Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Useless chatter duly noted." "Actually, now that I think about it, you were similarly unhelpful yesterday, AND you voted for Jedi Ahsoka well after the main discussion had concluded that she was, in fact, innocent. At the time, any chance of questioning you about it was rather drowned out by ex-Master Windu's confession, but since it's nice and quiet now: Care to explain yourself?" Okay, yesterday I tried to ignore it, but as of now I am ver much agreeing with Master Corobb (or are you a Padawan, I think I must have asked before). Volvif, you have been far too unhelpful for my liking. FoS: Voolvif Monn (JackJonespaw) Eeth's death was unorthodox (I mean, it would have made more sense to kill someone that was more active, like Coryn or Master Corobb, wouldn't it have? Maybe the Scum thought they would have protection, I guess I don't know.), but I think as well that it a Scum for a Town is actually an okay ratio. Master Koth will be missed, but if we can prevent his killer from killing any more, I think that his death will have not been in vain. Also, I have a new suspect to bring to the table: Bariss Offee (Scorpiox). My resoning? When Mace was accusing C-3P0 of being the Godfather, she kept saying "Why would a Sith out his Lord?". How did she know that that was what the Godfather was called? Care to explain yourself, Padawan Offee? Perhaps you could come to the realization that it is entirely possible that either Coryn or Corobb could be sith. As far as your second comment is concerned, you seem to be certain that the sith call their godfather "Lord". How would you know this for certain unless you are a sith? Although I wouldn't mind seeing Bariss Offee lynched for all the mindless petting and stroking he did yesterday while we are in a somewhat serious situation. He does not appear to be taking it seriously at all!
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Do not worry, my friend, it will do plenty of good. If she refuses to explain herself properly, we simply lynch her." Wow, thanks for stating the obvious.
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Au contraire, such things are often hinted at in the records of the night. The exact identity of the killer is rarely hinted at in the images, but the source of the kill (i.e. Scum kill vs. Vigilante kill vs. Serial Killer kill) is almost always indicated in some way. Like the "axe that killed Mister Bear?" (You know what I'm talking about). I've done a lot of " " today.
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Like the "axe that killed Mister Bear?" (You know what I'm talking about). I've done a lot of " " today. He is actually correct, for a good example, check Yakuza Mafia.
Flipz Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Wow, thanks for stating the obvious. "Forgive me for attempting to reassure you. Moons and stars..."
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 He is actually correct, for a good example, check Yakuza Mafia. One in a million. Oh and by the way I would once again like to FoS: Ili Seosty (Sisco)
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 One in a million. Oh and by the way I would once again like to FoS: Ili Seosty (Sisco) Witchbreed. Imhotep. All these Holovids showed it...
Flipz Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" "I have just recieved word of a Scum investigation result! I have to get some sleep tonight, but I have turned this name over to Coryn and C-3PO, and after my nap if they have not yet taken the proper steps behind the scenes and revealed the name of the Scum, I will."
Fred Daniel Yam Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" "I have just recieved word of a Scum investigation result! I have to get some sleep tonight, but I have turned this name over to Coryn and C-3PO, and after my nap if they have not yet taken the proper steps behind the scenes and revealed the name of the Scum, I will." This is great news! I have been thinking over this all night and I have come to the conclusion of FoS: Voolvif Moon (JackJonespaw)
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Witchbreed. Imhotep. All these Holovids showed it... I rest my case. "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" "I have just recieved word of a Scum investigation result! I have to get some sleep tonight, but I have turned this name over to Coryn and C-3PO, and after my nap if they have not yet taken the proper steps behind the scenes and revealed the name of the Scum, I will." Um, thanks for turning it over to two potential scum. Why didn't you just tell us yourself? Would it have disturbed your nappy duties? This is great news! I have been thinking over this all night and I have come to the conclusion of FoS: Voolvif Moon (JackJonespaw) You've been thinking of what exactly? And how does your quote tie into you FoSing Voolvif Monn? Wouldn't you like to wait for the result to be revealed? Or do you already know?
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" "I have just recieved word of a Scum investigation result! I have to get some sleep tonight, but I have turned this name over to Coryn and C-3PO, and after my nap if they have not yet taken the proper steps behind the scenes and revealed the name of the Scum, I will." What? Why not just say it, what will handing it over to those other two do? I don't get this. All you are doing is basically stopping the discussion until we get word of it....
Flipz Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 What? Why not just say it, what will handing it over to those other two do? I don't get this. All you are doing is basically stopping the discussion until we get word of it.... "We have to say this in such a way that we don't accidentally reveal our investigator. "
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "We have to say this in such a way that we don't accidentally reveal our investigator. " Here is an idea: Person X was investigated, as scum. Bam, done. I'm a genius.
