accusers, I see. As far as the SK vs. Scum debate, and the possibility of a Town vig, here's the possibilities as I see them: A. We have a vigilante and no SK. Either the scum or vig was blocked last night, their target had Doc protection, or he was Bulletproof. Highly unlikely, considering yesterday's discussion. B. We have a SK and no vig. Either the scum or SK was blocked last night, their target had Doc protection, or he was Bulletproof. Quite possible. C. We have a SK and a vig. Either the scum, SK or vig was blocked last night or their target had Doc protection. One of the other two was blocked/thwarted by a Doc/their target was Bulletproof. Possible. D. We have both. The Scum converted instead of killed last night, one of the two killing actions was thwarted. Possible. E. We have both. The SK has to flip a coin for killing priveleges, and came up tails last night. One killing action was thwarted. Possible. I'm inclined to go with B. or D. Thoughts?) If I might ad to your option D. If the scum realy has the ability to convert, it might be so that they can't kill during a night when they convert someone. I'm inclined to B or D too. I hope it's B. D would really suck...
Kadabra Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 If I might ad to your option D. If the scum realy has the ability to convert, it might be so that they can't kill during a night when they convert someone. I'm inclined to B or D too. I hope it's B. D would really suck... "Click chirp clack." (Which was already strongly implied. If they could convert and kill then I wouldn't have made that its own option, as the conversion could just be tacked on to any of the other scenarios. Useless post pretending to be helpful and repetitions of the suspicions I already voiced without adding anything to the discussion noted.)
badboytje88 Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Click chirp clack." (Which was already strongly implied. If they could convert and kill then I wouldn't have made that its own option, as the conversion could just be tacked on to any of the other scenarios. Useless post pretending to be helpful and repetitions of the suspicions I already voiced without adding anything to the discussion noted.) Oh I totally misread that. It' so dank early...
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 I'm sorry for summing up in a rushed manner. I just feel bad for being away from the action lately, and I'm so tired that I'm not thinking clearly. I think I'll turn in, and come back later when I can think clearly and contribute to the conversation. That, to me, indicates that you made a statement only because you didn't want to continue to seem inactive. It indicates that you were trying to appear active like a good Townie should be, but as I've said before, Townies don't need to try to look like Townies.
TheBoyWonder Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Voolvif Moon and Il Seosty are my main suspects. I voted for Volviff Moon yesterday, and v repeatedly called him out! Did we get a response? No. Volvif Moon, speak up.
Flipz Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Okay, I'm back. I've been tied up with some surprise family visits that began right in the middle of day one. Every time I logged on, I'd be called away for a picture or a family game or something of the like. But they're back in Georgia now. I'm here and ready to make up for lost time! One sith down! But I will mourn Master Koth. He was always nice to me when he passed by. So, Voolvif Monn eh? What's this nonsense about gender? I'm sorry for summing up in a rushed manner. I just feel bad for being away from the action lately, and I'm so tired that I'm not thinking clearly. I think I'll turn in, and come back later when I can think clearly and contribute to the conversation. "That still does not explain why you decided to vote, out of the blue, merely skimming through to see who was most likely to get a vote. There were 48 hours left in the day, and the day could not end before then without your vote. Surely you could have waited a day, to see if there was a candidate available then. Our votes our precious; they cannot be taken back, and if a bandwagon starts on someone who turns out to be innocent, it is almost impossible to stop it. It would have been more helpful to the loyal Jedi for you to simply not vote, and accept the penalty; the risk of starting a fast-moving, unstoppable bandwagon on a potentially loyal Jedi is simply too great to vote willy-nilly. It may sound harsh, but it's clear, given the rules, that careless voting is more dangerous to us than any other action." "And to be frank, I have been in your shoes and yet managed to hold my own and remain an active aid to the Good Guys. Forgive me if I come off a bit harsh, but: if I can do it, so can you." "Master Koon's suspect list matches my own. Allow me to express my thoughts thusly:" "FoS: Ili Seosty (Sisco) and FoS: Voolvif Moon."
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 I'm sorry for summing up in a rushed manner. I just feel bad for being away from the action lately, and I'm so tired that I'm not thinking clearly. I think I'll turn in, and come back later when I can think clearly and contribute to the conversation. Like 3PO said, why even bother to post if you have nothing to add? Posting simply because you want to look town (or, as you put it, 'feel bad about being away from the action') is not town - if you really were town, you wouldn't feel the need to post. FoS: Ili Seosty (Sisco) I REALLY want to lynch you today now.
