DarthPotato Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Well, let's not just blow off the rest of this day just because someone flipped scum in an inspection result. I'm still suspicious of Rocky, but if Paris really does come up scum then I'll admit that I'll be less suspicious of him. Paris was saying a couple times earlier today that he'd be a good lynch candidate, but by the way she was saying it it sounded like she wanted to step back a little for if he really was lynched. If Paris is Town then I'd still be suspicious of Rocky, but by the way things are looking I'm thinking Paris is scum and Rocky might actually be Townie after all. But we'll see tomorrow. Anyone? Abraham, are you suspicious of anyone other than Paris? I haven't exactly seen you scrutinize anyone other than the lynch candidates. Danyelle, where are you?
Fred Daniel Yam Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Anyone? Abraham, are you suspicious of anyone other than Paris? I haven't exactly seen you scrutinize anyone other than the lynch candidates. Danyelle, where are you? right now? No-one, I really need to re-read everything that's happened so far.
Mencot Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Anyone? Abraham, are you suspicious of anyone other than Paris? I haven't exactly seen you scrutinize anyone other than the lynch candidates. Danyelle, where are you? Not so much Abraham and Carlisa are some what but that is because of all the hype of the PMs Laurence sent out. But we should not quiet down now Council members, because that will just give the scum monster get on the edge of us. The biggest of course for today as we all know is to test the cop claim but we need to think hard on peoples comments and votes (but this is a bit hard because it is still day 2, so not much can be said yet about behaviour)
CMP Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Could've sworn I voted earlier. Vote: Shawty Paris (Tamomono)
Mencot Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Sorry Paris Lets put the cop to the bench: Vote: Paris Shawty (Tamomono)
Tamamono Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Sorry Paris Lets put the cop to the bench: Vote: Paris Shawty (Tamomono)
Mencot Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 MI bella bello, don´t cry We know that if our queen Paris turns out town, then who will get on the choppingblock pretty fast then. But everybody has been awfully quiet and what puts me in the eye two people, Alicia (legodad) and Melanie, where are you two chatterboxes. first you put out all kinds of things and in day one you Melanie was really vocal but now you are not... How many hours are left?
Waterbrick Down Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 MI bella bello, don´t cry We know that if our queen Paris turns out town, then who will get on the choppingblock pretty fast then. But everybody has been awfully quiet and what puts me in the eye two people, Alicia (legodad) and Melanie, where are you two chatterboxes. first you put out all kinds of things and in day one you Melanie was really vocal but now you are not... How many hours are left? Considering that all the evidence is now out there, there isn't much left to chat about.
PsyKater Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 MI bella bello, don´t cry We know that if our queen Paris turns out town, then who will get on the choppingblock pretty fast then. But everybody has been awfully quiet and what puts me in the eye two people, Alicia (legodad) and Melanie, where are you two chatterboxes. first you put out all kinds of things and in day one you Melanie was really vocal but now you are not... How many hours are left? Who is on the choppingblock then? I for myself do not know the identity of this person yet.
TrumpetKing Posted July 31, 2013 Author Posted July 31, 2013 Vote Tally Paris Shawty (Tamamono): 15 (Kadabra, DarthPotato, Waterbrick Down, Capt. Redblade, Dannylonglegs, Fred Daniel Yam, Captain Nemo, Endgame, Peanuts, Esurient, Kristel, LegoDad, PsyKater, CallMePie, Mencot) Abraham Petruzzi (Fred Daniel Yam): 1 (Tamamono) With 18 Players remaining, a majority of 10 is required to form a lynch. ~11.5 Hours until Day's end.
CMP Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Who is on the choppingblock then? I for myself do not know the identity of this person yet. The person who claims to have an investigation result on her, obviously...
DarthPotato Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 right now? No-one, I really need to re-read everything that's happened so far. Have you found anyone else your suspicious of yet?
PsyKater Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 The person who claims to have an investigation result on her, obviously... Yes, obviously. But I asked Benvolio and wonder why you are answering on his behalf. I asked him because I was curious what he meant...
CMP Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Yes, obviously. But I asked Benvolio and wonder why you are answering on his behalf. I asked him because I was curious what he meant... I answered because I thought it was obvious enough what he was referring to, but why did you ask if it's obvious to you, too?
Kristel Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Considering that all the evidence is now out there, there isn't much left to chat about. I don't think we have evidence yet, what we've got is claims and counterclaims. We won't know anything for sure until tomorrow morning. The person who claims to have an investigation result on her, obviously... It's obvious who will be under scrutiny tomorrow if Paris flips town, but I don't agree we should throw her straight on the chopping block. I'll wait to hear what Alicia has to say for herself first.
