Mencot Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 Whatever happened this morning, I will not only base my vote on who jumps, but also how those who jumped defended him/her self. I base my vote on two factors. 1. Your defence for yourself. 2. If anyone else support whatever you said. Davey, you defended yourself well. But the main problem is that I could not verify that with anyone else. So far no one came up to defend you. If this happens on Day 1 or 2, I would have deferred my judgement till later since it's very hard to determine who is Town and who's not. But it is Day 9 now and no one defended you (I just need one). Either 1. you are town but no one trust you or 2. you are scum and your scum buddies think you made a bad move this morning so they decided to ignore you or 3. you are the last scum. I don't wish to vote out Town so whoever thinks Davey is Town but is still hesitating, please step up and give your opinion. So for now, my vote today goes to: Vote: Davey Osborne (Mencot) lucy, you have made some good arguments, thats fair and square that you don´t trust me if non other do either. I think you are town, I have thought that all along. others who are loyal town in my opinion are, claire and brian. The rest are still unclear for me. And I don´t know who to vote for. Forgot about Jeanie, she is also town in my opinion So: Jeanie Claire Lucy Brian Add to that I don´t know who to vote for: mary-Jane hits my scum rader, she has been very aggressive today and really eager to vote somebody, and me who made a stupied mistake seem to be the victim. If there is more then one scum left hmm, gotta think on that who could be the other one!
mostlytechnic Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 So we're now at 3 for davey, 2 allison, and 3 unvoted. I won't be around much for the rest of the day, but I WILL be back before the end of the day and can switch my vote if needed to seal a lynch. Davey, you're saying I'm acting scummy by being aggressive and "scum do that at the end of the game". Well, I started being aggressive several days ago. Adriano said I was acting scummy back then because I changed style so much. In this case, it's not because I'm scum. It's because I was brand new to mafia games and had little clue what was going on, plus we had NO solid info for the first several days. Once I got more comfortable with the academy and some actual information (investigations, voting history, etc) was available, I stepped it up. I think most of the class agrees I'm town, not scum, so I'm not worried about a lynch right now. I'm just going to keep aggressively hunting the last of the scum so we can have our school back free from the Mesas! Most of my opinion of people at this point is based on actions. There are several (Brian, Bob, Lucy, Claire) who's activities make them town in my mind. There are others (Davey, Allison) who are less clear. And Jeanie of course... cleared by the investigator, but not by actions, and since godfather is a possibility, I'm not solidly trusting her yet either. Since we know there's at least 1 scum left, probably 2, possibly 3, well, I gotta go with what I've seen. That makes Davey and Allison the most likely scum so I'll vote for either today. I'm sure the blocker will block the other tonight, so as long as we lynch one and block the other, I think there's little chance of a townie dying tonight.
Mencot Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 3 scum no way. 2 left is more likely. You say you stepped it up after you became more familier with the game and have read on voting patterns. I think you should relook the patterns then. You say you gonna be celebrating tomorrow.. If you go with that vote you have now you will be celebrating with the scum.. Who are Probabl your buddies
mostlytechnic Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 I said probably 2. 3 is a slim possibility, but I can't rule it out since we DO NOT KNOW how many we started with.
badboytje88 Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 Oh my I am so torn between voting for Davey or voting vor Allison. I am a tad bit indecisive at the moment... I'll check in later to vote.
Mencot Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 I still don´t know who to vote for, last 15 minutes I have stared at the voting pattern trying to figure something out One thing I feel strange is Andrews voting on day 5 and 6 On day 5 he voted as only voter for Mary-Jane as all other voted for Shawna And day 6 "mixed vote day" he voted for Bob Busch, do anyone who was in contact with Andrew know why he did vote this way?
Hammerstein NWC Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 If you check hisposts for the day (particularly post #72 you will see that I was gunning quite hard for him after his poor performance and Simone getting mislynched. He actually casts doubt on Jeannie and Mary Jane at the time who had been going after him "continually" (his words) first but then votes for me... Obviously those were different times I'm certain Mary Jane isn't scum and Jeannie is solid town now but things weren't so sure back then. HIs reasons are clearly stated there 1) I was being too quiet (ie being a noob because I am a noob) 2) I had voted for him and was going for him pretty hard. Hope that clears that up.
