KotZ Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Ok, if I was truly a scum, would my statements really be this scummy as everyone claims? No, I'd try to keep a low profile, or not sound as stupid. at the very least. Also, nobody is/was defending me even from the beginning, correct? That means the scum wants me killed. They're hiding in with everyone else, so they are not to blame if I'm lynched and shown I'm town. Now is everybody who is accusing me is not necessarily scum, but I'm certain scum are in that group. Besides, why would scum kill scum? It's a classic tactic they would use, shift the blame onto somebody who can easily be made into a scapegoat. This is what I say: Vote: Lt. Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar)
Scouty Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 With that wimper of a "no lynch" and this vote: for whoever and change at the last minute, I'll Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk).
Dannylonglegs Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 I'm not one to vote early, but since we have unvotes (Masked Builder ) I'll place my vote for Vote: Lt. Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar). His behavior has been raising red flags in my opinion, all day, and his interactions with Ensign Peter Robbins have been even stranger. Don't think I'm doing this because I don't suspect Ensign Robbins though, he's my second suspect, but I think there's more of a chance of Wright being scum than Robbins. The way the two have acted today makes me feel like they are both scum trying to distance themselves, but there is a small voice in the back of my mind that thinks that Wright may have just been trying to buddy up to Robbins earlier.
Brickdoctor Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Ok, if I was truly a scum, would my statements really be this scummy as everyone claims? No, I'd try to keep a low profile, or not sound as stupid. at the very least. Or you tried to look like an active, helpful Townie, and you failed. It would be different if you were drawing attention to yourself by doing something that wasn't scummy. Also, nobody is/was defending me even from the beginning, correct? That means the scum wants me killed. Or your Scum teammates have already decided that there's no way for you to get out of this, and they don't want to be caught defending you.
KotZ Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 I'm not one to vote early, but since we have unvotes (Masked Builder ) I'll place my vote for Vote: Lt. Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar). His behavior has been raising red flags in my opinion, all day, and his interactions with Ensign Peter Robbins have been even stranger. Don't think I'm doing this because I don't suspect Ensign Robbins though, he's my second suspect, but I think there's more of a chance of Wright being scum than Robbins. The way the two have acted today makes me feel like they are both scum trying to distance themselves, but there is a small voice in the back of my mind that thinks that Wright may have just been trying to buddy up to Robbins earlier. I'm not sure how to take that. Back-handed compliment? I think Wright is scum, and I know for sure I am not. Have I made stupid comments? Absolutely. Does a stupid comment automatically equal scum? No.
CMP Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) Not voting....what kind of idiot would suggest that?
KotZ Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) Not voting....what kind of idiot would suggest that? This proud idiot would
Flipz Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 As I said before, I will Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk). The No Lynch suggestion alone is worth a lynch, and your somewhat-incoherent ramblings are a veritable playbook of rookie Scum mistakes. So long, scummo!
AwesomeStar Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 I'm not one to vote early, but since we have unvotes (Masked Builder ) I'll place my vote for Vote: Lt. Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar). His behavior has been raising red flags in my opinion, all day, and his interactions with Ensign Peter Robbins have been even stranger. Don't think I'm doing this because I don't suspect Ensign Robbins though, he's my second suspect, but I think there's more of a chance of Wright being scum than Robbins. The way the two have acted today makes me feel like they are both scum trying to distance themselves, but there is a small voice in the back of my mind that thinks that Wright may have just been trying to buddy up to Robbins earlier. And by buddying up you are of course referring to when I openly voiced my distrust of him and his constant shifting of the blame? I don't think I need to explain myself on this one. Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk). In fact, as Robbins himself said, why would scum kill scum?
KotZ Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 As I said before, I will Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk). The No Lynch suggestion alone is worth a lynch, and your somewhat-incoherent ramblings are a veritable playbook of rookie Scum mistakes. So long, scummo! How would you know that, if I can ask? Are you a scum?
Brickdoctor Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 I don't think I need to explain myself on this one. Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk). In fact, as Robbins himself said, why would scum kill scum? It's called bussing, and considering that you haven't exactly been free of suspicion today, I wouldn't say that your vote for Ensign Robbins does anything to make you seem more Townie.
