Heroica RPG - Cruel Angel's Thesis ~ Day Two

[CMP]

Wasn't there another spellcaster caught flinging spells?

"We know of only the three that struck during Day One."

[Scubacarrot]

"Then attack during the day and give reasoning. I said he was scum is not reasoning. Someone else said he was scum is not reasoning. I for one think we should kill U'Dargan. Buying the item that is most helpful to a Nephilim. I propose this: The HEROICANS DO NOT ATTACK AT NIGHT. There is much more we can learn from attacking during the day, and being open about it. If no Heroicans attack during the night, anyone that is caught attacking is instantly suspicious as well. By the way, I was the one that did the first strike on Kob. Sorry about that."

Scamander shakes his head, and rolls up another one.

[Tachyon]

And Zarissa's compliance doesn't necessarily clear her of all guilt.

Hence why I called for an investigation.

[CMP]

"Why, so the scum can make twice as much progress than us by, like, acting at night, too?"

Calico coughed and waved Scamander's smoke fumes out of her face.

[Scubacarrot]

"All of us have other helpful actions than attacking. You're proposing killing a potentially incredibly strong player because two people gave half-assed explanations they found him suspicious? I repeat myself, everyone involved in the death of Piro, if he turns out Heroican, I will go after with all my powers. You'd be dead. I promise you."

[Kadabra]

So we should just sit around in the day waiting for the Nephilim to politely reveal themselves to us, then do nothing at night while they murder us! Is that what you're saying?

[Scubacarrot]

"Don't pretend you are ignorant, Kharybdis. It doesn't look good on you."

[Fred Daniel Yam]

"Why, so the scum can make twice as much progress than us by, like, acting at night, too?"

Calico coughed and waved Scamander's smoke fumes out of her face.

Don't the scum already act at night...

[Kadabra]

"All of us have other helpful actions than attacking. You're proposing killing a potentially incredibly strong player because two people gave half-assed explanations they found him suspicious? I repeat myself, everyone involved in the death of Piro, if he turns out Heroican, I will go after with all my powers. You'd be dead. I promise you."

Also, we may have other powers but attacking is our most useful asset. It's the only way to get rid of scum. Also, how on Olegaia was Piro a strong player? And you, Mr. Minstrel, likely can't back up murder threats with song playing... Unless you have your scumbuddies like Ezeal and Piro backing you up, and they won't be able to do that when they're dead.

[CMP]

"You're proposing killing a potentially incredibly strong player because two people gave half-assed explanations they found him suspicious?"

"From the guy who helped out killing Kob, you'll forgive me if I find this hi-larious."

"I repeat myself, everyone involved in the death of Piro, if he turns out Heroican, I will go after with all my powers. You'd be dead. I promise you."

"Fine. If he turns out Nephilim, we're taking out your whole little block anyway, Goatass."

Don't the scum already act at night...

"Yeah, and we can too, which is why I'm not agreeing to not acting at night."

[Scubacarrot]

"It's not though. It's the prime way to get Heroicans killed. Which is what is happening. And strong as in strong physically. I don't know if you realize, but if it were up to the Nephilim, they'd get rid of the higher level players that aren't them sooner rather than later."

"From the guy who helped out killing Kob, you'll forgive me if I find this hi-larious."

Here's the difference: Suspicious Low level player with no further harsh implications if wrong, and only two actions needed. Versus: High level player that (I still haven't seen reasoning why he was suspicious) I don't find suspicious which would take a number of actions and would result in Heroica losing a strong player if dead. Dude, don't even try. You're not succeeding, at any rate.

[CMP]

"It's not though. It's the prime way to get Heroicans killed. Which is what is happening. And strong as in strong physically. I don't know if you realize, but if it were up to the Nephilim, they'd get rid of the higher level players that aren't them sooner rather than later."

"I don't know if you realize, but it is up to the Nephilim - if you haven't noticed, they're actively attacking people - and they've killed off the three weakest players so far."

[Brickdoctor]

The attack during the Night was coordinated in light of the suspicious activities of Piro Yesterday, which I will not list because they have already been detailed multiple times. Ezeal and his group are not believed to be trustworthy because of how they behaved outside of and in reference to the attack and because of what one of them is capable of doing compared to attacks that happened, not because of the attack itself.

"It's not though. It's the prime way to get Heroicans killed. Which is what is happening.

Actually, Ezeal is the only one who we know for certain killed a hero.

[Kadabra]

"It's not though. It's the prime way to get Heroicans killed. Which is what is happening. And strong as in strong physically. I don't know if you realize, but if it were up to the Nephilim, they'd get rid of the higher level players that aren't them sooner rather than later."

Really? It seems like they're picking off low level players first. You know, Pauline, Heron, the attempt on Calico's life, Kob.

[Scubacarrot]

because they have already been detailed multiple times.

Liar.

[CMP]

Liar.

"Idiot?"

We launched an attack on Piro last night that should have killed him (4 HP overkill, in fact) based on numerous red flags he raised, including discussion of the situation outside of the Hall and being on the scum list of confirmed Hallie Pauline, who is known to have excellent intuition in these scenarios. Despite this he survived, and seeing as no sane Hallie would Cover him we are acting in the assumption that he is Nephilim."

That's what we're doing.