Mencot Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 Yea thanks Bob, it clears yo up( altough you already were loyal in my eyes) but Mary-Jane is a diffrent chapter, she is also a noob (like me also) so that could explain some of her actions Iam gonna be away now (irl sleep, getting late) gonna vote for the one I find most scum, though my vote doesn´t matter much bcause this person isn´t on any others list Vote: Mary Jane (mostlytechnic) Ah almost forgot, someone always have said to the one voted out: "Any last words?" Mine are: Yea whatever this was fun, loyal townies, if you are around still tomorrow, beware of the scum, don´t trust the ones you think are your friends!
jimmynick Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 OK. I want to provide the help I've owed for a little while now. After a long lunch break sitting on the swings and playing tag with the laser turrets, I decided I would do a little research and present my findings to the class. I looked at the whirlwind bandwagon on John during Day Four. That still sticks out to me as the bandwagon left almost as soon as it arrived. Burton Guster gave the first vote for John Bender when he said: Vote: John Bender (Antonio) I am voting for John again because of his inactivity and when he does post his does not provide anything useful. But at the time, there were votes out for Andrew Clark, Cameron Frye, Shawna Spencer and me. People cottoned on to the suggestion of John Bender very quickly, and voting for him overtook voting for Andrew Clark when Adriano switched his vote from Burton Guster. Once John Bender had four votes and Andrew Clark had three, voting quickly piled up. Chuckie Miller (scum) obviously wanted to make sure we as a group decisively expelled John Bender, because he voted immediately after Adriano. Claire and Bobby voted afterwards. Shawna (scum) finished the lynch on John (not surprising at all). I wonder if there were more scum than two putting the heat on John at the very end. Is Claire or Bobby (or both) a scum? Fingers have pointed at them in the past, so I wonder if it's worth thinking about those two. Maybe I'm just reading too much into what seemed to be a mostly-townie lynch, though two known scum pushed it to the end. I'm getting tired and hungry again now, so I'm off to see if the nice lunch lady has any food left, and then I'll take a nap. I'll wake up a bit later. this is al I have to say for the time being. this is al I have to say for the time being. I'm sorry I can't capitalize or spell. Like I said, I'm tired and I need a nap.
Hammerstein NWC Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 I'm hitting the sack now! Hopefully see you guys in class tomorrow!
mostlytechnic Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 After discussing with others, I'm going to switch for now. Doesn't mean I don't still suspect Davey, but... Unvote: Davey Osborne (Mencot) Vote: Allison Reynolds (jamesn) With that, we're now at: 2 for davey, 3 allison, 1 for me, and 2 unvoted. That's Bob and Lucy voting Davey, Mary Jane, Claire, and Brian voting Allison Davey voting for me Jeanie and Allison unvoted yet. Davey, you willing to take your wasted vote off of me and help expel Allison?
jimmynick Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 Davey, you willing to take your wasted vote off of me and help expel Allison? Davey says he suspects you of being scum and if he wants to look town he wouldn't pay attention to you. I, for one: Vote: Davey Osborne (Mencot) For a couple of reasons: I'm Town I suspect Davey of being scum He's the other lynch candidate today Lynching me is a really bad idea. No-lynch, even, would be better than lynching me.
Mencot Posted April 18, 2013 Posted April 18, 2013 (woke up by two beeps from my mobile) emails from someone here whispering and asking me to change my vote before it is too late. I didn´t reconsider, but the I saw your last comment Allison Davey says he suspects you of being scum and if he wants to look town he wouldn't pay attention to you. I, for one: Vote: Davey Osborne (Mencot) For a couple of reasons: I'm Town I suspect Davey of being scum He's the other lynch candidate today Lynching me is a really bad idea. No-lynch, even, would be better than lynching me. If you truly was town, you would know I am town an wouldn´t vote for me. I trusted you as a friend but I had some doubts a few days ago, which I sayd in pm to Adriano. There for: Vote: Allison Reynolds (jamesn) Sorry, I truly hope this is the right thing to do. Now back to bed. Ah have to unvote also first (bit sleepy) Unvote: Mary Jane (mostlytechnic) Vote: Allison Reynolds (jamesn)
mostlytechnic Posted April 19, 2013 Posted April 19, 2013 Lots of talking going on with various people. Based on all that, I need to switch again. UnVote: Allison Reynolds (jamesn) Vote: Davey Osborne (Mencot) Current totals: 4 for davey, 3 allison, and 1 unvoted. That's Bob, Lucy, Allison, Mary Jane voting Davey, Claire, and Brian, and Davey voting Allison Jeanie unvoted yet.