Flipz Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Vote: Lt. Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar) I'm not one to vote early, but since we have unvotes (Masked Builder ) I'll place my vote for Vote: Lt. Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar). His behavior has been raising red flags in my opinion, all day, and his interactions with Ensign Peter Robbins have been even stranger. Don't think I'm doing this because I don't suspect Ensign Robbins though, he's my second suspect, but I think there's more of a chance of Wright being scum than Robbins. The way the two have acted today makes me feel like they are both scum trying to distance themselves, but there is a small voice in the back of my mind that thinks that Wright may have just been trying to buddy up to Robbins earlier. Any particular reason we should Lynch Lt. Wright instead of Vigkilling him? Robbins is a lot scummier at this point.
KotZ Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 I provided a defense like you all asked, though I fear it may have been too late.
Darkdragon Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Can I ask what makes you suspect him more than Robbins? Yeah of course, no problem. I had originally thought he was more suspicious than Robbins based on what he was saying and how he seemed to be trying and stop people from giving any accusations at all and not saying anything other than about coffee and washing (roleplaying). I'd even already said that I suspected him moreso than Robbins a few pages back, and even though I do feel that Robbins is a strong candidate for being scum, I don't think I should vote for him over my first choice at this point - I don't want to fall into a bandwagon mentality or secondguess myself yet. That said, I do think that Robbins is either scum or a totally useless townie who is going to get too many of us killed (by gaining all the townie focus and thus letting scum slip by unnoticed) if he is not lynched or killed very soon.
AwesomeStar Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 It's called bussing, and considering that you haven't exactly been free of suspicion today, I wouldn't say that your vote for Ensign Robbins does anything to make you seem more Townie. Free of suspicion? No. But have I back up and provided logical counter-arguments to those presented against me? I'd say so.
Flipz Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 How would you know that, if I can ask? Are you a scum? :laugh_hard: Of course I'm not, you know that already because you are a Scum! For your reference in the afterlife, I present you with these three data chips, containing valuable and useful information on such situations. That's how I know.
swils Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Well, for the time being, Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) seems like the obvious choice.
Dannylonglegs Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 This proud idiot would You're nailing yourself into a coffin right now, but if I'm right, you belong there. Any particular reason we should Lynch Lt. Wright instead of Vigkilling him? Robbins is a lot scummier at this point. Because Vigilantes are unreliable, and when uninstructed by someone they trust, could target anyone. The only weapon I can trust at the moment is my vote, so I'm using it for who I feel is more likely to be scum.
Flipz Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 You're nailing yourself into a coffin right now, but if I'm right, you belong there. Because Vigilantes are unreliable, and when uninstructed by someone they trust, could target anyone. The only weapon I can trust at the moment is my vote, so I'm using it for who I feel is more likely to be scum. Fair enough. They're almost undoubtedly both Scum, but I still think Robbins is scummier.
Fred Daniel Yam Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Wow, I've missed a lot when I was sleeping. That's what I get for living in a different time zone I guess. Based on all the comments so far I have made a few notes. Ensign Robbins seems to have resigned himself to be lynched and is going "I'm Town and I've provided a defence. Now I die." and he really seems to be playing the part of a sacrificial lamb here. In this case, I don't see why we should doubt his behaviour. Vote: Ensign Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) What does OMGUS and WIFOM mean by the way?
Tamamono Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Hoo, boy, I am sorry, fellas! There seems to be a lot going on, and I've been busy, busy, busy! After reading through everything, I'm confident that this is the right choice for today: Vote: Ensign Robbins (KingoftheZempk) I was the first to call out Ensign Robbins on his scummy behavior (not counting the Janitor accusation ), and he's gotten scummier and scummier by the minute. His almost pacifistic actions are definitely those of a scum scared out of his mind of being caught. When he's accused, he says "Whoa, slow down there, guys! We shouldn't accuse anybody yet!". When everyone's proven that it's a good thing to accuse people early, he concedes ground and tries to act like nothing happened. When he's accused almost to the point of being lynched, he gives up and tries to invoke pity in the rest of us, and when we scoff at him for his defeatist attitude, he suggests we NL. Textbook maneuvers. Quite frankly, this is the best lynch for today. While Wright as well is scummy, he's a different kind of scummy. Robbins is the best lynch for today regardless of affiliation. If he's scum, whoop-de-doo, we've got a great start. If he's town, we've used a ML (Mislynch) on someone who could potentially clog up our scumdars with scummy behavior when it matters more. I highly doubt he's a PR, because he would have surely claimed before. This is beneficial, guys.
