VOTING THREAD: Week Fifteen counters vs Week Fourteen Guerrillas

[Garmadon]

Week Fifteen counters vs Week Fourteen Guerrillas:

VOTING: Anyone can vote!

Voting closes June 14th

Which side won? Which was the best counter build?

Judging criteria: This is a straight one versus one contest. The challenger versus the best (in your opinion) counter build (if there are multiple counter builds). So judge solely on Challenger versus best counter build. Remember, story should play a bit into your judging criteria. Also, a counter must effectively undo the guerrilla attack. Even if the Counter MOC is better, if you don't think it successfully undoes the guerrilla attack, you should probably vote for the guerrilla attack.

Thank you!

Zone: A4

Challenger: LordDan

What Faction can counter: High Council

No counter? Desert King wins by default.

Zone: J7

Challenger: Jacob Nion

See it working.

Counter: Garmadon

Second Counter: Kai NRG

Zone: O16

Challenger: Kai NRG

Counter: Jacob Nion

Zone: G15

Challenger: Garmadon

Counter: LordDan

Zone: B12

Challenger: Kai NRG

Counter: Blufiji

+ Zone: B12

Challenger: Garmadon

Counter: Captain Braunsfeld

+ Zone: B12

Challenger: Marcu22

Counter: Captain Braunsfeld

Zone: F1

Challenger: Garmadon

Counter: mrcp6d

Zone: D13

Challenger: Adair

What Faction can counter: Desert King

No counter? High Council wins by default.

[Adair]

A lot of close ones here... well, mission accomplished with mine then, either way. :)

[Captain Braunsfeld]

A lot of close ones here... well, mission accomplished with mine then, either way. :)

Right, applies to all of us .. mission accomplished!

[Captain Braunsfeld]

I'd be interested to know when the last vote was cast on this one.

Reason: When I checked on Sunday evening (14th - European time) I had 14 votes for B12 and marcu22 had 13.

Since June 15th this has changed to a draw. Was that still "in time"?

[Jacob Nion]

I'd be interested to know when the last vote was cast on this one.

Reason: When I checked on Sunday evening (14th - European time) I had 14 votes for B12 and marcu22 had 13.

Since June 15th this has changed to a draw. Was that still "in time"?

Same on J7

Edit: oh come on guys! Voting has CLOSED how can it be that we write about voting after the deadline and people ccontinue doing it?

Cap and myself were both leading with 14 to 13 when voting was over

Edited June 17, 2015 by Jacob Nion

[Kai NRG]

Voting ain't closed until the fat lady sings... Edit: No reference to me of course.

But seriously, come on people! Give Ulandus a chance! After all, we had the better builds!

Maybe we can arrange for you to get the personal points anyway, would that make everyone happy?

Edited June 17, 2015 by Kai NRG

[Dr.Cogg]

Someone really needs to lock these after the voting done.

[Jacob Nion]

Voting ain't closed until the fat lady sings... Edit: No reference to me of course.

But seriously, come on people! Give Ulandus a chance! After all, we had the better builds!

Maybe we can arrange for you to get the personal points anyway, would that make everyone happy?

Personal points are not the point. I already held that square in my claws and I won't give it up. And I definitely won't accept illegal votes when it's about Sultan's Gate.

[Kai NRG]

Well, obviously it's Ska's call. And I agree that having unlocked expired voting threads is in no way ideal, but of course there's nothing Garmadon and ME can do about that.

[Garmadon]

Yes, I certainly see the problem here, it would have been highly preferable to lock the voting the day the rules specify it as ending. However, as Ska has been busy this hasn't been possible, so we'll just have to leave the decision up to him. As far as Captain B is concerned, the only thing involved is personal points (the capitol is defended anyways since the second attack lost to it's counter) so it could be easily solved by giving both of them the points, but the other case is more difficult... I can say that JN was ahead when the pole was specified as being closed though - it is finally up to Ska though. I'll call his attention to it

[Captain Braunsfeld]

Fine with me - my two key points were defense of the capital and getting some personal points for my efforts.

Marcu's build has been absolutely fine. I can understand that he still gets a lot of votes (meanwhile he's in lead).