Mencot Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Who is on the choppingblock then? I for myself do not know the identity of this person yet. I don't think we have evidence yet, what we've got is claims and counterclaims. We won't know anything for sure until tomorrow morning. It's obvious who will be under scrutiny tomorrow if Paris flips town, but I don't agree we should throw her straight on the chopping block. I'll wait to hear what Alicia has to say for herself first. Si, bella Alicia is who I meant and yes she will have some explaining to do. Because everything isn´t always cristalclear obviously. Like take this paris situation, yes I know we gotta do this to test it out but does anyone else get a bad feeling about this? Considering that all the evidence is now out there, there isn't much left to chat about. Hey there is plenty to talk about, this would just be one scum catch(considering paris is scum) we got 3-4 scum left after that and the monsters lurk and chat in the shadows, planning their next move. What will we council do next after this?
CMP Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 It's obvious who will be under scrutiny tomorrow if Paris flips town, but I don't agree we should throw her straight on the chopping block. I'll wait to hear what Alicia has to say for herself first. She'd have to say a hell of a lot to convince me of her innocence, that's for sure.
Peanuts Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 It's obvious who will be under scrutiny tomorrow if Paris flips town, but I don't agree we should throw her straight on the chopping block. I'll wait to hear what Alicia has to say for herself first. I agree. If Paris is town, we shouldn't just jump to the conclusion that the claim is a lie. There are more possibilities, and it's unlikely someone would lie that early. *to Henry* This investigation result seems to have a bad effect on the discussion. And on my hairstyle, too! I can feel my hair volume deminishing! You're right, it still looks perfect. Of course. Nothing to worry about...I'll just take a deep breath and calm down. *end of monologue* So, where was I? Oh, yeah, the discussion. I think if Paris is scum, it's less likely that certain people are scum, such as Ronald, Benvolio or me. Also, I wonder why Juliet seems to be so inclined to lynch someone who might be an investigator?
CMP Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Also, I wonder why Juliet seems to be so inclined to lynch someone who might be an investigator? Did you have to practice to make that far a jump to a conclusion? I'm not letting Alicia off the hook so easily if Paris comes up town. Because if she does, Alicia has just led us to lynch a PR. Maybe Paris was rolecopped and that's why they're doing it. Maybe Alicia just wanted to save her own megablocks. My point is, regardless of any circumstances, it's going to take a lot to convince me she's free of any guilt, since if Paris is town, I can almost guarantee she'll be quick to excuse herself with 'don't kill the messenger.'
Adam Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Shit, guys. I've just had my first ten minutes of Internet time in three days. I'm sorry for that inactivity, and I'm even sorrier to say that the next four days look to be just as sparse Internet-wise. That said, I will try to get online as often as possible, and I will briefly (my time runs short) discuss what I've taken away from the day. After that, I'll put together more extensive comments in word processing so I have them ready for when next I'm online. I was generally surprised by the investigator claim and discussion. Even with Tammo's public accusations of LegoDad, why would the investigator take so much of a risk in claiming to LegoDad? Why would he or she claim this early in the first place? And most of all, why were people so quick to take the investigation result as gospel? Hell, people were rejoicing. I expected people to be more skeptical following a certain role cop claim in an old western. That said, I do believe that the scum would be foolish to make a false role claim this early on, and I agree that the claim needs to be tested. By the way, Jelly never messaged me. Not surprising, since she and I have never chatted before. I must head out now, but I'll be back ASAP - hopefully ASAP translates into "tomorrow". Later.
Peanuts Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Did you have to practice to make that far a jump to a conclusion? I'm not letting Alicia off the hook so easily if Paris comes up town. Because if she does, Alicia has just led us to lynch a PR. Maybe Paris was rolecopped and that's why they're doing it. Maybe Alicia just wanted to save her own megablocks. My point is, regardless of any circumstances, it's going to take a lot to convince me she's free of any guilt, since if Paris is town, I can almost guarantee she'll be quick to excuse herself with 'don't kill the messenger.' I won't be letting her off the hook, but it would be quite an audacious move to claim cop, wouldn't it? Especially since they have to assume we actually have a cop who could counterclaim. And just to lynch a tracker, who they just as well might kill at night instead.
CMP Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 I won't be letting her off the hook, but it would be quite an audacious move to claim cop, wouldn't it? Especially since they have to assume we actually have a cop who could counterclaim. And just to lynch a tracker, who they just as well might kill at night instead. I'm listing possibilities here. I'm pretty sure Paris is scum based on the investigation result, but you never know.
