Shadows Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 So, your vote for me is based on a case made independently by Hinck and Scouty. But Hinck has just unvoted me, yet you're willing to hold your vote on me. He hasn't explained why and he was incredibly insistent while making the case, so it would be foolish to change votes. Out of interest, if Hinck, Scouty and I weren't potential lynches, who would you choose instead? If none of the events of the day had occurred, I have no idea, and that's the only way for that situation to happen. Without Hinck and Scouty pushing so hard to change and making sense in their reasoning, my vote would still be on Hinck.
Rick Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 Whatever, that's really the important part, not whether or not the scum benefit from knowledge that doesn't need to be advertised in case they missed it, right? All they'd have to do is read. I think they can do that. Since both are claiming to be PRs, you must know exactly what each one can supposedly do to be able to decide which is less important to the town. It just gets more and more interesting. I don't know what either can do or even claims to be able to do at night. Pandora, without even knowing Hinck's role, seems adamant that she'd be a major loss to the town. Hinck merely suggests he has a useful role. Or am I giving the scum useful information now that they may have missed?
Shadows Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 All they'd have to do is read. I think they can do that. Thanks for proving I'm town, it's already well established that I don't read. I don't know what either can do or even claims to be able to do at night. Pandora, without even knowing Hinck's role, seems adamant that she'd be a major loss to the town. Hinck merely suggests he has a useful role. Or am I giving the scum useful information now that they may have missed? As I said before, scum are usually the most vocal about their supposedly important roles as people with real ones try to keep that fact hidden, especially in a situation where there is no chance of them actually being lynched. You don't find that the least bit suspicious? Really?
Pandora Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 As I said before, scum are usually the most vocal about their supposedly important roles as people with real ones try to keep that fact hidden, especially in a situation where there is no chance of them actually being lynched. You don't find that the least bit suspicious? Really? But actually there is a real possibility of either of us being lynched. So we should go quietly?
Rick Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 He hasn't explained why and he was incredibly insistent while making the case, so it would be foolish to change votes. You said you basically trusted Hinck (someone you didn't trust all day) and Scouty's judgment. Yet, when Hinck changes his opinion, you're not changing your vote, because... ? You didn't need reasons to vote, but you do need reasons to unvote? As I said before, scum are usually the most vocal about their supposedly important roles as people with real ones try to keep that fact hidden, especially in a situation where there is no chance of them actually being lynched. You don't find that the least bit suspicious? Really? Oh, you've found your reason to vote for her now? But you were confident enough to vote for her before she even gave you that reason?
Hinckley Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 *A huge set piece swings in, somewhat like Les Miserables but more sewery. A sad 20’s orchestra ensemble plays jazzy music* *dons some 20’s style-raggedy clothes and dances some 20’s Charleston dances* Drawing Scum out Might have happened Not as clear as I’d hope for though! I’m not sorry! I’m not sorry! When you see that I’m a Townie Check out Scouty Examine his head! I’m not sorry! I’m not sorry! Once I was lynched And my fate synched I started poking Where I could People who knew Should quote me to Show my theories Understood! The PMs should Spell out clearly Without singing Clear and good! Pandora, if you're Town, Your suspicion Was correct, At least I think. You know the one You can see with Your mod vision, Here’s a wink. Maybe he was checking me out trying to draw Scum Hinck out? Scouty, Scouty, I said someone was suspicious On page 5, post one, think! Check out that one He's the worst one came a knockin' for Scummy me! I'm not sorry! Hey that's life! I'll vote: Shadows without strife! I was not shy about pointing every post out where he lied. "I can't be converted" "Uh-oh, I might be" Which one is it? Choose a side. "It's all def's fault, Logic, he haults." Scummy Shadows, blames the host! And be careful, As usual All the cast from last season, They're a talking scheming, balking notice their votes in a row. Scummy Shadows, way too nice. I accused him, he flew nice. Shrugged it off and voted Scouty inconsistent Three blind mice! This is prob'ly my last bow listen to me I'll show you how. Look at my songs Quote the PMs too Don't forget, Dave, Zepher, NightShroud, Darth Potatoo. *dances, bows, passes out*
