Flare Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 First of all, I am suspicious of Ili Seosty, she has been acting very suspicious and to be honest I've been suspecting that she was a scum since yesterday. So: FoS: Ili Seosty (Sisco) "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" "I have just recieved word of a Scum investigation result! I have to get some sleep tonight, but I have turned this name over to Coryn and C-3PO, and after my nap if they have not yet taken the proper steps behind the scenes and revealed the name of the Scum, I will." Seriously, Corobb!? Why would you give that important info to them instead of to everyone? Very suspicious I agree with Vebb: What? Why not just say it, what will handing it over to those other two do? I don't get this. All you are doing is basically stopping the discussion until we get word of it....
Palathadric Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Oh, wouldn't it be great if it turns out that the "untouchable" trident of Corobb, Coryn, and C-3PO (Three "C"s by the way) are all scum and we down them all one after the other, especially since they thought that they had enough of our trust to make comments such as these: Anyways, although I'm not 100% clear, I did lead the lynch on scum yesterday, so I urge all townies who have night actions to talk to me in private so I can get everybody organized. "Also, if anyone has any useful information from the Night, I urge you to contact someone you trust with the results of your efforts. Everyone, if you recieve important information from one of these individuals, give them a code name and then contact me. This is particularly true if a Blocker or Cop reports their result to you." It would be lovely and so maniacally ironical...but unforuntately it's impossible. I just don't see how a droid could be a sith.
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 This sounds ridiculously scummy to me. "I lead the lynch so you should all trust me. Yeah, because I bussed my partner and almost single-handedly got him lynched on Day 1. Oh, he has a knack for doing this, he loves to lead, basically trying a similair thing in Yakuza a similair situation. Saying it IS pretty scummy, but of course in that other situation he turned out to be good... Mhm, that's right. And, for the record, fishing for role claims is the tell of a nosy townie - not a scum. Scum like to walk a fine line, and fishing for role claims when you're scum is way out of line. I don't know why everyone persists to think that I'm scum simply because I ask people what their night actions are. Actually, from what I know of previous situations, I believe it is common for one type of weapon to be attributed to a certain type of killer. Yup, this is true - hence why I think that the droid is the SK. Perhaps you could come to the realization that it is entirely possible that either Coryn or Corobb could be sith. We lead the lynch on a scum yesterday. That's pretty much a confirmation of our innocence. If you honestly can't see that I'm town, then I'm sure we can lead the town to victory without you. "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" "I have just recieved word of a Scum investigation result! I have to get some sleep tonight, but I have turned this name over to Coryn and C-3PO, and after my nap if they have not yet taken the proper steps behind the scenes and revealed the name of the Scum, I will." Yes, this is true. I'm still waiting for confirmation from the investigator him/herself, but from what I've heard from Master Corobb, Sherlock Holmes investigated Hugar Ssiht last night and found him to be a Sith. Care to explain yourself Hugar, or shall we just string you up now? While I agree that this result should have been either presented to the public or not mentioned at all, just to clarify, Coryn and I were not told the identity of the investigator, only that of the investigated, and there may be some issues with the investigator's role claim, which is being discussed. Yes, there are several issues with the role claim, but don't worry! Everything is being straightened out now, and we'll have another scum conviction by the end of the day. Absolutely. Somebody has entrusted you with the knowledge that they play a powerful role for the town and you hand it over to others? Alright, maybe he/she gave you permission to do so...I wouldn't know, but it still sound ridiculous. :wall: Let me tell you a little something about situations like this. In order to achieve an efficient town win, someone has to handle this sort of information. We may not be 100% clear, but we're pretty damn close. Is there anyone else who you think would be better for handling this information? How about someone like Master Monn or Padawan Seosty? No? Then I'd suggest you stop wasting your time rambling about how the three of us are 'scum' Seriously, Corobb!? Why would you give that important info to them instead of to everyone? Very suspicious Honestly, you too? Why would scum fake an investigation result this early? It's basically an invitation to be strung up by their feet.