mostlytechnic Posted August 1, 2013 Posted August 1, 2013 I'm pretty sure Paris is scum too, but I still can't wrap my head around a cop claiming to anyone this early - and supposedly to more than one person! Before I forget... Vote: Paris Shawty (Tamomono) not that it's needed at this point, but still important to go on record with my position on things, despite my glossophobia
LegoDad Posted August 1, 2013 Posted August 1, 2013 I'm pretty sure Paris is scum too, but I still can't wrap my head around a cop claiming to anyone this early - and supposedly to more than one person! Before I forget... Vote: Paris Shawty (Tamomono) not that it's needed at this point, but still important to go on record with my position on things, despite my glossophobia I'm pretty sure the getting in touch with more than one person was a safeguard. If they messaged just one person, and that person is scum, the Cop is dead, and can be counterclaimed by the scum knowing full well who they killed. If they message two people, one is scum, the other hopefully town, there is someone else there that can live to tell the story and give the identity of the other messaged and the identity of the Cop. Believe me, school is running through my head like a train right now, analyzing differences and similarities, hoping to God that lightning doesn't strike twice. Paris went to school with me and knows this, which I believe to be the reason that she went so hard after the idea of another frame, trying to get everybody questioning themselves, and particularly myself. With the way she went off the handle and then went quiet, however, I am not terribly worried.
Dannylonglegs Posted August 1, 2013 Posted August 1, 2013 Due to the fact that I don't expect to be alive tomorrow, I'll share some more PMs. Again, my analysis assumes Paris is scum. Off Topic Banter. The best poets are the ones who are just trying to curse someone out when someone overanalyzes their words. You weren't trying to do exactly that, but hey, close enough. This was the first 'on-topic' item that came up, after we shared some youtube songs and accused each-other of being scum/SKs. Notice the not-accusing, but still critical reference to Alicia. I don't quite know what to make of it, especially considering how 'opposing' the two are. I may just be railroading, but I feel that there may be more to their interactions than meets the eye. Despite being the one to come-out with Paris's cop results (which would be a very smart move for a scum to make, and does not at all absolve her of suspicion), I think she may be in-league with him. Again, it's possible I'm just railroading here, and I'd like to reevaluate my analysis of their interactions before actually accusing her. It's equally possible that Paris just wants her lynched. I do not think the same goes for Melanie, who Paris says he contacted in addition to me. He sent out mild feelers early in the day to judge my opinion when I hadn't spoken in the thread, but I told him I did not feel she was scummy, and he agreed with me after. I feel safe in my assumption that Paris and she are not scummates, as I would not suspect him to attempt to slide a scummate into my trust like that so blatantly. I have not contacted Melanie to confirm that Paris did infact contact her, but that's easily done. Yeah, I'll be honest, I don't know how to feel about Jelly. Jelly, Legodad, and Darth Potato are all sorta on my '?' list. I already said that I don't know what I'm feelin' on Potato yet, but LegoDad is a huge "?" for me. He seems really confident. Scum confidence?? DP is another issue entirely. I don't like the way my suspicions of him are consistently cast off as being not valid when almost all of my other suspicions were taken as 'hmm, yes, that's possible.' Again, I might just be railroading, but it doesn't settle easily with me. That combined with his new-found aggressiveness from this morning combine to make me suspect Paris told DP how to act to make himself seem less scummy. Paris went on to tell me in private that DP's new aggressiveness was a town-tell. Alright, sounds good. It's looking like DarthPotato and I are both nailing scummos to the wall. I feel like DarthPotato is looking more and more town by the minute. Read the thread and give me your opinion on LegoDad's defense!! I don't want to convince myself that someone's scum again, but this dude is seriously asking for it. I think he's scum. ------ Even with all the scum defending scum we've been seeing in the past few games? Given, I think Nemo is more suspicious for this, but still. I have no read on DarthPotato yet. He's playing a bit more level-headed than in Mafia Mafia (where he was obvious scum), but then again, acting like that again would be utter suicide for him. I'll wait and see what the rest of the Day/tomorrow (game time) have in store before really passing any judgement on him... Unimportant talk related solely to Dave. I don't know, am I being too paranoid? I definitely think Captain Nemo and PirateDave are a team, but I'm afraid that I'm getting into the habit of suspecting everyone who doesn't absolutely agree with me. Then again, you disagree on my Dave read, and I don't particularly suspect you... yet. Yes, my Tammo-tendrils shoot out as soon as the first Day is posted. I've also contacted mostlytechnic, as I said, because his No Lynch idea seemed town to me. Neither of us really want to talk to the other one, though. All-game he has been pushing Nemo as his primary suspect to me. I do not know if this is a bussing attempt, or an attempt to get a lynchable Townie lynched. Same goes for Abraham, who's his other main suspect sort-of. He hadn't really pushed his scummyness to me in private. I did most of that actually, if I recall correctly. To be perfectly fair, as scum I know enough to hardbus even when it's not necessary. Still, I'm town. Lynch Nemo/Fred Daniel Yam in the coming days. Both are definitely scum. If there's one thing I can do for this ungrateful town it's catch them scum. This was one of his last on-topic not-personal statements. It's the one that's made me question my suspicions the most. I understand that it's likely just to make me question my accurate readings, but I wouldn't put "Hardbussing" beneath Paris, especially considering how wonderfully manipulative she is.
Recommended Posts