Shadows Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 You said you basically trusted Hinck (someone you didn't trust all day) and Scouty's judgment. Yet, when Hinck changes his opinion, you're not changing your vote, because... ? You didn't need reasons to vote, but you do need reasons to unvote? Now that he's posted his reasoning, which doesn't actually say anything, I see no reason to change my vote. Hinck, who is either being duped or is scum, will die shortly, and my vote will stand against Pandora who I also believe to be scum. I have a bad feeling the two teams just found each other but can't figure out how to save one of their own before it's too late. Oh, you've found your reason to vote for her now? But you were confident enough to vote for her before she even gave you that reason? Where did I say that was the reason? Hinck and Scouty gave a lot of reasons and now it's becoming obvious that at least one of my votes today was correct. Don't worry, we'll figure this out. Or maybe you should worry, huh? Notice how you avoid the real issue, the obvious scum tell on her part, and just go back to attacking me? I bet others will notice as well. "I can't be converted" "Uh-oh, I might be" Which one is it? Choose a side. You know why I said I couldn't be as much as Rick does, I always say it so maybe the idiot scum won't convert me. I'm also bulletproof and lynchproof, naturally. "It's all def's fault, Logic, he haults." Scummy Shadows, blames the host! I was the only one confused by the change in the way "day kills" were timed or Scouty being told one role by name and given another? That's scummy to you? The latter one, if Scouty is telling the truth, was literally a host mistake and he says we'll be seeing a comment to that effect at the end of the game, so excuse me. Scummy Shadows, way too nice. I accused him, he flew nice. You always attack me, it's what you do in every single game, it's why you were so easy to manipulate in the last one. You're predictable and boring about it. Why bother fighting that? Shrugged it off and voted Scouty inconsistent Three blind mice! I voted Scouty because he wrote what appeared to be a very suspicious PM to me and you exposed the ones he wrote you. Once he explained, I unvoted and wasn't the only one that thought it made you look suspicious. I only unvoted you because of the things you said about Pandora that Scouty was able to confirm and how much he suddenly seemed to trust you. I assumed he knew more than he could say, which seemed like a smart town attitude. That doesn't seem inconsistent at all.
def Posted January 18, 2013 Author Posted January 18, 2013 Vote Tally: Hinckley 10 (Zepher, Tammo, Big Cam, Nightshroud, JimButcher, Alopex, CallMePie, Adam, badboy, DarthPotato) Pandora 7 (Scouty, Dragonator, Shadows, iamded, TinyPies, Piratedave, TrumpetKing) Shadows 3 (Rick, Pandora, Hinckley) About 5 minutes left. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Hinckley is convicted. Day ends. No vignette in the next few hours, but before day two. Players have 20 hours to get night actions in.
def Posted January 18, 2013 Author Posted January 18, 2013 Hinckley confronts his accusers. "I know I was acting scummy! That's the whole point! If I was actually scummy, I wouldn't act scummy! Gah! Geez! <waltz waltz waltz>" "Well folks, I can't tell you if he was scum or not, but I can promise you one thing: There will be a lot less to read on day three!" Def addresses Pelly. "Pelly, I need you to take out the trash, wink wink. Why aren't you down there?" "....." "Folks, Pelly is upset that the Banana Sphinx has left the building, and refuses to kill. What can we do?" "......" "Oh really? Sounds intriguing." A whirling and chugging is heard approaching the room. In rolls... something. A monotone voice emits from the wheeled contraption. "I am - chk chk chk - Thomas. I am your - chk chk chk - doom." Hinckley takes in the hulking device. "You're taking me to the afterlife, right? I got so much to say! Ah man, I wanna go. Let's go!" Hinckley begins to skedaddle. As they exit, Thomas squelches, "Father, how do I turn off it's - chk chk chk - voice box? It is - chk chi - malfunctioning." ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ About 11 hours left to get in those night actions.
Recommended Posts