Rick Posted April 2, 2013 Posted April 2, 2013 Well, it's a risky move to lay the cards on the table like that and it's sure to unite the scum teams (if they hadn't already), but so far there's been no split in vote for Hinckley, suggesting we still outnumber the combined scum or - less likely - he's town. The most damning point is that he was tracked last night, and targeted Pandora. He later claimed watcher and put forward that Walter Kovacs targeted her. He's scum, for an entirely different reason. I understand, from what's been said here today, that li'l Hinckley trusted you and li'l Dave and then "conveniently" claimed watcher when he was seen targeting li'l Pandora. Shouldn't he have brought that up much earlier if he was trying to help the town? We were in a precarious enough situation already yesterday. Talking to you must have put him in the perfect position to subtly steer your decisions. The defeatist attitude at the start of the day wasn't the li'l Hinck I know. It seemed like he was already trying to cover his own big behind and wanted to scare you into not revealing what you know (although I don't know if he already knew the result on him from last night at that point). Now, why would Hinckley do this? If Hinckley is indeed the scum killer, and Walter was indeed converted, wouldn't they have found eachother pretty easily if they were in this block PM and in constant contact? The answer is yes. Hinckley is using Walter (willingly - they're both scum) as a scapegoat. He is trying to gain the trust of the town, so that he may kill without interference for the rest of the game. Leading the only successful lynch of a scum, who would doubt him? Looks like they screwed up that plan pretty badly then. ]On Night Three, TheBoyWonder was tracked, targeting me. [/b]How does that fit into anything? Well, when confronted, he made a ridiculous claim of Bodyguard (50/50 chance of protecting a target) in private. There wasn't a bodyguard last time, only a normal protector. And last game there were three kills because of a serial killer. Why would def remove a kill, but add in an extra protector? It's a poor claim. Our suspicion is that TheBoyWonder is the converter as a result. Now, this information got leaked to Hinckley shortly afterward. I think it was at this point the scum merged, with the unwitting help of the masons. In any case, I believe that Hinckley was able to convince him, after merging, to convert Walter Kovacs. I already said this in private to Dave, but li'l Wonderboy's claim is ridiculous indeed and now that we know li'l Hinck is most likely scum, I agree that it's likely they had already merged. The advantage is that this has probably turned into a regular class situation now. This is an all or nothing situation. Either we're completely screwed or we're taking out the mastermind. If we let you go through with your plan we would've been screwed anyway. I think we all feared it was an all-or-nothing situation at the start of the day already. At least, depending on the number of successful conversions, we have a chance this way. Vote: Li'l Hinckley (Hinckley)
CMP Posted April 2, 2013 Posted April 2, 2013 Looks like they screwed up that plan pretty badly then. I think it would've worked quite well, to be honest, if he hadn't been tracked.
Peanuts Posted April 2, 2013 Posted April 2, 2013 Peanuts would be able to verify he was blocked Night 3, unless he is scum. In which case he will lie through his teeth. I cannot confirm this. I didn't even have a night action on that day, so I can't exactly deny this, but I didn't get any notification that I was blocked. I assume, either Li'l hinckley is scum or we are dead anyway, so I'll just be bold as brass and jump on the bandwagon: Vote: Li'l Hinckley
def Posted April 2, 2013 Author Posted April 2, 2013 Vote Tally: Li'l Hinckley 11 (CallMePie, Endgame, Walter, PirateDave, BoyWonder, Capt. Redblade, Nightshroud, Zepher, Kiel, Rick, Peanuts) Li'l Walter Kovacs 1 (Hinckley)
Rick Posted April 2, 2013 Posted April 2, 2013 I think it would've worked quite well, to be honest, if he hadn't been tracked. He was aware there was a tracker (he knew about the result on li'l Wonderboy after all), so he was naive enough to think he wouldn't be tracked last night.
Hinckley Posted April 3, 2013 Posted April 3, 2013 Busy as I was all day, I'm glad the bandwagon piled on me yesterday and there wasn't a bunch to respond to today. I wouldn't have had time. Perfect timing. Best of luck, Townies. I really don't think it's as bad for us as Pie seems to think. We're in a good spot. Bring those Scumbos down. Goodbye now.
def Posted April 3, 2013 Author Posted April 3, 2013 There are just over seven hours in the day, but please send your night actions in now if you're inclined to. If they come in early, we can start the next day sooner than usual, since I'll be around the house tonight and tomorrow... We could start day six in less than 24 hours from now... (if you are unsure about your night actions and don't want to be rushed, we will continue with the regular schedule)
def Posted April 3, 2013 Author Posted April 3, 2013 Li'l Hinckley is convicted. Send your night actions in. Vote Tally: Li'l Hinckley 11 (CallMePie, Endgame, Walter, PirateDave, BoyWonder, Capt. Redblade, Nightshroud, Zepher, Kiel, Rick, Peanuts) Li'l Walter Kovacs 1 (Hinckley)
Recommended Posts