CorneliusMurdock Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 I'm not going to admit being a serial killer because I'm not one. I'm the vigilante and the town can see that. Your pathetic attempt to distract us won't work. I am scumhunting. You're scum. You're obsessing about a fictitious serial killer. 4-4 would be a loss if I wasn't able to kill a scum before the lynch. Duh. Not that we need to worry about it since you scum have basically admitted that there are only three of you left. I do think you had the oppurtunity to ask a question. I just think you lied about the question asked. It served as a distraction when the scum team needed one. Pay attention.
TrumpetKing Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 And I'm not going to admit to being scum because I'm not. A fictitious Serial Killer? We're warned about third parties in the rules and the numbers have enough room for a Serial Killer. Excuse me for being cautious of a Serial Killer when we're warned of them. In this game, you're right, 4-4 wouldn't be a loss, if you were a vig, but you're an SK, so it isn't even 4-4 anyways, but 1-3-4. I'm not scum, so I can't have admitted anything about numbers, as I don't know shit. Just as you speculated there were 4 scum, I speculate there's 3 and an SK, so don't megablocking accuse me for saying I think there's three scum. My theory isn't wrong just because you think you're right. In fact, it seems like you're consistently trying to convince me I'm wrong. Is it because I'm right? Why would I lie about the question I asked? What could I gain from asking a question if I were scum? I couldn't have asked who the PR's were, so do you have any better ideas on what I could have asked? What item did you take? It was the Sheriff's badge, correct?
CorneliusMurdock Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Calm down and pay attention. A lot of the points you're trying to bring up have been gone over already. Even if I were a serial killer, someone earlier pointed out that it doesn't make a difference to the scum's win condition. We still wouldn't have lost if there are 4 scum left. And I've repeated several times why you might have lied about the question you asked. It made a good distraction. Not enough to save Dexter but it had potential. As for "warnings" about third parties, I couldn't tell you how this has been set up. Serial killers are the most common third party but others are not unheard of. And just because the rules reference something, it doesn't mean that it exists. Sometimes a host will use misdirection to spice up a game.
Tamamono Posted September 16, 2013 Author Posted September 16, 2013 Voting is open. With 8 players, it takes 5 for a lynch.
CorneliusMurdock Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 I feel like we can all agree that Candy is scum. She seems to have known things she shouldn't like that Rolfie would be town. She's been one of my most adamant detractors, even though she makes no logical arguments to back her mistrust of me. I think she just wants the Vig gone because i'm in the way. Vote: Candy (Captain Nemo) If others agree that Terrence is a better lynch, I'm all for that as well. Or he may not be around to be lynched later.
Cecilie Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 I feel like we can all agree that Candy is scum. She seems to have known things she shouldn't like that Rolfie would be town. She's been one of my most adamant detractors, even though she makes no logical arguments to back her mistrust of me. I think she just wants the Vig gone because i'm in the way. Vote: Candy (Captain Nemo) If others agree that Terrence is a better lynch, I'm all for that as well. Or he may not be around to be lynched later. Voting has opened, so I think we can freely discuss your kill now. I've been thinking about the deadlines, and you said you originally had it at the 24-hour mark. That probably means that's the scum deadline for sending in whatever counteractions they might have. It makes no sense for them to be able to wait longer, if your kill can go in any time now. I'm going to say that Candy is actually least likely to be protected by the scum, as she seems to be the least useful of them. Therefore, I'd rather we lynch Terrance, and have you kill Candy. If others disagree, I'll gladly change my vote so we can secure a lynch, but for now: Vote: Terrance (TrumpetKing)
Kristel Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 ... Considering all three objects were taken, Bernard was town, you're a liar, and we don't know who the other riddle solver was, the third must be scum for me to know, correct? Who else solved the riddle then? Surely they must be scum if I am too, no? Dad suggested that Colin thought it was Dexter and that he had the hard hat. Vote: Candy (Captain Nemo) Vote: Terrance (TrumpetKing) Maybe we should talk first? I think there are most likely three scum remaining and that these are Candy, Terrence and Priscilla. I'm happy to go with Terrence for the lynch and let Colin decide whether to take out Candy or Priscilla. Vote: Terrence Knox (TrumpetKing)