Piro was attacked last night based on a number of red flags he raised (to name a few: Playing outside the thread, being on Pauline's list, being one of the spellcasters who could have been the one to assault Calico and then Theodor). Despite the fact that we did 4 damage overkill he survived. That means he was Covered by another hero. He was scummy to neutral at best yesterday, and no sane townie would have Covered him. Ergo, it must have been a scumbuddy who knew he was on Pauline's list or knew he was under suspicion some other way.

[Scubacarrot]

"I don't know if you realize, but it is up to the Nephilim - if you haven't noticed, they're actively attacking people - and they've killed off the three weakest players so far."

I personally think that in the attacks we saw yesterday evening, and last night, there were definitely some Nephilim. That's where we have to look. Going after Piro is deercrap.

[Kadabra]

We launched an attack on Piro last night that should have killed him (4 HP overkill, in fact) based on numerous red flags he raised, including discussion of the situation outside of the Hall and being on the scum list of confirmed Hallie Pauline, who is known to have excellent intuition in these scenarios. Despite this he survived, and seeing as no sane Hallie would Cover him we are acting in the assumption that he is Nephilim."

Your reason was that Kob found Luridan suspicious consistently and didn't stop thinking he was suspicious later. That could be applied to most of us. It's also interesting to note that both Piro and Fleyra questioned you at first and didn't seem to support your attack, (distancing themselves from a scumbuddy making a move that seemed like it might he unpopular?) then Fleyra changed to supporting you, even stating 'it is highly likely that the Orc Mage is one of the fallen angels'. What? How is that a true statement at all? Your only reasoning was tenuous at best. Trying to avoid her scumbuddy getting killed? Also, the two of them starting in opposition to you and now apparently being your 'friends' is a good example of either lying if they were already your friends or wishy-washyness if they weren't You three are scummiest than pond water.

I don't believe that's what's being suggested; the fact that Piro is one of those capable of using a magical attack is just something supporting our other suspicions.

That's what we're doing.

Piro was attacked last night based on a number of red flags he raised (to name a few: Playing outside the thread, being on Pauline's list, being one of the spellcasters who could have been the one to assault Calico and then Theodor). Despite the fact that we did 4 damage overkill he survived. That means he was Covered by another hero. He was scummy to neutral at best yesterday, and no sane townie would have Covered him. Ergo, it must have been a scumbuddy who knew he was on Pauline's list or knew he was under suspicion some other way.

Multiple times, see.

[CMP]

I personally think that in the attacks we saw yesterday evening, and last night, there were definitely some Nephilim. That's where we have to look. Going after Piro is deercrap.

"Have you, like, read anything??? The reason we're killing Piro is because we believe he's behind Paulie's death."

[Kadabra]

I personally think that in the attacks we saw yesterday evening, and last night, there were definitely some Nephilim. That's where we have to look. Going after Piro is deercrap.

We are looking there, genius. That's why Ezeal, Eris, and Piro are on the chopping block.

[Scubacarrot]

Playing outside the thread, not a scum action. Could have been the spellcaster. Actually. No, his class imbues his normal attacks with spells, which I THINK would still be an attack from the front row, so open. Being on the list of Pauline. Don't make me laugh. Try harder to justify this blatant attack on a Heroican. He turns out to be indeed Heroican... Well, Looks like we have some good targets to go after then. That's pretty rad.

This is not good reasoning, certainly not good enough reasoning to go after a high level player, in the night. Where you COULD have gotten away with everything if he was indeed killed. I think you took it public because he survived, and he SAW at least one of you attack. Little miscalculation.

[Brickdoctor]

Also, suspiciousness pointed out in public Yesterday:

Now, on the other hand, if anyone were to apologize or make excuses for their behavior in discussion that was outside the situation in the Hall — not that I would know about such things, and it's not as if this is some sort of game — then that would be suspicious to me.

[Scubacarrot]

Okay, nevermind on that point, Piro HAS a ranged attack. Still, I think this is a continuation of a miscalculation on the Nephilim's part. I guess we'll find out.

[Brickdoctor]

Playing outside the thread, not a scum action.

Playing outside the Hall to apologize or explain your own inactivity, yes, it is a scum action. I've seen it before.

This is not good reasoning, certainly not good enough reasoning to go after a high level player, in the night. Where you COULD have gotten away with everything if he was indeed killed. I think you took it public because he survived, and he SAW at least one of you attack. Little miscalculation.

Of course we took it public because he survived. There was absolutely no reason for him to be protected if he wasn't scum. He did nothing positive Yesterday.

[Kadabra]

Playing outside the thread, not a scum action. Could have been the spellcaster. Actually. No, his class imbues his normal attacks with spells, which I THINK would still be an attack from the front row, so open. Being on the list of Pauline. Don't make me laugh. Try harder to justify this blatant attack on a Heroican. He turns out to be indeed Heroican... Well, Looks like we have some good targets to go after then. That's pretty rad.

This is not good reasoning, certainly not good enough reasoning to go after a high level player, in the night. Where you COULD have gotten away with everything if he was indeed killed. I think you took it public because he survived, and he SAW at least one of you attack. Little miscalculation.

That's Chi Monk, not Battle Mage. Stop intentionally trying to confuse players who don't play the RPG.