Darth Nihilus Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Perhaps she had read Wookieepedia the Archives? Perhaps she was roleplaying made a lucky guess? Jedi Offee has yet to make a distinct impression on me, one way or the other. " "I would also like to resurrect my FoS against Jedi Seosty from yesterday. I saw you sneak in here, then out again a moment later. Why are you so determined not to contribute to our conversation??" Perhaps. I still do think that it's a viable suspicion, she hasn't been very helpful at all, and that comment just was really scummy to me. Like I said before, the scum like to baffle the town with their first kill (even though I still think this was the work of the SK). In any case, the scum would have had a hell of a time trying to kill one of us last night. I suppose you're right, but if it was the SK, why pick Koth? Maybe he came off as scummy to them. So it no longer makes Barriss a suspect; now it's just "something to consider", and you decide that you'd rather take what others have said and switch over to making Voolvif your main suspect? No, I was just saying that it's another possible lynch candidate, and I never said that Monn is my main suspect; only that he was everyone else's. Okay, yesterday I tried to ignore it, but as of now I am ver much agreeing with Master Corobb (or are you a Padawan, I think I must have asked before). Volvif, you have been far too unhelpful for my liking. FoS: Voolvif Monn (JackJonespaw) Perhaps you could come to the realization that it is entirely possible that either Coryn or Corobb could be sith. As far as your second comment is concerned, you seem to be certain that the sith call their godfather "Lord". How would you know this for certain unless you are a sith? Although I wouldn't mind seeing Bariss Offee lynched for all the mindless petting and stroking he did yesterday while we are in a somewhat serious situation. He does not appear to be taking it seriously at all! Yes, it is possible, but both of them have been consistently pro-town throughout the past Day (as well as through the short amount of time this one has been up), which I can hardly say for you. For example take the fact that in one post, you both agree with and partially accuse Corobb. Also, I never said I was certain that the Sith call their Godfather Lord, I only said that you would only be able to know for sure if you were a Sith.
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Alright, very good, was it that hard to say that in the first place, guys? No matter your intentions, you don't make symphaty with an action like that. I say we lynch the guy, and get this dayover with . *sympathy, day over.
MacK Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Yes, this is true. I'm still waiting for confirmation from the investigator him/herself, but from what I've heard from Master Corobb, Sherlock Holmes investigated Hugar Ssiht last night and found him to be a Sith. Yes, there are several issues with the role claim, but don't worry! Everything is being straightened out now, and we'll have another scum conviction by the end of the day. Well thank you for finally telling us the investigation result. How exactly do you go about testing an investigation claim without knowing the identity of the “investigator”?
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Well thank you for finally telling us the investigation result. How exactly do you go about testing an investigation claim without knowing the identity of the “investigator”? I know who Sherlock is, and I think he/she is trustworthy. The only way to know is to test this result.
MacK Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 While I agree that this result should have been either presented to the public or not mentioned at all, just to clarify, Coryn and I were not told the identity of the investigator, only that of the investigated, and there may be some issues with the investigator's role claim, which is being discussed. So C-3PO lied?
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 So C-3PO lied? 3PO didn't lie, but because of the 'revelation' that Mace Windu made yesterday, Master Corobb and I aren't letting him know everything until he's completely cleared. I still think the usurper theory is megablocks, but we're being careful about this.
badboytje88 Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "ATTENTION EVERYONE!" Wow I was really looking forward to hearing we found another scummy sith basterd. Then I heard I was the scummy sith basterd. Well I am not. Yesterday I've been working behind the screens with a number of our most outspoken townspeople. My intentions were pure. I am a pure Jedi. My mind isn't taken over by the darkside. Here are a couple of theories I have about the result: 1. The shrink/cop is insane. Only one way to find out unfortunately and that is to lynch me. 2. There is a framer amoungst us. He replaced my usually green lightsaber with a red one. 3. There is a redirector amoughst us. The cop targeted me but he got redirected to someone else, a member of team sith, thus my scummy result. 4. I am a member of the sith and I am lying to you. (which is not true)
Flare Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 What I personally don't like is how you three think that you are more responsible then other people, that you can take all these things onto your hands... how do we know that you aren't Sith? It is possible that you are trying to dump us by convincing us that you guys are the source or all information... who ever decided that you three should take care of all this stuff? Scummy, in my opinion. As for this Sherlock Holmes figure, and his victim whom you claim is a sith, you three could've easily come up with him just so you could get another Jedi knocked out, and make things easier for you guys. Another reason why I feel that you Coryn might be involved in this scummy plot, is because it seemed to me that you were relatively not participating in the first day and now all of a sudden you become an important figure? Huh? Seriously, whats happening here!? FoS: Coryn Kelens (Tamamono) I'm predicting a violent outburst against this from one of you three, so don't start barraging me with your "superior knowledge", because you're the only trustworthy people. Hah. Scum lies. ... 4. I am a member of the sith and I am lying to you. (which is not true) Well at least you're honest
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 I suppose you're right, but if it was the SK, why pick Koth? Maybe he came off as scummy to them. The SK doesn't have to pick a Scummy target. SKs are Independent, and they're win condition does not necessarily let them win with the Town or the Scum. The SK doesn't need to take out all the Scum, and the Town is unlikely to place a Watcher on a quiet, inactive player. 3PO didn't lie, but because of the 'revelation' that Mace Windu made yesterday, Master Corobb and I aren't letting him know everything until he's completely cleared. I still think the usurper theory is megablocks, but we're being careful about this. Yeah, they've been keeping secrets from me.