jimmynick Posted April 19, 2013 Posted April 19, 2013 OK. I've realised that at this stage, it won't hurt anyone (other than scum) to say this: You must not lynch me today because I am the doctor. I had a little suberfuge worked out with Cameron. He would "look like" the doctor in-thread (and I would distance myself from the role) so he'd get expelled by scum if it got to that (and it did, but it kept me around). These are my actions (I am allowed to target myself but not the same person two nights in a row): Night One - inherited Night Two - forgot to send in action on time Night Three - Andrew Night Four - Cameron Night Five - Brian Night Six - Adriano Night Seven - Mary Jane Night Eight - Claire This is why I was really very hesitant to vote for Burton Guster (the possibility I had protected the right person). I also wanted to confirm Shawna as killer because of my action on Nights Three and Four. Going into tonight, I will have about a 1 in 7 chance of choosing the right person to protect, but I know whom I will protect if I have the chance. Oh - I was successful on all nights. I've never been blocked. My prime suspects for scum at the moment are Davey and Bobby. I am keeping my vote where it is.
Darkdragon Posted April 19, 2013 Author Posted April 19, 2013 Davey Osbourne (Mencot) - 3 votes (Hammerstein NWC, Esurient, jamesn) Allison Reynolds (jamesn) - 4 votes (LegoDad, Purpearljellyblob, mostlytechnic, mencot) There are 2 hours left in the day.
mostlytechnic Posted April 19, 2013 Posted April 19, 2013 Those totals are not correct - my last vote was switching to Davey. But I may switch back. Don't know who I trust right now (well, there are some I trust, and some I don't. But not sure which way my vote should lie between Allison and Davey...)
Darkdragon Posted April 19, 2013 Author Posted April 19, 2013 Davey Osbourne (Mencot) - 4 votes (Hammerstein NWC, Esurient, jamesn, mostlytechnic) Allison Reynolds (jamesn) - 3 votes (LegoDad, Purpearljellyblob, mencot) There are 1.5 hours left in the day.
mostlytechnic Posted April 19, 2013 Posted April 19, 2013 Thanks for fixing the totals. Sorry to have to do this to the teachers, but... Unvote: Davey Osborne (Mencot) Vote: Allison Reynolds (jamesn) Reason: I don't trust her doc claim at this point. Some have expressed private doubts (wiht decent support) and it'd be too easy to fake. If she's scum claiming town doc, just announce tomorrow that she protected someone who didn't die. There's no way to verify her claim. I say expel allison, have our blocker block davey, and there's high odds of all the town surviving the night.
jimmynick Posted April 19, 2013 Posted April 19, 2013 You mustn't expel me! I'm town, and the doctor, and if you expel me you'll be incredibly vulnerable tomorrow! You can't afford to lose a townie. Why don't you give me specifics about doubts that I can respond to?
Mencot Posted April 19, 2013 Posted April 19, 2013 After discussing with others, I'm going to switch for now. Doesn't mean I don't still suspect Davey, but... Lots of talking going on with various people. Based on all that, I need to switch again. Who are you talking with in the shadows I think it is too late for Allison now (hopefuly she will turn up scum) but a real threat is Mary Jane also. Yea the blocker should block me then it would be proved I am really town, but that would mean that another town will be killed if there is more scum other then the one.
Darkdragon Posted April 19, 2013 Author Posted April 19, 2013 Davey Osbourne (Mencot) - 3 votes (Hammerstein NWC, Esurient, jamesn) Allison Reynolds (jamesn) - 4 votes (LegoDad, Purpearljellyblob, mencot, mostlytechnic) Non Voter - badboytje88 Day Nine has ended. A majority has not been reached. Day 9 is over and this post will now be locked. You have exactly 24 Hours from this post to submit your night actions. No late actions will be accepted.
Recommended Posts