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "We have to say this in such a way that we don't accidentally reveal our investigator. " And telling us that you've handed it over to them will do it? Man, you're brilliant! ...In case it couldn't already be detected.
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Here is my main gripe with this. So apparantly this investigator contacted you and gave a scum result. Alright, cool. The thing you do is relay it in public. Now YOU are handing the identity of this investigator over to two others. If we just get the result, we can discuss it, and come to a quick lynch, because let's face it, for the town, there is no reason not to test a scum investigation result. You just do it. I really don't see how you would give away the investigator's identity, maybe I am missing something, but I doubt it. There are a lot of ways to lay out information like this, and you are going to discuss it with your allies now? Really? Without getting ANY confirmation you have just given the investigator's identity to two players, who could be scum? On top of that, a statement like that completely limits the discussion we can have. So there's an investigation result coming, what can people do but wait?
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Here is an idea: Person X was investigated, as scum. Bam, done. I'm a genius. Ooooo, you are. You really are. Why did no one think of this before?
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 While I agree that this result should have been either presented to the public or not mentioned at all, just to clarify, Coryn and I were not told the identity of the investigator, only that of the investigated, and there may be some issues with the investigator's role claim, which is being discussed.
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 There are a lot of ways to lay out information like this, and you are going to discuss it with your allies now? Really? Without getting ANY confirmation you have just given the investigator's identity to two players, who could be scum? Absolutely. Somebody has entrusted you with the knowledge that they play a powerful role for the town and you hand it over to others? Alright, maybe he/she gave you permission to do so...I wouldn't know, but it still sound ridiculous. Beware of Sleeping Beauty! Beware of Sleeping Beauty! May her memory always haunt you!
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 While I agree that this result should have been either presented to the public or not mentioned at all, just to clarify, Coryn and I were not told the identity of the investigator, only that of the investigated, and there may be some issues with the investigator's role claim, which is being discussed. Okay, fair enough. But you ALWAYS test the investigation result, if it turns out to be false, you have a pretty good target for the next day. Honestly, if I was a bad tongue, I would say Corobb is making stuff up. And I don't see why this could not be done in public?
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 While I agree that this result should have been either presented to the public or not mentioned at all, just to clarify, Coryn and I were not told the identity of the investigator, only that of the investigated, and there may be some issues with the investigator's role claim, which is being discussed. Oops. Posted just after you. I am pleased to hear that no names have been dropped, but how can you discuss the investigator's claim if you don't even know who it is? I also don't see why it cannot be discussed here? Secondly. Why am I always just too late in posting.
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Okay, fair enough. But you ALWAYS test the investigation result, if it turns out to be false, you have a pretty good target for the next day. Honestly, if I was a bad tongue, I would say Corobb is making stuff up. And I don't see why this could not be done in public? Yes, as I said, this should have been revealed to the public or not mentioned at all. And I agree that there's not really anything else to do other than to test the result.
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Yes, as I said, this should have been revealed to the public or not mentioned at all. And I agree that there's not really anything else to do other than to test the result. I'm confused. You first say that it should be mentioned and then you, who know, don't mention it. Why not? Darn it. I meant "Reveal" not "Mention".
ADHO15 Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Yes, as I said, this should have been revealed to the public or not mentioned at all. And I agree that there's not really anything else to do other than to test the result. Sooo...? I was going to bring up a suspect of my own, but if a discussion is about to begin regarding a suspect investigated as Sith, then it might as well wait and not become unanswered or forgotten about. And a note regarding something I noticed whilst listening to today's conversations, most of you who call out seemingly 'useless' statements are also thereby making useless statements yourself, so it would be better for you to remain quiet and not become part of the problem. Not to mention it is also disrespectful and hypocritical coming from those of you who encourage 'speak your mind' and 'all discussion is useful'. Just my opinion.
Dannylonglegs Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" This is unexpected and great news! And also really loud. I think you should come out with the results of the investigation even if you decide the result is strange/ the claim is dubious. We should not only relly on the intuition of three people, no offence.
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 And a note regarding something I noticed whilst listening to today's conversations, most of you who call out seemingly 'useless' statements are also thereby making useless statements yourself, so it would be better for you to remain quiet and not become part of the problem. Not to mention it is also disrespectful and hypocritical coming from those of you who encourage 'speak your mind' and 'all discussion is useful'. Just my opinion. Yep. I mentioned this on day 1 as well. Although I think I have fallen prey to it somewhat myself. I was going to bring up a suspect of my own, but if a discussion is about to begin regarding a suspect investigated as Sith, then it might as well wait and not become unanswered or forgotten about. Well, you may as well bring it up since it seems that our trident of "untouchables" as I am beginning to refer to them as, are in no hurry to spill the beans as far as the investigative news is concerned.
Recommended Posts