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Here are a couple of theories I have about the result: 1. The shrink/cop is insane. Only one way to find out unfortunately and that is to lynch me. 2. There is a framer amoungst us. He replaced my usually green lightsaber with a red one. 3. There is a redirector amoughst us. The cop targeted me but he got redirected to someone else, a member of team sith, thus my scummy result. 4. I am a member of the sith and I am lying to you. (which is not true) Finally he replies. 1. We're not going to assume the unlikely until the investigation result has been tested. 2. We're not going to assume the unlikely until the investigation result has been tested. 3. We're not going to assume the unlikely until the investigation result has been tested. 4. This is likely and we're going to test it. What I personally don't like is how you three think that you are more responsible then other people, that you can take all these things onto your hands... how do we know that you aren't Sith? It is possible that you are trying to dump us by convincing us that you guys are the source or all information... who ever decided that you three should take care of all this stuff? Scummy, in my opinion. What about "got a confirmed scum lynched yesterday" do you not understand? Do you think there's anyone more suited to handle important information that us? If so, then please do tell. Until then, we'll handle it ourselves. As for this Sherlock Holmes figure, and his victim whom you claim is a sith, you three could've easily come up with him just so you could get another Jedi knocked out, and make things easier for you guys. You just don't get it, do you? If we were getting a Jedi lynched today, then that person would be shown as a Jedi the next day and we'd all be put under scrutiny - including the investigator. NOBODY fakes an investigation result this early. Another reason why I feel that you Coryn might be involved in this scummy plot, is because it seemed to me that you were relatively not participating in the first day and now all of a sudden you become an important figure? Huh? Not participating? Yeah, that's really great, coming from someone who barely spoke at all yesterday. No matter what my level of 'participation', I still got scum lynched.
Kadabra Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 "Click chirp chirp tweet chirp." (As far as I can see, we've got our lynchee confirmed. I'm not 100% sure on any of the "triumverate" , but I believe we can trust them for now. What I worry is that we have a group of powerful pro town players, and the Scum may have a converting ability... We have to be careful to see if any of their behavior changes, as if one of them becomes influenced by the Sith, they could easily abuse their position to bring us down.)
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Another reason why I feel that you Coryn might be involved in this scummy plot, is because it seemed to me that you were relatively not participating in the first day and now all of a sudden you become an important figure? Huh? Not participating? Coryn? Which rock were you hiding under? Also, while timestamps really mean nothing, so I don't know if anyone would be interested, I do have a hologram of a private conversation with Coryn in which he stated that he wanted to lynch Windu very early in the Day.
Scubacarrot Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 I think it should be obvious what needs to be done now, we lynch Hugar, naturally, if it turns out he is innocent, yup, we will have a lot to talk about, until then, I know what I am going to be doing when the voting starts.
Scorpiox Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Yes, this is true. I'm still waiting for confirmation from the investigator him/herself, but from what I've heard from Master Corobb, Sherlock Holmes investigated Hugar Ssiht last night and found him to be a Sith. Care to explain yourself Hugar, or shall we just string you up now? I wake to a revalation from one within us. Excellent! It seems that we already have our lynch for today, Hugar Ssiht, the confirmed scum. I'm pretty sure that this result is genuine, as, as others have said, creating a fake investigation result as early as night one would cast instant suspicion and likelyhood that the faker is scum the next day. The Sith wouldn't take such a risk this early, it would be as pointless as handing over their entire team ( ). Also, I seriously doubt that Hugar would have been framed, as I really don't think that the Sith would expect one such as him to be investigated and have the foresight to frame him in the case of his investigation based solely on day one. Hmm, Nahdar where are you? How many more innuendos do I have to make?
