Rufus Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 So, were there any pill claim discrepancies? You were telling the truth about Valhalla being placebo.
Piratedave84 Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Have a cold? The Godfather is high on my list of suspects after his weird contradiction about lynching Male Lover. Either you're not reading or conveniently skipped that. I did not see it, I went back and cross-read the thread and I can't really see it ... maybe I'm blind. I went back and analysed voting patterns and noticed that NPC had voted outside the 'norm' on both precedeeing days and that today he was the last one (as of this post) to vote; a change in my analysis may be waranted; NPC may be scum. Here are the voting charts for day 1, 2 and 3 Here's the pill list, their effects and whom picked what when: Why have the goon and PGO not voted yet? Based on the events of today, we need every vote we have and they know it, so why not vote? Royalty is in fact a Placebo Further to my assertion that Witch is scum, she has voted last (second last for today), on both lynch; she in fact voted dead last on the vote for Male Lover. The Paranoid Gun Owner hasn't been online since yesterday. The last thing she did was answer a PM I sent to her. The Goon has been online and is reading this topic right now. I just went to his profile and it shows last active as "private"; he also has truned of the "visitor" option; metagemey as hell but it sure looks scummy to me! Trying to hise something?
fhomess Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Why have the goon and PGO not voted yet? Based on the events of today, we need every vote we have and they know it, so why not vote? I voted above. You're doing a good job missing things today. I confirm Cursed pill as Placebo.
Piratedave84 Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I voted above. You're doing a good job missing things today. I confirm Cursed pill as Placebo. I also was entertained that he corrected the spelling of Usurper but then misspelled "oops". Vote: Usurper (TrumpetKing) I see that now! Thanks for voting ... Once called out!
jimmynick Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I have my pill now. I can confirm that the Deep Space pill is a placebo.
Hinckley Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I have my pill now. I can confirm that the Deep Space pill is a placebo. Who are you going to kill tonight, Serial Killer? The Witch, The NPC and the Parnaoid Gun Owner are pinging me pretty hard right now. That NPC especially...
jimmynick Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I can't tell now if you really think I'm the serial killer, because I'm not. Investigate me tonight. I'm not "inscrutable".
Piratedave84 Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Who are you going to kill tonight, Serial Killer? The Witch, The NPC and the Parnaoid Gun Owner are pinging me pretty hard right now. That NPC especially... How did you come to that conclusion?
Hinckley Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 In addition to my suspicions about The NPC, who is basically flying under the radar and only answering to direct accusations, not doing any Scum-hunting, I'm still suspicious of The Stump. I know Male Lover voted for him on Day One, but that doesn't mean anything. The Male Lover is a very smart person and the Scum may have taken advantage of the votes being so spread out to put some distance between themselves. It just bugs me a lot that The Stump chose the two-lynch rule and then did nothing to help find a viable alternative to The Cultist and ultimately just hopped on his bandwagon. I can't tell now if you really think I'm the serial killer, because I'm not. Investigate me tonight. I'm not "inscrutable". I don't know if I really think so or not either, but I'm having fun with the joke. Maybe The Witch or The NPC is the Serial Killer. Or The Paranoid Gun Owner. The Serial Killer should want to kill Scum too, so maybe they are one of the players acting very pro-Townie right now. Maybe it's that one dude...The Doctor.
jimmynick Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I would also support a lynch of the stump! I was primarily concerned about your apparently effortless flip-flop on The Stump @ First day lynch, I'm super busy today, but I'll address your concerns tomorrow (RL time). Let me just say that I was not opposed to the lynch of the stump, I was trying to explain how I thought he waranted scrutiny. Don't try to shift the focus towards me. Now is a good time. Took me about 2 hours to red the thread and here are my comments: I am town -I know this as per my PM from the werewolf NPC and Talking animal are likely town seeing asd they were both accused and scrutinized by known scum - Unconfirmed Female Lover is likely town based on his leading the charge against Legodad - Unconfirmed Cult Leader and Role Player are 'confirmed' town PR's Stump may be town; Male lover had voted for him day 1 - Unconfirmed FDL & Role Cop appear to be town and seem trusted by Role Player - Unconfirmed This leaves: BONAD, PGO, Witch and Goon as being "really unconfirmed". Based on my building a case (or truing to) against PGO and FDL's willingness to follow me, I theorize that PGO may be Town leaving the scum team as being: BONAD, Witch, Goon, Usurper and Snake Charmer along with LegoDad As of when I started to type this, the Goon and PGO had yet to vote. Thank you for your thoughts about everyone, but you didn't really answer my question about why you first really wanted to lynch Stump, then were opposed to lynching Stump and now are fairly keen to lynch him. All you've said today is that he might be town. Why do you think he might be scum? I agree, Stumpy may be scum because he's constantly defending and not being proactive in scum-hunting (same goes for NPC), but could you tell us what you think?