Dakar A Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 Well, it seems that everyone else has summed up my thoughts on the matter. Robbins was too easily giving up, and worked many of the scumtells that I've seen used before (especially excessive role-playing). While I feel that Wright would also be an excellent candidate, it seems that he got more cocky as the suspicion got drawn away from him, and repeatedly spoke too much for his own good. So... Vote: Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) What does OMGUS and WIFOM mean by the way? OMGUS- Oh my gosh, you suck and WIFOM- Wine in front of me ( based off the scene in the Princess Bride).
Flipz Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 Unofficial Vote Tally: Ensign Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) 10 Votes -- Brickdoctor, Scubacarrot, Peanuts, Scouty, CallMePie, Flipz, Awesomestar, swils, VolcanicPanic, Tamamono, Dakar A Lieutenant Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar) 3 Votes -- Darkdragon, KingoftheZempk, Dannylonglegs Still to vote (10): Fugazi, Dragonator, Kadabra, Shadows, Flare, Inconspicuous, Palathadric, Waterbrick Down, Masked Builder, CallMePie And while I'm goofing around with stats and the like, here's how many times each person has posted spoken up: KingoftheZempk 29 Brickdoctor 24 AwesomeStar 18 Scubacarrot 18 Peanuts 14 Flipz 13 Dakar A 14 CallMePie 11 Palathadric 11 darkdragon 8 Dannylonglegs 7 Scouty 5 swils 4 Bob 3 VolcanicPanik 3 Tamamono 3 Flare 3 Masked Builder 3 Waterbrick Down 2 Shadows 2 Fugazi 1 Inconspicuous 1 Dragonator 1 Kadabra 0 Now, I don't know about you, but I find it rather odd that Lieutenant Donna Willis has yet to speak up, despite almost 31 hours passing already today. Speak up, Lieutenant! We need your help! Since Ensign Robbins is most likely going to be lynched, those among us with Power Roles should begin thinking about potential targets; after all, a majority will be reached with just one more vote, which means the Day will end as soon as the Admiral sees it go through. If you have a Night Action, please contact someone you think you can trust; we need to start making connections--after all, the Scum are almost certainly sitting around behind the scenes, plotting their next move. If you wish to contact me, I promise I will NOT reveal your action and identity to ANYONE (not even silver-tongued, blue-haired Jedi! )without your express permission ; I will use code names if it becomes necessary to discuss your role. As you will have noted, I've publicly asked the Vigilante to kill Lt. Joshua Wright tonight, due to his scummy behavior; similarly, I have an optimal course of action planned out for the Night for any likely Role, so you need only come and ask and I will happily provide a target for you. If you are unsure about trusting me directly with your identity, feel free to utilize an intermediary, but I hope that come morning such measures will be proven unnecessary. Unofficial Vote Tally: Ensign Peter Robbins (KingoftheZempk) 11 Votes -- Brickdoctor, Scubacarrot, Peanuts, Scouty, CallMePie, Flipz, Awesomestar, swils, VolcanicPanic, Tamamono, Dakar A Lieutenant Joshua Wright (AwesomeStar) 3 Votes -- Darkdragon, KingoftheZempk, Dannylonglegs Still to vote (9): Fugazi, Dragonator, Kadabra, Shadows, Flare, Inconspicuous, Palathadric, Waterbrick Down, Masked Builder Whoops, couple of errors there. This is an accurate tally.
Dakar A Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 Snip I have a feeling that we'll be seeing one of your plays soon, eh? Everyone, he does have avalid point, and, based on his gameplay style, I'd vouch for him being Town, and trustworthy.
Recommended Posts