Cecilie Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Maybe we should talk first? Yeah, sorry, I'd just hate for us to miss this opportunity to get two in one day, since the scum have been so nice as to let us keep Colin for another day. I think there are most likely three scum remaining and that these are Candy, Terrence and Priscilla. I'm happy to go with Terrence for the lynch and let Colin decide whether to take out Candy or Priscilla. I agree with this. If the scum have a means of protecting against the vig kill, and their deadline is the same as Colin's original deadline, then I would guess they'd protect Terrance out of the three, since he seems to be the brains. If however, their deadline has been relaxed like Colin's (I would think they still have a harder deadline than Colin, since the kills have been shown before the end of the night, so they would have had to have their actions locked in by then), then that means they could now go ahead and protect Candy if we're basically telling them that's who we're going for, so we should leave it up to Colin to pick between Candy or Priscilla. I'm assuming they can't block Colin. Nobody was silenced today, and Colin wasn't blocked from killing yesterday. On another note. Does anyone remember our dear late Bernard calling out for the investigator? I first thought he was trying to pull a sting to lure out scum into claiming investigator, but I've been contacted by Kristina tonight, and this is not the case. She has reason to believe there is still an investigator among us, because the investigator apparently cannot be killed. I would be very surprised if we've lynched the investigator without them role-claiming, so why has nobody come forward with an investigator claim? So dear investigator, whoever you are, now is the time to speak. If you have results on those of us still alive now, it would be of great value to help us determine if we're on the right course. If we make any more mistakes now, it could be our last.
Kristel Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 I just wanted to confirm that I'm talking to Cebastian and also that I have reason to believe we still have an investigator. If so, now is the time to come forward. I could have sworn I saw Priscilla hanging around earlier. Wonder why she didn't stop and say hi?
CorneliusMurdock Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Lynching Terrance it is, then. Unvote: Candy (Captain Nemo) Vote: Terrance Knox (Trumpetking) Since we're still looking for the investigator, I'd like to remind them that this could be the last chance they have to help us. I'm pretty confidant about Terrance, Candy, and Priscilla but I'd sleep better if we had some back-up info.
mostlytechnic Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Maybe we should talk first? What then have we been doing for all day and the first part of tonight? What reason would you possibly have for waiting to vote? We can always change if something comes up (investigator results, people dropping dead, etc), but why wait and increase the risk of non-lynching? I'm assuming they can't block Colin. Nobody was silenced today, and Colin wasn't blocked from killing yesterday. On another note. Does anyone remember our dear late Bernard calling out for the investigator? I first thought he was trying to pull a sting to lure out scum into claiming investigator, but I've been contacted by Kristina tonight, and this is not the case. She has reason to believe there is still an investigator among us, because the investigator apparently cannot be killed. I would be very surprised if we've lynched the investigator without them role-claiming, so why has nobody come forward with an investigator claim? So dear investigator, whoever you are, now is the time to speak. If you have results on those of us still alive now, it would be of great value to help us determine if we're on the right course. If we make any more mistakes now, it could be our last. So then Dexter must have been their blocker. At least we got a scum ability, not just a peon with our first successful lynch. As for investigator, then either our original investigator is still alive (why haven't you said ANYTHING?????) or was one of Colin's kills or a scum kill, cause someone getting lynched would have said something even if their ability was getting passed on. Heck that'd be a great opportunity - you could say everything you knew and then the scum would have to start from scratch trying to figure out who the investigator was (or not state that your ability was getting passed on, and then they'd think the investigator was dead and not worry about that anymore). So the investigator must have died unexpectedly. Even so, why hasn't the new investigator said anything? If your ability really does pass on, then speak up since even if you die we don't lose the role! We can't afford any more mistakes. I could have sworn I saw Priscilla hanging around earlier. Wonder why she didn't stop and say hi? Are you really going down that useless path again? And I'll throw in, since no reason to wait: Vote: Terrance Knox (Trumpetking)
CorneliusMurdock Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 They said the investigator couldn't be killed. They never said anything about the ability being passed on. The only way to lose our investigator was a lynch? Did Byron or Doggy give any hints that it could have been one of them before they passed? Both had plenty of time to claim before the end. Who's left here that it could be and why won't they come forward?