Piratedave84 Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Originaly I suggestes that we lynch a lurker/inactiveplayer and gave Stump as an example and mentionned that we may want to lynch him as part of my analysis. At that point we did not have any other solid lead, so to me lynching a lurker was a good idea. I never pushed for a lynch; I don't know where this idea comes from. Several people then pointed out that it may not be the best idea and I agreed with them; this is ehat I think you are referring to as me no longer wanting to lynch him (even though I never actually pushed for his lynch). I think be may be town based on how scum have voted for him in the past. He was also cleared by role player earlier; I don't understand why you want me to prove he is scum. Where in my post do you see Me referring to Stump as scum?
Hinckley Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 The Royalty Pill has been taken by three suspects: The Doctor, The Paranoid Gun Owner and The NPC. We need to get that pill tomorrow. If Paranoid Gun Owner or NPC grab it again, they're automatically lynched.
Piratedave84 Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 The Royalty Pill has been taken by three suspects: The Doctor, The Paranoid Gun Owner and The NPC. We need to get that pill tomorrow. If Paranoid Gun Owner or NPC grab it again, they're automatically lynched. It's a placebo
Tamamono Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I've gotten all the PR claims. If there's anyone who is a town PR but has not yet claimed to me, please do so now. I want to make sure we don't have any scummos trying to infiltrate our spectacular townteam. The Paranoid Gun Owner hasn't been online since yesterday. The last thing she did was answer a PM I sent to her. The Goon has been online and is reading this topic right now. It'd be cool if PGO could actually, you know, sign on sometime soon. I just thought of something: Why didn't the Scum janitor The Male Lover? Wouldn't that have been really smart? It was a long shot and somewhat of a weak case I made against him. Him turning up Scum has led people to trust me. Why would they not try to avoid that. Was the janitor blocked? Or maybe their JOAT was busy framing or protecting ... But, the janitor would've been used really well on The Male Lover. This is a great point; I can say with complete certainty that it will no longer be of any use to them. We'll be lynching confirmeds from here-on out. Maybe we should look into who was blocked last night... The Witch, The NPC and the Parnaoid Gun Owner are pinging me pretty hard right now. That NPC especially... Is the NPC scum even though all 3 scum tried to get him lynched?
Hinckley Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I've gotten all the PR claims. If there's anyone who is a town PR but has not yet claimed to me, please do so now. I want to make sure we don't have any scummos trying to infiltrate our spectacular townteam. It'd be cool if PGO could actually, you know, sign on sometime soon. This is a great point; I can say with complete certainty that it will no longer be of any use to them. We'll be lynching confirmeds from here-on out. Maybe we should look into who was blocked last night... Is the NPC scum even though all 3 scum tried to get him lynched? You mean I have to go back and research everything? Mafia is hard...
Tamamono Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 You mean I have to go back and research everything? Mafia is hard... No you don't, I did it for you. Just read my posts, you lazy bum!!
mostlytechnic Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 I didn't get pill results for my selection - sending the werewolf a potato to ask about it....
TrumpetKing Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Serious Roleplayer, yeah, I'm the vanilla serial killer vigilante blocker role cop with a pet squirrel. #winning.
Tamamono Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Serious Roleplayer, yeah, I'm the vanilla serial killer vigilante blocker role cop with a pet squirrel. #winning. Is there some significance to the squirrel??
Hinckley Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 So, Tree Stump, what was the conversation with Darth Potato like regarding the God Pill. Surely you must've contacted him when you saw he got that pill. A Townie would definitely want to poke that person to make sure they're not Scum. I'm almost certain a true Townie would contact the recipient of the God Pill when they saw what rule change was chosen. Right? Do, what was said? Great WIFOM, by the way, Usurper and Snake Charmer. The invention, telling a Townie you received an invention, the summary of the fake conversation. Too bad it was "putting all of your Scum in one basket". But honestly, nice play.
Kadabra Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Strumpet. He's right, you know. You are just sitting here staring at all of us. We can see you. You too, Serial Killer! My Excel sheet is sending me messages. It can read your allegiance. It is an investigator. Where has that fence-riding, contradicting, Scummy Godfather gone? Abra-abra-Kadabra. I'm gonna reach out and lynch you...tomorrow. Abra-abra-Kadabra. Abra-Kadabra. I really feel like I'm missing something here. We talked about the fence straddling yesterday, and it really chafed my dick, so we're not doing that anymore. . Did you find something fresh back there that you want to bring up? If so, could you, y'know, tell me so I can respond?
DarthPotato Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 Great WIFOM, by the way, Usurper and Snake Charmer. The invention, telling a Townie you received an invention, the summary of the fake conversation. Too bad it was "putting all of your Scum in one basket". But honestly, nice play. We could have got away with it and have Usurper appear more Town if he didn't claim Role Cop.... Nah, just kidding, I can see why you were overeager, Usurper. Just take it as a learning experience.
TrumpetKing Posted June 3, 2013 Posted June 3, 2013 #sorry #comesfromneverbeingscumbeforeandgettingabiteager #squirrel #vanillatownieserialkillervigilanteblockerrolecopw/asquirel
mostlytechnic Posted June 4, 2013 Posted June 4, 2013 finally got my pill info, the magical is indeed a placebo. I'm now 0 for 3 in getting anything :(
Recommended Posts