Flare Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 C3PO and Coryn, I understand what you're saying, but still, I'm not planning on voting for Hugar, but if he does end up getting lynched then I will be most interested in seeing what the result will be. Un-FoS: Coryn Kelens (Tamamano) And my finger is still pointing at Ili Seosty as before, who hasn't explained any accusations against herself, like Coryn did.
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 C3PO and Coryn, I understand what you're saying, but still, I'm not planning on voting for Hugar, but if he does end up getting lynched then I will be most interested in seeing what the result will be. Wait, you're not voting for the almost confirmed scum!? FoS: Shaak Ti (Flare) This definitely looks like you're on the same team as him, and you just don't want him to get lynched.
Jedi master Brick Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Though we have a lynch for today I would like to think about the future aswell. To me Quinlan Vos has behaved scummy. He has flown under the radar, even though he has been in the room. He has not contributed or explained anything so we should keep an eye on him
Flare Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Wait, you're not voting for the almost confirmed scum!? FoS: Shaak Ti (Flare) This definitely looks like you're on the same team as him, and you just don't want him to get lynched. What the heck!? Look here, I don't know who is scum, Hugar or Ili, or whoever. And personally I don't know whether your investigation is trustworthy or not, since it comes from an unnamed "Sherlock Holmes", and its possible that he is lying, if you aren't. So all I can rely on is how people behave: Ili has been acting much more suspicious than Hugar ever has, which makes me suspect Ili a lot more than Hugar. I didn't ever say that I'm not voting for Hugar, but that it is probable that I won't, unless more facts come in that will make things more clear as to where this investigation came from in the first place. No offense, but you can't assume that I'm on the same team as him, I haven't been sticking up for him... I even said that I'd be interested in seeing the result of him getting lynched
Tamamono Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 What the heck!? Look here, I don't know who is scum, Hugar or Ili, or whoever. And personally I don't know whether your investigation is trustworthy or not, since it comes from an unnamed "Sherlock Holmes", and its possible that he is lying, if you aren't. So all I can rely on is how people behave: Ili has been acting much more suspicious than Hugar ever has, which makes me suspect Ili a lot more than Hugar. I didn't ever say that I'm not voting for Hugar, but that it is probable that I won't, unless more facts come in that will make things more clear as to where this investigation came from in the first place. :wall: How many times do I have to say it? The scum don't make up invesitgation results this early!
Jedi master Brick Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Wow I was really looking forward to hearing we found another scummy sith basterd. Then I heard I was the scummy sith basterd. Well I am not. Yesterday I've been working behind the screens with a number of our most outspoken townspeople. My intentions were pure. I am a pure Jedi. My mind isn't taken over by the darkside. Here are a couple of theories I have about the result: 1. The shrink/cop is insane. Only one way to find out unfortunately and that is to lynch me. 2. There is a framer amoungst us. He replaced my usually green lightsaber with a red one. 3. There is a redirector amoughst us. The cop targeted me but he got redirected to someone else, a member of team sith, thus my scummy result. 4. I am a member of the sith and I am lying to you. (which is not true) So this is what you are saying. I was going to be fine with the result, it looks all good, the result wil tell us who to lynnch, oh it is me it must be wrong. So it would be right to you if it was anyone else but you. We all have considerd the danger and we must find out. Good bye master jedi
Kadabra Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 :wall: How many times do I have to say it? The scum don't make up invesitgation results this early! Chirp chirp chirp. (There's always the possibility of Insanity, though the only way to test that is to lynch Master Ssiht. I will vote for him barring some startling rvelation that alters everything, though, as doing so can only help the town. [by getting a Scum or learning our Cop's sanity.])
Brickdoctor Posted May 14, 2012 Posted May 14, 2012 Though we have a lynch for today I would like to think about the future aswell. To me Quinlan Vos has behaved scummy. He has flown under the radar, even though he has been in the room. He has not contributed or explained anything so we should keep an eye on him Seriously, stop pointing out who's not contributing, because you're not doing much of it yourself. And personally I don't know whether your investigation is trustworthy or not, since it comes from an unnamed "Sherlock Holmes", and its possible that he is lying, if you aren't. And that is why we test the result by lynching Hugar.
Recommended Posts