Tamamono Posted September 16, 2013 Author Posted September 16, 2013 Vote Count Terrence Knox (Trumpetking) - 4 (Cecilie, Kristel, CorneliusMurdock, mostlytechnic) 36 hours until Dawn.
mostlytechnic Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 They said the investigator couldn't be killed. They never said anything about the ability being passed on. The only way to lose our investigator was a lynch? Did Byron or Doggy give any hints that it could have been one of them before they passed? Both had plenty of time to claim before the end. Who's left here that it could be and why won't they come forward? My bad, I assumed (and you know what assuming does...) that unkillable = pass on the ability. Most of the time I've seen unkillable roles it's meant that, but you're right, it doesn't have to.
Peanuts Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Candy is still pretty scummy, and I still think either Cebastian or Terrence has to be scum. I ranked Cebastian higher then Terrence, but Terrence has raised a few flags over the course of the night. I also still think Kristina is town, and if she says she's in contact with Cebastian and she thinks he's town, I guess I go ahead and believe her. So, I'm more sure about Candy then about Terrence, but seeing as I have been wrong before, I have no problem following the town and lynching either of the two.
CorneliusMurdock Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Why hesitate to vote, then, Pete?
Peanuts Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 Why hesitate to vote, then, Pete? There you go: Vote: Terrence Knox (Trumpetking)
Tamamono Posted September 16, 2013 Author Posted September 16, 2013 Vote Count Terrence Knox (Trumpetking) - 5 (Cecilie, Kristel, CorneliusMurdock, mostlytechnic, Peanuts) 28 hours until Dawn.
mostlytechnic Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 A few left to vote, and Terrance has been strangely quiet for someone about to be lynched. Giving up already, scummo?
Palathadric Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 They said the investigator couldn't be killed. They never said anything about the ability being passed on. What I wonder is how would Bernard have been able to know that without: A. being the investigator himself B. being in contact with the investigator (presumably would have to pass through Kristina) or C. having been told that by someone else (Kristina). In any case, it would seem to me that either Bernard was the investigator, was just making something up, or had gotten information from Kristina (which doesn't seem to be the case? ) In any case, since all communicating has to, it seems, go through Kristina, I don't see how she would know whether the investigator was killable or not without the investigator having told her that. Or do we have two communications people? As for me, I'm not the investigator. I honestly would prefer to vote Candy over Terrence as she seems the more suspicious one and the one whom I am more certain is scum, but I'll be a good little sheep. Baa, baa! Vote: Terrence Knox (Trumpetking)
Tamamono Posted September 16, 2013 Author Posted September 16, 2013 Vote Count Terrence Knox (Trumpetking) - 6 (Cecilie, Kristel, CorneliusMurdock, mostlytechnic, Peanuts, Palathadric) 27 hours until Dawn.
Kristel Posted September 16, 2013 Posted September 16, 2013 In the interests of not going off on a tangent, the information about the investigator came from me. I was told by someone who is now dead. They were town, so I have no reason to believe they would have lied about that.
Captain Nemo Posted September 17, 2013 Posted September 17, 2013 ....but I'll be a good little sheep. Baa, baa! Ummmm. Lamb chops Anywho, I'll place my vote on Terrence; since he seems the scummiest. Vote: Terrence Knox (Trumpetking)
Tamamono Posted September 17, 2013 Author Posted September 17, 2013 Vote Count Terrence Knox (Trumpetking) - 7 (Cecilie, Kristel, CorneliusMurdock, mostlytechnic, Peanuts, Palathadric, Captain Nemo) 26 hours until Dawn.
TrumpetKing Posted September 17, 2013 Posted September 17, 2013 Excuse me for being absent, I actually had personal reasons for being gone that took over for a moment. I already know there's nothing to do at this point to save me, but I'm still going to fight for my life, as I'm town. Just let me catch up.
Recommended Posts