Jedi master Brick Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Sorry I am late today I must of slept in. Mace Windu was mafia, no surprise there. The choice to kill Koth suggests it could be a vigilante kill, or it could be because they thought it is very likely CPO and Master Corobb would be protected. Volvif Moon's behaviour has been very sucspious, not contributing much and overacting. He was been ignorant yesterterday after we had found a good target, ignorrance is one of the biggest threats this temple have. Then we have Ili Seosty who rushed to vote yesterday on the pretence of being busy, that is no exuse. Think about it, if we all did that we who'd have 2 dead Jedi. Today's vote will be spit between those 2 people unless something new is. Also has anyone considererd that 1 of the people Mace named could be scum to through us off the scent because that is a possibility we should look into
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 ... Volvif Moon's behaviour has been very sucspious, not contributing much ... Funny you should say that, because that's exactly what you're doing.Nice summary.
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Anyways, although I'm not 100% clear, I did lead the lynch on scum yesterday, so I urge all townies who have night actions to talk to me in private so I can get everybody organized. This sounds ridiculously scummy to me. "I lead the lynch so you should all trust me. "Let us begin by examining this latest murder. Why was Master Koth chosen for death? If anyone knows why the Sith would want him dead over the rest of us, please speak up, either publicly or privately." "Also, if anyone has any useful information from the Night, I urge you to contact someone you trust with the results of your efforts. Everyone, if you recieve important information from one of these individuals, give them a code name and then contact me. This is particularly true if a Blocker or Cop reports their result to you." As far as Master Koth's death is concerned, I wouldn't be surprised if it were the work of a sith. Why should the target the more active members from the start when there's a good chance that they'll be protected. Instead focus on a random character, this is assuming that Koth was not a power role, which I am not altogether sure of but I kind of doubt, and then hope to lynch the active members once they get one or two lynches wrong. ...Am i making sense? Perhaps the death of anoter jedi is cloudy my senses. ...I hope not.
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Just adding to the conversation about last night's kill. There could also just be a vigilante, who just decided not to kill... Killing randomly, is perhaps not a great idea, just saying. Although I don't know, if there is a serial killer, it may mean we don't have a vig, often it is one or the other. I will also FoS: Ili Seosty, rereading statements, collecting your thoughts, and forming a helpful contribution really does not have to take that long, and even if your meditations did not allow for even that, posting useless things to appear contributing is not okay. It looks like you have something to hide that way. Somehow, I doubt we will get a proper explanation out of you, so I don't know how much good this FoS will do. This sounds ridiculously scummy to me. "I lead the lynch so you should all trust me. Oh, he has a knack for doing this, he loves to lead, basically trying a similair thing in Yakuza a similair situation. Saying it IS pretty scummy, but of course in that other situation he turned out to be good...
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Well, judging by the fact that the kill was performed with a vibroblade, I'd say it's highly possible that that was the work of the serial killer. Even if it wasn't, it's a common scum strategy to try to baffle the town. I would worry about it if I were you. Are you being sarcastic in the first point? If not, then I think it's ridiculous to base your ideas about it being a scum or serial killer by the image shown by Master Yoda. He wouldn't be allowed to give it away like that. I agree with your second point though. Scum like doing this.
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Are you being sarcastic in the first point? If not, then I think it's ridiculous to base your ideas about it being a scum or serial killer by the image shown by Master Yoda. He wouldn't be allowed to give it away like that. Actually, from what I know of previous situations, I believe it is common for one type of weapon to be attributed to a certain type of killer.
Flipz Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Are you being sarcastic in the first point? If not, then I think it's ridiculous to base your ideas about it being a scum or serial killer by the image shown by Master Yoda. He wouldn't be allowed to give it away like that. I agree with your second point though. Scum like doing this. "Au contraire, such things are often hinted at in the records of the night. The exact identity of the killer is rarely hinted at in the images, but the source of the kill (i.e. Scum kill vs. Vigilante kill vs. Serial Killer kill) is almost always indicated in some way. I do agree that, until I get a definite result from our Shrink, further speculation on this point is somewhat counterproductive." I will also FoS: Ili Seosty, rereading statements, collecting your thoughts, and forming a helpful contribution really does not have to take that long, and even if your meditations did not allow for even that, posting useless things to appear contributing is not okay. It looks like you have something to hide that way. Somehow, I doubt we will get a proper explanation out of you, so I don't know how much good this FoS will do. "Do not worry, my friend, it will do plenty of good. If she refuses to explain herself properly, we simply lynch her."
Recommended Posts